SOM-05-02 Chapter 05 · Shear Stresses

Shear Stress Distribution Profiles in Standard Cross-Sections

In this chapter (3 topics)
On this page

1. Topic Metadata & Scope

Attribute Specification
Topic ID SOM-05-02
Chapter Chapter 05: Shear Stresses in Beams (05_shear_stresses)
Subject Strength of Materials (Solid Mechanics)
Target Examinations GATE CE, UPSC ESE, SSC JE, State AE, RRB JE
Prerequisites SOM-04-01 (Pure Bending Theory & Flexure Formula), SOM-04-02 (Section Modulus & Area Moments of Inertia), SOM-05-01 (Transverse Shear Stress Formula & Shear Flow)
Authoritative Reference Codes IS 800:2007 (General Construction in Steel — Code of Practice), IS 456:2000 (Plain and Reinforced Concrete), IS 3629:1986 (Structural Timber in Building)
Key Terminology Transverse shear stress distribution, section shape factor for shear (τmax⁡/τavg\tau_{\max} / \tau_{\text{avg}}), shear stress step jump, non-central shear peak paradox, web shear percentage

2. Physical Mechanics & Theoretical Foundation

When a beam of arbitrary cross-section is subjected to a vertical transverse shear force VV, the horizontal and vertical shear stress τ(y)\tau(y) at any distance yy from the neutral axis (NA) is governed by the Jourawski transverse shear formula:

τ(y)=V⋅Q(y)I⋅b(y)\tau(y) = \frac{V \cdot Q(y)}{I \cdot b(y)}

Where:

  • VV is the transverse shear force at the cross-section [N][\text{N}].
  • II is the second moment of area of the entire cross-section about the neutral axis [mm4][\text{mm}^4].
  • Q(y)=∫yytopη dA=A′yˉ′Q(y) = \int_y^{y_{\text{top}}} \eta \, dA = A' \bar{y}' is the first moment of area of the portion of the cross-section above level yy about the neutral axis [mm3][\text{mm}^3].
  • b(y)b(y) is the actual cut width of the cross-section measured parallel to the neutral axis at level yy [mm][\text{mm}].

The Interplay Between Q(y)Q(y) and b(y)b(y)

The spatial profile of τ(y)\tau(y) across the depth of a beam is dictated entirely by the geometric ratio:

Q(y)b(y)\frac{Q(y)}{b(y)}
  1. Monotonically Increasing Q(y)Q(y) Towards the Neutral Axis: At the outermost fibers (y=ytopy = y_{\text{top}} or y=ybottomy = y_{\text{bottom}}), the cut area A′=0A' = 0, so Q=0Q = 0, requiring τ=0\tau = 0. As y→0y \to 0 (approaching the neutral axis), Q(y)Q(y) increases monotonically and reaches its absolute mathematical maximum at the neutral axis (Qmax⁡=QNAQ_{\max} = Q_{\text{NA}}).
  2. Constant Width Sections (b(y)=constantb(y) = \text{constant}): For cross-sections where the cut width bb is invariant with depth (such as rectangles), τ(y)\tau(y) is directly proportional to Q(y)Q(y). Therefore, the maximum shear stress τmax⁡\tau_{\max} must coincide exactly with the neutral axis, following a parabolic curve.
  3. Variable Width Sections (b(y)≠constantb(y) \ne \text{constant}): When b(y)b(y) varies along the depth (such as circles, triangles, diamonds, and T-sections), the denominator b(y)b(y) modulates the curve. If the width b(y)b(y) shrinks rapidly towards an apex or narrow zone, the ratio Q(y)/b(y)Q(y)/b(y) can peak at a level different from the neutral axis. This gives rise to the classic "non-central shear stress paradox" in triangular and diamond sections.
  4. Sudden Width Discontinuities (I-Sections, T-Sections): Where the width changes abruptly by an order of magnitude (from flange width BB to web thickness twt_w), Q(y)Q(y) remains continuous, producing a dramatic, instantaneous step jump in shear stress by the ratio B/twB/t_w.

3. Mathematical Derivations for Canonical Cross-Sections

3.1 Solid Rectangular Cross-Section (Width bb, Depth dd)

Consider a solid rectangular beam of width bb and depth dd. The neutral axis is at mid-depth, so −d/2≤y≤d/2-d/2 \le y \le d/2.

The area moment of inertia is:

I=bd312I = \frac{b d^3}{12}

Consider an arbitrary level yy above the neutral axis. The area of the cross-section above yy is:

A′=b⋅(d2−y)A' = b \cdot \left(\frac{d}{2} - y\right)

The centroid of this cut area is located at:

yˉ′=y+12(d2−y)=12(d2+y)\bar{y}' = y + \frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{d}{2} - y\right) = \frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{d}{2} + y\right)

The first moment of area Q(y)Q(y) is:

Q(y)=A′yˉ′=b(d2−y)⋅12(d2+y)=b2(d24−y2)Q(y) = A' \bar{y}' = b \left(\frac{d}{2} - y\right) \cdot \frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{d}{2} + y\right) = \frac{b}{2}\left(\frac{d^2}{4} - y^2\right)

Substituting Q(y)Q(y), II, and width bb into Jourawski's formula:

τ(y)=V⋅b2(d24−y2)(bd312)⋅b=6Vbd3(d24−y2)=3V2bd(1−4y2d2)\tau(y) = \frac{V \cdot \frac{b}{2}\left(\frac{d^2}{4} - y^2\right)}{\left(\frac{b d^3}{12}\right) \cdot b} = \frac{6 V}{b d^3}\left(\frac{d^2}{4} - y^2\right) = \frac{3 V}{2 b d}\left(1 - \frac{4 y^2}{d^2}\right)

Defining the average shear stress τavg=VA=Vbd\tau_{\text{avg}} = \frac{V}{A} = \frac{V}{b d}:

τ(y)=32τavg(1−4y2d2)\tau(y) = \frac{3}{2} \tau_{\text{avg}} \left(1 - \frac{4 y^2}{d^2}\right)

Key Characteristics:

  • Boundary Values: At top and bottom fibers (y=±d/2y = \pm d/2), τ(±d/2)=0\tau(\pm d/2) = 0.
  • Maximum Value: At the neutral axis (y=0y = 0): τmax⁡=τNA=32τavg=1.50⋅τavg\tau_{\max} = \tau_{\text{NA}} = \frac{3}{2} \tau_{\text{avg}} = 1.50 \cdot \tau_{\text{avg}}
  • Shear Carry by Middle Depth: The middle half of the depth (−d/4≤y≤d/4-d/4 \le y \le d/4) carries: Vmid-half=∫−d/4d/4τ(y)b dy=2∫0d/43V2d(1−4y2d2)dy=3Vd[d4−4(d/4)33d2]=3Vd[d4−d48]=1116V=68.75%VV_{\text{mid-half}} = \int_{-d/4}^{d/4} \tau(y) b \, dy = 2 \int_0^{d/4} \frac{3V}{2d}\left(1 - \frac{4y^2}{d^2}\right) dy = \frac{3V}{d}\left[\frac{d}{4} - \frac{4 (d/4)^3}{3 d^2}\right] = \frac{3V}{d}\left[\frac{d}{4} - \frac{d}{48}\right] = \frac{11}{16} V = 68.75\% V

3.2 Solid Circular Cross-Section (Diameter D=2RD = 2R)

Consider a circular beam of radius RR. The centroid and neutral axis coincide with the geometric center (y=0y = 0).

The area moment of inertia is:

I=πR44=πD464I = \frac{\pi R^4}{4} = \frac{\pi D^4}{64}

At a distance yy from the neutral axis, the width of the chord is:

b(y)=2R2−y2b(y) = 2 \sqrt{R^2 - y^2}

To find Q(y)Q(y), consider a horizontal strip of width b(η)=2R2−η2b(\eta) = 2\sqrt{R^2 - \eta^2} and thickness dηd\eta located at distance η\eta:

Q(y)=∫yRη⋅b(η) dη=∫yRη⋅2R2−η2 dηQ(y) = \int_y^R \eta \cdot b(\eta) \, d\eta = \int_y^R \eta \cdot 2\sqrt{R^2 - \eta^2} \, d\eta

Substitute u=R2−η2  ⟹  du=−2η dηu = R^2 - \eta^2 \implies du = -2\eta \, d\eta:

Q(y)=∫0R2−y2u1/2 du=[23u3/2]0R2−y2=23(R2−y2)3/2Q(y) = \int_0^{R^2 - y^2} u^{1/2} \, du = \left[ \frac{2}{3} u^{3/2} \right]_0^{R^2 - y^2} = \frac{2}{3} \left(R^2 - y^2\right)^{3/2}

Substituting into Jourawski's formula:

τ(y)=V⋅Q(y)I⋅b(y)=V⋅23(R2−y2)3/2(πR44)⋅2R2−y2=4V3πR4(R2−y2)=4V3(πR2)(1−y2R2)\tau(y) = \frac{V \cdot Q(y)}{I \cdot b(y)} = \frac{V \cdot \frac{2}{3} (R^2 - y^2)^{3/2}}{\left(\frac{\pi R^4}{4}\right) \cdot 2\sqrt{R^2 - y^2}} = \frac{4 V}{3 \pi R^4} (R^2 - y^2) = \frac{4 V}{3 (\pi R^2)} \left(1 - \frac{y^2}{R^2}\right)

Since τavg=VA=VπR2\tau_{\text{avg}} = \frac{V}{A} = \frac{V}{\pi R^2}:

τ(y)=43τavg(1−y2R2)\tau(y) = \frac{4}{3} \tau_{\text{avg}} \left(1 - \frac{y^2}{R^2}\right)

Key Characteristics:

  • Boundary Values: At top and bottom points (y=±Ry = \pm R), τ(±R)=0\tau(\pm R) = 0.
  • Maximum Value: At the neutral axis (y=0y = 0): τmax⁡=τNA=43τavg≈1.333⋅τavg\tau_{\max} = \tau_{\text{NA}} = \frac{4}{3} \tau_{\text{avg}} \approx 1.333 \cdot \tau_{\text{avg}}
  • Profile: Pure parabolic across depth, peaking at the neutral axis.

3.3 Thin-Walled Circular Tube (Mean Radius RmR_m, Thickness t≪Rmt \ll R_m)

For a thin-walled circular tube:

  • Cross-sectional area: A=2πRmtA = 2\pi R_m t
  • Area moment of inertia: I=πRm3tI = \pi R_m^3 t

At the neutral axis (y=0y = 0), the upper semicircle is cut across two wall thicknesses (bcut=2tb_{\text{cut}} = 2t). The first moment of area of the upper semicircle:

QNA=Asemi⋅yˉsemi=(πRmt)⋅(2Rmπ)=2Rm2tQ_{\text{NA}} = A_{\text{semi}} \cdot \bar{y}_{\text{semi}} = (\pi R_m t) \cdot \left(\frac{2 R_m}{\pi}\right) = 2 R_m^2 t

Substituting into Jourawski's formula:

τmax⁡=V⋅QNAI⋅b=V⋅(2Rm2t)(πRm3t)⋅(2t)=VπRmt\tau_{\max} = \frac{V \cdot Q_{\text{NA}}}{I \cdot b} = \frac{V \cdot (2 R_m^2 t)}{(\pi R_m^3 t) \cdot (2t)} = \frac{V}{\pi R_m t}

Comparing with τavg=VA=V2πRmt\tau_{\text{avg}} = \frac{V}{A} = \frac{V}{2\pi R_m t}:

τmax⁡=2.00⋅τavg\tau_{\max} = 2.00 \cdot \tau_{\text{avg}}

Key Characteristics:

  • The maximum shear stress in a thin-walled circular tube is twice the average shear stress (τmax⁡/τavg=2.0\tau_{\max}/\tau_{\text{avg}} = 2.0).
  • This is significantly higher than a solid circular section (1.3331.333) or solid rectangle (1.501.50) because the material is concentrated far from the NA, and the cut width at the NA is only 2t2t.

3.4 Symmetrical I-Beam (Flanges B×tfB \times t_f, Web tw×dwt_w \times d_w, Overall Depth DD)

Consider an I-section with overall depth DD, flange width BB, flange thickness tft_f, web thickness twt_w, and web depth dw=D−2tfd_w = D - 2t_f.

         |<--------- B --------->|
      +--+-----------------------+--+  ^
      |           Flange            |  | tf
      +--+---------+---+---------+--+  v
                   |   |               ^
                   |   |               |
         - - - - - | - |- - - - - - -  | dw   D
              N    |   |    A          |
                   |   | tw            v
      +--+---------+---+---------+--+  ^
      |           Flange            |  | tf
      +--+-----------------------+--+  v

The total moment of inertia about the neutral axis:

Ixx=BD312−(B−tw)dw312I_{xx} = \frac{B D^3}{12} - \frac{(B - t_w) d_w^3}{12}

Step 1: In the Flange (dw/2≤y≤D/2d_w/2 \le y \le D/2)

At level yy, the cut width is b(y)=Bb(y) = B. The area above yy is A′=B(D/2−y)A' = B (D/2 - y), with centroid yˉ′=12(D/2+y)\bar{y}' = \frac{1}{2}(D/2 + y).

Qf(y)=B2(D24−y2)Q_f(y) = \frac{B}{2}\left(\frac{D^2}{4} - y^2\right) τf(y)=V⋅Qf(y)I⋅B=V2I(D24−y2)\tau_f(y) = \frac{V \cdot Q_f(y)}{I \cdot B} = \frac{V}{2 I}\left(\frac{D^2}{4} - y^2\right)
  • At outer edge (y=D/2y = D/2): τ=0\tau = 0.
  • At flange-web junction within the flange (y=dw/2y = d_w/2): τf,junc=V8I(D2−dw2)\tau_{f, \text{junc}} = \frac{V}{8 I}\left(D^2 - d_w^2\right)

Step 2: In the Web at the Junction (y=dw/2y = d_w/2)

Immediately below the junction, the first moment of area QQ is identical (Q=QfQ = Q_f), but the cut width changes abruptly from BB to twt_w:

τw,junc=V⋅QfI⋅tw=Btw⋅τf,junc\tau_{w, \text{junc}} = \frac{V \cdot Q_f}{I \cdot t_w} = \frac{B}{t_w} \cdot \tau_{f, \text{junc}} τw,juncτf,junc=Btw\frac{\tau_{w, \text{junc}}}{\tau_{f, \text{junc}}} = \frac{B}{t_w}

Because B/twB/t_w typically ranges from 1010 to 2525 in rolled steel sections (e.g., ISMB, ISMC), the shear stress exhibits an abrupt step jump by a factor of 10 to 25!

Step 3: Maximum Shear Stress at Neutral Axis (y=0y = 0)

At the neutral axis, the cut includes the flange plus half the web:

QNA=Qf+Qw,half=Btf(D−tf2)+tw(dw2)(dw4)=Btf(D−tf)2+twdw28Q_{\text{NA}} = Q_f + Q_{w, \text{half}} = B t_f \left(\frac{D - t_f}{2}\right) + t_w \left(\frac{d_w}{2}\right) \left(\frac{d_w}{4}\right) = \frac{B t_f (D - t_f)}{2} + \frac{t_w d_w^2}{8}

The maximum shear stress at the neutral axis is:

τmax⁡=V⋅QNAI⋅tw=VI⋅tw[B8(D2−dw2)+twdw28]=V8I[Btw(D2−dw2)+dw2]\tau_{\max} = \frac{V \cdot Q_{\text{NA}}}{I \cdot t_w} = \frac{V}{I \cdot t_w}\left[\frac{B}{8}(D^2 - d_w^2) + \frac{t_w d_w^2}{8}\right] = \frac{V}{8 I}\left[\frac{B}{t_w}(D^2 - d_w^2) + d_w^2\right]

Web Shear Load Share:

The total vertical shear force carried by the web alone is obtained by integrating the web shear stress:

Vweb=∫−dw/2dw/2τw(y)⋅tw dy=VI[Qf⋅dw+twdw312]=VI[Qf⋅dw+Iweb]V_{\text{web}} = \int_{-d_w/2}^{d_w/2} \tau_w(y) \cdot t_w \, dy = \frac{V}{I}\left[Q_f \cdot d_w + \frac{t_w d_w^3}{12}\right] = \frac{V}{I}\left[Q_f \cdot d_w + I_{\text{web}}\right]

In practical structural steel I-sections:

Vweb≈85% to 98% of VV_{\text{web}} \approx 85\% \text{ to } 98\% \text{ of } V

The flanges carry less than 2% to 15%2\% \text{ to } 15\% of the vertical shear force. This fundamental insight justifies the standard structural engineering design rule: The web is designed to resist 100% of the vertical shear force.


3.5 T-Section (Flange B×tfB \times t_f, Web tw×dwt_w \times d_w)

In a T-section:

  1. The neutral axis does not lie at mid-depth; its position yˉ\bar{y} must first be computed from the top flange: yˉ=Btf(tf/2)+twdw(tf+dw/2)Btf+twdw\bar{y} = \frac{B t_f (t_f / 2) + t_w d_w (t_f + d_w / 2)}{B t_f + t_w d_w}
  2. If the neutral axis falls in the web (the common case), the maximum shear stress occurs at the neutral axis in the web: τmax⁡=VQNAIxxtw\tau_{\max} = \frac{V Q_{\text{NA}}}{I_{xx} t_w}
  3. At the flange-web junction, there is a step jump: τwebτflange=Btw\frac{\tau_{\text{web}}}{\tau_{\text{flange}}} = \frac{B}{t_w}
  4. At the top of the flange (y=yˉy = \bar{y}) and bottom of the stem (y=D−yˉy = D - \bar{y}), τ=0\tau = 0.

4. The Non-Central Peak Shear Stress Paradoxes

4.1 Triangular Cross-Section (Base bb, Height hh, Apex at Top)

Consider a triangular beam cross-section with base bb and height hh, with its apex pointing upwards.

                   ^ Apex (y = 0)
                  / \
                 /   \
    - - - - - - / - - \ - - - - - -  y = h/2 (MID-DEPTH: τ_max = 1.50 τ_avg)
               /       \
    - - - - - / - - - - \ - - - - -  y = 2h/3 (NEUTRAL AXIS: τ_NA = 1.333 τ_avg)
             /           \
            +-------------+          y = h (Base b: τ = 0)
            |<----- b ---->|

Step 1: Geometric Properties

  • Centroid is at distance 23h\frac{2}{3}h from the apex (13h\frac{1}{3}h from the base).
  • Second moment of area about the neutral axis: Ixx=bh336I_{xx} = \frac{b h^3}{36}
  • Average shear stress: τavg=VA=V12bh=2Vbh\tau_{\text{avg}} = \frac{V}{A} = \frac{V}{\frac{1}{2} b h} = \frac{2 V}{b h}

Step 2: First Moment of Area Q(y)Q(y) at Distance yy from Apex

Consider a horizontal level at distance yy from the apex (0≤y≤h0 \le y \le h).

  • Width at depth yy (by similar triangles): b(y)=bhyb(y) = \frac{b}{h} y
  • Area of the triangle above level yy: A′=12b(y)⋅y=12(bhy)y=b2hy2A' = \frac{1}{2} b(y) \cdot y = \frac{1}{2} \left(\frac{b}{h} y\right) y = \frac{b}{2h} y^2
  • Centroid of this upper triangle is at 23y\frac{2}{3}y from the apex.
  • Distance of this centroid from the overall neutral axis (which is at 23h\frac{2}{3}h from apex): yˉ′=23h−23y=23(h−y)\bar{y}' = \frac{2}{3}h - \frac{2}{3}y = \frac{2}{3}(h - y)
  • First moment of area Q(y)Q(y): Q(y)=A′yˉ′=(b2hy2)[23(h−y)]=b3hy2(h−y)Q(y) = A' \bar{y}' = \left(\frac{b}{2h} y^2\right) \left[\frac{2}{3}(h - y)\right] = \frac{b}{3h} y^2 (h - y)

Step 3: Shear Stress Distribution Equation

Substitute Q(y)Q(y), Ixx=bh336I_{xx} = \frac{b h^3}{36}, and b(y)=bhyb(y) = \frac{b}{h} y into Jourawski's formula:

τ(y)=V⋅Q(y)Ixx⋅b(y)=V⋅[b3hy2(h−y)](bh336)⋅(bhy)=V⋅13y(h−y)bh336=12Vbh3y(h−y)\tau(y) = \frac{V \cdot Q(y)}{I_{xx} \cdot b(y)} = \frac{V \cdot \left[\frac{b}{3h} y^2 (h - y)\right]}{\left(\frac{b h^3}{36}\right) \cdot \left(\frac{b}{h} y\right)} = \frac{V \cdot \frac{1}{3} y (h - y)}{\frac{b h^3}{36}} = \frac{12 V}{b h^3} y (h - y) τ(y)=12Vbh3(hy−y2)\tau(y) = \frac{12 V}{b h^3} (h y - y^2)

This is a pure parabola opening downwards.

Step 4: Locating the Maximum Shear Stress

To find the location of maximum shear stress, differentiate τ(y)\tau(y) with respect to yy and set to zero:

dτdy=12Vbh3(h−2y)=0  ⟹  h−2y=0  ⟹  y=h2\frac{d\tau}{dy} = \frac{12 V}{b h^3}(h - 2y) = 0 \implies h - 2y = 0 \implies y = \frac{h}{2}

[!IMPORTANT] In a triangular beam section, the maximum shear stress occurs at mid-depth (y=h/2y = h/2), NOT at the neutral axis (y=2h/3y = 2h/3)!

Step 5: Values at Mid-Depth and Neutral Axis

  1. At Mid-Depth (y=h/2y = h/2):

    τmax⁡=τ(h2)=12Vbh3(h2)(h−h2)=12Vbh3⋅h24=3Vbh\tau_{\max} = \tau\left(\frac{h}{2}\right) = \frac{12 V}{b h^3} \left(\frac{h}{2}\right) \left(h - \frac{h}{2}\right) = \frac{12 V}{b h^3} \cdot \frac{h^2}{4} = \frac{3 V}{b h}

    Expressing in terms of τavg=2Vbh\tau_{\text{avg}} = \frac{2V}{bh}:

    τmax⁡=32(2Vbh)=32τavg=1.50⋅τavg\tau_{\max} = \frac{3}{2} \left(\frac{2V}{bh}\right) = \frac{3}{2} \tau_{\text{avg}} = 1.50 \cdot \tau_{\text{avg}}
  2. At the Neutral Axis (y=2h/3y = 2h/3):

    τNA=τ(2h3)=12Vbh3(2h3)(h−2h3)=12Vbh3⋅2h29=8V3bh\tau_{\text{NA}} = \tau\left(\frac{2h}{3}\right) = \frac{12 V}{b h^3} \left(\frac{2h}{3}\right) \left(h - \frac{2h}{3}\right) = \frac{12 V}{b h^3} \cdot \frac{2 h^2}{9} = \frac{8 V}{3 b h}

    Expressing in terms of τavg=2Vbh\tau_{\text{avg}} = \frac{2V}{bh}:

    τNA=43(2Vbh)=43τavg≈1.333⋅τavg\tau_{\text{NA}} = \frac{4}{3} \left(\frac{2V}{bh}\right) = \frac{4}{3} \tau_{\text{avg}} \approx 1.333 \cdot \tau_{\text{avg}}
  3. The Famous Exam Ratio:

    τmax⁡τNA=32τavg43τavg=3/24/3=98=1.125\frac{\tau_{\max}}{\tau_{\text{NA}}} = \frac{\frac{3}{2} \tau_{\text{avg}}}{\frac{4}{3} \tau_{\text{avg}}} = \frac{3/2}{4/3} = \frac{9}{8} = 1.125

Step 6: Shear Force Carried by Upper and Lower Halves

  • Upper half (apex y=0y=0 to mid-depth y=h/2y=h/2): Vupper=∫0h/2τ(y)b(y) dy=∫0h/212Vh4y2(h−y) dy=12Vh4[hy33−y44]0h/2=516V=31.25%VV_{\text{upper}} = \int_0^{h/2} \tau(y) b(y) \, dy = \int_0^{h/2} \frac{12 V}{h^4} y^2 (h - y) \, dy = \frac{12 V}{h^4} \left[ \frac{h y^3}{3} - \frac{y^4}{4} \right]_0^{h/2} = \frac{5}{16} V = 31.25\% V
  • Lower half (mid-depth y=h/2y=h/2 to base y=hy=h): Vlower=V−516V=1116V=68.75%VV_{\text{lower}} = V - \frac{5}{16} V = \frac{11}{16} V = 68.75\% V

4.2 Diamond Cross-Section (Square of Diagonal DD Placed on Vertex)

Consider a square cross-section of side aa oriented with its diagonal D=a2D = a\sqrt{2} placed vertically.

                      ^ Top Vertex (z = 0)
                     / \
                    /   \
     - - - - - - - / - - \ - - - - - -  z = 3/8 D (PEAK: τ_max = 9/8 τ_avg)
                  /       \
     - - - - - - / - - - - \ - - - - -  z = D/2 (NEUTRAL AXIS: τ_NA = 1.0 τ_avg)
                 \         /
     - - - - - - - \ - - / - - - - - -  z = 5/8 D (PEAK: τ_max = 9/8 τ_avg)
                    \   /
                     \ /
                      v Bottom Vertex (z = D)

Step 1: Geometric Properties

  • Total vertical depth is DD.
  • Side of square a=D/2a = D / \sqrt{2}.
  • Cross-sectional area: A=a2=D22A = a^2 = \frac{D^2}{2}
  • Average shear stress: τavg=VA=2VD2\tau_{\text{avg}} = \frac{V}{A} = \frac{2 V}{D^2}
  • Second moment of area about horizontal diagonal (NA): Ixx=2×D(D/2)312=D448I_{xx} = 2 \times \frac{D (D/2)^3}{12} = \frac{D^4}{48}

Step 2: Shear Stress at Distance zz from Top Vertex (0≤z≤D/20 \le z \le D/2)

At distance zz from the top vertex:

  • Cut width: b(z)=2zb(z) = 2z
  • Area of the triangle above level zz: A′=12(2z)z=z2A' = \frac{1}{2} (2z) z = z^2
  • Distance of centroid of this triangle from the neutral axis: yˉ′=D2−23z\bar{y}' = \frac{D}{2} - \frac{2}{3} z
  • First moment of area Q(z)Q(z): Q(z)=A′yˉ′=z2(D2−23z)Q(z) = A' \bar{y}' = z^2 \left(\frac{D}{2} - \frac{2}{3} z\right)

Substituting into Jourawski's formula:

τ(z)=V⋅Q(z)Ixx⋅b(z)=V⋅z2(D2−23z)(D448)⋅(2z)=24VD4z(D2−23z)=4VD4z(3D−4z)\tau(z) = \frac{V \cdot Q(z)}{I_{xx} \cdot b(z)} = \frac{V \cdot z^2 \left(\frac{D}{2} - \frac{2}{3} z\right)}{\left(\frac{D^4}{48}\right) \cdot (2z)} = \frac{24 V}{D^4} z \left(\frac{D}{2} - \frac{2}{3} z\right) = \frac{4 V}{D^4} z (3D - 4z)

Step 3: Locating the Maximum Shear Stress

Differentiating τ(z)\tau(z) with respect to zz:

dτdz=4VD4(3D−8z)=0  ⟹  3D−8z=0  ⟹  z=38D\frac{d\tau}{dz} = \frac{4V}{D^4}(3D - 8z) = 0 \implies 3D - 8z = 0 \implies z = \frac{3}{8} D

By symmetry, another peak occurs at z=58Dz = \frac{5}{8} D (or distance 18D\frac{1}{8} D from the NA on both sides).

Step 4: Values at Peak and Neutral Axis

  1. At Peak (z=38Dz = \frac{3}{8} D):

    τmax⁡=4VD4(38D)(3D−4⋅38D)=4VD4(38D)(32D)=94VD2\tau_{\max} = \frac{4V}{D^4}\left(\frac{3}{8}D\right)\left(3D - 4 \cdot \frac{3}{8}D\right) = \frac{4V}{D^4}\left(\frac{3}{8}D\right)\left(\frac{3}{2}D\right) = \frac{9}{4} \frac{V}{D^2}

    Since τavg=2VD2\tau_{\text{avg}} = \frac{2V}{D^2}:

    τmax⁡=98(2VD2)=98τavg=1.125⋅τavg\tau_{\max} = \frac{9}{8} \left(\frac{2V}{D^2}\right) = \frac{9}{8} \tau_{\text{avg}} = 1.125 \cdot \tau_{\text{avg}}
  2. At the Neutral Axis (z=D2z = \frac{D}{2}):

    τNA=4VD4(D2)(3D−4⋅D2)=2VD3(D)=2VD2=1.00⋅τavg\tau_{\text{NA}} = \frac{4V}{D^4}\left(\frac{D}{2}\right)\left(3D - 4 \cdot \frac{D}{2}\right) = \frac{2V}{D^3}(D) = \frac{2V}{D^2} = 1.00 \cdot \tau_{\text{avg}}
  3. Ratio of Maximum to Neutral Axis Shear Stress:

    τmax⁡τNA=98τavg1.00τavg=98=1.125\frac{\tau_{\max}}{\tau_{\text{NA}}} = \frac{\frac{9}{8}\tau_{\text{avg}}}{1.00\tau_{\text{avg}}} = \frac{9}{8} = 1.125

[!NOTE] In a diamond section, the shear stress distribution exhibits a twin-peak profile with peaks at 3/8D3/8 D from top and bottom vertices. At the neutral axis, the stress actually dips to a local minimum equal to the average shear stress (τNA=τavg\tau_{\text{NA}} = \tau_{\text{avg}}).


5. Engineering Assumptions, Limitations & Boundary Conditions

  1. Free Traction-Free Boundary Condition: At any exposed horizontal surface not subjected to external applied shear traction, the vertical shear stress must vanish: τ(ytop)=0,τ(ybottom)=0\tau(y_{\text{top}}) = 0, \quad \tau(y_{\text{bottom}}) = 0 This is mathematically guaranteed by Q(yext)=0Q(y_{\text{ext}}) = 0.
  2. Uniform Shear Stress Across Width bb: Jourawski's formula assumes τ\tau is uniform along the horizontal cut line. This is an excellent engineering approximation for slender beams where width bb is small relative to depth dd (b≪db \ll d). For very wide flanges (b>2db > 2d), shear lag causes higher shear stresses near the web junction than at outer tips.
  3. Linear Elastic, Homogeneous & Isotropic Material: Hooke's law applies, and cross-sections remain free from local plate buckling.
  4. Prismatic Axis & Unchecked Torsion: The transverse shear load VV is assumed to pass directly through the shear center of the section. If VV does not pass through the shear center, torsional shearing stresses are superposed onto transverse flexural shearing stresses (detailed in SOM-05-03).

6. SVG Technical Illustrations

Figure 1: Shear Stress Distribution Profiles in Canonical Sections

The diagram below compares the geometry, neutral axis location, and shear stress profiles for Solid Rectangular, Solid Circular, Thin Circular Tube, and Symmetrical I-Beam cross-sections.

Shear Stress Distribution Profiles in Canonical Sections

Figure 2: The Non-Central Shear Stress Paradox (Triangular & Diamond Sections)

The diagram below provides a detailed side-by-side derivation analysis of why triangular and diamond cross-sections exhibit peak shear stresses away from the neutral axis.

Triangular & Diamond Cross-Section Non-Central Shear Stress Paradox

7. Python-Recalculated Solved Numerical Examples

Numerical Example 1: Solid Circular Section vs. Thin-Walled Circular Tube

Problem Statement:
A simply supported beam carries a transverse shear force V=50 kNV = 50\text{ kN}. Evaluate and compare the shear stress performance of:

  1. A solid circular cross-section of diameter D=150 mmD = 150\text{ mm}.
  2. A hollow thin-walled circular tube of outer diameter Do=150 mmD_o = 150\text{ mm} and wall thickness t=5 mmt = 5\text{ mm}. Specifically determine for both sections:
  • Cross-sectional area AA and average shear stress τavg\tau_{\text{avg}}.
  • Maximum shear stress τmax⁡\tau_{\max} and its ratio τmax⁡/τavg\tau_{\max}/\tau_{\text{avg}}.
  • Shear stress in the solid bar at a distance y=50 mmy = 50\text{ mm} from the neutral axis.
  • The material savings achieved by the tube and the corresponding penalty in peak shear stress.

Step-by-Step Solution:

Part A: Solid Circular Section

  1. Geometry & Average Stress:

    R=D2=75 mmR = \frac{D}{2} = 75\text{ mm} As=πR2=π(75)2=17,671.4587 mm2A_s = \pi R^2 = \pi (75)^2 = 17,671.4587\text{ mm}^2 τavg=VAs=50,000 N17,671.4587 mm2=2.8294 MPa\tau_{\text{avg}} = \frac{V}{A_s} = \frac{50,000\text{ N}}{17,671.4587\text{ mm}^2} = 2.8294\text{ MPa}
  2. Maximum Shear Stress:

    τmax⁡=43τavg=43(2.8294)=3.7726 MPa\tau_{\max} = \frac{4}{3} \tau_{\text{avg}} = \frac{4}{3} (2.8294) = 3.7726\text{ MPa}
  3. Shear Stress at y=50 mmy = 50\text{ mm}:

    τ(y)=τmax⁡(1−y2R2)=3.7726(1−502752)=3.7726(1−49)=3.7726×59=2.0959 MPa\tau(y) = \tau_{\max} \left(1 - \frac{y^2}{R^2}\right) = 3.7726 \left(1 - \frac{50^2}{75^2}\right) = 3.7726 \left(1 - \frac{4}{9}\right) = 3.7726 \times \frac{5}{9} = 2.0959\text{ MPa}

Part B: Thin-Walled Circular Tube

  1. Geometry & Average Stress:

    Do=150 mm,t=5 mm  ⟹  Di=150−2(5)=140 mmD_o = 150\text{ mm}, \quad t = 5\text{ mm} \implies D_i = 150 - 2(5) = 140\text{ mm} Ro=75 mm,Ri=70 mm,Rm=72.5 mmR_o = 75\text{ mm}, \quad R_i = 70\text{ mm}, \quad R_m = 72.5\text{ mm} At=π4(Do2−Di2)=π4(1502−1402)=π4(22,500−19,600)=2,277.6547 mm2A_t = \frac{\pi}{4}\left(D_o^2 - D_i^2\right) = \frac{\pi}{4}\left(150^2 - 140^2\right) = \frac{\pi}{4}(22,500 - 19,600) = 2,277.6547\text{ mm}^2 τavg=VAt=50,000 N2,277.6547 mm2=21.9524 MPa\tau_{\text{avg}} = \frac{V}{A_t} = \frac{50,000\text{ N}}{2,277.6547\text{ mm}^2} = 21.9524\text{ MPa}
  2. Second Moment of Area & First Moment of Area at NA:

    It=π64(Do4−Di4)=π64(1504−1404)=π64(506.25×106−384.16×106)=5.99313×106 mm4I_t = \frac{\pi}{64}\left(D_o^4 - D_i^4\right) = \frac{\pi}{64}\left(150^4 - 140^4\right) = \frac{\pi}{64}(506.25 \times 10^6 - 384.16 \times 10^6) = 5.99313 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^4

    For the semi-annulus above the neutral axis:

    QNA=23(Ro3−Ri3)=23(753−703)=23(421,875−343,000)=52,583.3333 mm3Q_{\text{NA}} = \frac{2}{3}\left(R_o^3 - R_i^3\right) = \frac{2}{3}\left(75^3 - 70^3\right) = \frac{2}{3}(421,875 - 343,000) = 52,583.3333\text{ mm}^3
  3. Maximum Shear Stress at NA: The horizontal cut across the tube at the neutral axis passes through two walls, so b=2t=10 mmb = 2t = 10\text{ mm}:

    τmax⁡=V⋅QNAIt⋅b=50,000×52,583.3333(5.99313×106)×10=2.629167×1095.99313×107=43.8700 MPa\tau_{\max} = \frac{V \cdot Q_{\text{NA}}}{I_t \cdot b} = \frac{50,000 \times 52,583.3333}{(5.99313 \times 10^6) \times 10} = \frac{2.629167 \times 10^9}{5.99313 \times 10^7} = 43.8700\text{ MPa}
  4. Ratio Comparison & Material Savings:

    τmax⁡τavg=43.870021.9524=1.9984≈2.00\frac{\tau_{\max}}{\tau_{\text{avg}}} = \frac{43.8700}{21.9524} = 1.9984 \approx 2.00 Material Savings=As−AtAs×100%=17,671.46−2,277.6517,671.46×100%=87.11%\text{Material Savings} = \frac{A_s - A_t}{A_s} \times 100\% = \frac{17,671.46 - 2,277.65}{17,671.46} \times 100\% = 87.11\%

    The tube saves 87.11%87.11\% of steel weight while peak shear stress increases from 3.77 MPa3.77\text{ MPa} to 43.87 MPa43.87\text{ MPa} (which remains well within allowable steel shear limits of 100 MPa100\text{ MPa}).


Numerical Example 2: Shear Mechanics of a Triangular Beam

Problem Statement:
An inverted triangular timber beam has base b=180 mmb = 180\text{ mm} and height h=300 mmh = 300\text{ mm}. The beam carries a vertical shear force V=36 kNV = 36\text{ kN} at a critical support. Calculate:

  1. The average shear stress τavg\tau_{\text{avg}}.
  2. The maximum shear stress τmax⁡\tau_{\max} and the distance from the apex where it occurs.
  3. The shear stress at the neutral axis τNA\tau_{\text{NA}}.
  4. The shear stress at y=100 mmy = 100\text{ mm} from apex and at y=250 mmy = 250\text{ mm} from apex.
  5. The total shear force carried by the upper half of the triangle (from apex y=0y=0 to y=150 mmy = 150\text{ mm}) and by the lower half.

Step-by-Step Solution:

  1. Cross-Sectional Area & Average Shear Stress:

    A=12bh=12(180)(300)=27,000 mm2A = \frac{1}{2} b h = \frac{1}{2}(180)(300) = 27,000\text{ mm}^2 τavg=VA=36,000 N27,000 mm2=1.3333 MPa\tau_{\text{avg}} = \frac{V}{A} = \frac{36,000\text{ N}}{27,000\text{ mm}^2} = 1.3333\text{ MPa}
  2. Maximum Shear Stress & Location: From theoretical derivation, maximum shear stress occurs at mid-depth:

    ypeak=h2=3002=150 mm from apexy_{\text{peak}} = \frac{h}{2} = \frac{300}{2} = 150\text{ mm from apex} τmax⁡=1.50⋅τavg=1.50×1.3333=2.0000 MPa\tau_{\max} = 1.50 \cdot \tau_{\text{avg}} = 1.50 \times 1.3333 = 2.0000\text{ MPa}
  3. Shear Stress at the Neutral Axis: The neutral axis is located at y=23h=200 mmy = \frac{2}{3}h = 200\text{ mm} from the apex:

    τNA=43⋅τavg=43×1.3333=1.7778 MPa\tau_{\text{NA}} = \frac{4}{3} \cdot \tau_{\text{avg}} = \frac{4}{3} \times 1.3333 = 1.7778\text{ MPa}

    Check exam ratio:

    τmax⁡τNA=2.00001.7778=1.1250=98[Exact validation]\frac{\tau_{\max}}{\tau_{\text{NA}}} = \frac{2.0000}{1.7778} = 1.1250 = \frac{9}{8} \quad \text{[Exact validation]}
  4. Shear Stress at Specific Depths: Using the governing profile τ(y)=12Vbh3y(h−y)\tau(y) = \frac{12 V}{b h^3} y (h - y):

    12Vbh3=12×36,000180×3003=432,0004.86×109=8.8889×10−5 N/mm4\frac{12 V}{b h^3} = \frac{12 \times 36,000}{180 \times 300^3} = \frac{432,000}{4.86 \times 10^9} = 8.8889 \times 10^{-5}\text{ N/mm}^4
    • At y=100 mmy = 100\text{ mm}: τ(100)=(8.8889×10−5)×100×(300−100)=8.8889×10−5×20,000=1.7778 MPa\tau(100) = (8.8889 \times 10^{-5}) \times 100 \times (300 - 100) = 8.8889 \times 10^{-5} \times 20,000 = 1.7778\text{ MPa} (Note: τ(100)=τ(200)=τNA\tau(100) = \tau(200) = \tau_{\text{NA}} because y(h−y)=100×200=200×100y(h-y) = 100 \times 200 = 200 \times 100, demonstrating parabolic symmetry about mid-depth y=150 mmy=150\text{ mm}!)
    • At y=250 mmy = 250\text{ mm}: τ(250)=(8.8889×10−5)×250×(300−250)=8.8889×10−5×12,500=1.1111 MPa\tau(250) = (8.8889 \times 10^{-5}) \times 250 \times (300 - 250) = 8.8889 \times 10^{-5} \times 12,500 = 1.1111\text{ MPa}
  5. Shear Force Division Across Upper and Lower Halves:

    • Upper half (apex to y=150 mmy = 150\text{ mm}): Vupper=516V=516×36,000=11,250 N=11.25 kN(31.25%)V_{\text{upper}} = \frac{5}{16} V = \frac{5}{16} \times 36,000 = 11,250\text{ N} = 11.25\text{ kN} \quad (31.25\%)
    • Lower half (y=150 mmy = 150\text{ mm} to y=300 mmy = 300\text{ mm}): Vlower=1116V=1116×36,000=24,750 N=24.75 kN(68.75%)V_{\text{lower}} = \frac{11}{16} V = \frac{11}{16} \times 36,000 = 24,750\text{ N} = 24.75\text{ kN} \quad (68.75\%)

Numerical Example 3: Symmetrical Steel I-Beam (ISMB 350)

Problem Statement:
A rolled steel I-beam ISMB 350 has the following cross-sectional dimensions:

  • Overall depth D=350 mmD = 350\text{ mm}
  • Flange width B=140 mmB = 140\text{ mm}
  • Flange thickness tf=14.2 mmt_f = 14.2\text{ mm}
  • Web thickness tw=8.1 mmt_w = 8.1\text{ mm}
  • Depth of web between flanges dw=D−2tf=350−28.4=321.6 mmd_w = D - 2t_f = 350 - 28.4 = 321.6\text{ mm}
  • Total second moment of area Ixx=134.604×106 mm4I_{xx} = 134.604 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^4

The beam is subjected to a vertical shear force V=120 kNV = 120\text{ kN}. Calculate:

  1. The shear stress in the flange at the junction with the web.
  2. The shear stress in the web immediately below the junction, and verify the step-jump ratio.
  3. The maximum shear stress at the neutral axis.
  4. The exact vertical shear force carried by the web alone, and the percentage of total shear it represents.
  5. The average web shear stress according to IS 800:2007 (τcode=V/[D⋅tw]\tau_{\text{code}} = V / [D \cdot t_w]), and compare it with the exact peak shear stress at the NA.

Step-by-Step Solution:

  1. Shear Stress in Flange at the Junction (y=dw/2=160.8 mmy = d_w/2 = 160.8\text{ mm}): The area of one flange above the junction:

    Af=B⋅tf=140×14.2=1,988 mm2A_f = B \cdot t_f = 140 \times 14.2 = 1,988\text{ mm}^2

    Distance from neutral axis to centroid of flange:

    yˉf=D−tf2=350−14.22=167.9 mm\bar{y}_f = \frac{D - t_f}{2} = \frac{350 - 14.2}{2} = 167.9\text{ mm}

    First moment of area of the flange:

    Qf=Afyˉf=1,988×167.9=333,785.20 mm3Q_f = A_f \bar{y}_f = 1,988 \times 167.9 = 333,785.20\text{ mm}^3

    At the junction within the flange, the cut width is b=B=140 mmb = B = 140\text{ mm}:

    τf,junc=V⋅QfI⋅B=120,000×333,785.20(134.604×106)×140=4.00542×10101.88446×1010=2.1255 MPa\tau_{f, \text{junc}} = \frac{V \cdot Q_f}{I \cdot B} = \frac{120,000 \times 333,785.20}{(134.604 \times 10^6) \times 140} = \frac{4.00542 \times 10^{10}}{1.88446 \times 10^{10}} = 2.1255\text{ MPa}
  2. Shear Stress in Web at the Junction (y=160.8 mmy = 160.8\text{ mm}): Immediately inside the web, QQ remains Qf=333,785.20 mm3Q_f = 333,785.20\text{ mm}^3, but the cut width contracts to b=tw=8.1 mmb = t_w = 8.1\text{ mm}:

    τw,junc=V⋅QfI⋅tw=120,000×333,785.20(134.604×106)×8.1=4.00542×10101.09029×109=36.7372 MPa\tau_{w, \text{junc}} = \frac{V \cdot Q_f}{I \cdot t_w} = \frac{120,000 \times 333,785.20}{(134.604 \times 10^6) \times 8.1} = \frac{4.00542 \times 10^{10}}{1.09029 \times 10^9} = 36.7372\text{ MPa}

    Step Jump Ratio:

    τw,juncτf,junc=36.73722.1255=17.284=Btw=1408.1=17.284[Exact match]\frac{\tau_{w, \text{junc}}}{\tau_{f, \text{junc}}} = \frac{36.7372}{2.1255} = 17.284 = \frac{B}{t_w} = \frac{140}{8.1} = 17.284 \quad \text{[Exact match]}
  3. Maximum Shear Stress at Neutral Axis (y=0y = 0): The first moment of area at the neutral axis includes the flange plus half the web:

    Qw,half=tw(dw2)(dw4)=twdw28=8.1×321.628=104,719.39 mm3Q_{w, \text{half}} = t_w \left(\frac{d_w}{2}\right) \left(\frac{d_w}{4}\right) = \frac{t_w d_w^2}{8} = \frac{8.1 \times 321.6^2}{8} = 104,719.39\text{ mm}^3 Qtotal, NA=Qf+Qw,half=333,785.20+104,719.39=438,504.59 mm3Q_{\text{total, NA}} = Q_f + Q_{w, \text{half}} = 333,785.20 + 104,719.39 = 438,504.59\text{ mm}^3

    Maximum shear stress at NA:

    τmax⁡=V⋅Qtotal, NAI⋅tw=120,000×438,504.59(134.604×106)×8.1=5.26206×10101.09029×109=48.2629 MPa\tau_{\max} = \frac{V \cdot Q_{\text{total, NA}}}{I \cdot t_w} = \frac{120,000 \times 438,504.59}{(134.604 \times 10^6) \times 8.1} = \frac{5.26206 \times 10^{10}}{1.09029 \times 10^9} = 48.2629\text{ MPa}
  4. Exact Vertical Shear Force Carried by Web:

    Iweb=twdw312=8.1×321.6312=22.4415×106 mm4I_{\text{web}} = \frac{t_w d_w^3}{12} = \frac{8.1 \times 321.6^3}{12} = 22.4415 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^4 Vweb=VI[Qf⋅dw+Iweb]=120,000134.604×106[(333,785.20×321.6)+22.4415×106]V_{\text{web}} = \frac{V}{I}\left[Q_f \cdot d_w + I_{\text{web}}\right] = \frac{120,000}{134.604 \times 10^6}\left[(333,785.20 \times 321.6) + 22.4415 \times 10^6\right] Vweb=120,000134.604×106[107.3453×106+22.4415×106]=120,000×129.7868×106134.604×106=115,714.92 N=115.71 kNV_{\text{web}} = \frac{120,000}{134.604 \times 10^6}\left[107.3453 \times 10^6 + 22.4415 \times 10^6\right] = \frac{120,000 \times 129.7868 \times 10^6}{134.604 \times 10^6} = 115,714.92\text{ N} = 115.71\text{ kN}

    Percentage of Shear Carried by Web:

    %Vweb=115.714.92120,000×100%=96.43%\% V_{\text{web}} = \frac{115.714.92}{120,000} \times 100\% = 96.43\%

    Flanges carry only 100%−96.43%=3.57%100\% - 96.43\% = 3.57\% of the vertical shear force.

  5. Comparison with IS 800:2007 Simplified Code Method: IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.4 calculates nominal shear strength using the gross web area Av=D⋅twA_v = D \cdot t_w:

    τcode, avg=VD⋅tw=120,000 N350×8.1 mm2=120,0002,835=42.3280 MPa\tau_{\text{code, avg}} = \frac{V}{D \cdot t_w} = \frac{120,000\text{ N}}{350 \times 8.1\text{ mm}^2} = \frac{120,000}{2,835} = 42.3280\text{ MPa}

    Comparing exact maximum web stress with code average web stress:

    τmax⁡τcode, avg=48.262942.3280=1.140\frac{\tau_{\max}}{\tau_{\text{code, avg}}} = \frac{48.2629}{42.3280} = 1.140

    The exact peak stress is only 14.0%14.0\% higher than the nominal code average stress, which is comfortably absorbed by the partial safety factor γm0=1.10\gamma_{m0} = 1.10.


8. Practical Engineering Applications & Structural Design Considerations

  1. Structural Steel Plate Girders & I-Sections (IS 800:2007): Because the web carries over 95%95\% of the vertical shear, deep plate girder webs are made as thin as possible to save weight. However, when the web slenderness ratio dw/tw>67ϵd_w / t_w > 67\epsilon, the web becomes vulnerable to shear buckling before shear yielding. Vertical intermediate stiffeners are then welded along the web to prevent buckling.
  2. Timber Beams Parallel-to-Grain Shear (IS 3629:1986): Wood fibers run longitudinally along the beam length. Timber has very low shear strength parallel to the grain (τallow≈0.8 to 1.5 MPa\tau_{\text{allow}} \approx 0.8 \text{ to } 1.5\text{ MPa}) compared to its bending tensile strength (σallow≈10 to 15 MPa\sigma_{\text{allow}} \approx 10 \text{ to } 15\text{ MPa}). Consequently, short, heavily loaded timber beams almost invariably fail by horizontal shear splitting along the neutral axis, where τmax⁡=1.5τavg\tau_{\max} = 1.5 \tau_{\text{avg}}.
  3. Reinforced Concrete Beams (IS 456:2000 Cl. 40): Concrete has weak tensile capacity. Because Mohr's circle dictates that pure shear on the neutral axis generates principal tensile stresses of magnitude σ1=τ\sigma_1 = \tau inclined at 45∘45^\circ, shear failure manifests as diagonal tension cracks starting near the support at the neutral axis. Shear stirrups (vertical or inclined) are provided to intercept these 45∘45^\circ diagonal tension cracks.
  4. Prestressed Concrete (P/A Pre-Compression Benefit): By applying an axial pre-compression σ0=P/A\sigma_0 = P/A, Mohr's circle is shifted to the right, dramatically reducing the principal tensile stress σ1=(σ0/2)2+τ2−(σ0/2)\sigma_1 = \sqrt{(\sigma_0 / 2)^2 + \tau^2} - (\sigma_0 / 2), thereby preventing diagonal shear cracking.

9. Comparative Analysis & Summary Matrix

Section Geometry Depth Dimension Neutral Axis Location (yNAy_{\text{NA}}) Second Moment of Area (II) First Moment at NA (QNAQ_{\text{NA}}) Cut Width at NA (bNAb_{\text{NA}}) Location of Peak Shear Stress Max Shear Stress Ratio (τmax⁡/τavg\tau_{\max}/\tau_{\text{avg}}) NA Shear Stress Ratio (τNA/τavg\tau_{\text{NA}}/\tau_{\text{avg}}) Peak-to-NA Ratio (τmax⁡/τNA\tau_{\max}/\tau_{\text{NA}})
Solid Rectangle Depth dd, Width bb d/2d/2 (Mid-depth) bd312\frac{bd^3}{12} bd28\frac{bd^2}{8} bb Neutral Axis (y=0y = 0) 1.501.50 (3/23/2) 1.501.50 (3/23/2) 1.0001.000
Solid Circle Diameter D=2RD = 2R RR (Center) πR44\frac{\pi R^4}{4} 23R3\frac{2}{3}R^3 2R=D2R = D Neutral Axis (y=0y = 0) 1.3331.333 (4/34/3) 1.3331.333 (4/34/3) 1.0001.000
Thin Tube Mean Rad RmR_m, Thk tt RmR_m (Center) πRm3t\pi R_m^3 t 2Rm2t2 R_m^2 t 2t2t Neutral Axis (y=0y = 0) 2.0002.000 (2/12/1) 2.0002.000 (2/12/1) 1.0001.000
Triangular (Apex Up) Base bb, Height hh 2h/32h/3 from apex (h/3h/3 from base) bh336\frac{bh^3}{36} bh23h4h29=481bh2\frac{b h^2}{3h} \frac{4h^2}{9} = \frac{4}{81}bh^2 23b\frac{2}{3}b Mid-depth (h/2h/2 from apex) 1.5001.500 (3/23/2) 1.3331.333 (4/34/3) 1.1251.125 (9/89/8)
Diamond (Square on Vertex) Diagonal DD vertical D/2D/2 from vertex D448\frac{D^4}{48} D316\frac{D^3}{16} DD 3/8D3/8 D & 5/8D5/8 D from vertices 1.1251.125 (9/89/8) 1.0001.000 (1/11/1) 1.1251.125 (9/89/8)
Symmetrical I-Beam Flange BB, Web twt_w, Depth DD D/2D/2 (Center) BD3−(B−tw)dw312\frac{BD^3 - (B-t_w)d_w^3}{12} BtfD−tf2+twdw28Bt_f\frac{D-t_f}{2} + \frac{t_w d_w^2}{8} twt_w Neutral Axis (y=0y = 0) VQNAItwτavg\frac{V Q_{\text{NA}}}{I t_w \tau_{\text{avg}}} VQNAItwτavg\frac{V Q_{\text{NA}}}{I t_w \tau_{\text{avg}}} 1.0001.000

10. Key Takeaways & Exam-Oriented Highlights

  1. Parabolic Profiles: In rectangular, circular, tubular, triangular, and diamond sections, the shear stress distribution follows a parabolic curve across depth.
  2. Boundary Zero Condition: At free top and bottom boundaries, τ=0\tau = 0 because there is no area above or below the cut (Q=0Q = 0).
  3. Rectangular Section Rule: τmax⁡=1.50τavg\tau_{\max} = 1.50 \tau_{\text{avg}}, occurring at the neutral axis. The middle half of a rectangular beam carries 68.75%68.75\% (1116\frac{11}{16}) of the total vertical shear.
  4. Circular Section Rule: τmax⁡=43τavg≈1.333τavg\tau_{\max} = \frac{4}{3} \tau_{\text{avg}} \approx 1.333 \tau_{\text{avg}}, occurring at the neutral axis.
  5. Thin Circular Tube Rule: τmax⁡=2.00τavg\tau_{\max} = 2.00 \tau_{\text{avg}} at the neutral axis.
  6. Triangular Section Paradox:
    • Maximum shear stress occurs at mid-depth h/2h/2, NOT at the neutral axis (2h/32h/3).
    • τmax⁡=1.50τavg\tau_{\max} = 1.50 \tau_{\text{avg}} (at h/2h/2).
    • τNA=43τavg\tau_{\text{NA}} = \frac{4}{3} \tau_{\text{avg}} (at 2h/32h/3).
    • Critical Ratio: τmax⁡τNA=98=1.125\frac{\tau_{\max}}{\tau_{\text{NA}}} = \frac{9}{8} = 1.125.
    • Upper half carries 31.25%31.25\% (5/165/16), lower half carries 68.75%68.75\% (11/1611/16) of total shear force.
  7. Diamond Section Paradox:
    • Maximum shear stress occurs at 3/8D3/8 D and 5/8D5/8 D from vertices (18D\frac{1}{8} D from NA).
    • τmax⁡=98τavg=1.125τavg\tau_{\max} = \frac{9}{8} \tau_{\text{avg}} = 1.125 \tau_{\text{avg}}.
    • At the neutral axis, τNA=1.00τavg\tau_{\text{NA}} = 1.00 \tau_{\text{avg}}.
    • Critical Ratio: τmax⁡τNA=98=1.125\frac{\tau_{\max}}{\tau_{\text{NA}}} = \frac{9}{8} = 1.125.
  8. I-Section Step Discontinuity: At the flange-web junction, τ\tau jumps abruptly by the factor B/twB/t_w. The web carries 85% to 98%85\% \text{ to } 98\% of the total vertical shear force.

11. Common Traps, Pitfalls & Counter-Intuitive Exam Scenarios

  • Trap 1: Assuming τmax⁡\tau_{\max} Always Occurs at the Neutral Axis:
    Misconception: Students instinctively answer that maximum shear stress occurs at the neutral axis for all beams.
    Correction: While true for symmetric sections with non-diminishing width (rectangles, circles, I-beams), it is false for triangles (peaks at h/2h/2) and diamonds (peaks at 3/8D3/8 D and 5/8D5/8 D).
  • Trap 2: Forgetting the Cut Width in Hollow Tubes:
    Misconception: Calculating shear stress at the NA of a tube using cut width b=tb = t.
    Correction: A horizontal plane through the neutral axis slices through both walls of the tube, so b=2tb = 2t. Omitting the factor of 2 doubles the calculated stress incorrectly.
  • Trap 3: Confusing τmax⁡/τavg\tau_{\max} / \tau_{\text{avg}} with τmax⁡/τNA\tau_{\max} / \tau_{\text{NA}}:
    Misconception: In competitive exam questions, students confuse the ratio with respect to average stress and the ratio with respect to neutral axis stress.
    Correction: For a triangle: τmax⁡/τavg=1.50\tau_{\max} / \tau_{\text{avg}} = 1.50, whereas τmax⁡/τNA=9/8=1.125\tau_{\max} / \tau_{\text{NA}} = 9/8 = 1.125. Always re-read the denominator requested in the question prompt.
  • Trap 4: Neglecting Flange Shear Force in Rolled Steel Sections:
    Misconception: Believing flanges carry no shear at all.
    Correction: Flanges carry vertical shear (typically 2%2\% to 8%8\%) and also carry significant horizontal transverse shear flows (q=VQ/Iq = V Q / I) which run from outer tips toward the web junction.
  • Trap 5: Using Section Depth Rather than Centroid Distance for QQ:
    Misconception: Using the distance to the outer fiber instead of the centroid yˉ′\bar{y}' of the cut area.
    Correction: Q=A′yˉ′Q = A' \bar{y}', where yˉ′\bar{y}' is measured from the neutral axis of the full section to the centroid of the isolated area A′A'.

12. Standard Code Provisions & Objective Practice Problems

Reference Code Clauses

  • IS 800:2007 (Cl. 8.4): Design shear strength of steel members Vd=Vn/γm0V_d = V_n / \gamma_{m0}, where Vn=Vp=Avfy3V_n = V_p = \frac{A_v f_y}{\sqrt{3}}. For rolled I-sections, shear area Av=D⋅twA_v = D \cdot t_w.
  • IS 800:2007 (Cl. 8.4.2): Shear buckling resistance must be verified when dw/tw>67ϵd_w / t_w > 67\epsilon, where ϵ=250/fy\epsilon = \sqrt{250 / f_y}.
  • IS 456:2000 (Cl. 40.1): Nominal shear stress in RCC beams τv=Vubd\tau_v = \frac{V_u}{b d}, with maximum design shear stress limited to τc,max⁡\tau_{c, \max} per Table 20.
  • IS 3629:1986 (Cl. 6.3): Horizontal shear stress in timber beams must satisfy τ=3V2bd≤τallow, parallel\tau = \frac{3 V}{2 b d} \le \tau_{\text{allow, parallel}}.

Objective Practice Problems

Problem 1 (GATE CE / ESE)

In a beam of triangular cross-section of base bb and height hh, subjected to vertical shear force VV, the maximum shear stress occurs at:

  • (A) The neutral axis (2h/32h/3 from the apex)
  • (B) The base of the triangle
  • (C) Mid-depth (h/2h/2 from the apex)
  • (D) h/3h/3 from the apex

Answer: (C)
Solution: τ(y)=12Vbh3y(h−y)\tau(y) = \frac{12 V}{b h^3} y (h - y). Setting dτ/dy=0  ⟹  h−2y=0  ⟹  y=h/2d\tau/dy = 0 \implies h - 2y = 0 \implies y = h/2 (mid-depth).


Problem 2 (SSC JE / RRB JE)

The ratio of maximum shear stress to average shear stress in a solid circular beam cross-section is:

  • (A) 1.501.50
  • (B) 1.331.33
  • (C) 1.1251.125
  • (D) 2.002.00

Answer: (B)
Solution: For a solid circle, τmax⁡=43τavg≈1.333\tau_{\max} = \frac{4}{3} \tau_{\text{avg}} \approx 1.333.


Problem 3 (GATE CE / State AE)

For a square beam cross-section of side aa with its diagonal positioned vertically, the ratio of maximum shear stress to the shear stress at the neutral axis is:

  • (A) 1.001.00
  • (B) 1.1251.125
  • (C) 1.3331.333
  • (D) 1.5001.500

Answer: (B)
Solution: For a diamond section (square on vertex), τmax⁡=98τavg\tau_{\max} = \frac{9}{8} \tau_{\text{avg}} occurring at 3/8D3/8 D from vertex, while τNA=1.00τavg\tau_{\text{NA}} = 1.00 \tau_{\text{avg}} at the neutral axis. Hence, τmax⁡τNA=9/81.0=98=1.125\frac{\tau_{\max}}{\tau_{\text{NA}}} = \frac{9/8}{1.0} = \frac{9}{8} = 1.125.


Problem 4 (ESE / State AE)

In a rectangular beam of width bb and depth dd carrying vertical shear force VV, what percentage of the total shear force is resisted by the middle half of the section (between y=−d/4y = -d/4 and y=+d/4y = +d/4)?

  • (A) 50.0%50.0\%
  • (B) 68.75%68.75\%
  • (C) 75.0%75.0\%
  • (D) 87.5%87.5\%

Answer: (B)
Solution: Vmid-half=∫−d/4d/4τ(y)b dy=1116V=0.6875V=68.75%V_{\text{mid-half}} = \int_{-d/4}^{d/4} \tau(y) b \, dy = \frac{11}{16} V = 0.6875 V = 68.75\%.


Problem 5 (GATE CE)

A thin-walled circular tube of mean radius RR and wall thickness tt (t≪Rt \ll R) is subjected to shear force VV. If τavg=V/(2πRt)\tau_{\text{avg}} = V / (2\pi R t), the maximum shear stress in the tube is:

  • (A) 43τavg\frac{4}{3} \tau_{\text{avg}}
  • (B) 1.50τavg1.50 \tau_{\text{avg}}
  • (C) 2.00τavg2.00 \tau_{\text{avg}}
  • (D) π2τavg\frac{\pi}{2} \tau_{\text{avg}}

Answer: (C)
Solution: At the neutral axis, QNA=2R2tQ_{\text{NA}} = 2 R^2 t, I=πR3tI = \pi R^3 t, and cut width b=2tb = 2t. Thus, τmax⁡=V(2R2t)(πR3t)(2t)=VπRt=2⋅V2πRt=2.00τavg\tau_{\max} = \frac{V (2 R^2 t)}{(\pi R^3 t)(2t)} = \frac{V}{\pi R t} = 2 \cdot \frac{V}{2\pi R t} = 2.00 \tau_{\text{avg}}.