SOM-10-01 Chapter 10 · Strain Energy & Impact Loading

Resilience, Proof Resilience & Strain Energy Under Axial Load

1. Topic Title & Metadata Header

  • Topic ID: SOM-10-01
  • Module / Subject: Strength of Materials (Mechanics of Solids)
  • Chapter 10: Strain Energy & Impact Loading
  • Topic Title: Resilience, Proof Resilience, Modulus of Resilience & Axial Strain Energy Formulations
  • Prerequisites: SOM-01-01 to SOM-01-04 (Stress, Strain, Hooke's Law & Bar Elongations).
  • Target Examinations: GATE CE, UPSC ESE (Civil), SSC JE (Civil), State AE/JE, RRB JE (Civil).
  • Quality Assurance Gate: Level 1 through Level 7 Verification Protocol Enforced.

2. Introduction & Physical Mechanics

Whenever external forces act upon a deformable elastic body, they displace their points of application and perform external work. Provided the material remains within its proportional elastic limit and no energy is dissipated as heat or permanent plastic flow, the principle of conservation of energy dictates that:

External Work Done (Wext)=Internal Strain Energy Stored (U)\text{External Work Done } (W_{\text{ext}}) = \text{Internal Strain Energy Stored } (U)

This stored internal energy is called Strain Energy (or potential energy of deformation). When the external forces are removed, the stored strain energy is released, causing the body to spring back to its original undeformed configuration.

In civil and structural engineering, understanding elastic energy storage is essential for:

  • Blast, Shock, and Impact Mitigation: Buffers, fender piles in harbors, railway couplings, and bridge expansion dampers must absorb large amounts of kinetic energy without undergoing permanent damage.
  • Seismic Resistant Design (IS 1893:2016): Structures subjected to earthquake ground motions must absorb and dissipate cyclic seismic energy through controlled elastic and ductile mechanisms.
  • Energy Methods in Structural Analysis (SOM-07-04): Castigliano's theorems, the unit load method, and Rayleigh-Ritz approximations all originate from the foundational mathematical formulation of internal strain energy.

3. Foundational Definitions & Geometric Interpretations

3.1 Strain Energy Density (uu)

Consider a differential element of volume dV=dx dy dzdV = dx \, dy \, dz subjected to a uniaxial normal stress σ\sigma. As the stress increases monotonically from 00 to σ\sigma, the corresponding strain increases linearly from 00 to ϵ=σE\epsilon = \frac{\sigma}{E}.

The incremental work done per unit volume during a strain increment dϵd\epsilon is dW=σ dϵdW = \sigma \, d\epsilon.
Integrating over the elastic deformation:

u=∫0ϵσ dϵ=∫0ϵ(Eϵ) dϵ=12Eϵ2=12σϵ=σ22Eu = \int_0^\epsilon \sigma \, d\epsilon = \int_0^\epsilon (E \epsilon) \, d\epsilon = \frac{1}{2} E \epsilon^2 = \frac{1}{2} \sigma \epsilon = \frac{\sigma^2}{2E}

The quantity uu represents the Strain Energy Density (strain energy per unit volume), with SI units of J/m3\text{J/m}^3 or N⋅mm/mm3=MPa\text{N}\cdot\text{mm/mm}^3 = \text{MPa}.

The total strain energy UU in a body of volume VV is obtained by volume integration:

U=∫Vu dV=∫Vσ22E dVU = \int_V u \, dV = \int_V \frac{\sigma^2}{2E} \, dV

3.2 Resilience

Resilience is the capacity of a material or structural member to absorb energy when deformed elastically and release that energy upon unloading without any permanent plastic deformation.

3.3 Proof Resilience (UpU_p)

Proof Resilience is the maximum strain energy that can be absorbed by a body up to its elastic limit (or yield point) without undergoing permanent set:

Up=∫Vσy22E dVU_p = \int_V \frac{\sigma_y^2}{2E} \, dV

For a prismatic body of volume VV under uniform stress:

Up=σy22E⋅VU_p = \frac{\sigma_y^2}{2E} \cdot V

where σy\sigma_y is the yield stress (or elastic limit stress) of the material.


3.4 Modulus of Resilience (upu_p)

The Modulus of Resilience is defined as the proof resilience per unit volume of the material. Geometrically, it equals the area under the linear elastic portion of the engineering stress-strain curve (up to the proportional limit):

up=Area of Elastic Triangle=12⋅σy⋅ϵy=12⋅σy⋅(σyE)=σy22Eu_p = \text{Area of Elastic Triangle} = \frac{1}{2} \cdot \sigma_y \cdot \epsilon_y = \frac{1}{2} \cdot \sigma_y \cdot \left(\frac{\sigma_y}{E}\right) = \frac{\sigma_y^2}{2E}

Key Material Selection Insight: To maximize the Modulus of Resilience (up=σy22Eu_p = \frac{\sigma_y^2}{2E}), an ideal shock-absorbing material must possess:

  1. A high yield strength (σy\sigma_y),
  2. A low modulus of elasticity (EE).

This explains why mechanical springs and structural dampers are manufactured from high-strength heat-treated alloy steels (σy≈1000−1500 MPa\sigma_y \approx 1000 - 1500\text{ MPa}), which absorb up to 25×25\times more elastic shock energy per cubic metre than standard structural mild steel (σy≈250 MPa\sigma_y \approx 250\text{ MPa}).


3.5 Modulus of Toughness vs. Modulus of Resilience

Property Modulus of Resilience (upu_p) Modulus of Toughness (utu_t)
Definition Maximum energy absorbed per unit volume within the elastic limit. Total energy absorbed per unit volume up to complete fracture / rupture.
Stress-Strain Area Area of the linear elastic triangle up to σy\sigma_y. Entire area under the complete stress-strain curve up to fracture ϵf\epsilon_f.
Physical Significance Measures resistance to elastic shock & vibration (spring action). Measures resistance to impact fracture & catastrophic tearing.
Typical Value (Mild Steel) ≈0.156 N⋅mm/mm3\approx 0.156\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm/mm}^3 ≈80−120 N⋅mm/mm3\approx 80 - 120\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm/mm}^3 (>500×>500\times larger than resilience!)
Deformation Regime Strictly elastic (ΔLperm=0\Delta L_{\text{perm}} = 0). Dominated by extensive plastic yielding and necking.

4. Analytical Formulations for Axial Strain Energy

4.1 Prismatic Bar Subjected to Gradually Applied Load PP

Consider a prismatic bar of length LL, cross-sectional area AA, and Young's modulus EE. When an axial tensile load increases gradually from 00 to PP, the elongation δ\delta increases linearly from 00 to PLAE\frac{PL}{AE}.

The average load resisting deformation is 0+P2=P2\frac{0 + P}{2} = \frac{P}{2}. The external work done is:

Wext=Area under P−δ diagram=12P⋅δW_{\text{ext}} = \text{Area under } P-\delta \text{ diagram} = \frac{1}{2} P \cdot \delta

Since Wext=UW_{\text{ext}} = U:

U=12P⋅δ=12P⋅(PLAE)=P2L2AEU = \frac{1}{2} P \cdot \delta = \frac{1}{2} P \cdot \left(\frac{P L}{A E}\right) = \frac{P^2 L}{2 A E}

Alternatively, expressing in terms of axial stress σ=PA\sigma = \frac{P}{A} and volume V=A⋅LV = A \cdot L:

U=(Aσ)2L2AE=σ22E(A⋅L)=σ22E⋅V=u⋅VU = \frac{(A \sigma)^2 L}{2 A E} = \frac{\sigma^2}{2E} (A \cdot L) = \frac{\sigma^2}{2E} \cdot V = u \cdot V

4.2 Stepped Bar Under Axial Load

For a bar composed of nn distinct prismatic segments, each having length LiL_i, cross-sectional area AiA_i, and modulus EiE_i, carrying axial force PiP_i:

U=∑i=1nPi2Li2AiEiU = \sum_{i=1}^n \frac{P_i^2 L_i}{2 A_i E_i}

Crucial Energy Distribution Insight: Notice that for a given axial force PP, the strain energy stored in a segment scales inversely with area (Ui∝1AiU_i \propto \frac{1}{A_i}). Consequently, the thinnest segment stores the overwhelming majority of the total strain energy and undergoes the highest stress concentration. In design of shock-absorbing bolts and tie rods, reducing the diameter of the shank to match the root diameter of the threads distributes strain energy uniformly, drastically increasing total impact capacity (waisted or reduced-shank bolts).


4.3 Circular Linearly Tapering Bar

Consider a circular bar of length LL whose diameter varies linearly from d1d_1 at x=0x = 0 to d2d_2 at x=Lx = L subjected to an axial pull PP. The diameter at distance xx from the smaller end is:

d(x)=d1+(d2−d1L)x=d1+kx,where k=d2−d1Ld(x) = d_1 + \left(\frac{d_2 - d_1}{L}\right) x = d_1 + k x, \quad \text{where } k = \frac{d_2 - d_1}{L}

The cross-sectional area at distance xx is:

A(x)=π4[d(x)]2A(x) = \frac{\pi}{4} [d(x)]^2

The strain energy of an elemental slice of length dxdx is dU=P2dx2A(x)EdU = \frac{P^2 dx}{2 A(x) E}. Integrating over length LL:

U=∫0LP22(π4[d(x)]2)E dx=2P2πE∫0Ldx(d1+kx)2U = \int_0^L \frac{P^2}{2 \left(\frac{\pi}{4} [d(x)]^2\right) E} \, dx = \frac{2 P^2}{\pi E} \int_0^L \frac{dx}{(d_1 + k x)^2} U=2P2πE[−1k(d1+kx)]0L=2P2πEk[1d1−1d2]=2P2πE(d2−d1L)[d2−d1d1d2]U = \frac{2 P^2}{\pi E} \left[ -\frac{1}{k (d_1 + k x)} \right]_0^L = \frac{2 P^2}{\pi E k} \left[ \frac{1}{d_1} - \frac{1}{d_2} \right] = \frac{2 P^2}{\pi E \left(\frac{d_2 - d_1}{L}\right)} \left[ \frac{d_2 - d_1}{d_1 d_2} \right] U=2P2LπE⋅d1d2=P2L2(π4d1d2)E=P2L2AeffEU = \frac{2 P^2 L}{\pi E \cdot d_1 d_2} = \frac{P^2 L}{2 \left(\frac{\pi}{4} d_1 d_2\right) E} = \frac{P^2 L}{2 A_{\text{eff}} E}

where Aeff=π4d1d2A_{\text{eff}} = \frac{\pi}{4} d_1 d_2 is the geometric mean area of the tapering bar.


4.4 Hanging Vertical Bar Under Self-Weight Alone

Consider a vertical bar of uniform cross-sectional area AA, length LL, unit weight γ=ρg\gamma = \rho g, and total self-weight W=γALW = \gamma A L, fixed rigidly at the top end and hanging freely.

Choose coordinate xx measured upward from the free bottom end (x=0x = 0 at bottom, x=Lx = L at fixed top support).
The axial tensile force P(x)P(x) supported by a cross-section at height xx equals the weight of the bar segment hanging below it:

P(x)=γ⋅A⋅x=(WL)xP(x) = \gamma \cdot A \cdot x = \left(\frac{W}{L}\right) x

The strain energy stored in an elemental slice dxdx is dU=[P(x)]2dx2AEdU = \frac{[P(x)]^2 dx}{2AE}. Integrating over the entire length:

Uself-weight=∫0L[(WL)x]22AE dx=W22AEL2∫0Lx2 dx=W22AEL2[L33]U_{\text{self-weight}} = \int_0^L \frac{\left[\left(\frac{W}{L}\right) x\right]^2}{2 A E} \, dx = \frac{W^2}{2 A E L^2} \int_0^L x^2 \, dx = \frac{W^2}{2 A E L^2} \left[ \frac{L^3}{3} \right] Uself-weight=W2L6AE=13[W2L2AE]U_{\text{self-weight}} = \frac{W^2 L}{6 A E} = \frac{1}{3} \left[ \frac{W^2 L}{2 A E} \right]

High-Yield Exam Theorem: The strain energy stored in a vertical bar due to its own self-weight WW is exactly one-third (1/31/3) of the strain energy that would be stored if the entire self-weight WW were applied as an external concentrated load at the bottom end!


4.5 Vertical Bar Under Combined Self-Weight (WW) and Terminal Load (P0P_0)

If a concentrated downward pull P0P_0 is applied at the bottom end of the hanging bar, the axial tensile force at distance xx from the bottom becomes:

P(x)=P0+(WL)xP(x) = P_0 + \left(\frac{W}{L}\right) x

Squaring the internal force:

[P(x)]2=P02+2P0(WL)x+(WL)2x2[P(x)]^2 = P_0^2 + 2 P_0 \left(\frac{W}{L}\right) x + \left(\frac{W}{L}\right)^2 x^2

Integrating the strain energy:

Utotal=∫0L[P(x)]22AE dx=12AE∫0L[P02+2P0WLx+W2L2x2]dxU_{\text{total}} = \int_0^L \frac{[P(x)]^2}{2AE} \, dx = \frac{1}{2AE} \int_0^L \left[ P_0^2 + \frac{2 P_0 W}{L} x + \frac{W^2}{L^2} x^2 \right] dx Utotal=12AE[P02L+2P0WL(L22)+W2L2(L33)]U_{\text{total}} = \frac{1}{2AE} \left[ P_0^2 L + \frac{2 P_0 W}{L} \left(\frac{L^2}{2}\right) + \frac{W^2}{L^2} \left(\frac{L^3}{3}\right) \right] Utotal=P02L2AE+P0WL2AE+W2L6AEU_{\text{total}} = \frac{P_0^2 L}{2AE} + \frac{P_0 W L}{2AE} + \frac{W^2 L}{6AE}

5. Principle of Non-Superposition of Strain Energy

A foundational trap in structural mechanics is attempting to superimpose strain energies of separate loads.

In linear elasticity, stresses and displacements are linear functions of loads, so superposition strictly holds:

σtotal=σ1+σ2,δtotal=δ1+δ2\sigma_{\text{total}} = \sigma_1 + \sigma_2, \quad \delta_{\text{total}} = \delta_1 + \delta_2

However, strain energy is a quadratic function of loads (U∝P2U \propto P^2). Therefore:

U(P1+P2)=(P1+P2)2L2AE=P12L2AE+P1P2LAE+P22L2AEU(P_1 + P_2) = \frac{(P_1 + P_2)^2 L}{2AE} = \frac{P_1^2 L}{2AE} + \frac{P_1 P_2 L}{AE} + \frac{P_2^2 L}{2AE} U(P1+P2)=U(P1)+U(P2)+P1P2LAE≠U(P1)+U(P2)U(P_1 + P_2) = U(P_1) + U(P_2) + \frac{P_1 P_2 L}{AE} \ne U(P_1) + U(P_2)

The Cross-Product Energy Term (U12U_{12}): The term U12=P1P2LAE=P1δ2=P2δ1U_{12} = \frac{P_1 P_2 L}{AE} = P_1 \delta_2 = P_2 \delta_1 represents the mutual work done by load P1P_1 riding through the displacement produced by load P2P_2.

  • Simple superposition of strain energy (Utotal=U1+U2U_{\text{total}} = U_1 + U_2) is valid if and only if the stresses/displacements caused by P1P_1 and P2P_2 are mutually orthogonal (e.g., an axial force and an uncoupled torsional moment).
  • Whenever two loads cause stresses along the same degree of freedom, the cross-product term must be included!

6. SVG Technical Illustrations

6.1 Resilience & Modulus of Resilience

The illustration below demonstrates the geometric areas defining the Modulus of Resilience and Modulus of Toughness on the stress-strain curve, alongside the load-deformation work relationship.

Resilience and Modulus of Resilience

6.2 Axial Strain Energy Configurations & Superposition

The diagram below details the axial energy distributions in stepped, tapering, and hanging bars, highlighting the self-weight 1/31/3 factor and the mandatory cross-coupling energy term.

Axial Strain Energy Configurations

7. Solved Numerical Examples

Example 7.1: Resilience & Proof Resilience of Structural Steels

Problem Statement:
A circular mild steel tension rod of diameter d=25 mmd = 25\text{ mm} and length L=2.0 mL = 2.0\text{ m} (2000 mm2000\text{ mm}) has a yield strength of σy=250 MPa\sigma_y = 250\text{ MPa} and Young's modulus E=200 GPa=2.0×105 MPaE = 200\text{ GPa} = 2.0 \times 10^5\text{ MPa}. The rod carries a working axial tensile load of P=60 kN=60000 NP = 60\text{ kN} = 60000\text{ N}.

  1. Calculate the working axial stress σ\sigma and total elongation δ\delta.
  2. Determine the strain energy stored at the working load (UU) and the strain energy density (uu).
  3. Determine the Proof Resilience (UpU_p) and Modulus of Resilience (upu_p) of the rod.
  4. If an alloy spring steel of identical dimensions with σy2=600 MPa\sigma_{y2} = 600\text{ MPa} and E=200 GPaE = 200\text{ GPa} is used instead, calculate its modulus of resilience and compare its energy absorption capacity with mild steel.

Step-by-Step Solution:

  1. Section Properties & Working Response:

    • Cross-sectional area: A=π4d2=π4(25)2=490.874 mm2A = \frac{\pi}{4} d^2 = \frac{\pi}{4} (25)^2 = 490.874\text{ mm}^2
    • Total volume of rod: V=A⋅L=490.874 mm2×2000 mm=981747.7 mm3≈9.8175×10−4 m3V = A \cdot L = 490.874\text{ mm}^2 \times 2000\text{ mm} = 981747.7\text{ mm}^3 \approx 9.8175 \times 10^{-4}\text{ m}^3
    • Working stress: σ=PA=60000 N490.874 mm2=122.231 MPa<σy(Elastic)\sigma = \frac{P}{A} = \frac{60000\text{ N}}{490.874\text{ mm}^2} = 122.231\text{ MPa} < \sigma_y \quad (\text{Elastic})
    • Elongation under working load: δ=PLAE=60000×2000490.874×200000=1.2×1089.8175×107=1.2223 mm\delta = \frac{P L}{A E} = \frac{60000 \times 2000}{490.874 \times 200000} = \frac{1.2 \times 10^8}{9.8175 \times 10^7} = 1.2223\text{ mm}
  2. Working Strain Energy (UU) and Density (uu):

    U=12P⋅δ=12×60000 N×1.22231 mm=36669.3 N⋅mm=36.669 JoulesU = \frac{1}{2} P \cdot \delta = \frac{1}{2} \times 60000\text{ N} \times 1.22231\text{ mm} = 36669.3\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} = 36.669\text{ Joules}
    • Strain energy density: u=σ22E=(122.231)22×200000=14940.4400000=0.03735 N⋅mm/mm3u = \frac{\sigma^2}{2E} = \frac{(122.231)^2}{2 \times 200000} = \frac{14940.4}{400000} = 0.03735\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm/mm}^3

    (Verification: U=u⋅V=0.03735×981747.7=36668 N⋅mm=36.67 JU = u \cdot V = 0.03735 \times 981747.7 = 36668\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} = 36.67\text{ J}. Verified).

  3. Proof Resilience & Modulus of Resilience (Mild Steel):

    • Modulus of Resilience: up=σy22E=(250)22×200000=62500400000=0.15625 N⋅mm/mm3=0.15625 MJ/m3u_p = \frac{\sigma_y^2}{2E} = \frac{(250)^2}{2 \times 200000} = \frac{62500}{400000} = 0.15625\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm/mm}^3 = 0.15625\text{ MJ/m}^3
    • Proof Resilience: Up=up⋅V=0.15625 N⋅mm/mm3×981747.7 mm3=153398 N⋅mm=153.40 JoulesU_p = u_p \cdot V = 0.15625\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm/mm}^3 \times 981747.7\text{ mm}^3 = 153398\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} = 153.40\text{ Joules}
  4. Comparison with High-Strength Alloy Steel (σy2=600 MPa\sigma_{y2} = 600\text{ MPa}):

    up2=σy222E=(600)22×200000=360000400000=0.9000 N⋅mm/mm3u_{p2} = \frac{\sigma_{y2}^2}{2E} = \frac{(600)^2}{2 \times 200000} = \frac{360000}{400000} = 0.9000\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm/mm}^3
    • Ratio of Resilience Capacities: up2up=(σy2σy)2=(600250)2=(2.4)2=5.76\frac{u_{p2}}{u_p} = \left(\frac{\sigma_{y2}}{\sigma_y}\right)^2 = \left(\frac{600}{250}\right)^2 = (2.4)^2 = 5.76

(Conclusion: The alloy steel provides 5.76×5.76\times higher elastic energy absorption capacity with zero increase in material volume or weight).


Example 7.2: Stepped Bar vs. Uniform Bar of Equal Volume

Problem Statement:
Two bars A and B are fabricated from the same steel (E=200 GPaE = 200\text{ GPa}). Both bars have the same total length of L=900 mmL = 900\text{ mm} and the same total volume VV.

  • Bar B (Stepped): Consists of two cylindrical segments:
    • Segment 1: Length L1=300 mmL_1 = 300\text{ mm}, diameter d1=20 mmd_1 = 20\text{ mm}.
    • Segment 2: Length L2=600 mmL_2 = 600\text{ mm}, diameter d2=40 mmd_2 = 40\text{ mm}.
  • Bar A (Uniform): Has a constant diameter dAd_A along its full 900 mm900\text{ mm} length such that VA=VBV_A = V_B.
    An axial tensile load of P=40 kN=40000 NP = 40\text{ kN} = 40000\text{ N} is applied to both bars.
  1. Determine the diameter dAd_A of the uniform bar.
  2. Calculate the strain energy stored in Bar A (UAU_A) and Bar B (UBU_B).
  3. Determine the ratio UB/UAU_B / U_A and explain the physical reason for the difference.

Step-by-Step Solution:

  1. Volume and Area Determinations:

    • Bar B Segments: A1=π4(20)2=100π≈314.159 mm2A_1 = \frac{\pi}{4} (20)^2 = 100 \pi \approx 314.159\text{ mm}^2 A2=π4(40)2=400π≈1256.637 mm2A_2 = \frac{\pi}{4} (40)^2 = 400 \pi \approx 1256.637\text{ mm}^2 VB=A1L1+A2L2=(100π×300)+(400π×600)=30000π+240000π=270000π≈848230.0 mm3V_B = A_1 L_1 + A_2 L_2 = (100 \pi \times 300) + (400 \pi \times 600) = 30000 \pi + 240000 \pi = 270000 \pi \approx 848230.0\text{ mm}^3
    • Bar A Dimensions (Equal Volume VA=VBV_A = V_B, L=900 mmL = 900\text{ mm}): AA=VBL=270000π900=300π≈942.478 mm2A_A = \frac{V_B}{L} = \frac{270000 \pi}{900} = 300 \pi \approx 942.478\text{ mm}^2 dA=4AAπ=4×300ππ=1200≈34.641 mmd_A = \sqrt{\frac{4 A_A}{\pi}} = \sqrt{\frac{4 \times 300 \pi}{\pi}} = \sqrt{1200} \approx 34.641\text{ mm}
  2. Strain Energy Calculations (P=40000 N,E=200000 MPaP = 40000\text{ N}, E = 200000\text{ MPa}):

    • Bar A (Uniform): UA=P2L2AAE=(40000)2×9002×(300π)×200000=1.6×109×9001.2×108π=12000π≈3819.7 N⋅mm=3.820 JU_A = \frac{P^2 L}{2 A_A E} = \frac{(40000)^2 \times 900}{2 \times (300 \pi) \times 200000} = \frac{1.6 \times 10^9 \times 900}{1.2 \times 10^8 \pi} = \frac{12000}{\pi} \approx 3819.7\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} = 3.820\text{ J}
    • Bar B (Stepped):
      • Segment 1: U1=P2L12A1E=(40000)2×3002×(100π)×200000=4.8×10114×107π=12000π≈3819.7 N⋅mm=3.820 JU_1 = \frac{P^2 L_1}{2 A_1 E} = \frac{(40000)^2 \times 300}{2 \times (100 \pi) \times 200000} = \frac{4.8 \times 10^{11}}{4 \times 10^7 \pi} = \frac{12000}{\pi} \approx 3819.7\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} = 3.820\text{ J}
      • Segment 2: U2=P2L22A2E=(40000)2×6002×(400π)×200000=9.6×10111.6×108π=6000π≈1909.9 N⋅mm=1.910 JU_2 = \frac{P^2 L_2}{2 A_2 E} = \frac{(40000)^2 \times 600}{2 \times (400 \pi) \times 200000} = \frac{9.6 \times 10^{11}}{1.6 \times 10^8 \pi} = \frac{6000}{\pi} \approx 1909.9\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} = 1.910\text{ J}
      • Total Strain Energy in Bar B: UB=U1+U2=12000π+6000π=18000π≈5729.6 N⋅mm=5.730 JU_B = U_1 + U_2 = \frac{12000}{\pi} + \frac{6000}{\pi} = \frac{18000}{\pi} \approx 5729.6\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} = 5.730\text{ J}
  3. Ratio & Physical Explanation:

    UBUA=18000/π12000/π=1800012000=1.500\frac{U_B}{U_A} = \frac{18000 / \pi}{12000 / \pi} = \frac{18000}{12000} = 1.500

    (Bar B absorbs 1.50×1.50\times more strain energy than Bar A for identical material mass!)

    • Physical Insight:
      In Bar B, the axial stress in Segment 1 is σ1=40000314.16=127.32 MPa\sigma_1 = \frac{40000}{314.16} = 127.32\text{ MPa}, compared to σA=40000942.48=42.44 MPa\sigma_A = \frac{40000}{942.48} = 42.44\text{ MPa} in Bar A. Because strain energy density scales with stress squared (u∝σ2u \propto \sigma^2), the high stress in the thinner segment massively amplifies energy absorption. Notice that Segment 1 occupies only one-third of the length but accounts for two-thirds (66.7%66.7\%) of the total energy!

Example 7.3: Deep Vertical Borehole Drill Pipe (Self-Weight + End Pull)

Problem Statement:
A heavy steel drill string hanging vertically in an exploratory borehole has a length of L=100 mL = 100\text{ m} (100000 mm100000\text{ mm}) and cross-sectional area A=5000 mm2A = 5000\text{ mm}^2.
Given: Steel density ρ=7850 kg/m3\rho = 7850\text{ kg/m}^3 (g=9.81 m/s2  ⟹  γ=7.70085×10−5 N/mm3g = 9.81\text{ m/s}^2 \implies \gamma = 7.70085 \times 10^{-5}\text{ N/mm}^3) and E=200 GPa=2.0×105 MPaE = 200\text{ GPa} = 2.0 \times 10^5\text{ MPa}.
A drilling bit and bottom pull impose a terminal tensile load of P0=150 kN=150000 NP_0 = 150\text{ kN} = 150000\text{ N} at the free lower end.

  1. Calculate the total self-weight WW of the drill pipe.
  2. Calculate the strain energy stored if the terminal pull P0P_0 acted alone (UP0U_{P0}).
  3. Calculate the strain energy stored if the self-weight WW acted alone (UWU_W).
  4. Calculate the true total strain energy stored under simultaneous action of self-weight and end pull (UtotalU_{\text{total}}).
  5. Calculate the cross-coupling energy term and verify that energy superposition fails.

Step-by-Step Solution:

  1. Total Self-Weight (WW):

    W=γ⋅A⋅L=(7.70085×10−5 N/mm3)×5000 mm2×100000 mm=38504.25 N≈38.504 kNW = \gamma \cdot A \cdot L = (7.70085 \times 10^{-5}\text{ N/mm}^3) \times 5000\text{ mm}^2 \times 100000\text{ mm} = 38504.25\text{ N} \approx 38.504\text{ kN}
  2. Strain Energy Due to P0P_0 Alone:

    UP0=P02L2AE=(150000)2×1000002×5000×200000=2.25×1010×1052×109=2.25×10152×109=1125000 N⋅mm=1125.000 JoulesU_{P0} = \frac{P_0^2 L}{2 A E} = \frac{(150000)^2 \times 100000}{2 \times 5000 \times 200000} = \frac{2.25 \times 10^{10} \times 10^5}{2 \times 10^9} = \frac{2.25 \times 10^{15}}{2 \times 10^9} = 1125000\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} = 1125.000\text{ Joules}
  3. Strain Energy Due to Self-Weight WW Alone:

    UW=W2L6AE=(38504.25)2×1000006×5000×200000=1.482577×109×1056×109=1.482577×10146×109=24709.6 N⋅mm=24.710 JoulesU_W = \frac{W^2 L}{6 A E} = \frac{(38504.25)^2 \times 100000}{6 \times 5000 \times 200000} = \frac{1.482577 \times 10^9 \times 10^5}{6 \times 10^9} = \frac{1.482577 \times 10^{14}}{6 \times 10^9} = 24709.6\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} = 24.710\text{ Joules}
  4. Cross-Coupling Mutual Work Term (UcrossU_{\text{cross}}):

    Ucross=P0WL2AE=150000×38504.25×1000002×5000×200000=5.775638×10142×109=288781.9 N⋅mm=288.782 JoulesU_{\text{cross}} = \frac{P_0 W L}{2 A E} = \frac{150000 \times 38504.25 \times 100000}{2 \times 5000 \times 200000} = \frac{5.775638 \times 10^{14}}{2 \times 10^9} = 288781.9\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} = 288.782\text{ Joules}
  5. True Total Strain Energy (UtotalU_{\text{total}}):

    Utotal=UP0+Ucross+UW=1125.000+288.782+24.710=1438.492 JoulesU_{\text{total}} = U_{P0} + U_{\text{cross}} + U_W = 1125.000 + 288.782 + 24.710 = 1438.492\text{ Joules}
  • Verification of Superposition Failure: UP0+UW=1125.000+24.710=1149.710 JoulesU_{P0} + U_W = 1125.000 + 24.710 = 1149.710\text{ Joules} Discrepancy=Utotal−(UP0+UW)=1438.492−1149.710=288.782 J=Ucross\text{Discrepancy} = U_{\text{total}} - (U_{P0} + U_W) = 1438.492 - 1149.710 = 288.782\text{ J} = U_{\text{cross}} (Simply adding the two independent strain energies underestimates the true energy by 288.78 J288.78\text{ J} or 20.1%20.1\%!).

8. Indian Standard Code Provisions & Engineering Practice

  1. IS 800:2007 (General Construction in Steel — Section 12):

    • Incorporates energy absorption criteria in the design of seismic bracing and tension tie rods.
    • Requires reduced-shank (waisted) anchor bolts in heavy industrial foundations to ensure that under extreme earthquake tension, yielding and energy dissipation occur along the ductile unthreaded shank rather than by brittle stripping of thread roots.
  2. IS 1893:2016 (Criteria for Earthquake Resistant Design of Structures):

    • The Response Reduction Factor (RR) directly accounts for a structure's ability to absorb earthquake energy through inelastic deformation (toughness) while maintaining elastic stability (resilience).
  3. IS 1757:1988 (Method for Charpy Impact Test on Metallic Materials):

    • Standard test method for determining the total notch impact energy absorption of structural steels at room and sub-zero temperatures.
    • Specifies minimum absorbed energy requirements (27 J27\text{ J} at specified temperatures) for structural steel grades (IS 2062).

9. Common Misconceptions & High-Yield Exam Traps

  1. Superimposing Strain Energies Directly:

    • Trap: Calculating Utotal=U(P1)+U(P2)U_{\text{total}} = U(P_1) + U(P_2).
    • Correction: Strain energy is quadratic (U∝P2U \propto P^2). The cross-product term U12=P1P2LAEU_{12} = \frac{P_1 P_2 L}{AE} must be added whenever loads act in the same direction!
  2. Self-Weight Strain Energy Factor (1/31/3 vs. 1/21/2):

    • Trap: Thinking self-weight strain energy is W2L2AE\frac{W^2 L}{2AE} or W2L4AE\frac{W^2 L}{4AE}.
    • Correction: Because axial force varies linearly from 00 to WW, force squared varies quadratically (x2x^2). Integrating x2x^2 produces x33\frac{x^3}{3}, giving strictly U=W2L6AE=13(W2L2AE)U = \frac{W^2 L}{6AE} = \frac{1}{3} \left(\frac{W^2 L}{2AE}\right).
  3. Confusing Modulus of Resilience with Proof Resilience:

    • Trap: Using Modulus of Resilience (upu_p) when asked for total energy capacity (UpU_p).
    • Correction: Modulus of Resilience is an intensive material property (energy per unit volume: σy22E\frac{\sigma_y^2}{2E} in N⋅mm/mm3\text{N}\cdot\text{mm/mm}^3). Proof Resilience is an extensive property of the entire body (Up=up⋅VU_p = u_p \cdot V in Joules).
  4. Assuming Higher Modulus of Elasticity (EE) Increases Resilience:

    • Trap: Believing a stiffer material stores more elastic energy.
    • Correction: Stiffer materials store less elastic energy for a given stress: up=σy22Eu_p = \frac{\sigma_y^2}{2E}. High resilience requires high σy\sigma_y and low EE!
  5. Equating High Toughness to High Resilience:

    • Trap: Thinking a tough material is automatically resilient.
    • Correction: Mild steel is extremely tough (80−120 MJ/m380-120\text{ MJ/m}^3) due to huge plastic ductility, but has low resilience (0.156 MJ/m30.156\text{ MJ/m}^3). Spring steel has high resilience but lower toughness.

10. Previous Year Competitive Exam Questions

Question 1 (GATE CE — 1 Mark)

The strain energy stored in a solid uniform bar of length LL, cross-sectional area AA, and elastic modulus EE due to its own weight WW hanging vertically is:

  • (A) W2L2AE\frac{W^2 L}{2 A E}
  • (B) W2L3AE\frac{W^2 L}{3 A E}
  • (C) W2L6AE\frac{W^2 L}{6 A E}
  • (D) W2L8AE\frac{W^2 L}{8 A E}

Answer: (C)
Solution:
P(x)=WxLP(x) = \frac{W x}{L}.
U=∫0LP(x)22AEdx=W22AEL2∫0Lx2dx=W22AEL2L33=W2L6AEU = \int_0^L \frac{P(x)^2}{2AE} dx = \frac{W^2}{2AE L^2} \int_0^L x^2 dx = \frac{W^2}{2AE L^2} \frac{L^3}{3} = \frac{W^2 L}{6AE}.


Question 2 (UPSC ESE)

The Modulus of Resilience of a material is defined as:

  • (A) Strain energy stored per unit volume up to proportional limit
  • (B) Total strain energy stored up to fracture
  • (C) Maximum load a material can carry without yielding
  • (D) Ratio of proof stress to yield stress

Answer: (A)
Solution:
Modulus of resilience is the strain energy density stored in the material when stressed up to the proportional limit / elastic limit: up=σy22Eu_p = \frac{\sigma_y^2}{2E}.


Question 3 (SSC JE)

If the diameter of an axially loaded circular bar is doubled while keeping the load and length constant, the strain energy stored will become:

  • (A) 2 times
  • (B) 4 times
  • (C) 14\frac{1}{4} of original
  • (D) 12\frac{1}{2} of original

Answer: (C)
Solution:
U=P2L2AEU = \frac{P^2 L}{2AE}. Area A=π4d2A = \frac{\pi}{4} d^2. When diameter is doubled (d→2dd \to 2d), area increases by 4×4\times (A→4AA \to 4A). Therefore, U→U4U \to \frac{U}{4}.


Question 4 (State AE)

Two bars of the same material and length have diameters dd and 2d2d respectively. If both bars are subjected to the same tensile load PP, the ratio of strain energy stored in the first bar to that in the second bar is:

  • (A) 1:21 : 2
  • (B) 2:12 : 1
  • (C) 4:14 : 1
  • (D) 16:116 : 1

Answer: (C)
Solution:
U∝1A∝1d2U \propto \frac{1}{A} \propto \frac{1}{d^2}.
U1U2=d22d12=(2d)2d2=4\frac{U_1}{U_2} = \frac{d_2^2}{d_1^2} = \frac{(2d)^2}{d^2} = 4.


11. Comprehensive Summary & Formula Sheet

Parameter / Configuration Mathematical Formula Key Assumptions & Conditions
Strain Energy Density (uu) u=σ22E=12σϵu = \frac{\sigma^2}{2E} = \frac{1}{2} \sigma \epsilon Linearly elastic material (Hooke's Law)
Modulus of Resilience (upu_p) up=σy22Eu_p = \frac{\sigma_y^2}{2E} Area of elastic triangle up to yield stress σy\sigma_y
Proof Resilience (UpU_p) Up=up⋅V=(σy22E)VU_p = u_p \cdot V = \left(\frac{\sigma_y^2}{2E}\right) V Maximum elastic energy capacity of entire body
Prismatic Bar Under Load PP U=P2L2AE=12PδU = \frac{P^2 L}{2AE} = \frac{1}{2} P \delta Gradually applied axial load, uniform area AA
Stepped Bar U=∑i=1nPi2Li2AiEiU = \sum_{i=1}^n \frac{P_i^2 L_i}{2 A_i E_i} Thinnest segment stores highest energy share
Circular Tapering Bar (d1→d2d_1 \to d_2) U=2P2LπEd1d2=P2L2AeffEU = \frac{2 P^2 L}{\pi E d_1 d_2} = \frac{P^2 L}{2 A_{\text{eff}} E} Aeff=π4d1d2A_{\text{eff}} = \frac{\pi}{4} d_1 d_2 (geometric mean area)
Vertical Bar Under Self-Weight WW Uself-weight=W2L6AEU_{\text{self-weight}} = \frac{W^2 L}{6AE} Triangular axial force distribution P(x)=Wx/LP(x) = W x / L
Self-Weight to End Load Ratio Uself-weightUend load=13\frac{U_{\text{self-weight}}}{U_{\text{end load}}} = \frac{1}{3} Fundamental structural theorem
Combined Self-Weight + Load P0P_0 U=P02L2AE+P0WL2AE+W2L6AEU = \frac{P_0^2 L}{2AE} + \frac{P_0 W L}{2AE} + \frac{W^2 L}{6AE} Mandatory cross-coupling term: Superposition fails!
Cross-Product Energy Term (U12U_{12}) U12=P1P2LAEU_{12} = \frac{P_1 P_2 L}{AE} Mutual work done by P1P_1 through δ2\delta_2