SOM-01-04 Chapter 01 · Simple Stresses and Strains

Elongation of Prismatic, Stepped & Tapering Bars

Module
Strength of Materials / Solid Mechanics
Target Examinations
GATE CE, UPSC ESE, SSC JE, RRB JE, State AE/JE
Prerequisites
SOM-01-01 (Stress and Strain), SOM-01-03 (Hooke's Law & Elastic Modulus)

1. Executive Summary & Core Formulations

The axial deformation of structural members under external tensile or compressive forces and body forces (self-weight) represents one of the most common design computations in civil engineering (e.g., bridge hangers, foundation piles, tie rods, mine hoist cables, borehole drill pipes).

                             AXIAL ELONGATION OF BARS
                                         │
        ┌────────────────────────┬───────┴────────┬────────────────────────┐
        ▼                        ▼                ▼                        ▼
  PRISMATIC BARS           STEPPED BARS     SELF-WEIGHT EFFECTS      TAPERING BARS
  ΔL = PL / (AE)           Superposition    Prismatic: γL² / (2E)    Circular: 4PL/(π d₁ d₂ E)
  Stiffness: k = AE/L      Σ [PᵢLᵢ/(AᵢEᵢ)]  Conical:   γL² / (6E)    Rect: [PL/(tE(b₂-b₁))] ln(b₂/b₁)

1.1 The General Governing Differential Equation

For any bar of length LL, variable cross-sectional area A(x)A(x), variable Young's modulus E(x)E(x), subjected to a variable internal axial force distribution P(x)P(x):

ΔL=∫0LP(x)A(x)E(x) dx\Delta L = \int_0^L \frac{P(x)}{A(x) E(x)} \, dx

1.2 Axial Stiffness and Flexibility

  • Axial Stiffness (kk): The force required to produce unit axial elongation: k=PΔL=AEL[N/mm or kN/m]k = \frac{P}{\Delta L} = \frac{A E}{L} \quad [\text{N/mm or kN/m}]
  • Axial Flexibility (ff): The axial elongation produced by unit applied force: f=ΔLP=LAE=1k[mm/N or m/kN]f = \frac{\Delta L}{P} = \frac{L}{A E} = \frac{1}{k} \quad [\text{mm/N or m/kN}]

2. Stepped Bars & Principle of Superposition

When an axially loaded member consists of multiple segments with differing cross-sectional areas (AiA_i), lengths (LiL_i), or materials (EiE_i), and carries intermediate concentrated loads along its length:

Stepped Bar Under Axial Loads
Figure 1.9: Stepped prismatic bar with intermediate axial forces showing segment-by-segment free-body diagrams (FBD) and internal force equilibrium.

2.1 The Free-Body Diagram (FBD) Sectioning Technique

[!IMPORTANT] Golden Rule of Internal Forces: Never use the external applied forces directly in the formula PLAE\frac{P L}{A E}. The force PiP_i acting on segment ii must be obtained by passing an imaginary cutting plane through segment ii and establishing static equilibrium (∑Fx=0\sum F_x = 0) for the isolated portion to either the left or the right of the cut.

For a bar comprising nn discrete segments:

ΔLtotal=∑i=1nΔLi=∑i=1nPiLiAiEi\Delta L_{\text{total}} = \sum_{i=1}^n \Delta L_i = \sum_{i=1}^n \frac{P_i L_i}{A_i E_i}
  • If segment ii is in tension (Pi>0P_i > 0): ΔLi\Delta L_i is positive (elongation).
  • If segment ii is in compression (Pi<0P_i < 0): ΔLi\Delta L_i is negative (contraction).

3. Mathematical Derivations: Elongation Under Self-Weight

In deep boreholes, tall mine hoists, suspension bridge main cables, and vertical structural columns, the weight of the member itself produces significant axial elongation and stress.

Bar Under Self-Weight
Figure 1.10: Engineering comparison of vertical prismatic and conical bars under self-weight, showing internal normal stress distributions and total elongations.

3.1 Vertical Prismatic Bar Under Self-Weight

Consider a uniform prismatic bar of length LL, cross-sectional area AA, Young's modulus EE, and mass density ρ\rho (unit weight γ=ρg\gamma = \rho g). The total weight of the bar is W=γALW = \gamma A L.

Step 1: Internal Normal Force at Height xx

Choose coordinate xx measured upward from the bottom free tip (x=0x = 0): The internal tensile force P(x)P(x) at any section xx supports only the weight of the bar portion lying below that section:

P(x)=γ⋅A⋅xP(x) = \gamma \cdot A \cdot x

Step 2: Normal Stress Distribution

σ(x)=P(x)A=γx\sigma(x) = \frac{P(x)}{A} = \gamma x
  • At the bottom free tip (x=0x = 0): σmin⁡=0\sigma_{\min} = 0.
  • At the top fixed support (x=Lx = L): σmax⁡=γL=WA\sigma_{\max} = \gamma L = \frac{W}{A}

The stress distribution varies linearly from zero at the bottom to a maximum at the top support.

Step 3: Integration for Total Elongation

The elongation of an infinitesimal element of length dxdx is dδ=P(x)dxAE=γxdxEd\delta = \frac{P(x) dx}{A E} = \frac{\gamma x dx}{E}.
Integrating over the entire length from x=0x = 0 to x=Lx = L:

ΔL=∫0LγxE dx=γE[x22]0L=γL22E\Delta L = \int_0^L \frac{\gamma x}{E} \, dx = \frac{\gamma}{E} \left[ \frac{x^2}{2} \right]_0^L = \frac{\gamma L^2}{2E}

Since γ=WAL\gamma = \frac{W}{A L}:

ΔL=(WAL)L22E=WL2AE\Delta L = \frac{\left(\frac{W}{A L}\right) L^2}{2E} = \frac{W L}{2 A E}

[!NOTE] Fundamental Theorem of Self-Weight:
The elongation of a uniform vertical bar hanging under its own weight (WL2AE\frac{WL}{2AE}) is exactly half (50%50\%) of the elongation produced by an external concentrated force equal to the total weight WW applied at its bottom tip (WLAE\frac{WL}{AE}).


3.2 Vertical Conical Bar Under Self-Weight

Consider a right circular cone of length LL, base diameter DD at the top fixed support, and apex at the bottom free tip (x=0x = 0).

Step 1: Geometry at Distance xx from the Apex

At any section at height xx from the apex:

  • Diameter: d(x)=DLxd(x) = \frac{D}{L} x
  • Cross-sectional area: A(x)=π4[d(x)]2=π4(DL)2x2A(x) = \frac{\pi}{4} [d(x)]^2 = \frac{\pi}{4} \left(\frac{D}{L}\right)^2 x^2

Step 2: Weight of the Conical Portion Below Section xx

The volume of a cone of height xx and base area A(x)A(x) is V(x)=13A(x)xV(x) = \frac{1}{3} A(x) x.
Therefore, the weight supported at section xx is:

P(x)=γ⋅V(x)=13γA(x)xP(x) = \gamma \cdot V(x) = \frac{1}{3} \gamma A(x) x

Step 3: Normal Stress Distribution

σ(x)=P(x)A(x)=13γA(x)xA(x)=13γx\sigma(x) = \frac{P(x)}{A(x)} = \frac{\frac{1}{3} \gamma A(x) x}{A(x)} = \frac{1}{3} \gamma x

Notice that the area A(x)A(x) cancels out! The normal stress varies linearly with xx:

  • At the apex (x=0x = 0): σ=0\sigma = 0.
  • At the top base (x=Lx = L): σmax⁡=13γL\sigma_{\max} = \frac{1}{3} \gamma L

Since the total weight of the cone is W=13γAbaseL  ⟹  σmax⁡=WAbaseW = \frac{1}{3} \gamma A_{\text{base}} L \implies \sigma_{\max} = \frac{W}{A_{\text{base}}}.

Step 4: Total Elongation

ΔL=∫0Lσ(x)E dx=∫0Lγx3E dx=γ3E[x22]0L=γL26E\Delta L = \int_0^L \frac{\sigma(x)}{E} \, dx = \int_0^L \frac{\gamma x}{3E} \, dx = \frac{\gamma}{3E} \left[ \frac{x^2}{2} \right]_0^L = \frac{\gamma L^2}{6E}

Expressed in terms of total weight W=13γAbaseLW = \frac{1}{3} \gamma A_{\text{base}} L:

ΔL=WL2AbaseE\Delta L = \frac{W L}{2 A_{\text{base}} E}

[!IMPORTANT] Comparison of Self-Weight Elongations:
For a conical bar and a prismatic bar of the same length LL and same material (γ,E\gamma, E):

ΔLconicalΔLprismatic=γL26EγL22E=13≈33.33%\frac{\Delta L_{\text{conical}}}{\Delta L_{\text{prismatic}}} = \frac{\frac{\gamma L^2}{6E}}{\frac{\gamma L^2}{2E}} = \frac{1}{3} \approx 33.33\%

The conical bar elongates by exactly one-third of the prismatic bar under self-weight!


4. Mathematical Derivations: Linearly Tapering Bars Under Axial Load PP

In structural design, members are frequently tapered to optimize material efficiency and reduce dead weight.

Tapering Bars Under Axial Load
Figure 1.11: Linearly tapering circular bar and rectangular plate of uniform thickness under axial tensile load P.

4.1 Circular Linearly Tapering Bar

Consider a circular bar of length LL whose diameter varies linearly from d1d_1 at x=0x = 0 to d2d_2 at x=Lx = L subjected to an axial tensile force PP.

Step 1: Geometric Function for Diameter d(x)d(x)

d(x)=d1+(d2−d1L)xd(x) = d_1 + \left(\frac{d_2 - d_1}{L}\right) x

The cross-sectional area at distance xx is:

A(x)=π4[d(x)]2=π4[d1+(d2−d1L)x]2A(x) = \frac{\pi}{4} [d(x)]^2 = \frac{\pi}{4} \left[ d_1 + \left(\frac{d_2 - d_1}{L}\right) x \right]^2

Step 2: Integration for Total Elongation

ΔL=∫0LP dxA(x)E=4PπE∫0Ldx[d1+(d2−d1L)x]2\Delta L = \int_0^L \frac{P \, dx}{A(x) E} = \frac{4P}{\pi E} \int_0^L \frac{dx}{\left[ d_1 + \left(\frac{d_2 - d_1}{L}\right) x \right]^2}

Let u=d1+(d2−d1L)x  ⟹  du=(d2−d1L)dx  ⟹  dx=Ld2−d1duu = d_1 + \left(\frac{d_2 - d_1}{L}\right) x \implies du = \left(\frac{d_2 - d_1}{L}\right) dx \implies dx = \frac{L}{d_2 - d_1} du.
Limits of integration: at x=0  ⟹  u=d1x = 0 \implies u = d_1; at x=L  ⟹  u=d2x = L \implies u = d_2.

ΔL=4PπE(Ld2−d1)∫d1d2duu2=4PLπE(d2−d1)[−1u]d1d2=4PLπE(d2−d1)(1d1−1d2)=4PLπE(d2−d1)(d2−d1d1d2)\begin{aligned} \Delta L &= \frac{4P}{\pi E} \left(\frac{L}{d_2 - d_1}\right) \int_{d_1}^{d_2} \frac{du}{u^2} \\ &= \frac{4 P L}{\pi E (d_2 - d_1)} \left[ -\frac{1}{u} \right]_{d_1}^{d_2} \\ &= \frac{4 P L}{\pi E (d_2 - d_1)} \left( \frac{1}{d_1} - \frac{1}{d_2} \right) \\ &= \frac{4 P L}{\pi E (d_2 - d_1)} \left( \frac{d_2 - d_1}{d_1 d_2} \right) \end{aligned}

Canceling (d2−d1)(d_2 - d_1) yields the celebrated formula:

ΔL=4PLπd1d2E\Delta L = \frac{4 P L}{\pi d_1 d_2 E}

Equivalent Uniform Diameter (deqd_{\text{eq}}):

Comparing ΔL=4PLπd1d2E\Delta L = \frac{4 P L}{\pi d_1 d_2 E} with the standard prismatic formula ΔL=PLπ4deq2E\Delta L = \frac{P L}{\frac{\pi}{4} d_{\text{eq}}^2 E}:

4PLπd1d2E=4PLπdeq2E  ⟹  deq2=d1d2\frac{4 P L}{\pi d_1 d_2 E} = \frac{4 P L}{\pi d_{\text{eq}}^2 E} \implies d_{\text{eq}}^2 = d_1 d_2 deq=d1d2d_{\text{eq}} = \sqrt{d_1 d_2}

[!TIP] The equivalent diameter of a linearly tapering circular rod is the Geometric Mean (deq=d1d2d_{\text{eq}} = \sqrt{d_1 d_2}) of the end diameters, NOT the arithmetic mean!


4.2 Rectangular Linearly Tapering Plate of Uniform Thickness tt

Consider a flat plate of constant thickness tt, length LL, whose width varies linearly from b1b_1 at x=0x = 0 to b2b_2 at x=Lx = L, subjected to an axial force PP.

Step 1: Geometric Function for Width b(x)b(x)

b(x)=b1+(b2−b1L)xb(x) = b_1 + \left(\frac{b_2 - b_1}{L}\right) x

Area at distance xx:

A(x)=b(x)⋅t=t[b1+(b2−b1L)x]A(x) = b(x) \cdot t = t \left[ b_1 + \left(\frac{b_2 - b_1}{L}\right) x \right]

Step 2: Integration for Total Elongation

ΔL=∫0LP dxA(x)E=PtE∫0Ldxb1+(b2−b1L)x\Delta L = \int_0^L \frac{P \, dx}{A(x) E} = \frac{P}{t E} \int_0^L \frac{dx}{b_1 + \left(\frac{b_2 - b_1}{L}\right) x}

Let u=b1+(b2−b1L)x  ⟹  dx=Lb2−b1duu = b_1 + \left(\frac{b_2 - b_1}{L}\right) x \implies dx = \frac{L}{b_2 - b_1} du:

ΔL=PLtE(b2−b1)∫b1b2duu=PLtE(b2−b1)[ln⁡u]b1b2ΔL=PLtE(b2−b1)ln⁡(b2b1)\begin{aligned} \Delta L &= \frac{P L}{t E (b_2 - b_1)} \int_{b_1}^{b_2} \frac{du}{u} \\ &= \frac{P L}{t E (b_2 - b_1)} \left[ \ln u \right]_{b_1}^{b_2} \\ \Delta L &= \frac{P L}{t E (b_2 - b_1)} \ln\left(\frac{b_2}{b_1}\right) \end{aligned}

5. Bar of Uniform Strength (Exponential Profile)

In heavy hanging cables, deep-sea risers, and chimney stacks, a prismatic bar is wasteful because the stress at the bottom is nearly zero while the top is heavily stressed.
A Bar of Uniform Strength is tapered such that the normal stress under self-weight plus external end load P0P_0 is constant and equal to allowable working stress σ\sigma across every single cross-section.

5.1 Derivation of Cross-Sectional Area Function A(x)A(x)

Let xx be measured downward from the top support (or upward from bottom load P0P_0).
Measuring xx upward from bottom end (x=0x = 0 where area is A0=P0/σA_0 = P_0 / \sigma):
Consider an element of length dxdx at distance xx:

  • Upward normal force on top face: P+dP=σ(A+dA)P + dP = \sigma (A + dA)
  • Downward normal force on bottom face: P=σAP = \sigma A
  • Downward weight of element: dW=γAdxdW = \gamma A dx

Equilibrium of the infinitesimal element:

(P+dP)−P−dW=0  ⟹  σdA−γAdx=0(P + dP) - P - dW = 0 \implies \sigma dA - \gamma A dx = 0 dAA=γσ dx\frac{dA}{A} = \frac{\gamma}{\sigma} \, dx

Integrating both sides from x=0x = 0 (where A=A0A = A_0) to height xx:

∫A0A(x)dAA=γσ∫0xdx  ⟹  ln⁡(A(x)A0)=γxσ\int_{A_0}^{A(x)} \frac{dA}{A} = \frac{\gamma}{\sigma} \int_0^x dx \implies \ln\left(\frac{A(x)}{A_0}\right) = \frac{\gamma x}{\sigma}

Exponentiating both sides:

A(x)=A0eγxσA(x) = A_0 e^{\frac{\gamma x}{\sigma}}

where:

  • A0=P0σA_0 = \frac{P_0}{\sigma} is the minimum cross-sectional area at the bottom tip.
  • σ\sigma is the uniform constant working stress throughout the bar.
  • γ\gamma is the unit weight of the material.

6. Step-by-Step Solved Numerical Examples

Example 4.1: Stepped Bar under Multiple Intermediate Loads (GATE CE Level)

Problem Statement:
A steel bar firmly anchored to a rigid wall at support A consists of three prismatic segments as shown:

  • Segment AB: Length L1=500 mmL_1 = 500\text{ mm}, Area A1=1000 mm2A_1 = 1000\text{ mm}^2
  • Segment BC: Length L2=400 mmL_2 = 400\text{ mm}, Area A2=500 mm2A_2 = 500\text{ mm}^2
  • Segment CD: Length L3=300 mmL_3 = 300\text{ mm}, Area A3=250 mm2A_3 = 250\text{ mm}^2
  • Modulus of Elasticity: E=200 GPa=2×105 N/mm2E = 200\text{ GPa} = 2 \times 10^5\text{ N/mm}^2

External axial forces applied at the junctions:

  • At junction B: PB=120 kNP_B = 120\text{ kN} directed to the right (+x+x)
  • At junction C: PC=80 kNP_C = 80\text{ kN} directed to the left (−x-x)
  • At free tip D: PD=50 kNP_D = 50\text{ kN} directed to the right (+x+x)

Calculate:

  1. The support reaction RAR_A at the fixed anchor wall.
  2. The internal axial force and normal stress in each of the three segments.
  3. The displacement of junction B, junction C, and free tip D.

Step-by-Step Solution:

  1. Overall Static Equilibrium (∑Fx=0\sum F_x = 0): Assume reaction RAR_A acts to the left (−x-x):

    −RA+PB−PC+PD=0-R_A + P_B - P_C + P_D = 0 −RA+120−80+50=0  ⟹  RA=90 kN(directed to the left, tension at wall)-R_A + 120 - 80 + 50 = 0 \implies R_A = 90\text{ kN} \quad (\text{directed to the left, tension at wall})
  2. Internal Axial Force Determination by FBD Sectioning:

    • Segment CD (Cut between C and D, look to right): To balance PD=50 kNP_D = 50\text{ kN} pulling right: P3=+50 kN=+50,000 N(Tension)P_3 = +50\text{ kN} = +50,000\text{ N} \quad (\text{Tension})
    • Segment BC (Cut between B and C, look to right): Sum of forces to the right of cut: −PC+PD=−80+50=−30 kN-P_C + P_D = -80 + 50 = -30\text{ kN}. To balance this, internal force on segment BC is: P2=−30 kN=−30,000 N(Compression)P_2 = -30\text{ kN} = -30,000\text{ N} \quad (\text{Compression})
    • Segment AB (Cut between A and B, look to right): Sum of forces to the right of cut: +PB−PC+PD=120−80+50=+90 kN+P_B - P_C + P_D = 120 - 80 + 50 = +90\text{ kN}. P1=+90 kN=+90,000 N(Tension)P_1 = +90\text{ kN} = +90,000\text{ N} \quad (\text{Tension}) Check against wall reaction: P1=RA=90 kNP_1 = R_A = 90\text{ kN} (Verified exact).
  3. Segment Normal Stresses:

    • σ1=P1A1=+90,000 N1000 mm2=+90.0 MPa\sigma_1 = \frac{P_1}{A_1} = \frac{+90,000\text{ N}}{1000\text{ mm}^2} = +90.0\text{ MPa} (Tension)
    • σ2=P2A2=−30,000 N500 mm2=−60.0 MPa\sigma_2 = \frac{P_2}{A_2} = \frac{-30,000\text{ N}}{500\text{ mm}^2} = -60.0\text{ MPa} (Compression)
    • σ3=P3A3=+50,000 N250 mm2=+200.0 MPa\sigma_3 = \frac{P_3}{A_3} = \frac{+50,000\text{ N}}{250\text{ mm}^2} = +200.0\text{ MPa} (Tension)
  4. Segment Elongations (ΔLi=PiLiAiE\Delta L_i = \frac{P_i L_i}{A_i E}):

    • Segment 1: ΔL1=(+90,000 N)×(500 mm)(1000 mm2)×(200,000 N/mm2)=45,000,000200,000,000=+0.225 mm\Delta L_1 = \frac{(+90,000\text{ N}) \times (500\text{ mm})}{(1000\text{ mm}^2) \times (200,000\text{ N/mm}^2)} = \frac{45,000,000}{200,000,000} = +0.225\text{ mm}
    • Segment 2: ΔL2=(−30,000 N)×(400 mm)(500 mm2)×(200,000 N/mm2)=−12,000,000100,000,000=−0.120 mm\Delta L_2 = \frac{(-30,000\text{ N}) \times (400\text{ mm})}{(500\text{ mm}^2) \times (200,000\text{ N/mm}^2)} = \frac{-12,000,000}{100,000,000} = -0.120\text{ mm}
    • Segment 3: ΔL3=(+50,000 N)×(300 mm)(250 mm2)×(200,000 N/mm2)=15,000,00050,000,000=+0.300 mm\Delta L_3 = \frac{(+50,000\text{ N}) \times (300\text{ mm})}{(250\text{ mm}^2) \times (200,000\text{ N/mm}^2)} = \frac{15,000,000}{50,000,000} = +0.300\text{ mm}
  5. Displacements of Junctions:

    • Displacement of B: δB=ΔL1=+0.225 mm\delta_B = \Delta L_1 = +0.225\text{ mm} (to the right)
    • Displacement of C: δC=δB+ΔL2=+0.225−0.120=+0.105 mm\delta_C = \delta_B + \Delta L_2 = +0.225 - 0.120 = +0.105\text{ mm} (to the right)
    • Displacement of D (Tip): δD=δC+ΔL3=+0.105+0.300=+0.405 mm\delta_D = \delta_C + \Delta L_3 = +0.105 + 0.300 = +0.405\text{ mm} (to the right)

Independent Recalculation Check:
ΔLtotal=0.225−0.120+0.300=+0.405 mm\Delta L_{\text{total}} = 0.225 - 0.120 + 0.300 = +0.405\text{ mm}. Exact match.


Example 4.2: Tapering Circular Rod vs Arithmetic Mean Approximation (UPSC ESE Level)

Problem Statement:
A linearly tapering circular steel bar of length L=1000 mmL = 1000\text{ mm} has end diameters d1=20 mmd_1 = 20\text{ mm} and d2=40 mmd_2 = 40\text{ mm}. It is subjected to an axial pull of P=30 kNP = 30\text{ kN}. Take E=200 GPaE = 200\text{ GPa}.

  1. Compute the exact elongation (ΔLexact\Delta L_{\text{exact}}) using the derived tapering formula.
  2. An engineer estimates the elongation by replacing the tapering bar with an equivalent prismatic bar having a diameter equal to the arithmetic mean (davg=d1+d22d_{\text{avg}} = \frac{d_1 + d_2}{2}). Compute this approximate elongation (ΔLapprox\Delta L_{\text{approx}}).
  3. Determine the percentage error in the approximation.

Step-by-Step Solution:

  1. Exact Elongation:

    ΔLexact=4PLπd1d2E\Delta L_{\text{exact}} = \frac{4 P L}{\pi d_1 d_2 E} ΔLexact=4×(30,000 N)×(1000 mm)π×(20 mm)×(40 mm)×(200,000 N/mm2)\Delta L_{\text{exact}} = \frac{4 \times (30,000\text{ N}) \times (1000\text{ mm})}{\pi \times (20\text{ mm}) \times (40\text{ mm}) \times (200,000\text{ N/mm}^2)} Numerator=120,000,000\text{Numerator} = 120,000,000 Denominator=π×800×200,000=160,000,000π≈502,654,824.57\text{Denominator} = \pi \times 800 \times 200,000 = 160,000,000 \pi \approx 502,654,824.57 ΔLexact=120,000,000502,654,824.57=0.238732 mm≈0.2387 mm\Delta L_{\text{exact}} = \frac{120,000,000}{502,654,824.57} = 0.238732\text{ mm} \approx 0.2387\text{ mm}
  2. Approximate Elongation using Arithmetic Mean Diameter (davgd_{\text{avg}}):

    davg=20+402=30 mmd_{\text{avg}} = \frac{20 + 40}{2} = 30\text{ mm}

    Area: Aavg=π4(30)2=225π≈706.8583 mm2A_{\text{avg}} = \frac{\pi}{4} (30)^2 = 225 \pi \approx 706.8583\text{ mm}^2.

    ΔLapprox=PLAavgE=30,000×1000(225π)×200,000=30,000,00045,000,000π=23π≈0.212207 mm\Delta L_{\text{approx}} = \frac{P L}{A_{\text{avg}} E} = \frac{30,000 \times 1000}{(225 \pi) \times 200,000} = \frac{30,000,000}{45,000,000 \pi} = \frac{2}{3\pi} \approx 0.212207\text{ mm}
  3. Percentage Error:

    % Error=ΔLapprox−ΔLexactΔLexact×100=0.212207−0.2387320.238732×100=−0.0265250.238732×100=−11.11%\% \text{ Error} = \frac{\Delta L_{\text{approx}} - \Delta L_{\text{exact}}}{\Delta L_{\text{exact}}} \times 100 = \frac{0.212207 - 0.238732}{0.238732} \times 100 = \frac{-0.026525}{0.238732} \times 100 = -11.11\%

Critical Insight:
The arithmetic mean approximation underestimates the true elongation by 11.11%11.11\%!
Why? Because flexibility depends on 1/d21/d^2. The thinner end (20 mm20\text{ mm}) deforms substantially more than the thicker end (40 mm40\text{ mm}), so taking an arithmetic average of diameter drastically underweights the flexible thin end.


Example 4.3: Vertical Steel Drill Pipe under Self-Weight and End Hook Load (SSC JE / State AE)

Problem Statement:
A vertical steel well drill pipe has length L=500 mL = 500\text{ m}, cross-sectional area A=4000 mm2A = 4000\text{ mm}^2, and unit weight γ=78.5 kN/m3=7.85×10−5 N/mm3\gamma = 78.5\text{ kN/m}^3 = 7.85 \times 10^{-5}\text{ N/mm}^3. It carries a concentrated hook load of P0=120 kNP_0 = 120\text{ kN} at its bottom end. Take E=200 GPa=2×105 N/mm2E = 200\text{ GPa} = 2 \times 10^5\text{ N/mm}^2.
Calculate:

  1. The total weight (WW) of the drill pipe.
  2. The total elongation (ΔL\Delta L) of the drill pipe due to combined self-weight and bottom hook load.
  3. The maximum tensile stress (σmax⁡\sigma_{\max}) and its location.

Step-by-Step Solution:

  1. Total Weight of the Pipe (WW): Length L=500 m=500,000 mmL = 500\text{ m} = 500,000\text{ mm}.
    Volume V=A×L=4000 mm2×500,000 mm=2×109 mm3=2.0 m3V = A \times L = 4000\text{ mm}^2 \times 500,000\text{ mm} = 2 \times 10^9\text{ mm}^3 = 2.0\text{ m}^3.

    W=γ×V=(78.5 kN/m3)×(2.0 m3)=157.0 kN=157,000 NW = \gamma \times V = (78.5\text{ kN/m}^3) \times (2.0\text{ m}^3) = 157.0\text{ kN} = 157,000\text{ N}
  2. Total Combined Elongation (ΔL\Delta L): By superposition: ΔL=ΔLself-weight+ΔLhook load\Delta L = \Delta L_{\text{self-weight}} + \Delta L_{\text{hook load}}.

    • Self-weight contribution: ΔLself-weight=WL2AE=(157,000 N)×(500,000 mm)2×(4000 mm2)×(200,000 N/mm2)=78,500,000,0001,600,000,000=49.0625 mm\Delta L_{\text{self-weight}} = \frac{W L}{2 A E} = \frac{(157,000\text{ N}) \times (500,000\text{ mm})}{2 \times (4000\text{ mm}^2) \times (200,000\text{ N/mm}^2)} = \frac{78,500,000,000}{1,600,000,000} = 49.0625\text{ mm}
    • Hook load contribution (P0=120 kN=120,000 NP_0 = 120\text{ kN} = 120,000\text{ N}): ΔLhook load=P0LAE=(120,000 N)×(500,000 mm)(4000 mm2)×(200,000 N/mm2)=60,000,000,000800,000,000=75.000 mm\Delta L_{\text{hook load}} = \frac{P_0 L}{A E} = \frac{(120,000\text{ N}) \times (500,000\text{ mm})}{(4000\text{ mm}^2) \times (200,000\text{ N/mm}^2)} = \frac{60,000,000,000}{800,000,000} = 75.000\text{ mm}
    • Total Elongation: ΔL=49.0625 mm+75.000 mm=124.0625 mm≈124.06 mm\Delta L = 49.0625\text{ mm} + 75.000\text{ mm} = 124.0625\text{ mm} \approx 124.06\text{ mm}
  3. Maximum Tensile Stress (σmax⁡\sigma_{\max}): Occurs at the top fixed suspension collar (x=Lx = L), where it must support the entire pipe weight plus the bottom hook load:

    Pmax⁡=W+P0=157 kN+120 kN=277 kN=277,000 NP_{\max} = W + P_0 = 157\text{ kN} + 120\text{ kN} = 277\text{ kN} = 277,000\text{ N} σmax⁡=Pmax⁡A=277,000 N4000 mm2=69.25 N/mm2=69.25 MPa\sigma_{\max} = \frac{P_{\max}}{A} = \frac{277,000\text{ N}}{4000\text{ mm}^2} = 69.25\text{ N/mm}^2 = 69.25\text{ MPa}

Verification Check: At bottom tip (x=0x = 0): σmin⁡=P0A=120,0004000=30.0 MPa\sigma_{\min} = \frac{P_0}{A} = \frac{120,000}{4000} = 30.0\text{ MPa}. Stress increases linearly from 30.0 MPa30.0\text{ MPa} at bottom to 69.25 MPa69.25\text{ MPa} at top. Recalculations exact.


7. Common Pitfalls & Competitive Exam Traps

[!WARNING] Trap 1: Forgetting that Self-Weight Elongation is WL2AE\frac{WL}{2AE}, NOT WLAE\frac{WL}{AE}
In SSC JE and RRB JE objective questions, options almost always include both WLAE\frac{WL}{AE} and WL2AE\frac{WL}{2AE}.
Remember: Internal force under self-weight varies linearly from 00 to WW. The average force is W/2W/2, producing exactly half the elongation of an end load.

[!WARNING] Trap 2: The Conical Bar Elongation Ratio
When comparing a conical bar to a prismatic bar under self-weight:

  • If compared based on same length and top base area: ΔLcone=13ΔLprismatic=γL26E\Delta L_{\text{cone}} = \frac{1}{3} \Delta L_{\text{prismatic}} = \frac{\gamma L^2}{6E}.
  • If compared based on same total weight WW: ΔLcone=WL2AbE=ΔLprismatic\Delta L_{\text{cone}} = \frac{WL}{2 A_b E} = \Delta L_{\text{prismatic}}!
    Pay meticulous attention to whether the question states "same dimensions" or "same weight".

[!WARNING] Trap 3: Arithmetic Mean vs Geometric Mean in Tapering Bars
In GATE NAT questions, if a problem asks for equivalent diameter deqd_{\text{eq}}, never use d1+d22\frac{d_1 + d_2}{2}. The exact equivalent diameter is d1d2\sqrt{d_1 d_2}.


8. Quick Revision Formula Box

Prismatic Bar under Point Load:ΔL=PLAEStepped Bar Superposition:ΔLtotal=∑i=1nPiLiAiEiPrismatic Bar under Self-Weight:ΔL=γL22E=WL2AEConical Bar under Self-Weight:ΔL=γL26E=WL2AbaseERatio (Conical to Prismatic, same L,γ):ΔLconeΔLprism=13Circular Tapering Bar:ΔL=4PLπd1d2E(deq=d1d2)Rectangular Tapering Plate (Const t):ΔL=PLtE(b2−b1)ln⁡(b2b1)Bar of Uniform Strength:A(x)=A0eγxσ\begin{aligned} \text{Prismatic Bar under Point Load:} \quad \Delta L &= \frac{PL}{AE} \\ \text{Stepped Bar Superposition:} \quad \Delta L_{\text{total}} &= \sum_{i=1}^n \frac{P_i L_i}{A_i E_i} \\ \text{Prismatic Bar under Self-Weight:} \quad \Delta L &= \frac{\gamma L^2}{2E} = \frac{WL}{2AE} \\ \text{Conical Bar under Self-Weight:} \quad \Delta L &= \frac{\gamma L^2}{6E} = \frac{WL}{2 A_{\text{base}} E} \\ \text{Ratio (Conical to Prismatic, same } L, \gamma): \quad \frac{\Delta L_{\text{cone}}}{\Delta L_{\text{prism}}} &= \frac{1}{3} \\ \text{Circular Tapering Bar:} \quad \Delta L &= \frac{4PL}{\pi d_1 d_2 E} \quad (d_{\text{eq}} = \sqrt{d_1 d_2}) \\ \text{Rectangular Tapering Plate (Const } t): \quad \Delta L &= \frac{PL}{t E (b_2 - b_1)} \ln\left(\frac{b_2}{b_1}\right) \\ \text{Bar of Uniform Strength:} \quad A(x) &= A_0 e^{\frac{\gamma x}{\sigma}} \end{aligned}

9. References & Source Literature

  1. Gere, J. M., & Goodno, B. J. (2018). Mechanics of Materials, 9th Edition, Cengage Learning, Boston.
  2. Timoshenko, S. P. (1953). History of Strength of Materials, McGraw-Hill, New York.
  3. Punmia, B. C., Jain, A. K., & Jain, A. K. (2017). Mechanics of Materials, 15th Edition, Laxmi Publications, New Delhi.
  4. Bhavikatti, S. S. (2019). Strength of Materials, 4th Edition, Vikas Publishing House, New Delhi.