SOM-06-01 Chapter 06 · Torsion of Shafts

Pure Torsion Formula & Kinematics of Circular Shafts

In this chapter (3 topics)
On this page
  1. 1. Topic Metadata & Scope
  2. 2. Physical Mechanics & Theoretical Foundation
  3. 2.1 The Concept of Pure Torsion
  4. 2.2 Why Circular Shafts Behave Differently from Non-Circular Shafts
  5. 3. Kinematics & Derivations of the Torsion Formula
  6. 3.1 Fundamental Assumptions of Pure Torsion in Circular Shafts
  7. 3.2 Kinematic Derivation of Torsional Shear Strain (γ)
  8. 3.3 Hooke's Law in Shear & Shear Stress Distribution
  9. 3.4 Internal Resisting Torque Equilibrium & Polar Moment of Inertia (J)
  10. 3.5 The Universal Torsion Equation
  11. 4. Torsional Section Properties & Parameter Definitions
  12. 4.1 Polar Moment of Inertia (J)
  13. 4.2 Polar Section Modulus (Zp)
  14. 4.3 Torsional Rigidity, Stiffness, and Flexibility
  15. 4.4 Power Transmission by Rotating Shafts
  16. 5. State of Stress & Contrasting Material Failure Modes
  17. 5.1 Stress Tensor on the Surface of a Shaft in Torsion
  18. 5.2 Mohr's Circle Analysis & Helical Principal Planes
  19. 5.3 Contrasting Failure Modes: Ductile vs. Brittle Materials
  20. 6. SVG Technical Illustrations
  21. Figure 1: Kinematic Deformation of Circular Shafts Under Pure Torsion
  22. Figure 2: Polar Shear Stress Distribution Across Solid and Hollow Shafts
  23. 7. Python-Recalculated Solved Numerical Examples
  24. Numerical Example 1: Transmission Drive Shaft Sizing (Strength vs. Stiffness)
  25. Numerical Example 2: Stepped Circular Shaft with Intermediate Torques
  26. Numerical Example 3: Weight Economy & Performance of Hollow vs. Solid Shafts
  27. 8. Practical Engineering Applications & Structural Design Considerations
  28. 9. Comparative Analysis & Summary Matrix
  29. 10. Key Takeaways & Exam-Oriented Highlights
  30. 11. Common Traps, Pitfalls & Counter-Intuitive Exam Scenarios
  31. 12. Standard Code Provisions & Objective Practice Problems
  32. Reference Code Clauses
  33. Objective Practice Problems

1. Topic Metadata & Scope

Attribute Specification
Topic ID SOM-06-01
Chapter Chapter 06: Torsion of Circular Shafts (06_torsion_of_shafts)
Subject Strength of Materials (Solid Mechanics)
Target Examinations GATE CE, UPSC ESE, SSC JE, State AE, RRB JE
Prerequisites SOM-01-01 (Concept of Stress, Strain & Shear Modulus GG), SOM-04-01 (Flexure Analogy), SOM-04-02 (Second Moment of Area & Polar Moment of Inertia JJ)
Authoritative Reference Codes IS 2494 (Shaft Design Principles), IS 800:2007 (General Construction in Steel — Torsional Warping & Section Properties), ASME Code for Design of Transmission Shafting
Key Terminology Pure torsion, angle of twist (θ\theta), torsional shear strain (γ\gamma), polar moment of inertia (JJ), polar section modulus (ZpZ_p), torsional rigidity (GJGJ), torsional stiffness (ktk_t), power transmission equation (P=2πNT/60P = 2\pi NT/60), helical tensile fracture

2. Physical Mechanics & Theoretical Foundation

2.1 The Concept of Pure Torsion

Torsion refers to the twisting of a structural member or machine component when it is subjected to a couple or moment that acts about its longitudinal centroidal axis. This twisting moment is called a Torque (TT) or Twisting Couple:

T=F⋅d[N⋅m or N⋅mm]T = F \cdot d \quad [\text{N}\cdot\text{m} \text{ or } \text{N}\cdot\text{mm}]

A shaft is said to be in a state of Pure Torsion when:

  1. The twisting moment TT is applied uniformly at the ends of the shaft without any concurrent transverse shear forces (V=0V = 0) or bending moments (M=0M = 0).
  2. The cross-section is uniform along its entire length (prismatic shaft).
  3. The internal resisting actions on any transverse cut section consist exclusively of a pure internal twisting moment.

2.2 Why Circular Shafts Behave Differently from Non-Circular Shafts

The mathematical simplicity of circular shaft torsion arises from axial symmetry (axisymmetry):

  • In a circular or annular (hollow) shaft, every point on a concentric circle is geometrically indistinguishable from every other point. When twisted, cross-sections merely rotate as rigid discs about the central axis.
  • Zero Out-of-Plane Warping: Circular cross-sections remain strictly flat and plane after twisting. Longitudinal lines become helical, but cross-sectional planes do not bulge, buckle, or warp out of their initial planes.
  • Non-Circular Shafts (Rectangles, Ellipses, I-Beams): In sharp contrast, non-circular sections lack axisymmetry. When twisted, their cross-sections experience severe out-of-plane warping (St. Venant warping). Consequently, the elementary circular torsion formula cannot be applied to rectangular or structural steel I-sections without major warping corrections.

3. Kinematics & Derivations of the Torsion Formula

3.1 Fundamental Assumptions of Pure Torsion in Circular Shafts

  1. Plane Sections Remain Plane: Cross-sections perpendicular to the longitudinal axis remain flat, plane, and circular after twisting (no out-of-plane warping).
  2. Radial Lines Remain Straight: Any straight radial line on a cross-section remains straight and merely rotates through an angle of twist θ\theta.
  3. Axisymmetry of Deformation: The shaft twists uniformly along its length; concentric circles on the cross-section remain concentric circles of unchanged radius.
  4. Homogeneous, Isotropic & Linear Elastic: The material obeys Hooke's law in shear (τ=Gγ\tau = G \gamma), and the proportional limit is nowhere exceeded.
  5. Small Deformations: The angle of twist per unit length is small, such that tan⁡γ≈γ\tan\gamma \approx \gamma and sin⁡θ≈θ\sin\theta \approx \theta.

3.2 Kinematic Derivation of Torsional Shear Strain (γ\gamma)

Consider a circular shaft of length LL and radius R=D/2R = D/2 fixed against rotation at the left end (x=0x = 0) and subjected to an external torque TT at the free right end (x=Lx = L).

       Fixed End                                         Free End
      +---------+=======================================+---------+
      |/////////| A-----------------------------------B |         |  ^
      |/////////|  \                                    |    O    |  | R
      |/////////|   \---------------------------------B'|    •    |  v
      +---------+=======================================+---------+
      |<----------------------- L --------------------->|
  1. Consider a longitudinal line ABAB on the outer cylindrical surface of the shaft prior to the application of torque, where AA is at the fixed end and BB is at the free end.
  2. When the torque TT is applied, the cross-section at the free end rotates rigidly through an Angle of Twist θ\theta (measured in radians).
  3. The point BB on the outer circumference moves along a circular arc to position B′B'. The length of this circular arc at the end face is: Arc BB′=R⋅θ\text{Arc } BB' = R \cdot \theta
  4. Simultaneously, the longitudinal line ABAB deforms into a helical curve AB′AB'. Because the angle of distortion is very small, the engineering shear strain γmax⁡\gamma_{\max} of the surface fiber at AA is: tan⁡γmax⁡≈γmax⁡=Arc BB′AB=R⋅θL\tan\gamma_{\max} \approx \gamma_{\max} = \frac{\text{Arc } BB'}{AB} = \frac{R \cdot \theta}{L}
  5. Now consider an internal cylindrical layer of radius rr (0≤r≤R0 \le r \le R). The radial line from the center OO to radius rr rotates through the exact same angle of twist θ\theta. The arc displacement at radius rr is r⋅θr \cdot \theta. Therefore, the shear strain γ(r)\gamma(r) at any radial distance rr from the longitudinal axis is:
γ(r)=r⋅θL\gamma(r) = \frac{r \cdot \theta}{L}

[!IMPORTANT] The torsional shear strain γ(r)\gamma(r) in a circular shaft is identically zero at the longitudinal axis (r=0r = 0) and increases strictly linearly with radius to reach its maximum value γmax⁡=RθL\gamma_{\max} = \frac{R\theta}{L} at the outermost surface (r=Rr = R).


3.3 Hooke's Law in Shear & Shear Stress Distribution

Since the material is linear elastic, the relationship between shear stress τ(r)\tau(r) and shear strain γ(r)\gamma(r) is governed by Hooke's law in shear:

τ(r)=G⋅γ(r)\tau(r) = G \cdot \gamma(r)

Where GG is the Shear Modulus (Modulus of Rigidity) of the material [N/mm2 or MPa][\text{N/mm}^2 \text{ or } \text{MPa}].

Substituting the kinematic shear strain equation:

τ(r)=G(r⋅θL)=(G⋅θL)r\tau(r) = G \left(\frac{r \cdot \theta}{L}\right) = \left(\frac{G \cdot \theta}{L}\right) r

Dividing both sides by the radial coordinate rr:

τ(r)r=τmax⁡R=G⋅θL\frac{\tau(r)}{r} = \frac{\tau_{\max}}{R} = \frac{G \cdot \theta}{L}

This demonstrates that the shear stress τ(r)\tau(r) varies strictly linearly with radial distance rr from the center of the shaft.


3.4 Internal Resisting Torque Equilibrium & Polar Moment of Inertia (JJ)

To establish equilibrium, the sum of moments of all internal tangential shearing stresses across the cross-section must equal the externally applied torque TT.

Consider a thin elemental concentric annular ring of radius rr, radial thickness drdr, and elemental cross-sectional area:

dA=2πr drdA = 2\pi r \, dr
  1. The shear stress acting tangentially on this elemental ring is τ(r)=τmax⁡Rr\tau(r) = \frac{\tau_{\max}}{R} r.
  2. The internal tangential shear force dFdF acting on this elemental ring is: dF=τ(r) dA=(τmax⁡Rr)dAdF = \tau(r) \, dA = \left(\frac{\tau_{\max}}{R} r\right) dA
  3. Because this shear force acts tangentially at radius rr from the center of the shaft, its internal resisting torque dTdT about the central axis is: dT=r⋅dF=r⋅(τmax⁡Rr dA)=τmax⁡Rr2 dAdT = r \cdot dF = r \cdot \left(\frac{\tau_{\max}}{R} r \, dA\right) = \frac{\tau_{\max}}{R} r^2 \, dA
  4. Integrating over the entire cross-sectional area AA gives the total internal resisting torque TT: T=∫AdT=τmax⁡R∫Ar2 dAT = \int_A dT = \frac{\tau_{\max}}{R} \int_A r^2 \, dA

The integral ∫Ar2 dA\int_A r^2 \, dA is defined mathematically as the Polar Second Moment of Area (Polar Moment of Inertia), denoted by JJ:

J=∫Ar2 dA=∬(x2+y2) dA=Ixx+IyyJ = \int_A r^2 \, dA = \iint (x^2 + y^2) \, dA = I_{xx} + I_{yy}

Therefore:

T=τmax⁡R⋅J  ⟹  TJ=τmax⁡RT = \frac{\tau_{\max}}{R} \cdot J \implies \frac{T}{J} = \frac{\tau_{\max}}{R}

For any arbitrary radial coordinate rr:

TJ=τ(r)r\frac{T}{J} = \frac{\tau(r)}{r}

3.5 The Universal Torsion Equation

Combining the kinematic-elastic relation and the equilibrium relation yields the Universal Torsion Formula for Circular Shafts:

TJ=τr=G⋅θL\frac{T}{J} = \frac{\tau}{r} = \frac{G \cdot \theta}{L}

Where:

  • TT = Applied twisting moment [N⋅mm][\text{N}\cdot\text{mm}]
  • JJ = Polar moment of inertia of the cross-section [mm4][\text{mm}^4]
  • τ\tau = Shear stress at radial distance rr from the central axis [N/mm2 or MPa][\text{N/mm}^2 \text{ or } \text{MPa}]
  • rr = Radial distance of the point from the center [mm][\text{mm}]
  • GG = Shear modulus of rigidity [N/mm2 or MPa][\text{N/mm}^2 \text{ or } \text{MPa}]
  • θ\theta = Angle of twist over length LL [radians][\text{radians}]
  • LL = Length of the shaft segment [mm][\text{mm}]

4. Torsional Section Properties & Parameter Definitions

4.1 Polar Moment of Inertia (JJ)

  • Solid Circular Shaft of Diameter DD (Radius R=D/2R = D/2): J=∫0Rr2(2πr dr)=2π[r44]0R=πR42=πD432≈0.09817⋅D4J = \int_0^R r^2 (2\pi r \, dr) = 2\pi \left[\frac{r^4}{4}\right]_0^R = \frac{\pi R^4}{2} = \frac{\pi D^4}{32} \approx 0.09817 \cdot D^4
  • Hollow Circular Shaft (Outer Diameter DoD_o, Inner Diameter did_i, ratio k=di/Dok = d_i / D_o): J=π(Do4−di4)32=πDo4(1−k4)32J = \frac{\pi (D_o^4 - d_i^4)}{32} = \frac{\pi D_o^4 (1 - k^4)}{32}

4.2 Polar Section Modulus (ZpZ_p)

Analogous to the elastic flexural section modulus Z=I/ymax⁡Z = I / y_{\max}, the Polar Section Modulus ZpZ_p measures the geometric capacity of a shaft to resist torsion for a given allowable shear stress τallow\tau_{\text{allow}}:

Zp=Jrmax⁡Z_p = \frac{J}{r_{\max}}

The maximum torque that a shaft can safely transmit based on strength criteria is:

Tsafe=τallow⋅ZpT_{\text{safe}} = \tau_{\text{allow}} \cdot Z_p
  • Solid Circular Shaft: Zp=πD432D2=πD316≈0.19635⋅D3Z_p = \frac{\frac{\pi D^4}{32}}{\frac{D}{2}} = \frac{\pi D^3}{16} \approx 0.19635 \cdot D^3
  • Hollow Circular Shaft: Zp=π(Do4−di4)32Do2=π(Do4−di4)16Do=πDo3(1−k4)16Z_p = \frac{\frac{\pi (D_o^4 - d_i^4)}{32}}{\frac{D_o}{2}} = \frac{\pi (D_o^4 - d_i^4)}{16 D_o} = \frac{\pi D_o^3 (1 - k^4)}{16}

4.3 Torsional Rigidity, Stiffness, and Flexibility

  1. Torsional Rigidity (G⋅JG \cdot J):
    The product of shear modulus GG and polar moment of inertia JJ. It represents the resistance of the cross-section to angular twisting [N⋅mm2][\text{N}\cdot\text{mm}^2].
  2. Torsional Stiffness (ktk_t):
    The torque required to produce a unit angle of twist (1 radian1\text{ radian}) over the shaft length LL: kt=Tθ=G⋅JL[N⋅mm/rad]k_t = \frac{T}{\theta} = \frac{G \cdot J}{L} \quad [\text{N}\cdot\text{mm/rad}]
  3. Torsional Flexibility (ftf_t):
    The reciprocal of torsional stiffness; the angle of twist produced by a unit torque: ft=1kt=θT=LG⋅J[rad/N⋅mm]f_t = \frac{1}{k_t} = \frac{\theta}{T} = \frac{L}{G \cdot J} \quad [\text{rad/N}\cdot\text{mm}]

4.4 Power Transmission by Rotating Shafts

In civil engineering machinery (generators, hydraulic pumps, turbine drive shafts, conveyor drives), shafts rotate at speed NN [rpm][\text{rpm}] and transmit power PP [Watts][\text{Watts}]:

The angular velocity ω\omega in radians per second:

ω=2πN60[rad/s]\omega = \frac{2\pi N}{60} \quad [\text{rad/s}]

Power transmitted:

P=T⋅ω=2πNT60[Watts]P = T \cdot \omega = \frac{2\pi N T}{60} \quad [\text{Watts}]

Rearranging for the design twisting moment TT:

T=60⋅P2πN[N⋅m]=60⋅P2πN×103[N⋅mm]T = \frac{60 \cdot P}{2\pi N} \quad [\text{N}\cdot\text{m}] = \frac{60 \cdot P}{2\pi N} \times 10^3 \quad [\text{N}\cdot\text{mm}]

If power is expressed in kilowatts (PkWP_{\text{kW}}):

T=9550⋅PkWN[N⋅m]T = \frac{9550 \cdot P_{\text{kW}}}{N} \quad [\text{N}\cdot\text{m}]

5. State of Stress & Contrasting Material Failure Modes

5.1 Stress Tensor on the Surface of a Shaft in Torsion

Consider an infinitesimal element on the outer cylindrical surface of a shaft subjected to pure torque TT:

  • On the transverse plane (perpendicular to the shaft axis): Normal stress σx=0\sigma_x = 0, shear stress τxy=τmax⁡\tau_{xy} = \tau_{\max}.
  • On the longitudinal plane (parallel to the shaft axis): By Cauchy's complementary shear law, an identical shear stress τyx=τmax⁡\tau_{yx} = \tau_{\max} acts along the length.
  • Normal stress σy=0\sigma_y = 0.

This represents a state of Pure Shear.

             Transverse Plane (x-face)
                   +--------+   ^
                   |        |   | tau
             <---  |        |  ---> tau
             tau   |        |
                   +--------+
                        v tau

5.2 Mohr's Circle Analysis & Helical Principal Planes

Plotting this pure shear state on Mohr's circle:

  • Center of circle: σavg=σx+σy2=0\sigma_{\text{avg}} = \frac{\sigma_x + \sigma_y}{2} = 0
  • Radius of circle: RMohr=(σx−σy2)2+τxy2=τmax⁡R_{\text{Mohr}} = \sqrt{\left(\frac{\sigma_x - \sigma_y}{2}\right)^2 + \tau_{xy}^2} = \tau_{\max}
  • Principal Stresses: σ1=+τmax⁡(Pure Uniaxial Tension)\sigma_1 = +\tau_{\max} \quad (\text{Pure Uniaxial Tension}) σ2=−τmax⁡(Pure Uniaxial Compression)\sigma_2 = -\tau_{\max} \quad (\text{Pure Uniaxial Compression}) σ3=0\sigma_3 = 0
  • Principal Plane Orientation: tan⁡2θp=2τxyσx−σy=2τ0=∞  ⟹  2θp=90∘  ⟹  θp=45∘\tan 2\theta_p = \frac{2\tau_{xy}}{\sigma_x - \sigma_y} = \frac{2\tau}{0} = \infty \implies 2\theta_p = 90^\circ \implies \theta_p = 45^\circ

The principal planes are oriented at 45∘45^\circ to the longitudinal axis of the shaft.

                     45° Helical Plane
                        /  ^  /
                       /  /  /  sigma_1 = +tau (Tension)
                      /  /  /
                     /  v  /

5.3 Contrasting Failure Modes: Ductile vs. Brittle Materials

The state of pure shear explains the fundamentally different failure patterns observed in practice and frequently tested in competitive examinations:

  1. Ductile Materials (Mild Steel, Structural Aluminum, Copper):
    • Ductile metals are weak in shear but strong in tension.
    • Failure occurs when the maximum shear stress reaches the shear yield strength (τmax⁡=τy\tau_{\max} = \tau_y).
    • Failure Surface: Fails along a transverse cross-sectional plane at 90∘90^\circ to the shaft axis by ductile sliding and shear cup-and-cone formation.
  2. Brittle Materials (Cast Iron, Plain Concrete, Geotechnical Rock Cores, Blackboard Chalk):
    • Brittle materials are exceptionally weak in tension (tensile strength is typically only 10% to 15%10\% \text{ to } 15\% of compressive strength) and fail by tensile cleavage fracture rather than shear slip.
    • Because the maximum tensile stress σ1=+τmax⁡\sigma_1 = +\tau_{\max} acts perpendicular to planes inclined at 45∘45^\circ, the material fractures along a 45∘45^\circ helical spiral surface.
    • Exam Observation: When a stick of classroom chalk is twisted by hand, it invariably breaks along a smooth 45∘45^\circ helical fracture line.

6. SVG Technical Illustrations

Figure 1: Kinematic Deformation of Circular Shafts Under Pure Torsion

The diagram below shows the kinematic deformation of a circular shaft, showing longitudinal line distortion, angle of twist θ\theta, engineering shear strain γ\gamma, and the 45∘45^\circ principal tensile helical failure mechanism.

Kinematics of Circular Shafts Under Pure Torsion

Figure 2: Polar Shear Stress Distribution Across Solid and Hollow Shafts

The diagram below compares the radial shear stress distribution between a solid shaft and a hollow circular shaft, illustrating the extreme material inefficiency of the central core.

Polar Shear Stress Distribution Across Solid and Hollow Circular Shafts

7. Python-Recalculated Solved Numerical Examples

Numerical Example 1: Transmission Drive Shaft Sizing (Strength vs. Stiffness)

Problem Statement:
A solid steel drive shaft rotates at N=300 rpmN = 300\text{ rpm} and transmits P=75 kWP = 75\text{ kW} of mechanical power. The shaft is L=2.5 mL = 2.5\text{ m} long, and its material has a shear modulus G=80 GPa=80,000 MPaG = 80\text{ GPa} = 80,000\text{ MPa}. The design criteria specify:

  1. Maximum allowable shear stress τallow=60 MPa\tau_{\text{allow}} = 60\text{ MPa}.
  2. Maximum allowable angle of twist θallow=1.0∘\theta_{\text{allow}} = 1.0^\circ over the entire 2.5 m2.5\text{ m} length.

Calculate:

  • The required shaft diameter based on strength criteria (DstrengthD_{\text{strength}}).
  • The required shaft diameter based on torsional stiffness/rigidity criteria (DstiffnessD_{\text{stiffness}}).
  • The governing minimum diameter, select an appropriate commercial size (rounded up to the next integer millimeter), and compute the actual maximum shear stress and actual angle of twist for the selected shaft.

Step-by-Step Solution:

  1. Torque Transmitted by the Shaft:

    ω=2πN60=2π(300)60=10π=31.4159 rad/s\omega = \frac{2\pi N}{60} = \frac{2\pi (300)}{60} = 10\pi = 31.4159\text{ rad/s} T=Pω=75,000 W31.4159 rad/s=2,387.3241 N⋅m=2,387,324.15 N⋅mmT = \frac{P}{\omega} = \frac{75,000\text{ W}}{31.4159\text{ rad/s}} = 2,387.3241\text{ N}\cdot\text{m} = 2,387,324.15\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm}
  2. Diameter Based on Strength Criteria:

    τmax⁡=TZp=16TπD3≤τallow\tau_{\max} = \frac{T}{Z_p} = \frac{16 T}{\pi D^3} \le \tau_{\text{allow}} Dstrength≥(16⋅Tπ⋅τallow)1/3=(16×2,387,324.15π×60)1/3=(38,197,186.4188.4956)1/3=(202,642.36)1/3=58.7368 mmD_{\text{strength}} \ge \left(\frac{16 \cdot T}{\pi \cdot \tau_{\text{allow}}}\right)^{1/3} = \left(\frac{16 \times 2,387,324.15}{\pi \times 60}\right)^{1/3} = \left(\frac{38,197,186.4}{188.4956}\right)^{1/3} = (202,642.36)^{1/3} = 58.7368\text{ mm}
  3. Diameter Based on Torsional Stiffness (Angle of Twist):

    θallow=1.0∘=1.0×π180=0.0174533 radians\theta_{\text{allow}} = 1.0^\circ = 1.0 \times \frac{\pi}{180} = 0.0174533\text{ radians} θ=T⋅LG⋅J=T⋅LG⋅(πD432)=32⋅T⋅Lπ⋅G⋅D4≤θallow\theta = \frac{T \cdot L}{G \cdot J} = \frac{T \cdot L}{G \cdot \left(\frac{\pi D^4}{32}\right)} = \frac{32 \cdot T \cdot L}{\pi \cdot G \cdot D^4} \le \theta_{\text{allow}} Dstiffness≥(32⋅T⋅Lπ⋅G⋅θallow)1/4=(32×2,387,324.15×2,500π×80,000×0.0174533)1/4D_{\text{stiffness}} \ge \left(\frac{32 \cdot T \cdot L}{\pi \cdot G \cdot \theta_{\text{allow}}}\right)^{1/4} = \left(\frac{32 \times 2,387,324.15 \times 2,500}{\pi \times 80,000 \times 0.0174533}\right)^{1/4} Numerator=1.909859×1011\text{Numerator} = 1.909859 \times 10^{11} Denominator=4,386.491\text{Denominator} = 4,386.491 NumeratorDenominator=43,539,566.27\frac{\text{Numerator}}{\text{Denominator}} = 43,539,566.27 Dstiffness≥(43,539,566.27)1/4=81.2309 mmD_{\text{stiffness}} \ge (43,539,566.27)^{1/4} = 81.2309\text{ mm}
  4. Governing Diameter & Commercial Selection: Comparing the two requirements:

    • Strength requires D≥58.74 mmD \ge 58.74\text{ mm}
    • Stiffness requires D≥81.23 mmD \ge 81.23\text{ mm}
    Dgov=max⁡(58.74,81.23)=81.2309 mm(Stiffness governs!)D_{\text{gov}} = \max(58.74, 81.23) = 81.2309\text{ mm} \quad (\mathbf{Stiffness \ governs!})

    Select commercial integer diameter: D=82 mmD = 82\text{ mm}.

  5. Actual Performance with D=82 mmD = 82\text{ mm}:

    J=π(82)432=4.4382×106 mm4J = \frac{\pi (82)^4}{32} = 4.4382 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^4 Zp=π(82)316=108,249.20 mm3Z_p = \frac{\pi (82)^3}{16} = 108,249.20\text{ mm}^3 τactual=TZp=2,387,324.15108,249.20=22.0516 MPa(≪60 MPa)\tau_{\text{actual}} = \frac{T}{Z_p} = \frac{2,387,324.15}{108,249.20} = 22.0516\text{ MPa} \quad (\ll 60\text{ MPa}) θactual=T⋅LG⋅J=2,387,324.15×2,50080,000×4.4382×106=0.016807 rad=0.9630∘(<1.0∘)\theta_{\text{actual}} = \frac{T \cdot L}{G \cdot J} = \frac{2,387,324.15 \times 2,500}{80,000 \times 4.4382 \times 10^6} = 0.016807\text{ rad} = 0.9630^\circ \quad (< 1.0^\circ)

Numerical Example 2: Stepped Circular Shaft with Intermediate Torques

Problem Statement:
A stepped circular shaft ABCABC is rigidly clamped at support AA and free at end CC.

  • Segment ABAB: Diameter D1=80 mmD_1 = 80\text{ mm}, Length L1=1.2 m=1,200 mmL_1 = 1.2\text{ m} = 1,200\text{ mm}.
  • Segment BCBC: Diameter D2=60 mmD_2 = 60\text{ mm}, Length L2=1.0 m=1,000 mmL_2 = 1.0\text{ m} = 1,000\text{ mm}.
  • Material: Shear modulus G=80 GPa=80,000 MPaG = 80\text{ GPa} = 80,000\text{ MPa}. Torques applied:
  • At junction BB: TB=3.5 kN⋅m=3.5×106 N⋅mmT_B = 3.5\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} = 3.5 \times 10^6\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} (clockwise).
  • At free end CC: TC=1.5 kN⋅m=1.5×106 N⋅mmT_C = 1.5\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} = 1.5 \times 10^6\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} (clockwise).

Calculate:

  1. The internal torque in segments ABAB and BCBC.
  2. The maximum torsional shear stress in each segment (τAB\tau_{AB} and τBC\tau_{BC}).
  3. The angle of twist at junction BB (θB\theta_B) and the total angle of twist at free end CC (θC\theta_C).
  4. The maximum engineering shear strain in segments ABAB and BCBC.

Step-by-Step Solution:

  1. Internal Torques (Free-Body Sections):

    • Cutting through segment BCBC and considering the free portion to the right: TBC=TC=1.5×106 N⋅mm=1.50 kN⋅mT_{BC} = T_C = 1.5 \times 10^6\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} = 1.50\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}
    • Cutting through segment ABAB and considering the free portion to the right: TAB=TB+TC=3.5×106+1.5×106=5.0×106 N⋅mm=5.00 kN⋅mT_{AB} = T_B + T_C = 3.5 \times 10^6 + 1.5 \times 10^6 = 5.0 \times 10^6\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} = 5.00\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}
  2. Geometric Properties:

    • Segment ABAB (D1=80 mmD_1 = 80\text{ mm}): J1=π(80)432=4.02124×106 mm4J_1 = \frac{\pi (80)^4}{32} = 4.02124 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^4 Zp1=π(80)316=100,530.96 mm3Z_{p1} = \frac{\pi (80)^3}{16} = 100,530.96\text{ mm}^3
    • Segment BCBC (D2=60 mmD_2 = 60\text{ mm}): J2=π(60)432=1.27235×106 mm4J_2 = \frac{\pi (60)^4}{32} = 1.27235 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^4 Zp2=π(60)316=42,411.50 mm3Z_{p2} = \frac{\pi (60)^3}{16} = 42,411.50\text{ mm}^3
  3. Maximum Shear Stresses:

    τAB=TABZp1=5.0×106100,530.96=49.7359 MPa\tau_{AB} = \frac{T_{AB}}{Z_{p1}} = \frac{5.0 \times 10^6}{100,530.96} = 49.7359\text{ MPa} τBC=TBCZp2=1.5×10642,411.50=35.3678 MPa\tau_{BC} = \frac{T_{BC}}{Z_{p2}} = \frac{1.5 \times 10^6}{42,411.50} = 35.3678\text{ MPa}
  4. Angles of Twist:

    • Twist of segment ABAB (which equals angle of twist at BB since AA is fixed): θB=θAB=TAB⋅L1G⋅J1=(5.0×106)×1,20080,000×4.02124×106=6.0×1093.21699×1011=0.018651 rad\theta_B = \theta_{AB} = \frac{T_{AB} \cdot L_1}{G \cdot J_1} = \frac{(5.0 \times 10^6) \times 1,200}{80,000 \times 4.02124 \times 10^6} = \frac{6.0 \times 10^9}{3.21699 \times 10^{11}} = 0.018651\text{ rad} θB=0.018651×180π=1.0686∘\theta_B = 0.018651 \times \frac{180}{\pi} = 1.0686^\circ
    • Twist of segment BCBC relative to BB: θBC=TBC⋅L2G⋅J2=(1.5×106)×1,00080,000×1.27235×106=1.5×1091.01788×1011=0.014736 rad\theta_{BC} = \frac{T_{BC} \cdot L_2}{G \cdot J_2} = \frac{(1.5 \times 10^6) \times 1,000}{80,000 \times 1.27235 \times 10^6} = \frac{1.5 \times 10^9}{1.01788 \times 10^{11}} = 0.014736\text{ rad} θBC=0.014736×180π=0.8443∘\theta_{BC} = 0.014736 \times \frac{180}{\pi} = 0.8443^\circ
    • Total twist at free end CC: θC=θB+θBC=0.018651+0.014736=0.033387 rad=1.0686∘+0.8443∘=1.9130∘\theta_C = \theta_B + \theta_{BC} = 0.018651 + 0.014736 = 0.033387\text{ rad} = 1.0686^\circ + 0.8443^\circ = 1.9130^\circ
  5. Maximum Shear Strains:

    γAB=τABG=49.735980,000=6.21699×10−4\gamma_{AB} = \frac{\tau_{AB}}{G} = \frac{49.7359}{80,000} = 6.21699 \times 10^{-4} γBC=τBCG=35.367880,000=4.42097×10−4\gamma_{BC} = \frac{\tau_{BC}}{G} = \frac{35.3678}{80,000} = 4.42097 \times 10^{-4}

Numerical Example 3: Weight Economy & Performance of Hollow vs. Solid Shafts

Problem Statement:
A solid steel shaft of diameter Ds=100 mmD_s = 100\text{ mm} transmits a torque T=8.0 kN⋅mT = 8.0\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}. The shaft is to be replaced by a hollow circular shaft of the same material (G=80 GPaG = 80\text{ GPa}) with outer diameter Do=120 mmD_o = 120\text{ mm} such that the maximum shear stress in both shafts is identical. Determine:

  1. The maximum shear stress in the solid shaft.
  2. The required internal diameter did_i and the diameter ratio k=di/Dok = d_i / D_o of the hollow shaft.
  3. The percentage weight reduction achieved by switching to the hollow shaft.
  4. The ratio of torsional stiffness (GJ)h/(GJ)s(GJ)_h / (GJ)_s between the two shafts.
  5. The angle of twist per meter length for both shafts.

Step-by-Step Solution:

  1. Solid Shaft Performance:

    Zps=πDs316=π(100)316=196,349.54 mm3Z_{ps} = \frac{\pi D_s^3}{16} = \frac{\pi (100)^3}{16} = 196,349.54\text{ mm}^3 Js=πDs432=π(100)432=9.81748×106 mm4J_s = \frac{\pi D_s^4}{32} = \frac{\pi (100)^4}{32} = 9.81748 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^4 τs=TZps=8.0×106 N⋅mm196,349.54 mm3=40.7437 MPa\tau_s = \frac{T}{Z_{ps}} = \frac{8.0 \times 10^6\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm}}{196,349.54\text{ mm}^3} = 40.7437\text{ MPa} As=πDs24=π(100)24=7,853.98 mm2A_s = \frac{\pi D_s^2}{4} = \frac{\pi (100)^2}{4} = 7,853.98\text{ mm}^2
  2. Required Internal Diameter of Hollow Shaft: For equal strength under the same torque TT, the polar section moduli must be identical (Zph=ZpsZ_{ph} = Z_{ps}):

    Zph=πDo3(1−k4)16=Zps=πDs316Z_{ph} = \frac{\pi D_o^3 (1 - k^4)}{16} = Z_{ps} = \frac{\pi D_s^3}{16} Do3(1−k4)=Ds3  ⟹  1−k4=(DsDo)3=(100120)3=(0.833333)3=0.578704D_o^3 (1 - k^4) = D_s^3 \implies 1 - k^4 = \left(\frac{D_s}{D_o}\right)^3 = \left(\frac{100}{120}\right)^3 = (0.833333)^3 = 0.578704 k4=1−0.578704=0.421296k^4 = 1 - 0.578704 = 0.421296 k=(0.421296)1/4=0.805727≈0.8057k = (0.421296)^{1/4} = 0.805727 \approx 0.8057 di=k⋅Do=0.805727×120=96.6872 mm≈96.69 mmd_i = k \cdot D_o = 0.805727 \times 120 = 96.6872\text{ mm} \approx 96.69\text{ mm}
  3. Weight Economy Calculation: Cross-sectional area of hollow shaft:

    Ah=π4(Do2−di2)=π4(1202−96.68722)=π4(14,400−9,348.42)=π4(5,051.58)=3,967.57 mm2A_h = \frac{\pi}{4}\left(D_o^2 - d_i^2\right) = \frac{\pi}{4}\left(120^2 - 96.6872^2\right) = \frac{\pi}{4}(14,400 - 9,348.42) = \frac{\pi}{4}(5,051.58) = 3,967.57\text{ mm}^2

    Percentage Weight Savings:

    Weight Savings=As−AhAs×100%=7,853.98−3,967.577,853.98×100%=49.48% Steel Saved!\text{Weight Savings} = \frac{A_s - A_h}{A_s} \times 100\% = \frac{7,853.98 - 3,967.57}{7,853.98} \times 100\% = \mathbf{49.48\% \text{ Steel Saved!}}
  4. Torsional Stiffness Ratio:

    Jh=π(Do4−di4)32=π(1204−96.68724)32=π(207.36×106−87.39×106)32=1.17810×107 mm4J_h = \frac{\pi (D_o^4 - d_i^4)}{32} = \frac{\pi (120^4 - 96.6872^4)}{32} = \frac{\pi (207.36 \times 10^6 - 87.39 \times 10^6)}{32} = 1.17810 \times 10^7\text{ mm}^4 Stiffness Ratio=(GJ)h(GJ)s=JhJs=1.17810×1079.81748×106=1.2000(20% Stiffer!)\text{Stiffness Ratio} = \frac{(GJ)_h}{(GJ)_s} = \frac{J_h}{J_s} = \frac{1.17810 \times 10^7}{9.81748 \times 10^6} = \mathbf{1.2000 \quad (20\% \text{ Stiffer!})}
  5. Angle of Twist Per Meter Length (L=1,000 mmL = 1,000\text{ mm}):

    • Solid Shaft: θs=T⋅LG⋅Js=(8.0×106)×1,00080,000×9.81748×106=0.010186 rad/m=0.5836∘/m\theta_s = \frac{T \cdot L}{G \cdot J_s} = \frac{(8.0 \times 10^6) \times 1,000}{80,000 \times 9.81748 \times 10^6} = 0.010186\text{ rad/m} = 0.5836^\circ/\text{m}
    • Hollow Shaft: θh=T⋅LG⋅Jh=(8.0×106)×1,00080,000×1.17810×107=0.008488 rad/m=0.4863∘/m\theta_h = \frac{T \cdot L}{G \cdot J_h} = \frac{(8.0 \times 10^6) \times 1,000}{80,000 \times 1.17810 \times 10^7} = 0.008488\text{ rad/m} = 0.4863^\circ/\text{m}

    The hollow shaft reduces angular twist by 16.7%16.7\% while saving half the metal!


8. Practical Engineering Applications & Structural Design Considerations

  1. Automotive Propeller & Drive Shafts: Because drive shafts run the entire length of vehicles, weight is critical for fuel efficiency and natural frequency. By using thin hollow steel tubes (k≈0.85 to 0.92k \approx 0.85 \text{ to } 0.92), automotive engineers avoid whirling resonance frequencies while saving hundreds of kilograms of unsprung weight.
  2. Deep Borehole Drilling & Geotechnical Rotary Rigs: Drill strings used in soil sampling, pile boring, and petroleum drilling are hollow steel pipes. The hollow core allows drilling fluid (bentonite slurry) to be pumped down to the cutting bit while providing maximum torsional rigidity against rotational stall.
  3. Marine Ship Propeller Shafts: Massive commercial ship propeller shafts (often over 600 mm600\text{ mm} in diameter and 50 m50\text{ m} long) are forged hollow. Boring out the central 50%50\% diameter core removes 25%25\% of the weight while reducing torsional strength by only 6.25%6.25\%.
  4. Torque Limiter Shear Pins: In mechanical drives subject to jamming (sludge scrapers in water treatment plants, stone crushers), a sacrificial shear pin of calibrated diameter is inserted. When torque exceeds TsafeT_{\text{safe}}, the pin shears cleanly at its outer radius, disengaging the motor to prevent catastrophic gearbox destruction.

9. Comparative Analysis & Summary Matrix

Attribute / Parameter Solid Circular Shaft (DD) Hollow Circular Shaft (Do,di,k=di/DoD_o, d_i, k = d_i/D_o) Performance Comparison
Cross-Sectional Area (AA) πD24\frac{\pi D^2}{4} πDo2(1−k2)4\frac{\pi D_o^2 (1 - k^2)}{4} Hollow has far less area for same diameter
Polar Moment of Inertia (JJ) πD432\frac{\pi D^4}{32} πDo4(1−k4)32\frac{\pi D_o^4 (1 - k^4)}{32} Hollow concentrates mass at larger radius
Polar Section Modulus (ZpZ_p) πD316≈0.1963D3\frac{\pi D^3}{16} \approx 0.1963 D^3 πDo3(1−k4)16\frac{\pi D_o^3 (1 - k^4)}{16} Measure of strength capacity against twisting
Minimum Shear Stress (τmin⁡\tau_{\min}) 00 (at center r=0r = 0) k⋅τmax⁡k \cdot \tau_{\max} (at inner wall r=di/2r = d_i/2) Hollow has no inactive material near zero
Maximum Shear Stress (τmax⁡\tau_{\max}) 16TπD3\frac{16 T}{\pi D^3} (at surface) 16TDoπ(Do4−di4)\frac{16 T D_o}{\pi (D_o^4 - d_i^4)} Peaks at outer surface for both
Stress Distribution Profile Triangular (apex at center) Trapezoidal (elevated base) Hollow profile is much flatter and efficient
Angle of Twist (θ\theta) 32TLπGD4\frac{32 T L}{\pi G D^4} 32TLπGDo4(1−k4)\frac{32 T L}{\pi G D_o^4 (1 - k^4)} Inversely proportional to 4th power of diameter
Weight for Same Strength Baseline (100%100\%) ≈50% to 60%\approx 50\% \text{ to } 60\% (with k=0.8k = 0.8) 40% to 50%40\% \text{ to } 50\% weight reduction

10. Key Takeaways & Exam-Oriented Highlights

  1. The Universal Torsion Equation: TJ=τr=G⋅θL\frac{T}{J} = \frac{\tau}{r} = \frac{G \cdot \theta}{L}
  2. Kinematic Law: Plane sections remain plane; radial lines remain straight. γ(r)=rθL\gamma(r) = \frac{r\theta}{L}.
  3. Linear Shear Stress: τ(r)\tau(r) varies linearly from 00 at the center to τmax⁡\tau_{\max} at the outer boundary.
  4. Polar Modulus: Zp=πD316Z_p = \frac{\pi D^3}{16} for solid shafts; Zp=πDo3(1−k4)16Z_p = \frac{\pi D_o^3 (1 - k^4)}{16} for hollow shafts.
  5. Power Transmission Formula: P=2πNT60  ⟹  T=60P2πN=9550PkWNP = \frac{2\pi N T}{60} \implies T = \frac{60 P}{2\pi N} = \frac{9550 P_{\text{kW}}}{N}
  6. Ductile vs. Brittle Torsional Failure:
    • Ductile materials fail on the transverse 90∘90^\circ plane (shear failure).
    • Brittle materials fail along a 45∘45^\circ helical spiral (tensile cleavage failure perpendicular to principal stress σ1=+τ\sigma_1 = +\tau).
  7. Design Governing Check: Shafts must be verified for both Strength (T≤τallowZpT \le \tau_{\text{allow}} Z_p) and Stiffness (θ≤θallow\theta \le \theta_{\text{allow}}). For long shafts, stiffness almost always governs!

11. Common Traps, Pitfalls & Counter-Intuitive Exam Scenarios

  • Trap 1: Forgetting to Convert Degrees to Radians:
    Misconception: Directly plugging θ=1∘\theta = 1^\circ into J=TLGθJ = \frac{T L}{G \theta}.
    Correction: θ\theta in the torsion formula is strictly in radians! You must multiply degrees by π180\frac{\pi}{180} before calculating.
  • Trap 2: Confusing ZpZ_p with Flexural Section Modulus ZZ:
    Misconception: Using Z=πD332Z = \frac{\pi D^3}{32} instead of Zp=πD316Z_p = \frac{\pi D^3}{16}.
    Correction: Polar moment of inertia is twice the rectangular moment of inertia (J=2IxxJ = 2 I_{xx}). Thus, Zp=2ZZ_p = 2 Z for a solid circular cross-section!
  • Trap 3: Mixing Up Power Units:
    Misconception: Using PP in kW directly without multiplying by 10310^3 to get Watts (N⋅m/s\text{N}\cdot\text{m/s}).
    Correction: If PP is in kW, T=75,000×602πNT = \frac{75,000 \times 60}{2\pi N} gives TT in N⋅m\text{N}\cdot\text{m}. Multiply by 10310^3 to get N⋅mm\text{N}\cdot\text{mm}.
  • Trap 4: Miscalculating Core Torque Capacity:
    Misconception: Believing the inner core of radius R/2R/2 carries 50%50\% of the torque.
    Correction: Torque varies with r4r^4! The inner half radius carries only (0.5)4=116=6.25%(0.5)^4 = \frac{1}{16} = 6.25\% of total torque capacity.
  • Trap 5: Applying Circular Torsion to Non-Circular Sections:
    Misconception: Using τ=16T/(πbd2)\tau = 16T / (\pi b d^2) for rectangular beams.
    Correction: Rectangular bars experience severe warping. Maximum shear stress in a rectangle occurs at the midpoint of the longer edge, not at the corners (where τ=0\tau = 0!).

12. Standard Code Provisions & Objective Practice Problems

Reference Code Clauses

  • IS 2494: Mechanical transmission shafting design: allowable shear stress under pure torsion is limited to 0.30fy0.30 f_y or 0.18fu0.18 f_u, whichever is smaller, reduced by a keyway factor of 0.750.75.
  • ASME Code for Design of Transmission Shafting: Design based on maximum shear stress theory with shock and fatigue factors KmK_m and KtK_t.
  • IS 800:2007 (Cl. 8.9): Torsional warping must be accounted for in open thin-walled sections; circular hollow sections (CHS) are recommended for pure torsion.

Objective Practice Problems

Problem 1 (GATE CE)

A solid circular shaft of diameter DD is subjected to a torque TT. If the diameter of the shaft is doubled, its torque-carrying capacity for the same allowable shear stress becomes:

  • (A) 2 times
  • (B) 4 times
  • (C) 8 times
  • (D) 16 times

Answer: (C)
Solution: Tsafe=τallow⋅Zp=τallow⋅πD316T_{\text{safe}} = \tau_{\text{allow}} \cdot Z_p = \tau_{\text{allow}} \cdot \frac{\pi D^3}{16}. Since T∝D3T \propto D^3, doubling DD increases capacity by 23=82^3 = 8 times.


Problem 2 (SSC JE / RRB JE)

A piece of blackboard chalk is twisted to failure. The fracture surface will be:

  • (A) A transverse plane perpendicular to the axis
  • (B) A longitudinal plane parallel to the axis
  • (C) A helical spiral surface inclined at 45∘45^\circ to the axis
  • (D) A cup-and-cone irregular surface

Answer: (C)
Solution: Chalk is a brittle material that is much weaker in tension than in shear. Under pure torsion, the maximum principal tensile stress σ1=+τ\sigma_1 = +\tau acts on planes inclined at 45∘45^\circ to the longitudinal axis, causing tensile cleavage failure along a 45∘45^\circ helical spiral.


Problem 3 (GATE CE / State AE)

The ratio of polar section modulus ZpZ_p to flexural section modulus ZZ for a solid circular cross-section is:

  • (A) 0.50.5
  • (B) 1.01.0
  • (C) 1.51.5
  • (D) 2.02.0

Answer: (D)
Solution: J=Ixx+Iyy=2IxxJ = I_{xx} + I_{yy} = 2 I_{xx}. Since radius RR is identical for both, Zp=J/R=2(Ixx/R)=2ZZ_p = J / R = 2 (I_{xx} / R) = 2 Z.


Problem 4 (UPSC ESE)

A shaft transmitting power PP at N rpmN\text{ rpm} is subjected to a torque TT. If the rotational speed NN is doubled while the transmitted power PP remains constant, the torque TT on the shaft:

  • (A) Doubles
  • (B) Quadruples
  • (C) Halves
  • (D) Remains unchanged

Answer: (C)
Solution: P=2πNT60  ⟹  T=60P2πNP = \frac{2\pi N T}{60} \implies T = \frac{60 P}{2\pi N}. If PP is constant and NN doubles, TT is halved.


Problem 5 (GATE CE / ESE)

In a hollow circular shaft of outer diameter DoD_o and inner diameter di=Do/2d_i = D_o / 2, what fraction of the total torsional strength of a solid shaft of diameter DoD_o is retained?

  • (A) 50.0%50.0\%
  • (B) 75.0%75.0\%
  • (C) 93.75%93.75\%
  • (D) 96.875%96.875\%

Answer: (C)
Solution: k=di/Do=0.5k = d_i / D_o = 0.5. The ratio of polar section moduli is ZphZps=1−k4=1−(0.5)4=1−0.0625=0.9375=93.75%\frac{Z_{ph}}{Z_{ps}} = 1 - k^4 = 1 - (0.5)^4 = 1 - 0.0625 = 0.9375 = 93.75\%. Boring out the inner half diameter removes 25%25\% of the weight while retaining 93.75%93.75\% of the strength!