STEEL-05-04 Chapter 05 · Plate Girders

Gantry Girders & Industrial Roof Trusses (IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.2, Cl. 8.9 & IS 875)

In this chapter (4 topics)
On this page
  1. 1. Executive Summary & Code Hierarchy
  2. 2. Gantry Crane Runway Mechanics & Operational Load Combinations
  3. 2.1 Wheel Load Computation
  4. 2.2 Dynamic Allowances & Design Wheel Loads (IS 875 Part 2)
  5. 3. Built-Up Gantry Girder Cross-Section Architecture
  6. 3.1 Why Plain Rolled I-Beams Fail
  7. 3.2 The ISMB + Channel Built-Up Section
  8. 4. Biaxial Bending Capacity & Interaction Analysis
  9. 4.1 Cross-Section Properties of Built-Up Section
  10. 4.2 Biaxial Bending Interaction Check (IS 800 Cl. 9.3.2)
  11. 5. Serviceability & Deflection Limitations (IS 800 Table 6)
  12. 6. Industrial Roof Trusses: Geometry, Configurations & Spacing
  13. 6.1 Common Configurations & Span Suitability
  14. 6.2 Economical Proportions
  15. 7. Roof Truss Load Analysis & Wind Pressure (IS 875)
  16. 7.1 Dead Loads (DL) per IS 875 (Part 1)
  17. 7.2 Imposed (Live) Loads (LL) per IS 875 (Part 2)
  18. 7.3 Wind Loads (WL) per IS 875 (Part 3)
  19. 7.4 The Reversal of Stress Phenomenon
  20. 8. Purlin Design on Sloping Roofs (IS 800 Cl. 8.9)
  21. 8.1 Load Resolution
  22. 8.2 Bending Moments in Purlins
  23. 8.3 Biaxial Bending Check
  24. 9. SVG Engineering Visualizations
  25. FIGURE STEEL-05-04A: Gantry Girder Cross-Section & Biaxial Mechanics
  26. FIGURE STEEL-05-04B: Industrial Roof Truss Geometry & Purlin Biaxial Bending
  27. 10. Complete Step-by-Step Mathematical Derivations
  28. Derivation 1: Absolute Maximum Bending Moment Under Two Moving Wheel Loads
  29. Derivation 2: Net Aerodynamic Wind Uplift on Lightweight Roofs
  30. 11. Multi-Exam Comprehensive Solved Examples
  31. Example 1: Full Gantry Girder Design under Crane Wheel Loads (GATE CE / ESE Conventional)
  32. Example 2: Industrial Roof Truss Load Calculation & Wind Uplift
  33. Example 3: Channel Purlin Design under Biaxial Bending
  34. 12. Exam Traps, Common Pitfalls & Practical Fabrication Rules
  35. Trap 1: Forgetting that Lateral Surge is Shared by Four Wheels
  36. Trap 2: Deflection Calculation with Factored Loads
  37. Trap 3: Stress Reversal in Truss Ties
  38. Trap 4: Purlin Orientation & Cleat Details
  39. 13. Official Exam Practice Questions
  40. Question 1 (GATE CE)
  41. Question 2 (UPSC ESE)
  42. Question 3 (SSC JE)
  43. Question 4 (State AE / RRB JE)
  44. Question 5 (UPSC ESE Conventional)

1. Executive Summary & Code Hierarchy

In heavy industrial manufacturing plants, steel mills, shipyards, and railway maintenance workshops, large structural frameworks are required to enclose vast column-free spaces while supporting heavy dynamic material-handling machinery. The two defining structural components of such industrial complexes are Gantry Girders and Industrial Roof Trusses:

  1. Gantry Girders (Crane Runway Beams):

    • Structural members that support overhead travelling cranes (EOT or HOT cranes).
    • Unlike stationary building girders, gantry girders are subjected to heavy moving concentrated dynamic wheel loads acting concurrently with transverse lateral surge (from crab acceleration and sudden braking) and longitudinal tractive forces.
    • These simultaneous multi-directional dynamic forces induce severe biaxial bending (MzM_z and MyM_y), torsion, and localized web fatigue.
    • Standard rolled I-beams lack adequate lateral flexural stiffness; hence, gantry girders almost universally utilize built-up cross-sections (e.g., an ISMB rolled I-beam reinforced with an ISMC channel welded toes-down to the top flange).
  2. Industrial Roof Trusses & Purlins:

    • Pitched triangulated open-web frameworks (Fink, Pratt, Howe, Warren) designed to span large industrial bays (L=12 m to 36 mL = 12\text{ m to }36\text{ m}) under combinations of dead load (roofing sheets and insulation), variable maintenance live load, and severe aerodynamic wind forces.
    • Roof slopes subject transverse purlins (channels or angles spanning between trusses) to biaxial bending under gravity loads inclined to their principal axes.
    • High aerodynamic wind suction frequently exceeds the light dead weight of industrial roofs, causing complete stress reversal in truss ties and rafter members.

The statutory design frameworks governing these industrial systems include:

  • IS 800:2007 (Section 8.2, 8.9 & Section 9.3): General Construction in Steel — Code of Practice.
  • IS 875 (Part 1, 2 & 3):1987 (Reaffirmed 2018): Code of Practice for Design Loads for Buildings and Structures (Part 1: Dead Loads, Part 2: Imposed Loads, Part 3: Wind Loads).
  • AISC Design Guide 7: Industrial Buildings — Roofs to Column Anchorage.
  • Eurocode 3 (EN 1993-6): Crane Supporting Structures.
┌───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│                  GANTRY GIRDER CRANE LOADS (IS 875 PART 2)                        │
├───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│ 1. Maximum Static Wheel Load (W_static):                                          │
│    Obtained by placing the crab at minimum hook approach to one runway rail.     │
│                                                                                   │
│ 2. Vertical Dynamic Impact Allowances (Table 1):                                  │
│    - Electrically Operated Travelling (EOT) Cranes: +25% of static wheel load.    │
│    - Hand Operated Travelling (HOT) Cranes:        +10% of static wheel load.    │
│                                                                                   │
│ 3. Lateral Surge Load (Transverse to Runway):                                     │
│    - 10% of weight of (Crab + Lifted Hook Load) shared equally among wheels.      │
│                                                                                   │
│ 4. Longitudinal Tractive / Braking Force:                                         │
│    - 5% of total static wheel loads acting parallel to runway rail.               │
└───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

2. Gantry Crane Runway Mechanics & Operational Load Combinations

2.1 Wheel Load Computation

Consider an overhead travelling crane of capacity QQ (hook load) operating across a bay width (crane bridge span) LcL_c.

  • Weight of crane bridge girder =Wbridge= W_{bridge}.
  • Weight of crab (trolley with hoist machinery) =Wcrab= W_{crab}.
  • Minimum hook approach distance from rail =chook= c_{hook}.

The crane bridge dead weight is distributed equally between the two runway rails:

Rbridge=Wbridge2R_{bridge} = \frac{W_{bridge}}{2}

The maximum reaction from the crab and lifted hook load occurs when the crab is positioned at the extreme end of travel (minimum hook approach):

Rcrab=(Q+Wcrab)(Lc−chook)LcR_{crab} = \frac{(Q + W_{crab}) (L_c - c_{hook})}{L_c}

The maximum static load on one runway rail is:

Wrail=Rbridge+RcrabW_{rail} = R_{bridge} + R_{crab}

For a standard crane with an end carriage supported by two wheels per rail, the static wheel load is:

Wstatic=Wrail2W_{static} = \frac{W_{rail}}{2}

2.2 Dynamic Allowances & Design Wheel Loads (IS 875 Part 2)

To account for dynamic shock, track unevenness, rail joint impacts, and rapid acceleration/braking:

  1. Vertical Dynamic Wheel Load (WvW_v):

    Wv=1.25⋅Wstatic(for EOT cranes)Wv=1.10⋅Wstatic(for Hand cranes)\begin{aligned} W_v &= 1.25 \cdot W_{static} \quad (\text{for EOT cranes}) \\ W_v &= 1.10 \cdot W_{static} \quad (\text{for Hand cranes}) \end{aligned}
  2. Lateral Surge Load (HlatH_{lat}): During transverse movement of the crab across the crane bridge, sudden braking induces inertia forces transverse to the gantry girder rails. IS 875 (Part 2) specifies the total lateral surge as:

    Htotal=0.10⋅(Q+Wcrab)H_{total} = 0.10 \cdot (Q + W_{crab})

    This force is shared equally across the 4 wheels of the crane (2 wheels on each rail). Thus, the lateral surge load per wheel is:

    Hwheel=Htotal4=0.10(Q+Wcrab)4H_{wheel} = \frac{H_{total}}{4} = \frac{0.10 (Q + W_{crab})}{4}
  3. Longitudinal Tractive Force (TlongT_{long}): When the crane accelerates or brakes along the runway rail, braking friction develops along the rail head:

    Trail=0.05⋅Wrail=0.05⋅(2⋅Wstatic)T_{rail} = 0.05 \cdot W_{rail} = 0.05 \cdot (2 \cdot W_{static})

    acting at the top of the crane rail parallel to the longitudinal axis of the gantry girder.


3. Built-Up Gantry Girder Cross-Section Architecture

3.1 Why Plain Rolled I-Beams Fail

A standard rolled I-section (e.g., ISMB 500) has a very high major-axis moment of inertia IzI_z, but its minor-axis moment of inertia IyI_y is extremely small (typically Iy≈120 to 135IzI_y \approx \frac{1}{20}\text{ to }\frac{1}{35} I_z). Under the lateral surge load HlatH_{lat}, a plain I-beam experiences:

  1. Excessive lateral bending stresses σby=My/Zy\sigma_{by} = M_y / Z_y.
  2. Severe Lateral-Torsional Buckling (LTB) of the unbraced top flange.
  3. Rapid fatigue cracking at the web-flange junction.

3.2 The ISMB + Channel Built-Up Section

To overcome this vulnerability, industrial structural engineers fabricate a composite built-up section by welding an ISMC channel section with its toes pointing downward directly onto the top flange of the rolled I-beam:

                  Crane Rail
                  ┌────────┐
                  └────────┘
       ISMC CHANNEL (Toes Pointing Down)
    ┌──────────────────────────────────┐
    │                                  │
    └──┐                            ┌──┘
    ═══╧════════════════════════════╧═══
    │   Top Flange of Rolled I-Beam    │
    ════════════════════════════════════
                   │  │
                   │  │  Web of I-Beam
                   │  │  (Major depth D)
                   │  │
    ════════════════════════════════════
    │  Bottom Flange of Rolled I-Beam  │
    ════════════════════════════════════

Key Structural Advantages:

  1. Massive Lateral Stiffness: The web of the channel lies horizontally, creating a wide flange plate of width bc≈250 to 400 mmb_c \approx 250\text{ to }400\text{ mm} at the extreme top fiber. This increases IyI_y by 400% to 700%400\%\text{ to }700\%, suppressing lateral deflection and preventing LTB.
  2. Downward Toes: Welding the channel toes downward simplifies automatic fillet welding to the I-beam flange and provides a clean, flat top surface for seating the crane rail.
  3. Elevated Neutral Axis: The added top steel shifts the neutral axis upward (ybar>D/2y_{bar} > D/2), placing greater section modulus at the compression fiber where concurrent vertical and lateral bending stresses add up.

4. Biaxial Bending Capacity & Interaction Analysis

4.1 Cross-Section Properties of Built-Up Section

Consider an ISMB of area A1A_1, depth D1D_1, and moments of inertia Iz1,Iy1I_{z1}, I_{y1}, combined with an ISMC channel of area A2A_2, web thickness tw2t_{w2}, depth D2D_2 (channel web length), and moments of inertia Ix2,Iy2I_{x2}, I_{y2}.

  • Total cross-sectional area: Atotal=A1+A2A_{total} = A_1 + A_2
  • Height of centroid above bottom flange: yˉ=A1(D1/2)+A2(D1+tw2−Cy)Atotal\bar{y} = \frac{A_1 (D_1 / 2) + A_2 (D_1 + t_{w2} - C_y)}{A_{total}}
  • Distance to top extreme fiber: ytop=(D1+tw2)−yˉy_{top} = (D_1 + t_{w2}) - \bar{y}
  • Major-axis moment of inertia: Izz=[Iz1+A1(yˉ−D12)2]+[Iy2+A2(ytop−Cy)2]I_{zz} = \left[ I_{z1} + A_1 \left(\bar{y} - \frac{D_1}{2}\right)^2 \right] + \left[ I_{y2} + A_2 (y_{top} - C_y)^2 \right]
  • Minor-axis moment of inertia: Iyy=Iy1+Ix2I_{yy} = I_{y1} + I_{x2} (Note: The major axis x−xx-x of the channel becomes parallel to the y−yy-y axis of the gantry girder!)

4.2 Biaxial Bending Interaction Check (IS 800 Cl. 9.3.2)

At the top fiber, maximum vertical bending compressive stress acts concurrently with lateral bending compressive stress from surge:

MuzMdz+MuyMdy≤1.0\frac{M_{uz}}{M_{dz}} + \frac{M_{uy}}{M_{dy}} \le 1.0

where:

  • Muz=1.5(Mz,live+Mz,dead)M_{uz} = 1.5 (M_{z,live} + M_{z,dead}) is the factored vertical bending moment.
  • Muy=1.5My,liveM_{uy} = 1.5 M_{y,live} is the factored horizontal bending moment.
  • Mdz=Zez,top⋅fyγm0M_{dz} = \frac{Z_{ez,top} \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} is the design bending capacity about the major axis.
  • Mdy=Zey,top⋅fyγm0M_{dy} = \frac{Z_{ey,top} \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} is the design lateral bending capacity of the top flange assembly (Zey,top≈Iyy,top/(D2/2)Z_{ey,top} \approx I_{yy,top} / (D_2 / 2)).

5. Serviceability & Deflection Limitations (IS 800 Table 6)

In gantry girder design, serviceability deflection limits frequently govern over strength criteria. Excessive vertical deflection causes the crane bridge to tilt and jam, while excessive horizontal deflection spreads or tightens the track gauge, causing wheel flanges to bind and potentially derail.

All deflection checks are performed under unfactored serviceability live loads without dynamic impact allowances:

Crane Type / Operating ConditionMaximum Permissible Deflection (IS 800 Table 6)Manually Operated Cranes (HOT)δv≤L/500Electrically Operated Cranes (EOT) up to 500 kN capacityδv≤L/750(or L/600 for light duty)Electrically Operated Cranes (EOT) over 500 kN capacityδv≤L/1000Charging Cranes / Heavy Steel Plant Mill Cranesδv≤L/1000 to L/1200Horizontal Lateral Deflection (All Cranes)δh≤min⁡(L/400,10 mm)\begin{array}{|l|l|} \hline \textbf{Crane Type / Operating Condition} & \textbf{Maximum Permissible Deflection (IS 800 Table 6)} \\ \hline \text{Manually Operated Cranes (HOT)} & \delta_v \le L / 500 \\ \text{Electrically Operated Cranes (EOT) up to } 500\text{ kN capacity} & \delta_v \le L / 750 \quad (\text{or } L / 600\text{ for light duty}) \\ \text{Electrically Operated Cranes (EOT) over } 500\text{ kN capacity} & \delta_v \le L / 1000 \\ \text{Charging Cranes / Heavy Steel Plant Mill Cranes} & \delta_v \le L / 1000\text{ to }L / 1200 \\ \hline \textbf{Horizontal Lateral Deflection (All Cranes)} & \delta_h \le \min(L / 400, 10\text{ mm}) \\ \hline \end{array}

6. Industrial Roof Trusses: Geometry, Configurations & Spacing

An industrial roof truss is a plane triangulated structure carrying roof sheeting across long spans.

       FINK (FRENCH) TRUSS                         PRATT TRUSS
          (Economical for spans 12-20 m)             (Webs in tension under gravity)
                     ▲                                          ▲
                    / \                                        /|\
                   /   \                                      / | \
                  /  /\ \                                    /  |  \
                 /  /  \ \                                  /   |   \
                /__/____\_\                                /____|____\

6.1 Common Configurations & Span Suitability

  1. King Post Truss: Spans up to 6 m6\text{ m} (simple triangular truss with a central vertical tie).
  2. Queen Post Truss: Spans 6 m to 10 m6\text{ m to }10\text{ m} (two vertical ties with a horizontal straining beam).
  3. Howe Truss: Spans 6 m to 30 m6\text{ m to }30\text{ m} (vertical web members are in tension; diagonal web members are in compression under gravity).
  4. Pratt Truss: Spans 6 m to 30 m6\text{ m to }30\text{ m} (vertical web members are in compression; diagonal web members are in tension under gravity). Highly economical because longer diagonals are in tension, eliminating buckling concerns.
  5. Fink (French) Truss: Spans 12 m to 20 m12\text{ m to }20\text{ m} (internal sub-triangulation minimizes the unsupported length of the compression rafter).
  6. North-Light (Saw-Tooth) Truss: Spans 8 m to 15 m8\text{ m to }15\text{ m} (steep glazed vertical/inclined pitch facing North, providing uniform glare-free natural sunlight for textile and precision manufacturing plants).

6.2 Economical Proportions

  • Pitch (Rise to Span Ratio h/Lh/L): Pitch=14 to 16(Slope θ≈14∘ to 30∘)\text{Pitch} = \frac{1}{4} \text{ to } \frac{1}{6} \quad (\text{Slope } \theta \approx 14^\circ \text{ to } 30^\circ) Note: Slopes flatter than 14∘14^\circ (1/81/8 pitch) cause rainwater ponding and leakage at sheet overlaps. Slopes steeper than 30∘30^\circ (1/31/3 pitch) increase wind suction forces and truss self-weight.
  • Truss Spacing (SS): Spacing S≈13 to 15 of span(typically 3.0 m to 6.0 m)\text{Spacing } S \approx \frac{1}{3} \text{ to } \frac{1}{5} \text{ of span} \quad (\text{typically } 3.0\text{ m to }6.0\text{ m}) (Rule of thumb: Overall cost of roof system is minimized when: Cost of Trusses = Cost of Purlins + Cost of Roof Covering).

7. Roof Truss Load Analysis & Wind Pressure (IS 875)

7.1 Dead Loads (DL) per IS 875 (Part 1)

  • Corrugated Galvanized Iron (GI) sheets: 100 to 160 N/m2100\text{ to }160\text{ N/m}^2 of plan area.
  • Corrugated Asbestos Cement (AC) sheets: 160 to 210 N/m2160\text{ to }210\text{ N/m}^2.
  • Purlins: 100 to 150 N/m2100\text{ to }150\text{ N/m}^2.
  • Empirical Truss Self-Weight (wtrussw_{truss}): wtruss=10(L3+5)(N/m2 of plan area)w_{truss} = 10 \left( \frac{L}{3} + 5 \right) \quad (\text{N/m}^2\text{ of plan area}) where LL is the truss span in meters.

7.2 Imposed (Live) Loads (LL) per IS 875 (Part 2)

For sloping roofs with slope θ>10∘\theta > 10^\circ (where access is not provided except for maintenance):

LL=0.75−0.02(θ−10∘)(kN/m2 of plan area)LL = 0.75 - 0.02 (\theta - 10^\circ) \quad (\text{kN/m}^2\text{ of plan area})

subject to an absolute minimum threshold:

LL≥0.40 kN/m2LL \ge 0.40\text{ kN/m}^2

7.3 Wind Loads (WL) per IS 875 (Part 3)

  1. Design Wind Speed (VzV_z):

    Vz=Vb⋅k1⋅k2⋅k3⋅k4V_z = V_b \cdot k_1 \cdot k_2 \cdot k_3 \cdot k_4

    where VbV_b is basic wind speed, k1k_1 is risk coefficient (probability factor), k2k_2 is terrain and height factor, k3k_3 is topography factor, and k4k_4 is cyclonic importance factor.

  2. Design Wind Pressure (pzp_z):

    pz=0.6⋅Vz2(N/m2)p_z = 0.6 \cdot V_z^2 \quad (\text{N/m}^2)
  3. Wind Force on Roof Surface:

    Fwind=(Cpe−Cpi)⋅A⋅pzF_{wind} = (C_{pe} - C_{pi}) \cdot A \cdot p_z

    where CpeC_{pe} is the external pressure coefficient (Table 5 of IS 875 Pt 3), CpiC_{pi} is internal pressure coefficient (±0.20\pm 0.20 for normal permeability <5%< 5\%, ±0.50\pm 0.50 for medium 5–20%5\text{–}20\%), and AA is surface area.

7.4 The Reversal of Stress Phenomenon

For typical roof pitches (θ=15∘ to 30∘\theta = 15^\circ\text{ to }30^\circ), external wind flow induces severe aerodynamic suction on both the windward (Cpe≈−0.70C_{pe} \approx -0.70) and leeward (Cpe≈−0.40C_{pe} \approx -0.40) slopes. When combined with internal pressure (Cpi=+0.50C_{pi} = +0.50), the net wind uplift is:

Cp,net=−0.70−(+0.50)=−1.20(Net upward suction)C_{p,net} = -0.70 - (+0.50) = -1.20 \quad (\text{Net upward suction})

Because industrial roofs are lightweight (DL≈0.35 kN/m2DL \approx 0.35\text{ kN/m}^2 vs Wind Uplift ≈1.50 kN/m2\approx 1.50\text{ kN/m}^2), the upward wind suction overcomes gravity dead load, causing:

  1. The bottom tie (which carries tension under gravity) to undergo complete reversal into compression.
  2. The principal rafter (which carries compression under gravity) to undergo reversal into tension.
  3. Under IS 800:2007 Table 3, members subjected to compression resulting from wind/earthquake reversal must have a slenderness ratio: KLr≤350\frac{KL}{r} \le 350

8. Purlin Design on Sloping Roofs (IS 800 Cl. 8.9)

Purlins are continuous beams supported at truss panel nodes. Because they rest directly on the sloping principal rafter, their major axis x−xx-x is tilted at angle θ\theta to the horizontal.

                  w_u (Vertical Gravity Load)
                  │
                  ▼
              ┌───────┐
              │ \  θ  │
        w_un  │  \    │  w_up
        ◄─────┼───\   ▼
      (Normal)│    \ (Parallel)
              └─────\
                     \ Rafter Slope θ

8.1 Load Resolution

Let wuw_u be the factored vertical gravity load per meter run of purlin:

  • Component Normal to Roof (wunw_{un}): wun=wucos⁡θ(causes major-axis bending Mux)w_{un} = w_u \cos\theta \quad (\text{causes major-axis bending } M_{ux})
  • Component Parallel to Roof (wupw_{up}): wup=wusin⁡θ(causes minor-axis bending Muy)w_{up} = w_u \sin\theta \quad (\text{causes minor-axis bending } M_{uy})

8.2 Bending Moments in Purlins

Assuming purlins are continuous over trusses of spacing LL (IS 800 Cl. 8.9):

Mux=wun⋅L210M_{ux} = \frac{w_{un} \cdot L^2}{10} Muy=wup⋅L210M_{uy} = \frac{w_{up} \cdot L^2}{10}

(If sag rods are provided at mid-span, the minor-axis span is halved to L/2L/2, drastically reducing minor-axis moment to Muy=wup(L/2)28M_{uy} = \frac{w_{up} (L/2)^2}{8}).

8.3 Biaxial Bending Check

MuxMdx+MuyMdy≤1.0\frac{M_{ux}}{M_{dx}} + \frac{M_{uy}}{M_{dy}} \le 1.0

9. SVG Engineering Visualizations

FIGURE STEEL-05-04A: Gantry Girder Cross-Section & Biaxial Mechanics

The following technical diagram details the crane runway geometry, dynamic load vectors (Wv,Hlat,TW_v, H_{lat}, T), the built-up ISMB + ISMC cross-section, and the biaxial interaction formulation.

Gantry Girder Cross Section Crane Loads and Biaxial Mechanics

FIGURE STEEL-05-04B: Industrial Roof Truss Geometry & Purlin Biaxial Bending

The following engineering drawing illustrates the Fink roof truss configuration, wind pressure suction distribution, compression reversal in the bottom tie, and the tilted purlin cross-section.

Industrial Roof Truss Geometry Wind Pressure and Purlin Biaxial Bending

10. Complete Step-by-Step Mathematical Derivations

Derivation 1: Absolute Maximum Bending Moment Under Two Moving Wheel Loads

Consider a simply supported gantry girder of span LL traversed by two equal moving wheel loads WW separated by fixed wheel base distance aa (a<La < L). Let the resultant of the two loads be R=2WR = 2 W, located midway between them (distance a/2a/2 from each wheel).

  1. Let wheel 1 be located at distance xx from the left support AA.
  2. The resultant RR is located at distance xR=x+a/2x_R = x + a/2 from support AA.
  3. By moment equilibrium about support BB (∑MB=0\sum M_B = 0): RA⋅L=R[L−(x+a/2)]  ⟹  RA=RL(L−x−a2)R_A \cdot L = R [L - (x + a/2)] \implies R_A = \frac{R}{L} \left( L - x - \frac{a}{2} \right)
  4. The bending moment under wheel 1 is: M1=RA⋅x=RL(L−x−a2)x=RL[(L−a2)x−x2]M_1 = R_A \cdot x = \frac{R}{L} \left( L - x - \frac{a}{2} \right) x = \frac{R}{L} \left[ \left(L - \frac{a}{2}\right) x - x^2 \right]
  5. To find the position xx that maximizes M1M_1, differentiate with respect to xx and set to zero: dM1dx=RL[(L−a2)−2x]=0\frac{d M_1}{d x} = \frac{R}{L} \left[ \left(L - \frac{a}{2}\right) - 2x \right] = 0 2x=L−a2  ⟹  x=L2−a4■2x = L - \frac{a}{2} \implies x = \frac{L}{2} - \frac{a}{4} \quad \blacksquare

Muller-Breslau Criterion: The absolute maximum bending moment occurs under one of the wheels when that wheel and the resultant are positioned symmetrically about the centerline of the span.

The distance from the centerline of the span to the wheel is:

Δ=L2−x=a4\Delta = \frac{L}{2} - x = \frac{a}{4}

The maximum bending moment evaluates to:

Mmax⁡=2WL(L2−a4)2=W2L(L−a2)2■M_{\max} = \frac{2 W}{L} \left( \frac{L}{2} - \frac{a}{4} \right)^2 = \frac{W}{2 L} \left( L - \frac{a}{2} \right)^2 \quad \blacksquare

Derivation 2: Net Aerodynamic Wind Uplift on Lightweight Roofs

Consider a roof truss of plan area AplanA_{plan} and true sloping surface area Aslope=Aplan/cos⁡θA_{slope} = A_{plan} / \cos\theta.

  1. Total downward gravity dead load: WDL=wDL⋅Aplan(acts vertically downward)W_{DL} = w_{DL} \cdot A_{plan} \quad (\text{acts vertically downward})
  2. Total upward wind uplift force normal to the roof surface: Fwind=Cp,net⋅pz⋅Aslope(acts normal to roof)F_{wind} = C_{p,net} \cdot p_z \cdot A_{slope} \quad (\text{acts normal to roof})
  3. Resolving the wind uplift into the vertical direction: Fwind,vert=Fwind⋅cos⁡θ=(Cp,net⋅pz⋅Aslope)cos⁡θ=Cp,net⋅pz⋅AplanF_{wind,vert} = F_{wind} \cdot \cos\theta = (C_{p,net} \cdot p_z \cdot A_{slope}) \cos\theta = C_{p,net} \cdot p_z \cdot A_{plan}
  4. The net vertical design force for limit state of strength (Load Combination: 0.9DL+1.5WL0.9 DL + 1.5 WL per IS 800 Table 4): Fnet,vert=0.90WDL−1.50(Cp,net⋅pz⋅Aplan)F_{net,vert} = 0.90 W_{DL} - 1.50 (C_{p,net} \cdot p_z \cdot A_{plan}) When 1.50Cp,netpz>0.90wDL1.50 C_{p,net} p_z > 0.90 w_{DL}, the net force is directed upwards, proving mathematically that net tension develops at the column anchor bolts and compressive axial forces develop in the bottom tie members ■\blacksquare.

11. Multi-Exam Comprehensive Solved Examples

Example 1: Full Gantry Girder Design under Crane Wheel Loads (GATE CE / ESE Conventional)

Problem Statement: Design a gantry girder for an electrically operated overhead travelling (EOT) crane with the following technical data:

  • Crane capacity Q=200 kNQ = 200\text{ kN}
  • Weight of crane bridge Wbridge=150 kNW_{bridge} = 150\text{ kN}
  • Weight of crab Wcrab=40 kNW_{crab} = 40\text{ kN}
  • Crane runway span (bay width) Lc=16.0 mL_c = 16.0\text{ m}
  • Minimum hook approach chook=1.0 mc_{hook} = 1.0\text{ m}
  • Gantry girder span L=6.0 mL = 6.0\text{ m}
  • Wheel base distance a=3.0 ma = 3.0\text{ m} (2 wheels per end carriage)
  • Self-weight of gantry girder and rail =1.50 kN/m= 1.50\text{ kN/m}
  • Structural steel: Fe 410 (fy=250 MPaf_y = 250\text{ MPa}, γm0=1.10\gamma_{m0} = 1.10, E=2×105 MPaE = 2 \times 10^5\text{ MPa})

Verify an adopted built-up cross-section consisting of an ISMB 500 rolled I-beam with an ISMC 300 channel welded toes-down to the top flange for biaxial bending and serviceability deflection.

Solution:

Step 1: Maximum Static Wheel Load

  • Weight of bridge per runway rail: Rbridge=1502=75.0 kNR_{bridge} = \frac{150}{2} = 75.0\text{ kN}
  • Maximum reaction from crab + hook load: Rcrab=(200+40)×(16.0−1.0)16.0=240×15.016.0=225.0 kNR_{crab} = \frac{(200 + 40) \times (16.0 - 1.0)}{16.0} = \frac{240 \times 15.0}{16.0} = 225.0\text{ kN}
  • Total static load on one rail: Wrail=75.0+225.0=300.0 kNW_{rail} = 75.0 + 225.0 = 300.0\text{ kN}
  • Static wheel load (2 wheels per rail): Wstatic=300.02=150.00 kNW_{static} = \frac{300.0}{2} = \mathbf{150.00\text{ kN}}

Step 2: Dynamic Factored Design Loads (IS 875 Part 2)

  • Vertical impact allowance (+25% for EOT): Wimp=1.25×150.0=187.50 kNW_{imp} = 1.25 \times 150.0 = 187.50\text{ kN}
  • Factored vertical design wheel load: Wu,v=1.5×187.50=281.25 kN per wheelW_{u,v} = 1.5 \times 187.50 = \mathbf{281.25\text{ kN per wheel}}
  • Lateral surge load (10% of crab + hook load shared across 4 wheels): Hwheel=0.10×(200+40)4=24.04=6.00 kNH_{wheel} = \frac{0.10 \times (200 + 40)}{4} = \frac{24.0}{4} = 6.00\text{ kN}
  • Factored lateral design load: Hu,lat=1.5×6.00=9.00 kN per wheelH_{u,lat} = 1.5 \times 6.00 = \mathbf{9.00\text{ kN per wheel}}

Step 3: Maximum Bending Moments on Gantry Girder

  • Span L=6.0 mL = 6.0\text{ m}, wheel base a=3.0 ma = 3.0\text{ m}.
  • By the Muller-Breslau criterion, maximum moment occurs when the wheel is at: x=L2−a4=6.02−3.04=3.0−0.75=2.25 m from supportx = \frac{L}{2} - \frac{a}{4} = \frac{6.0}{2} - \frac{3.0}{4} = 3.0 - 0.75 = 2.25\text{ m from support}
  • Resultant R=2×187.5=375 kNR = 2 \times 187.5 = 375\text{ kN} at xR=2.25+1.50=3.75 mx_R = 2.25 + 1.50 = 3.75\text{ m}.
  • Support reaction: RA=375×(6.0−3.75)6.0=375×2.256.0=140.625 kNR_A = \frac{375 \times (6.0 - 3.75)}{6.0} = \frac{375 \times 2.25}{6.0} = 140.625\text{ kN}
  • Maximum unfactored live vertical moment: Mz,live=RA×2.25=140.625×2.25=316.41 kN-mM_{z,live} = R_A \times 2.25 = 140.625 \times 2.25 = 316.41\text{ kN-m}
  • Dead load moment (wd=1.5 kN/mw_d = 1.5\text{ kN/m}): Mz,dead=1.5×6.028=6.75 kN-mM_{z,dead} = \frac{1.5 \times 6.0^2}{8} = 6.75\text{ kN-m}
  • Total factored vertical bending moment: Muz=1.5×(316.41+6.75)=1.5×323.16=484.73 kN-mM_{uz} = 1.5 \times (316.41 + 6.75) = 1.5 \times 323.16 = \mathbf{484.73\text{ kN-m}}
  • Total factored horizontal bending moment: Muy=1.5×(6.00187.50×316.41)=1.5×10.13=15.19 kN-mM_{uy} = 1.5 \times \left( \frac{6.00}{187.50} \times 316.41 \right) = 1.5 \times 10.13 = \mathbf{15.19\text{ kN-m}}

Step 4: Cross-Section Properties of Built-Up Section

  • Components:
    • ISMB 500: A1=11,074 mm2,D1=500 mm,Iz1=45,218.3×104 mm4,Iy1=1,369.8×104 mm4A_1 = 11,074\text{ mm}^2, D_1 = 500\text{ mm}, I_{z1} = 45,218.3 \times 10^4\text{ mm}^4, I_{y1} = 1,369.8 \times 10^4\text{ mm}^4.
    • ISMC 300: A2=4,564 mm2,tw2=7.6 mm,D2=300 mm,Ix2=6,362.6×104 mm4,Iy2=310.8×104 mm4,Cy=23.6 mmA_2 = 4,564\text{ mm}^2, t_{w2} = 7.6\text{ mm}, D_2 = 300\text{ mm}, I_{x2} = 6,362.6 \times 10^4\text{ mm}^4, I_{y2} = 310.8 \times 10^4\text{ mm}^4, C_y = 23.6\text{ mm}.
  • Total area: Atotal=11,074+4,564=15,638 mm2A_{total} = 11,074 + 4,564 = \mathbf{15,638\text{ mm}^2}
  • Distance of combined centroid from bottom fiber: yˉ=11,074×250+4,564×(500+7.6−23.6)15,638=2,768,500+2,208,97615,638=318.3 mm\bar{y} = \frac{11,074 \times 250 + 4,564 \times (500 + 7.6 - 23.6)}{15,638} = \frac{2,768,500 + 2,208,976}{15,638} = \mathbf{318.3\text{ mm}}
  • Distance to top fiber: ytop=507.6−318.3=189.3 mmy_{top} = 507.6 - 318.3 = \mathbf{189.3\text{ mm}}
  • Moments of inertia: Izz=[45218.3×104+11074(318.3−250)2]+[310.8×104+4564(484.0−318.3)2]=63,226.1×104 mm4I_{zz} = \left[ 45218.3\times 10^4 + 11074(318.3 - 250)^2 \right] + \left[ 310.8\times 10^4 + 4564(484.0 - 318.3)^2 \right] = \mathbf{63,226.1 \times 10^4\text{ mm}^4} Iyy=Iy1+Ix2=1369.8×104+6362.6×104=7,732.4×104 mm4I_{yy} = I_{y1} + I_{x2} = 1369.8\times 10^4 + 6362.6\times 10^4 = \mathbf{7,732.4 \times 10^4\text{ mm}^4}

Step 5: Biaxial Bending Capacity Check

  • Section modulus about major axis: Zez,top=Izzytop=63,226.1×104189.3=3.340×106 mm3Z_{ez,top} = \frac{I_{zz}}{y_{top}} = \frac{63,226.1 \times 10^4}{189.3} = 3.340 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^3
  • Major-axis design moment capacity: Mdz=Zez,top⋅fyγm0=3.340×106×2501.10×106=759.06 kN-mM_{dz} = \frac{Z_{ez,top} \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} = \frac{3.340 \times 10^6 \times 250}{1.10 \times 10^6} = \mathbf{759.06\text{ kN-m}}
  • Lateral section modulus of top flange assembly: Zey,top≈Iyy,topD2/2=6362.6×104+0.5(1369.8×104)150=7047.5×104150=0.470×106 mm3Z_{ey,top} \approx \frac{I_{yy,top}}{D_2 / 2} = \frac{6362.6\times 10^4 + 0.5(1369.8\times 10^4)}{150} = \frac{7047.5\times 10^4}{150} = 0.470 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^3
  • Minor-axis design moment capacity: Mdy=Zey,top⋅fyγm0=0.470×106×2501.10×106=106.78 kN-mM_{dy} = \frac{Z_{ey,top} \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} = \frac{0.470 \times 10^6 \times 250}{1.10 \times 10^6} = \mathbf{106.78\text{ kN-m}}
  • Biaxial Interaction Check (IS 800 Cl. 9.3.2): MuzMdz+MuyMdy=484.73759.06+15.19106.78=0.639+0.142=0.781≤1.0  ⟹  SAFE!\frac{M_{uz}}{M_{dz}} + \frac{M_{uy}}{M_{dy}} = \frac{484.73}{759.06} + \frac{15.19}{106.78} = 0.639 + 0.142 = \mathbf{0.781 \le 1.0 \implies SAFE!}

Step 6: Vertical Deflection Serviceability Check

  • Checked under unfactored static live load (W=150 kNW = 150\text{ kN}) positioned symmetrically at x=1.5 mx = 1.5\text{ m} from supports: δv=W⋅x24EIzz(3L2−4x2)=(150×103)×150024×200000×(63226.1×104)[3(6000)2−4(1500)2]\delta_v = \frac{W \cdot x}{24 E I_{zz}} (3 L^2 - 4 x^2) = \frac{(150 \times 10^3) \times 1500}{24 \times 200000 \times (63226.1 \times 10^4)} [3 (6000)^2 - 4 (1500)^2] δv=2.25×1083.035×1015[108×106−9×106]=7.414×10−8×(99×106)=7.34 mm\delta_v = \frac{2.25 \times 10^8}{3.035 \times 10^{15}} [108 \times 10^6 - 9 \times 10^6] = 7.414 \times 10^{-8} \times (99 \times 10^6) = \mathbf{7.34\text{ mm}}
  • Permissible limit for EOT crane up to 500 kN500\text{ kN} capacity (IS 800 Table 6): δv,lim⁡=L750=6000750=8.00 mm\delta_{v,\lim} = \frac{L}{750} = \frac{6000}{750} = \mathbf{8.00\text{ mm}}
  • Comparison: δv=7.34 mm≤δv,lim⁡=8.00 mm  ⟹  DEFLECTION IS SATISFIED!\delta_v = 7.34\text{ mm} \le \delta_{v,\lim} = 8.00\text{ mm} \implies \mathbf{DEFLECTION\ IS\ SATISFIED!}

Example 2: Industrial Roof Truss Load Calculation & Wind Uplift

Problem Statement: An industrial roof truss has a span L=16.0 mL = 16.0\text{ m} and central rise h=3.2 mh = 3.2\text{ m} (pitch =1/5= 1/5). Trusses are spaced at S=4.0 mS = 4.0\text{ m} along the building length. The basic wind speed is Vb=47 m/sV_b = 47\text{ m/s}. Terrain category is 2 with building height 10 m10\text{ m} (k1=1.0,k2=0.98,k3=1.0,k4=1.0k_1 = 1.0, k_2 = 0.98, k_3 = 1.0, k_4 = 1.0). External suction Cpe=−0.70C_{pe} = -0.70 and internal pressure Cpi=+0.50C_{pi} = +0.50.

  1. Compute the design dead load, live load, and wind pressure.
  2. Determine whether stress reversal occurs in the bottom tie member.

Solution:

Step 1: Geometry & Slope

  • Half-span =8.0 m= 8.0\text{ m}, Rise =3.2 m= 3.2\text{ m}. tan⁡θ=3.28.0=0.40  ⟹  θ=21.8∘\tan\theta = \frac{3.2}{8.0} = 0.40 \implies \theta = 21.8^\circ

Step 2: Dead Loads per Plan Area

  • GI Sheeting =0.15 kN/m2= 0.15\text{ kN/m}^2
  • Purlins =0.10 kN/m2= 0.10\text{ kN/m}^2
  • Self-weight of truss: wtruss=10(163+5)=10(5.33+5)=103.3 N/m2=0.103 kN/m2w_{truss} = 10 \left( \frac{16}{3} + 5 \right) = 10 (5.33 + 5) = 103.3\text{ N/m}^2 = 0.103\text{ kN/m}^2
  • Total Dead Load DL=0.15+0.10+0.103=0.353 kN/m2DL = 0.15 + 0.10 + 0.103 = \mathbf{0.353\text{ kN/m}^2}

Step 3: Imposed (Live) Load per IS 875 Part 2

  • For θ=21.8∘>10∘\theta = 21.8^\circ > 10^\circ: LL=0.75−0.02(21.8−10)=0.75−0.236=0.514 kN/m2≥0.40 kN/m2LL = 0.75 - 0.02 (21.8 - 10) = 0.75 - 0.236 = \mathbf{0.514\text{ kN/m}^2 \ge 0.40\text{ kN/m}^2}

Step 4: Design Wind Pressure per IS 875 Part 3

  • Design wind speed: Vz=47.0×1.0×0.98×1.0×1.0=46.06 m/sV_z = 47.0 \times 1.0 \times 0.98 \times 1.0 \times 1.0 = 46.06\text{ m/s}
  • Basic wind pressure: pz=0.6⋅Vz2=0.6×(46.06)2×10−3=1.273 kN/m2p_z = 0.6 \cdot V_z^2 = 0.6 \times (46.06)^2 \times 10^{-3} = \mathbf{1.273\text{ kN/m}^2}
  • Net aerodynamic pressure coefficient: Cp,net=Cpe−Cpi=−0.70−(+0.50)=−1.20(Net Upward Suction)C_{p,net} = C_{pe} - C_{pi} = -0.70 - (+0.50) = \mathbf{-1.20 \quad (\text{Net Upward Suction})}
  • Net wind uplift pressure: pwind,net=−1.20×1.273=−1.527 kN/m2p_{wind,net} = -1.20 \times 1.273 = \mathbf{-1.527\text{ kN/m}^2}

Step 5: Stress Reversal Assessment

  • Downward gravity load for wind combination (0.90DL0.90 DL): wgravity=0.90×0.353=0.318 kN/m2w_{gravity} = 0.90 \times 0.353 = \mathbf{0.318\text{ kN/m}^2}
  • Upward wind uplift: wuplift=1.50×1.527=2.291 kN/m2w_{uplift} = 1.50 \times 1.527 = \mathbf{2.291\text{ kN/m}^2}
  • Net vertical force: wnet=0.318−2.291=−1.973 kN/m2(Massive Net Upward Suction)w_{net} = 0.318 - 2.291 = \mathbf{-1.973\text{ kN/m}^2 \quad (\text{Massive Net Upward Suction})}
  • Conclusion: Net upward suction dominates by over 600%600\%. The bottom tie member experiences complete stress reversal into compression and must be detailed as a strut with KL/r≤350KL/r \le 350.

Example 3: Channel Purlin Design under Biaxial Bending

Problem Statement: Design a continuous channel purlin for the roof in Example 2 (truss spacing L=4.0 mL = 4.0\text{ m}, purlin spacing along slope sp=1.50 ms_p = 1.50\text{ m}, slope θ=21.8∘\theta = 21.8^\circ). Verify an ISMC 125 channel (Zpx=75.3×103 mm3,Zpy=18.2×103 mm3,fy=250 MPaZ_{px} = 75.3 \times 10^3\text{ mm}^3, Z_{py} = 18.2 \times 10^3\text{ mm}^3, f_y = 250\text{ MPa}).

Solution:

Step 1: Factored Gravity Load on Purlin

  • Gravity load per unit length of purlin: w=(DL+LL)×sp=(0.353+0.514)×1.50=0.867×1.50=1.301 kN/mw = (DL + LL) \times s_p = (0.353 + 0.514) \times 1.50 = 0.867 \times 1.50 = 1.301\text{ kN/m}
  • Factored vertical load: wu=1.5×1.301=1.952 kN/mw_u = 1.5 \times 1.301 = \mathbf{1.952\text{ kN/m}}

Step 2: Component Resolution

  • Normal component (major axis): wun=wucos⁡(21.8∘)=1.952×0.9285=1.812 kN/mw_{un} = w_u \cos(21.8^\circ) = 1.952 \times 0.9285 = \mathbf{1.812\text{ kN/m}}
  • Parallel component (minor axis): wup=wusin⁡(21.8∘)=1.952×0.3714=0.725 kN/mw_{up} = w_u \sin(21.8^\circ) = 1.952 \times 0.3714 = \mathbf{0.725\text{ kN/m}}

Step 3: Bending Moments (Continuous Purlin over Trusses)

  • Major-axis moment: Mux=wun⋅L210=1.812×4.0210=2.899 kN-mM_{ux} = \frac{w_{un} \cdot L^2}{10} = \frac{1.812 \times 4.0^2}{10} = \mathbf{2.899\text{ kN-m}}
  • Minor-axis moment: Muy=wup⋅L210=0.725×4.0210=1.160 kN-mM_{uy} = \frac{w_{up} \cdot L^2}{10} = \frac{0.725 \times 4.0^2}{10} = \mathbf{1.160\text{ kN-m}}

Step 4: Design Moment Capacities of ISMC 125

  • Major-axis capacity: Mdx=Zpx⋅fyγm0=75.3×103×2501.10×106=17.11 kN-mM_{dx} = \frac{Z_{px} \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} = \frac{75.3 \times 10^3 \times 250}{1.10 \times 10^6} = \mathbf{17.11\text{ kN-m}}
  • Minor-axis capacity: Mdy=Zpy⋅fyγm0=18.2×103×2501.10×106=4.14 kN-mM_{dy} = \frac{Z_{py} \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} = \frac{18.2 \times 10^3 \times 250}{1.10 \times 10^6} = \mathbf{4.14\text{ kN-m}}

Step 5: Biaxial Interaction Check

MuxMdx+MuyMdy=2.89917.11+1.1604.14=0.169+0.280=0.450≤1.0  ⟹  SAFE!\frac{M_{ux}}{M_{dx}} + \frac{M_{uy}}{M_{dy}} = \frac{2.899}{17.11} + \frac{1.160}{4.14} = 0.169 + 0.280 = \mathbf{0.450 \le 1.0 \implies SAFE!}

12. Exam Traps, Common Pitfalls & Practical Fabrication Rules

Trap 1: Forgetting that Lateral Surge is Shared by Four Wheels

  • The Trap: Calculating lateral surge as 10%10\% of crane capacity and applying it directly to a single wheel.
  • The Reality: Lateral surge (10%10\% of crab + load) acts on the entire crane carriage and is distributed across all 4 wheels (2 on each runway rail). Each wheel carries only one-quarter of the total surge!

Trap 2: Deflection Calculation with Factored Loads

  • Frequent Exam Failure: Using factored loads (1.5Wimp1.5 W_{imp}) to check gantry girder deflection.
  • Standard Rule: Deflection is a Serviceability Limit State (SLS) check. It must be computed using unfactored static wheel loads WITHOUT any impact factor!

Trap 3: Stress Reversal in Truss Ties

  • Students frequently select bottom tie members based purely on tension capacity. In reality, aerodynamic wind suction reverses the force into compression. The member must be checked as a column with the slenderness limit KL/r≤350KL/r \le 350.

Trap 4: Purlin Orientation & Cleat Details

  • Purlins must be oriented with their top flanges pointing up the slope to facilitate rain sheet fastening. Cleats must be sized to prevent the purlin from overturning under the down-slope load component wupw_{up}.

13. Official Exam Practice Questions

Question 1 (GATE CE)

In an industrial building, an electrically operated overhead travelling crane of capacity 250 kN250\text{ kN} produces a maximum static wheel load of 120 kN120\text{ kN}. According to IS 875 (Part 2), the design vertical wheel load including dynamic impact allowance is:

  • (A) 132 kN132\text{ kN}
  • (B) 150 kN150\text{ kN}
  • (C) 168 kN168\text{ kN}
  • (D) 180 kN180\text{ kN}

Detailed Solution:

  • For EOT cranes, IS 875 (Part 2) mandates an impact allowance of +25%+25\%.
  • Wv=1.25×120=150 kNW_{v} = 1.25 \times 120 = 150\text{ kN}.
  • Correct Answer: (B)

Question 2 (UPSC ESE)

Which of the following built-up cross-sections is most commonly preferred for a gantry girder supporting an EOT crane?

  • (A) Plain rolled I-beam with symmetrical cover plates on top and bottom flanges.
  • (B) Rolled I-beam with a channel section placed toes-down on the top flange.
  • (C) Rolled I-beam with a channel section placed toes-up on the bottom flange.
  • (D) Box section formed by two rolled I-beams placed side by side.

Detailed Solution:

  • Welding a channel toes-down on the top flange massively increases IyyI_{yy} and lateral section modulus precisely where lateral surge acts, preventing lateral-torsional buckling.
  • Correct Answer: (B)

Question 3 (SSC JE)

As per IS 800:2007 Table 6, the maximum permissible vertical deflection for a gantry girder carrying an electrically operated crane up to 500 kN500\text{ kN} capacity is:

  • (A) L/500L / 500
  • (B) L/600L / 600
  • (C) L/750L / 750
  • (D) L/1000L / 1000

Detailed Solution:

  • For EOT cranes up to 500 kN500\text{ kN} capacity, the vertical deflection limit is L/750L / 750 (or L/600L / 600 for light duty).
  • Correct Answer: (C)

Question 4 (State AE / RRB JE)

For an industrial roof truss with a pitch angle of 25∘25^\circ, the design imposed (live) load on plan area according to IS 875 (Part 2) is:

  • (A) 0.75 kN/m20.75\text{ kN/m}^2
  • (B) 0.45 kN/m20.45\text{ kN/m}^2
  • (C) 0.40 kN/m20.40\text{ kN/m}^2
  • (D) 0.55 kN/m20.55\text{ kN/m}^2

Detailed Solution:

  • LL=0.75−0.02(25−10)=0.75−0.02(15)=0.75−0.30=0.45 kN/m2≥0.40 kN/m2LL = 0.75 - 0.02 (25 - 10) = 0.75 - 0.02 (15) = 0.75 - 0.30 = 0.45\text{ kN/m}^2 \ge 0.40\text{ kN/m}^2.
  • Correct Answer: (B)

Question 5 (UPSC ESE Conventional)

Explain why purlins on a sloping roof are subjected to biaxial bending. Describe the structural role of sag rods in purlin design and how they alter the bending moment about the minor axis.

Detailed Solution:

  1. Biaxial Bending Mechanics:
    • Purlins rest on the sloping principal rafters of the truss, which are inclined at angle θ\theta to the horizontal.
    • Gravity loads (dead load of sheeting and live load) act purely vertically downward.
    • The purlin's principal axes are tilted: major axis x−xx-x is parallel to the purlin web (perpendicular to the roof), while minor axis y−yy-y is parallel to the roof surface.
    • Resolving the vertical load ww yields:
      • Normal component wn=wcos⁡θw_n = w \cos\theta inducing bending about the major axis x−xx-x.
      • Parallel component wp=wsin⁡θw_p = w \sin\theta inducing bending about the weak minor axis y−yy-y.
    • The purlin must simultaneously resist both moments, resulting in biaxial bending: MxMdx+MyMdy≤1.0\frac{M_x}{M_{dx}} + \frac{M_y}{M_{dy}} \le 1.0.
  2. Role of Sag Rods:
    • Because standard channel and angle purlins have very small minor axis stiffness IyI_y, the down-slope component wpw_p can cause excessive lateral deflection and twisting.
    • Sag rods (mild steel tension tie rods of 10–16 mm10\text{–}16\text{ mm} diameter) are installed at mid-span or third-points, connecting adjacent purlins together and tying them to the ridge purlin.
    • Sag rods act as intermediate supports in the plane of the roof, reducing the effective span for minor-axis bending from LL to L/2L/2 (or L/3L/3).
    • This reduces the minor-axis bending moment by 75%75\% (from wpL2/10w_p L^2 / 10 down to wp(L/2)2/8w_p (L/2)^2 / 8), allowing much lighter and more economical purlin sections.