STEEL-04-03 Chapter 04 · Design of Beams

Web Buckling, Web Crippling & Stiffener Provisions

Module
Design of Steel Structures (IS 800:2007)
Chapter 04
Design of Beams and Flexural Members
Topic Code
STEEL-04-03
Target Examinations
GATE CE, UPSC ESE, SSC JE, State AE/JE, RRB JE

1. Topic Overview & Engineering Significance

In structural steel beams and plate girders, concentrated loads—such as column reactions on transfer girders, wheel loads from overhead travelling (EOT) cranes, and reactions at end supports—are transferred directly across the flange into the thin, slender web plate. Because the web possesses a high ratio of depth to thickness (d/twd/t_w), it is exceptionally vulnerable to severe localized stress concentrations.

Under the Limit State Method of IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.7, two distinct localized limit states govern the safety of unstiffened beam webs under concentrated forces:

  1. Web Crippling (Local Compressive Crushing / Yielding - Cl. 8.7.4): A localized yielding failure occurring directly at the junction of the web with the flange root fillet due to extreme bearing stress concentration. The load disperses through the flange and fillet at a slope of 1:2.51:2.5. This limit state depends strictly on material yield strength (fyf_y), web thickness (twt_w), and bearing length (b1b_1), and is entirely independent of the overall depth of the beam.
  2. Web Buckling (Strut Column Action - Cl. 8.7.3.1): A stability failure where the web behaves as a vertical compression column spanning between flanges, transferring the concentrated load down to the support or into the beam depth. The load disperses at an angle of 45∘45^\circ to the neutral axis (D/2D/2). This limit state is governed by Euler-type column buckling under Buckling Curve c, with an effective strut length of KL=0.70dKL = 0.70 d, making it heavily dependent on the clear web depth (dd).

When either web crippling or web buckling capacity is exceeded, structural failure is averted by providing Load-Carrying / Bearing Stiffeners (Cl. 8.7.3 & 8.7.5). Understanding the distinct mechanics, code dispersion geometries, and stiffener detailing rules is paramount for both professional structural design and top performance in competitive examinations.


2. Code Provisions & Theoretical Derivations

2.1 Mechanics of Web Crippling (IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.7.4)

Web crippling represents localized plastic folding / crushing of the web at the junction of the web and the root fillet of the flange.

Dispersion Geometry:

The concentrated force applied over a stiff bearing length b1b_1 disperses through the flange thickness tft_f and the root fillet radius r1r_1 at a slope of 1 vertical:2.5 horizontal1\text{ vertical} : 2.5\text{ horizontal}. The depth from the outer face of the flange to the toe of the fillet is:

h1=tf+r1(for rolled sections)h_1 = t_f + r_1 \quad (\text{for rolled sections}) h1=tf(for welded sections without root fillets)h_1 = t_f \quad (\text{for welded sections without root fillets})

The horizontal spread n2n_2 beyond the stiff bearing plate is:

n2=2.5⋅h1=2.5(tf+r1)n_2 = 2.5 \cdot h_1 = 2.5 (t_f + r_1)

Effective Bearing Length (BcripB_{crip}):

  • At End Support (Dispersion on one side only): Bcrip=b1+n2=b1+2.5(tf+r1)B_{crip} = b_1 + n_2 = b_1 + 2.5(t_f + r_1)
  • Under Interior Concentrated Load (Dispersion on both sides): Bcrip=b1+2n2=b1+5.0(tf+r1)B_{crip} = b_1 + 2 n_2 = b_1 + 5.0(t_f + r_1)

Design Crippling Resistance (FcrwF_{crw}):

The design bearing capacity against web crippling is:

Fcrw=(b1+n2)⋅tw⋅fywγm0F_{crw} = \frac{(b_1 + n_2) \cdot t_w \cdot f_{yw}}{\gamma_{m0}}

Where:

  • b1b_1 is the stiff bearing length (minimum contact length between bearing plate and flange).
  • twt_w is the web thickness.
  • fywf_{yw} is the characteristic yield strength of the web (250 MPa250\text{ MPa} for E250).
  • γm0=1.10\gamma_{m0} = 1.10 is the partial safety factor against yield (Table 5).

Adequacy Criterion:

Fapplied≤FcrwF_{applied} \le F_{crw}

If Fapplied>FcrwF_{applied} > F_{crw}, the web crushes locally. The engineer must either increase the bearing length b1b_1, choose a section with thicker web twt_w, or provide bearing stiffeners.


2.2 Mechanics of Web Buckling (IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.7.3.1)

Web buckling treats the portion of the web carrying the concentrated force as an equivalent vertical compression strut spanning between the top and bottom flanges.

Dispersion Geometry:

The concentrated load disperses from the edges of the stiff bearing plate at an angle of 45∘45^\circ up to the neutral axis of the beam, which is located at depth D/2D/2. Because tan⁡(45∘)=1.0\tan(45^\circ) = 1.0, the horizontal spread n1n_1 on each side is equal to the vertical distance to the neutral axis:

n1=D2n_1 = \frac{D}{2}

Effective Width of Web Strut (BbuckB_{buck}):

  • At End Support (Dispersion on one side only): Bbuck=b1+n1=b1+D2B_{buck} = b_1 + n_1 = b_1 + \frac{D}{2}
  • Under Interior Concentrated Load (Dispersion on both sides): Bbuck=b1+2n1=b1+2(D2)=b1+DB_{buck} = b_1 + 2 n_1 = b_1 + 2\left(\frac{D}{2}\right) = b_1 + D

Effective Cross-Section & Radius of Gyration:

The effective area of the web column strut is:

Aw=Bbuck⋅twA_w = B_{buck} \cdot t_w

The second moment of area about the longitudinal weak axis of the web is:

I=Bbuck⋅tw312I = \frac{B_{buck} \cdot t_w^3}{12}

The radius of gyration of the rectangular web strip is:

r=IAw=tw212=tw23≈0.28867twr = \sqrt{\frac{I}{A_w}} = \sqrt{\frac{t_w^2}{12}} = \frac{t_w}{2\sqrt{3}} \approx 0.28867 t_w

Effective Strut Length (KLKL):

Assuming the flanges are restrained against lateral translation and rotation (standard condition):

KL=0.70dKL = 0.70 d

Where dd is the clear depth of the web between root fillets (d=D−2(tf+r1)d = D - 2(t_f + r_1)). If flanges are unrestrained against rotation, KL=1.0dKL = 1.0 d.

Strut Slenderness (λ\lambda):

λ=KLr=0.70dtw/(23)=1.43⋅dtw≈2.425(dtw)\lambda = \frac{KL}{r} = \frac{0.70 d}{t_w / (2\sqrt{3})} = \frac{1.4\sqrt{3} \cdot d}{t_w} \approx 2.425 \left(\frac{d}{t_w}\right)

Design Compressive Stress (fcdf_{cd}):

The design compressive stress fcdf_{cd} is obtained from Buckling Curve c (α=0.49\alpha = 0.49) using the Perry-Robertson formula:

fcd=χ⋅fyγm0f_{cd} = \frac{\chi \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} χ=1ϕ+ϕ2−λˉ2≤1.0,ϕ=0.5[1+0.49(λˉ−0.2)+λˉ2],λˉ=fyfcc\chi = \frac{1}{\phi + \sqrt{\phi^2 - \bar{\lambda}^2}} \le 1.0, \qquad \phi = 0.5\left[1 + 0.49(\bar{\lambda} - 0.2) + \bar{\lambda}^2\right], \qquad \bar{\lambda} = \sqrt{\frac{f_y}{f_{cc}}}

Design Buckling Resistance (FcdwF_{cdw}):

Fcdw=Bbuck⋅tw⋅fcd=(b1+n1)⋅tw⋅fcdF_{cdw} = B_{buck} \cdot t_w \cdot f_{cd} = (b_1 + n_1) \cdot t_w \cdot f_{cd}

Adequacy Criterion:

Fapplied≤FcdwF_{applied} \le F_{cdw}

2.3 Bearing Stiffener Design Provisions (IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.7.1 - 8.7.5)

When an unstiffened web is inadequate (Fapplied>FcrwF_{applied} > F_{crw} or Fapplied>FcdwF_{applied} > F_{cdw}), a pair of vertical flat plates is welded to opposite sides of the web directly under the point of load application.

1. Outstand Width & Local Buckling Limit (Table 2):

To prevent local buckling of the stiffener plates, the outstand width bsb_s from the face of the web must satisfy:

bsts≤14ϵ  ⟹  ts≥bs14ϵ\frac{b_s}{t_s} \le 14\epsilon \implies t_s \ge \frac{b_s}{14\epsilon}

Where ϵ=250/fy\epsilon = \sqrt{250/f_y}. In addition, bsb_s should fit within the flange overhang:

bs≤bf−tw2b_s \le \frac{b_f - t_w}{2}

2. Effective Cruciform Column Section (Cl. 8.7.1.5):

The bearing stiffener pair acts compositely with an effective length of the beam web to form a cruciform compression column:

  • At End Support: Web contributes a length of 20tw20 t_w (measured from centerline of stiffeners towards the span). Aeff=2(bs⋅ts)+20tw⋅twA_{eff} = 2(b_s \cdot t_s) + 20 t_w \cdot t_w
  • Under Interior Point Load: Web contributes 20tw20 t_w on EACH side (total web length =40tw= 40 t_w). Aeff=2(bs⋅ts)+40tw⋅twA_{eff} = 2(b_s \cdot t_s) + 40 t_w \cdot t_w

3. Moment of Inertia and Buckling Capacity of Cruciform Strut:

The moment of inertia about the web centerline (axis of buckling) is:

Ieff≈2[ts⋅bs312+(bs⋅ts)(bs+tw2)2]+Lweb⋅tw312I_{eff} \approx 2 \left[ \frac{t_s \cdot b_s^3}{12} + (b_s \cdot t_s) \left(\frac{b_s + t_w}{2}\right)^2 \right] + \frac{L_{web} \cdot t_w^3}{12} reff=IeffAeff,KL=0.70d  ⟹  λ=KLreffr_{eff} = \sqrt{\frac{I_{eff}}{A_{eff}}}, \qquad KL = 0.70 d \implies \lambda = \frac{KL}{r_{eff}}

Using Buckling Curve c, design compressive capacity is:

Pcd=Aeff⋅fcd≥FappliedP_{cd} = A_{eff} \cdot f_{cd} \ge F_{applied}

4. Bearing Check at Contact Face with Flange (Cl. 8.7.5.2):

The ends of bearing stiffeners are machined to bear tightly against the loaded flange. To clear the web-to-flange weld bead or root radius, stiffeners are chamfered/snipped by 15 to 20 mm15\text{ to }20\text{ mm} at corners. Net bearing contact area:

Aq=2(bs−snip)⋅tsA_q = 2(b_s - \text{snip}) \cdot t_s

The design bearing capacity is:

Fpsd=Aq⋅fy0.80⋅γm0≥FappliedF_{psd} = \frac{A_q \cdot f_y}{0.80 \cdot \gamma_{m0}} \ge F_{applied}

5. Connection to Web (Cl. 8.7.5.3):

The stiffeners must be connected to the web by continuous fillet welds designed to transfer the full applied reaction RuR_u:

qweld=Fapplied4⋅Lweld⋅tt≤fu3⋅γmwq_{weld} = \frac{F_{applied}}{4 \cdot L_{weld} \cdot t_t} \le \frac{f_u}{\sqrt{3} \cdot \gamma_{mw}}

3. Visual Diagrams & Structural Behavior

Figure 1: Dispersion Geometries & Failure Modes: Web Crippling vs Web Buckling

The following diagram contrasts the 1:2.51:2.5 root dispersion of web crippling with the 45∘45^\circ neutral-axis dispersion of web buckling.

Web Buckling vs Web Crippling Dispersion Mechanisms

Figure 2: Bearing Stiffener Detailing & Effective Cruciform Strut

The figure below depicts the structural detailing of bearing stiffeners, weld snip clearances, and the effective cruciform compression column cross-section.

Bearing Stiffener Detailing and Effective Strut Cross-Section

4. Mathematical Formulations & Design Procedures

+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
|            FLOWCHART: WEB CRIPPLING, BUCKLING & STIFFENER VERIFICATION          |
+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
                                         |
                                         v
                         [ Step 1: Input Beam & Load Data ]
                         Reaction / Point Load: F ; Bearing length: b1
                         Section: D, bf, tf, tw, r1, d = D - 2(tf + r1)
                                         |
                                         v
                         [ Step 2: Web Crippling Check ]
                         End Support:      n2 = 2.5 (tf + r1)
                         Interior Load:    n2 = 5.0 (tf + r1)
                         Fcrw = [ (b1 + n2) * tw * fyw ] / gm0
                                         |
                                  F <= Fcrw ?
                                 /           \
                            (YES)             (NO: Crippling Fails!)
                             /                   |
                            v                    |
                 [ Step 3: Web Buckling Check ]  |
                 End Support:   n1 = D / 2       |
                 Interior Load: n1 = D           |
                 B_buck = b1 + n1                |
                 KL = 0.70 d ; r = tw / (2*sqrt(3))
                 lambda = KL / r                 |
                 f_cd from Curve c (alpha = 0.49)|
                 Fcdw = B_buck * tw * f_cd       |
                            |                    |
                     F <= Fcdw ?                 |
                    /           \                |
               (YES)             (NO: Buckling)  |
                /                     \          |
               v                       v         v
     [ SAFE WITHOUT STIFFENERS ]     [ PROVIDE BEARING STIFFENERS ]
                                     1. Select bs <= (bf - tw)/2, ts >= bs / 14
                                     2. Form Cruciform Section:
                                        End: Aeff = 2(bs*ts) + 20 tw^2
                                        Int: Aeff = 2(bs*ts) + 40 tw^2
                                     3. Check column buckling: Pcd = Aeff * fcd >= F
                                     4. Check bearing: Fpsd = Aq * fy / (0.8 gm0) >= F
                                     5. Design 4 lines of web fillet welds

5. Solved Numerical Examples

Problem 1: Complete Web Buckling & Crippling Verification at End Support

Statement:
An ISMB 450 @ 72.4 kg/m beam transmits a factored end reaction Ru=300 kNR_u = 300\text{ kN} to a concrete support pedestal through a steel bearing plate of length b1=100 mmb_1 = 100\text{ mm}. Steel grade is E250 (fy=250 MPaf_y = 250\text{ MPa}, γm0=1.10\gamma_{m0} = 1.10, E=2.0×105 MPaE = 2.0 \times 10^5\text{ MPa}).
Section dimensions:

  • Overall depth D=450.0 mmD = 450.0\text{ mm}
  • Flange width bf=150.0 mmb_f = 150.0\text{ mm}
  • Flange thickness tf=17.4 mmt_f = 17.4\text{ mm}
  • Web thickness tw=9.4 mmt_w = 9.4\text{ mm}
  • Root radius r1=15.0 mmr_1 = 15.0\text{ mm}

Verify whether the unstiffened beam web is adequate against web crippling and web buckling in accordance with IS 800:2007.

Solution:

Step 1: Section Parameters

  • Distance from outer flange face to root of fillet: h1=tf+r1=17.4+15.0=32.4 mmh_1 = t_f + r_1 = 17.4 + 15.0 = 32.4\text{ mm}
  • Clear web depth between root fillets: d=D−2(tf+r1)=450.0−2(32.4)=450.0−64.8=385.2 mmd = D - 2(t_f + r_1) = 450.0 - 2(32.4) = 450.0 - 64.8 = 385.2\text{ mm}

Step 2: Web Crippling Verification (IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.7.4) At an end support, load disperses on one side only at a slope of 1:2.51:2.5:

n2=2.5⋅h1=2.5×32.4=81.0 mmn_2 = 2.5 \cdot h_1 = 2.5 \times 32.4 = 81.0\text{ mm}

Effective bearing length at the root of the fillet:

Bcrip=b1+n2=100.0+81.0=181.0 mmB_{crip} = b_1 + n_2 = 100.0 + 81.0 = 181.0\text{ mm}

Design crippling resistance:

Fcrw=Bcrip⋅tw⋅fyγm0=181.0×9.4×2501.10×103=425,3501.10×103=386.68 kNF_{crw} = \frac{B_{crip} \cdot t_w \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} = \frac{181.0 \times 9.4 \times 250}{1.10 \times 10^3} = \frac{425,350}{1.10 \times 10^3} = 386.68\text{ kN}

Check adequacy:

Ru=300.0 kN≤Fcrw=386.68 kN(Safe against Crippling! Capacity utilization =77.6%)R_u = 300.0\text{ kN} \le F_{crw} = 386.68\text{ kN} \quad (\text{Safe against Crippling! Capacity utilization } = 77.6\%)

Step 3: Web Buckling Verification (IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.7.3.1) At an end support, the load disperses at 45∘45^\circ to the neutral axis (D/2=225.0 mmD/2 = 225.0\text{ mm}):

n1=D2=450.02=225.0 mmn_1 = \frac{D}{2} = \frac{450.0}{2} = 225.0\text{ mm}

Effective width of web column strut:

Bbuck=b1+n1=100.0+225.0=325.0 mmB_{buck} = b_1 + n_1 = 100.0 + 225.0 = 325.0\text{ mm}

Effective strut cross-sectional area:

Aw=Bbuck⋅tw=325.0×9.4=3055.0 mm2A_w = B_{buck} \cdot t_w = 325.0 \times 9.4 = 3055.0\text{ mm}^2

Effective length of web column (flanges restrained against rotation):

KL=0.70⋅d=0.70×385.2=269.64 mmKL = 0.70 \cdot d = 0.70 \times 385.2 = 269.64\text{ mm}

Radius of gyration:

r=tw23=9.43.4641=2.7135 mmr = \frac{t_w}{2\sqrt{3}} = \frac{9.4}{3.4641} = 2.7135\text{ mm}

Slenderness ratio of web strut:

λ=KLr=269.642.7135=99.37\lambda = \frac{KL}{r} = \frac{269.64}{2.7135} = 99.37

Design compressive stress fcdf_{cd} from Perry-Robertson formula (Buckling Curve c, α=0.49\alpha = 0.49):

  • Euler critical stress: fcc=π2⋅Eλ2=π2×200,000(99.37)2=1,973,920.889874.40=199.90 MPaf_{cc} = \frac{\pi^2 \cdot E}{\lambda^2} = \frac{\pi^2 \times 200,000}{(99.37)^2} = \frac{1,973,920.88}{9874.40} = 199.90\text{ MPa}
  • Non-dimensional slenderness: λˉ=fyfcc=250199.90=1.2506=1.1183\bar{\lambda} = \sqrt{\frac{f_y}{f_{cc}}} = \sqrt{\frac{250}{199.90}} = \sqrt{1.2506} = 1.1183
  • ϕ=0.5[1+0.49(λˉ−0.2)+λˉ2]=0.5[1+0.49(0.9183)+(1.1183)2]=0.5[1+0.4500+1.2506]=1.3503\phi = 0.5\left[1 + 0.49(\bar{\lambda} - 0.2) + \bar{\lambda}^2\right] = 0.5\left[1 + 0.49(0.9183) + (1.1183)^2\right] = 0.5[1 + 0.4500 + 1.2506] = 1.3503
  • Stress reduction factor: χ=1ϕ+ϕ2−λˉ2=11.3503+1.35032−1.11832=11.3503+1.8233−1.2506=11.3503+0.7568=0.4746\chi = \frac{1}{\phi + \sqrt{\phi^2 - \bar{\lambda}^2}} = \frac{1}{1.3503 + \sqrt{1.3503^2 - 1.1183^2}} = \frac{1}{1.3503 + \sqrt{1.8233 - 1.2506}} = \frac{1}{1.3503 + 0.7568} = 0.4746
  • Design compressive stress: fcd=χ⋅fyγm0=0.4746×2501.10=107.87 MPaf_{cd} = \frac{\chi \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} = \frac{0.4746 \times 250}{1.10} = 107.87\text{ MPa}

Design web buckling resistance:

Fcdw=Aw⋅fcd=3055.0×107.87103=329.54 kNF_{cdw} = A_w \cdot f_{cd} = \frac{3055.0 \times 107.87}{10^3} = 329.54\text{ kN}

Check adequacy:

Ru=300.0 kN≤Fcdw=329.54 kN(Safe against Buckling! Capacity utilization =91.0%)R_u = 300.0\text{ kN} \le F_{cdw} = 329.54\text{ kN} \quad (\text{Safe against Buckling! Capacity utilization } = 91.0\%)

Conclusion: The unstiffened web of ISMB 450 is SAFE against both web crippling and web buckling. No bearing stiffeners are required.


Problem 2: Interior Concentrated Load: Failure Investigation & Minimum Bearing Length

Statement:
An ISLB 400 @ 56.9 kg/m beam (D=400 mmD = 400\text{ mm}, bf=165 mmb_f = 165\text{ mm}, tf=12.5 mmt_f = 12.5\text{ mm}, tw=8.0 mmt_w = 8.0\text{ mm}, r1=16.0 mmr_1 = 16.0\text{ mm}, d=343.0 mmd = 343.0\text{ mm}, fy=250 MPaf_y = 250\text{ MPa}, γm0=1.10\gamma_{m0} = 1.10) supports an interior concentrated factored column load Pu=450 kNP_u = 450\text{ kN}. The column transfers load through a base plate currently provided with a bearing length b1=75 mmb_1 = 75\text{ mm}.

  1. Investigate the adequacy of the unstiffened web.
  2. If inadequate, compute the minimum stiff bearing length b1,reqb_{1,req} required to avoid providing bearing stiffeners.

Solution:

Step 1: Check Web Crippling under Interior Load Under an interior load, dispersion occurs on both sides:

h1=tf+r1=12.5+16.0=28.5 mmh_1 = t_f + r_1 = 12.5 + 16.0 = 28.5\text{ mm} n2=2×[2.5⋅h1]=5.0×28.5=142.5 mmn_2 = 2 \times [2.5 \cdot h_1] = 5.0 \times 28.5 = 142.5\text{ mm} Bcrip=b1+n2=75.0+142.5=217.5 mmB_{crip} = b_1 + n_2 = 75.0 + 142.5 = 217.5\text{ mm}

Design crippling resistance:

Fcrw=217.5×8.0×2501.10×103=435,0001.10×103=395.45 kNF_{crw} = \frac{217.5 \times 8.0 \times 250}{1.10 \times 10^3} = \frac{435,000}{1.10 \times 10^3} = 395.45\text{ kN}

Comparison:

Pu=450.0 kN>Fcrw=395.45 kN  ⟹  WEB CRIPPLING FAILS! (1.14× overload)P_u = 450.0\text{ kN} > F_{crw} = 395.45\text{ kN} \implies \mathbf{WEB\ CRIPPLING\ FAILS!\ (1.14\times\ overload)}

Step 2: Check Web Buckling under Interior Load Dispersion occurs on both sides to the neutral axis (D/2=200.0 mmD/2 = 200.0\text{ mm}):

n1=2×D2=D=400.0 mmn_1 = 2 \times \frac{D}{2} = D = 400.0\text{ mm} Bbuck=b1+n1=75.0+400.0=475.0 mmB_{buck} = b_1 + n_1 = 75.0 + 400.0 = 475.0\text{ mm} Aw=Bbuck⋅tw=475.0×8.0=3800.0 mm2A_w = B_{buck} \cdot t_w = 475.0 \times 8.0 = 3800.0\text{ mm}^2

Slenderness calculation:

KL=0.70⋅d=0.70×343.0=240.1 mmKL = 0.70 \cdot d = 0.70 \times 343.0 = 240.1\text{ mm} r=tw23=8.03.4641=2.3094 mmr = \frac{t_w}{2\sqrt{3}} = \frac{8.0}{3.4641} = 2.3094\text{ mm} λ=240.12.3094=103.97\lambda = \frac{240.1}{2.3094} = 103.97

For λ=103.97\lambda = 103.97 on Curve c (α=0.49\alpha = 0.49):

  • fcc=π2×200,000(103.97)2=182.61 MPaf_{cc} = \frac{\pi^2 \times 200,000}{(103.97)^2} = 182.61\text{ MPa}
  • λˉ=250/182.61=1.1701\bar{\lambda} = \sqrt{250 / 182.61} = 1.1701
  • ϕ=0.5[1+0.49(0.9701)+1.17012]=1.4222\phi = 0.5[1 + 0.49(0.9701) + 1.1701^2] = 1.4222
  • χ=11.4222+1.42222−1.17012=0.4483\chi = \frac{1}{1.4222 + \sqrt{1.4222^2 - 1.1701^2}} = 0.4483
  • fcd=0.4483×2501.10=101.89 MPaf_{cd} = \frac{0.4483 \times 250}{1.10} = 101.89\text{ MPa}

Design web buckling capacity:

Fcdw=3800.0×101.89103=387.18 kNF_{cdw} = \frac{3800.0 \times 101.89}{10^3} = 387.18\text{ kN}

Comparison:

Pu=450.0 kN>Fcdw=387.18 kN  ⟹  WEB BUCKLING FAILS! (1.16× overload)P_u = 450.0\text{ kN} > F_{cdw} = 387.18\text{ kN} \implies \mathbf{WEB\ BUCKLING\ FAILS!\ (1.16\times\ overload)}

Step 3: Minimum Bearing Length (b1,reqb_{1,req}) Calculation To make the unstiffened web safe without stiffeners, both conditions must be met:

  1. For Web Crippling:

    Pu≤(b1+n2)⋅tw⋅fyγm0  ⟹  b1,req=Pu⋅γm0tw⋅fy−n2P_u \le \frac{(b_1 + n_2) \cdot t_w \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} \implies b_{1,req} = \frac{P_u \cdot \gamma_{m0}}{t_w \cdot f_y} - n_2 b1,req=450×103×1.108.0×250−142.5=495,0002000−142.5=247.5−142.5=105.0 mmb_{1,req} = \frac{450 \times 10^3 \times 1.10}{8.0 \times 250} - 142.5 = \frac{495,000}{2000} - 142.5 = 247.5 - 142.5 = 105.0\text{ mm}
  2. For Web Buckling:

    Pu≤(b1+n1)⋅tw⋅fcd  ⟹  b1,req=Pu×103tw⋅fcd−n1P_u \le (b_1 + n_1) \cdot t_w \cdot f_{cd} \implies b_{1,req} = \frac{P_u \times 10^3}{t_w \cdot f_{cd}} - n_1 b1,req=450×1038.0×101.89−400.0=450,000815.12−400.0=552.07−400.0=152.1 mmb_{1,req} = \frac{450 \times 10^3}{8.0 \times 101.89} - 400.0 = \frac{450,000}{815.12} - 400.0 = 552.07 - 400.0 = 152.1\text{ mm}

Conclusion:
To prevent both web crippling and web buckling without providing stiffeners, the bearing plate length must be increased from 75 mm75\text{ mm} to at least 152.1 mm152.1\text{ mm} (governed by web buckling). If space restricts b1≤75 mmb_1 \le 75\text{ mm}, bearing stiffeners must be provided.


Problem 3: Complete Design of Load-Carrying Bearing Stiffeners

Statement:
A welded plate girder with clear web depth d=1150 mmd = 1150\text{ mm}, web thickness tw=10.0 mmt_w = 10.0\text{ mm}, and flange plates 400×25 mm400 \times 25\text{ mm} carries a factored end reaction Ru=1200 kNR_u = 1200\text{ kN}. Steel grade is E250 (fy=250 MPaf_y = 250\text{ MPa}, γm0=1.10\gamma_{m0} = 1.10, γmw=1.25\gamma_{mw} = 1.25).
Design a pair of flat plates as end bearing stiffeners, verifying:

  1. Local buckling limit of stiffener plates.
  2. Buckling capacity of the effective cruciform compression column.
  3. Bearing resistance at the flange contact face.
  4. Fillet weld connection to the web.

Solution:

Step 1: Stiffener Geometry Selection

  • Available width under the flange: bs,max⁡=bf−tw2=400.0−10.02=195.0 mmb_{s,\max} = \frac{b_f - t_w}{2} = \frac{400.0 - 10.0}{2} = 195.0\text{ mm} Adopt stiffener outstand width: bs=150.0 mmb_s = 150.0\text{ mm}.
  • Thickness requirement to prevent local plate buckling (Table 2): bsts≤14ϵ=14×1.0=14.0  ⟹  ts≥150.014=10.71 mm\frac{b_s}{t_s} \le 14\epsilon = 14 \times 1.0 = 14.0 \implies t_s \ge \frac{150.0}{14} = 10.71\text{ mm} Adopt stiffener plate thickness: ts=16.0 mmt_s = 16.0\text{ mm}. bsts=150.016.0=9.38≤14.0(Class 3 Plastic/Compact plate, Safe!)\frac{b_s}{t_s} = \frac{150.0}{16.0} = 9.38 \le 14.0 \quad (\text{Class 3 Plastic/Compact plate, Safe!})

Step 2: Effective Cruciform Strut Section Properties (Cl. 8.7.1.5) At an end support, the length of web contributing to the strut is 20tw20 t_w:

Lweb=20⋅tw=20×10.0=200.0 mmL_{web} = 20 \cdot t_w = 20 \times 10.0 = 200.0\text{ mm}

Total effective cross-sectional area:

Aeff=2(bs⋅ts)+Lweb⋅tw=2(150.0×16.0)+200.0×10.0=4800.0+2000.0=6800.0 mm2A_{eff} = 2(b_s \cdot t_s) + L_{web} \cdot t_w = 2(150.0 \times 16.0) + 200.0 \times 10.0 = 4800.0 + 2000.0 = 6800.0\text{ mm}^2

Moment of inertia about the web centerline (z−zz-z axis):

  • Distance from web centerline to centroid of each stiffener plate: xˉ=bs+tw2=150.0+10.02=80.0 mm\bar{x} = \frac{b_s + t_w}{2} = \frac{150.0 + 10.0}{2} = 80.0\text{ mm}
  • Stiffener contribution: Istiff=2×[ts⋅bs312+(bs⋅ts)⋅xˉ2]=2×[16.0×150.0312+2400.0×80.02]I_{stiff} = 2 \times \left[ \frac{t_s \cdot b_s^3}{12} + (b_s \cdot t_s) \cdot \bar{x}^2 \right] = 2 \times \left[ \frac{16.0 \times 150.0^3}{12} + 2400.0 \times 80.0^2 \right] Istiff=2×[4.50×106+15.36×106]=2×19.86×106=39.72×106 mm4I_{stiff} = 2 \times [4.50 \times 10^6 + 15.36 \times 10^6] = 2 \times 19.86 \times 10^6 = 39.72 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^4
  • Web contribution: Iweb=Lweb⋅tw312=200.0×10.0312=0.0167×106 mm4I_{web} = \frac{L_{web} \cdot t_w^3}{12} = \frac{200.0 \times 10.0^3}{12} = 0.0167 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^4
  • Total moment of inertia: Itotal=39.72×106+0.0167×106=39.737×106 mm4I_{total} = 39.72 \times 10^6 + 0.0167 \times 10^6 = 39.737 \times 10^6\text{ mm}^4

Radius of gyration:

reff=ItotalAeff=39.737×1066800.0=5843.68=76.44 mmr_{eff} = \sqrt{\frac{I_{total}}{A_{eff}}} = \sqrt{\frac{39.737 \times 10^6}{6800.0}} = \sqrt{5843.68} = 76.44\text{ mm}

Step 3: Column Buckling Capacity Check Effective strut length:

KL=0.70⋅d=0.70×1150.0=805.0 mmKL = 0.70 \cdot d = 0.70 \times 1150.0 = 805.0\text{ mm}

Slenderness ratio:

λ=KLreff=805.076.44=10.53\lambda = \frac{KL}{r_{eff}} = \frac{805.0}{76.44} = 10.53

Since λ=10.53≤20\lambda = 10.53 \le 20, column buckling is fully suppressed (pure yielding governs!):

fcd=fyγm0=250.01.10=227.27 MPaf_{cd} = \frac{f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} = \frac{250.0}{1.10} = 227.27\text{ MPa}

Design buckling capacity of cruciform column:

Pcd=Aeff⋅fcd=6800.0×227.27103=1545.45 kNP_{cd} = A_{eff} \cdot f_{cd} = \frac{6800.0 \times 227.27}{10^3} = 1545.45\text{ kN}

Adequacy:

Ru=1200.0 kN≤Pcd=1545.45 kN(Safe! Capacity utilization =77.6%)R_u = 1200.0\text{ kN} \le P_{cd} = 1545.45\text{ kN} \quad (\text{Safe! Capacity utilization } = 77.6\%)

Step 4: Bearing Check at Contact Face with Flange (Cl. 8.7.5.2) Provide 15×15 mm15 \times 15\text{ mm} corner snips to clear the flange-to-web weld bead. Net bearing contact area:

Aq=2(bs−15.0)⋅ts=2(150.0−15.0)×16.0=2×135.0×16.0=4320.0 mm2A_q = 2(b_s - 15.0) \cdot t_s = 2(150.0 - 15.0) \times 16.0 = 2 \times 135.0 \times 16.0 = 4320.0\text{ mm}^2

Design bearing resistance:

Fpsd=Aq⋅fy0.80⋅γm0=4320.0×2500.80×1.10×103=1,080,0000.88×103=1227.27 kNF_{psd} = \frac{A_q \cdot f_y}{0.80 \cdot \gamma_{m0}} = \frac{4320.0 \times 250}{0.80 \times 1.10 \times 10^3} = \frac{1,080,000}{0.88 \times 10^3} = 1227.27\text{ kN}

Adequacy:

Ru=1200.0 kN≤Fpsd=1227.27 kN(Safe! Capacity utilization =97.8%)R_u = 1200.0\text{ kN} \le F_{psd} = 1227.27\text{ kN} \quad (\text{Safe! Capacity utilization } = 97.8\%)

Step 5: Design of Fillet Weld Connection to Web The stiffener pair is connected to the web by 4 lines of continuous fillet weld along the clear depth d=1150 mmd = 1150\text{ mm}. Net weld length per line (excluding two end snips of 15 mm15\text{ mm}):

Lline=d−2(15)=1150−30=1120.0 mmL_{line} = d - 2(15) = 1150 - 30 = 1120.0\text{ mm}

Total effective weld length:

Ltotal=4×1120.0=4480.0 mmL_{total} = 4 \times 1120.0 = 4480.0\text{ mm}

Provide a 6 mm6\text{ mm} fillet weld:

  • Throat thickness: tt=0.70×6.0=4.2 mmt_t = 0.70 \times 6.0 = 4.2\text{ mm}
  • Design shear capacity of weld: fwd=fu3⋅γmw=410.03×1.25=189.37 MPaf_{wd} = \frac{f_u}{\sqrt{3} \cdot \gamma_{mw}} = \frac{410.0}{\sqrt{3} \times 1.25} = 189.37\text{ MPa}
  • Applied shear stress on weld: qweld=Ru×103Ltotal⋅tt=1200×1034480.0×4.2=1,200,00018,816.0=63.78 MPaq_{weld} = \frac{R_u \times 10^3}{L_{total} \cdot t_t} = \frac{1200 \times 10^3}{4480.0 \times 4.2} = \frac{1,200,000}{18,816.0} = 63.78\text{ MPa}

Adequacy:

qweld=63.78 MPa≤fwd=189.37 MPa(Safe! Weld utilization =33.7%)q_{weld} = 63.78\text{ MPa} \le f_{wd} = 189.37\text{ MPa} \quad (\text{Safe! Weld utilization } = 33.7\%)

6. Comparative Engineering Analysis

Attribute / Parameter Web Crippling (Bearing Crushing) Web Buckling (Column Strut Instability)
Governing Code Clause IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.7.4 IS 800:2007 Cl. 8.7.3.1
Physical Failure Mode Localized compressive yielding / accordion crushing at root fillet Lateral out-of-plane column buckling across web depth
Load Dispersion Slope 1:2.51 : 2.5 (1 vertical to 2.5 horizontal) 45∘45^\circ (tan⁡45∘=1.0\tan 45^\circ = 1.0)
Dispersion Target Depth Root of fillet: h1=tf+r1h_1 = t_f + r_1 Neutral axis: depth =D/2= D/2
Spread Length (nn) at Support n2=2.5(tf+r1)n_2 = 2.5(t_f + r_1) n1=D/2n_1 = D / 2
Spread Length (nn) at Interior n2=5.0(tf+r1)n_2 = 5.0(t_f + r_1) n1=Dn_1 = D
Dependence on Beam Depth dd Independent of dd (pure local effect) Heavily dependent on dd (λ∝d/tw\lambda \propto d/t_w)
Strut Slenderness & Curve Not applicable (pure bearing stress) λ=KL/r\lambda = KL/r with KL=0.70dKL = 0.70 d, Curve c
Primary Remedy Increase bearing length b1b_1, increase twt_w, or bearing stiffener Provide vertical load-carrying / bearing stiffeners

7. Design Pitfalls & Practical Field Considerations

  1. Confusion Between 1:2.51:2.5 and 45∘45^\circ Dispersion Angles:
    Candidates and young engineers frequently swap the dispersion angles:

    • Web Crippling uses 1:2.51 : 2.5 through the flange and root fillet.
    • Web Buckling uses 45∘45^\circ to the neutral axis.
      Swapping these yields drastically erroneous effective bearing widths and non-conservative results.
  2. Neglecting the Root Radius r1r_1 in Rolled Sections:
    In rolled I-beams, the distance from flange face to the root of fillet is h1=tf+r1h_1 = t_f + r_1. Omitting r1r_1 reduces the calculated crippling resistance by 2.5r1twfy/γm02.5 r_1 t_w f_y / \gamma_{m0}—which can be up to 20%20\% of the section capacity!

  3. Ignoring Weld Bead Clearance (The Snip Rule):
    Bearing stiffeners must never touch the web-to-flange fillet weld. Fabricators must clip the stiffener corners by at least 15 mm×15 mm15\text{ mm} \times 15\text{ mm} (or 20 mm×20 mm20\text{ mm} \times 20\text{ mm}). Failing to detail this snip causes the stiffener to ride on the weld bead, creating severe stress concentrations and preventing tight bearing contact with the flange.

  4. Interior vs Support Dispersion Factors:
    At an end support, load disperses into the span on one side only. Under an interior concentrated load, load disperses symmetrically on both sides. Using the interior multiplier (5.0h15.0 h_1 or DD) at an end support is a critical non-conservative design error.


8. Summary of Critical Formulae

========================================================================================
                      IS 800:2007 WEB CRIPPLING & BUCKLING CHEAT SHEET
========================================================================================
• Web Crippling Resistance (Cl. 8.7.4):
    Fcrw = [ (b1 + n2) * tw * fyw ] / gm0
    Support:   n2 = 2.5 (tf + r1)
    Interior:  n2 = 5.0 (tf + r1)

• Web Buckling Resistance (Cl. 8.7.3.1):
    Fcdw = (b1 + n1) * tw * fcd
    Support:   n1 = D / 2
    Interior:  n1 = D
    Effective Length:  KL = 0.70 d  (where d = D - 2(tf + r1))
    Radius of Gyration: r = tw / (2 * sqrt(3))
    Slenderness: lambda = KL / r ≈ 2.425 (d / tw)
    Column Curve: Curve c (alpha = 0.49)

• Stiffener Local Buckling Limit (Table 2):
    bs / ts <= 14 epsilon

• Effective Cruciform Stiffener Section (Cl. 8.7.1.5):
    End Support:      Aeff = 2(bs * ts) + 20 tw^2
    Interior Load:    Aeff = 2(bs * ts) + 40 tw^2

• Bearing Check at Flange Contact (Cl. 8.7.5.2):
    Fpsd = [ Aq * fy ] / [ 0.80 * gm0 ] >= Fapplied
    where Aq = 2 (bs - snip) * ts
========================================================================================

9. Exam Traps & Tricks

  1. The Dispersion Slope Question:
    Question: "In IS 800:2007, web crippling dispersion slope is taken as:"
    Options: (A) 1:11:1 (B) 1:21:2 (C) 1:2.51:2.5 (D) 1:45∘1:45^\circ
    Trap: Option (D) mixes units. The correct code value is 1:2.51:2.5 (Option C).

  2. Depth Dependence Trap:
    Question: "Which failure mode depends directly on the clear depth of the beam web dd?"
    Answer: Web Buckling. Web crippling depends only on (tf+r1)(t_f + r_1) and twt_w, not on dd.

  3. Effective Length of Web Strut:
    In GATE CE, the effective length of the web column strut for restrained flanges is strictly 0.70d0.70 d, where dd is the clear depth between fillets (NOT the overall depth DD).

  4. Web Length in Stiffener Strut:
    Question: "What length of web acts with an end bearing stiffener?"
    Answer: Exactly 20tw20 t_w. For an intermediate stiffener under an interior load, it is 2×20tw=40tw2 \times 20 t_w = 40 t_w.


  1. IS 800:2007: General Construction in Steel — Code of Practice, Bureau of Indian Standards, New Delhi. (Sections 8.7.1 through 8.7.5).
  2. Subramanian, N.: Design of Steel Structures (Limit State Method), Oxford University Press.
  3. Duggal, S.K.: Limit State Design of Steel Structures, McGraw Hill Education.
  4. Bhavikatti, S.S.: Design of Steel Structures (IS: 800-2007), I.K. International Publishing House.

11. Practice Problems with Answer Keys

Problem 1 (GATE CE Objective)

A rolled steel I-section beam has tf=16 mmt_f = 16\text{ mm}, r1=14 mmr_1 = 14\text{ mm}, tw=10 mmt_w = 10\text{ mm}, and fy=250 MPaf_y = 250\text{ MPa}. It rests on an end bearing plate of length b1=100 mmb_1 = 100\text{ mm}. The design bearing strength of the web against crippling under IS 800:2007 is:
(A) 325.0 kN325.0\text{ kN}
(B) 397.7 kN397.7\text{ kN}
(C) 450.2 kN450.2\text{ kN}
(D) 511.4 kN511.4\text{ kN}
Answer: (B)
Hint: h1=16+14=30 mmh_1 = 16 + 14 = 30\text{ mm}. n2=2.5×30=75 mmn_2 = 2.5 \times 30 = 75\text{ mm}. Bcrip=100+75=175 mmB_{crip} = 100 + 75 = 175\text{ mm}.
Fcrw=175×10×2501.10×103=437,5001100=397.73 kNF_{crw} = \frac{175 \times 10 \times 250}{1.10 \times 10^3} = \frac{437,500}{1100} = 397.73\text{ kN}.

Problem 2 (UPSC ESE Objective)

In the design of bearing stiffeners for plate girders according to IS 800:2007, the outstand bsb_s of the stiffener from the web face of thickness tst_s is limited to:
(A) 12tsϵ12 t_s \epsilon
(B) 14tsϵ14 t_s \epsilon
(C) 16tsϵ16 t_s \epsilon
(D) 20tsϵ20 t_s \epsilon
Answer: (B)
Hint: From Table 2 (Maximum Slenderness Ratios for Stiffeners to prevent local buckling).

Problem 3 (GATE CE Numerical Answer Type)

An ISMB 500 beam (D=500 mmD = 500\text{ mm}, tw=10.2 mmt_w = 10.2\text{ mm}) rests on an end support with b1=120 mmb_1 = 120\text{ mm}. The effective width of the web acting as a column strut against web buckling (in mm\text{mm}) is ______.
Answer: 370
Hint: At an end support, n1=D/2=500/2=250 mmn_1 = D/2 = 500/2 = 250\text{ mm}.
Bbuck=b1+n1=120+250=370 mmB_{buck} = b_1 + n_1 = 120 + 250 = 370\text{ mm}.


12. Cross-Topic Linkages & Forward References