STEEL-02-02 Chapter 02 · Design of Tension Members

Shear Lag Effect & Angles under Axial Tension (IS 800:2007 Cl. 6.3.3)

In this chapter (4 topics)
On this page

1. Topic Overview & Engineering Context

In structural steel design, angle sections (equal and unequal angles) are the most widely used profile for tension members in roof trusses, communication towers, electrical transmission line towers, and bracing systems due to their ease of fabrication, direct bolting/welding to gusset plates, and geometric compactness. However, when an angle section is connected through only one of its legs to a gusset plate (with the other leg remaining unconnected or "outstanding"), the tensile load transfer into the member becomes non-uniform.

This non-uniform stress distribution is known as the shear lag effect:

  1. Near the connection, the tensile force is transmitted directly into the connected leg through the fasteners or welds.
  2. The outstanding leg receives tensile stress indirectly, via transverse in-plane shear flowing through the corner heel junction of the angle.
  3. Because steel has finite shear stiffness (G≈76.9 GPaG \approx 76.9\text{ GPa}), shear deformations cause the longitudinal tensile strains and stresses in the outstanding leg to "lag" behind those in the connected leg.
  4. As a result, the stress is concentrated near the fastener line in the connected leg and decays sharply toward the tip of the outstanding leg. At ultimate rupture, the outstanding leg does not develop its full tensile strength.

To quantify this loss of efficiency, IS 800:2007 Clause 6.3.3 formulates the design net rupture strength (TdnT_{dn}) by decomposing the angle into a connected leg component that ruptures at ultimate strength (fuf_u) and an outstanding leg component that yields at reduced efficiency governed by a shear lag factor (β\beta):

Tdn=0.90⋅Anc⋅fuγm1+β⋅Ago⋅fyγm0T_{dn} = \frac{0.90 \cdot A_{nc} \cdot f_u}{\gamma_{m1}} + \frac{\beta \cdot A_{go} \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}}
                 +-------------------------------------------------------------+
                 |            AXIAL TENSION IN ANGLE SECTIONS                  |
                 +-------------------------------------------------------------+
                                               |
                 +-----------------------------+-----------------------------+
                 |                                                           |
                 v                                                           v
     [CONNECTED LEG (Anc)]                                       [OUTSTANDING LEG (Ago)]
     * Direct mechanical attachment                              * No direct connection
     * Governed by Net Rupture:                                  * Governed by Shear Lag Yielding:
       T1 = (0.90 * Anc * fu) / γm1                                T2 = (β * Ago * fy) / γm0
     * High stress concentration                                 * Stress decays toward tip

2. Governing Codes, Standards & Design Philosophy

The design of structural steel angle tension members subjected to shear lag is codified in IS 800:2007 (Limit State Method):

  1. Clause 6.3.3 (Rupture Strength of Angles Connected through One Leg):
    • The design rupture strength of a single angle connected by one leg (either bolted or welded) is: Tdn=0.90⋅Anc⋅fuγm1+β⋅Ago⋅fyγm0T_{dn} = \frac{0.90 \cdot A_{nc} \cdot f_u}{\gamma_{m1}} + \frac{\beta \cdot A_{go} \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}}
    • The shear lag factor β\beta is calculated as: β=1.4−0.076(wt)(fyfu)(bsLc)\beta = 1.4 - 0.076 \left( \frac{w}{t} \right) \left( \frac{f_y}{f_u} \right) \left( \frac{b_s}{L_c} \right) subject to codified boundary limits: 0.70≤β≤fu⋅γm0fy⋅γm1≈1.440.70 \le \beta \le \frac{f_u \cdot \gamma_{m0}}{f_y \cdot \gamma_{m1}} \approx 1.44 (For Fe 410 steel with fy=250 MPa,fu=410 MPa,γm0=1.10,γm1=1.25f_y = 250\text{ MPa}, f_u = 410\text{ MPa}, \gamma_{m0} = 1.10, \gamma_{m1} = 1.25: the upper bound is 410×1.10250×1.25=1.4432\frac{410 \times 1.10}{250 \times 1.25} = 1.4432.)
  2. Simplified Preliminary Design Alternative (Cl. 6.3.3): Alternatively, the code permits a simplified expression for preliminary sizing: Tdn=α⋅An⋅fuγm1T_{dn} = \frac{\alpha \cdot A_n \cdot f_u}{\gamma_{m1}} where AnA_n is the total net area of the angle, and α\alpha is an empirical shear lag factor:
    • α=0.60\alpha = 0.60 for 1 or 2 bolts in line.
    • α=0.70\alpha = 0.70 for 3 bolts in line.
    • α=0.80\alpha = 0.80 for 4 or more bolts in line, or for welded connections.
  3. Double Angles Connected Back-to-Back (IS 800 Cl. 6.3.3 & Cl. 10.2.5.5):
    • When two angles are placed back-to-back on opposite sides of a gusset plate, out-of-plane eccentricity is eliminated.
    • To ensure the two angles act as an integrated structural unit, tack bolting / tack welding is mandatory at regular intervals: Pitch of tack fasteners ≤1000 mm for tension members\text{Pitch of tack fasteners } \le 1000\text{ mm for tension members} Pitch of tack fasteners ≤600 mm for compression members\text{Pitch of tack fasteners } \le 600\text{ mm for compression members}
    • When properly tack-bolted on opposite sides of the gusset plate, TdnT_{dn} is twice the capacity of a single angle.

3. Kinematics, Mechanics & Fundamental Principles

3.1 The Mechanics of Shear Lag in Un-symmetrical Profiles

Consider a single angle ISA b1×b2×tb_1 \times b_2 \times t connected to a gusset plate along leg b1b_1:

  1. Load Introduction: The external axial tension PP is applied via the gusset plate directly into the connected leg.
  2. Internal Shear Flow: To equilibrate the total member cross-section, load must diffuse from the connected leg into the outstanding leg across the 90∘90^\circ heel junction. This transfer occurs exclusively through longitudinal shear stresses (τxy\tau_{xy}).
  3. Shear Strain Lag: The shear strain γ=τ/G\gamma = \tau / G creates a distortion profile where longitudinal displacements u(x,y)u(x, y) in the outstanding leg lag behind displacements in the connected leg: ∂u∂y=τxyG≠0\frac{\partial u}{\partial y} = \frac{\tau_{xy}}{G} \neq 0
  4. Stress Profile: At sections near the connection, the tensile stress σx(y)=E∂u∂x\sigma_x(y) = E \frac{\partial u}{\partial x} is highest at the line of fasteners in the connected leg, and drops exponentially toward the tip of the outstanding leg.
  5. Effective Width Concept: At ultimate failure, the connected leg reaches its full plastic net rupture strength (0.90Ancfu/γm10.90 A_{nc} f_u / \gamma_{m1}), whereas the outstanding leg contributes only an effective portion of its yield capacity (βAgofy/γm0\beta A_{go} f_y / \gamma_{m0}).
       [Gusset]  Connected Leg (b1)        Corner Heel       Outstanding Leg (b2 = w)
          ||    +-------------------------+-----------------------------------------+
          ||    |  (o) Bolt Line          |                                         |
          ||    |  Peak Stress σmax       |                                         |
          ||    |=========================|===========\                             |
          ||    |                         |            \   Decaying Stress          |
          ||    |                         |             \                           |
          ||    +-------------------------+--------------\--------------------------+
                                                          \--> Minimum Stress σmin at Tip

3.2 Influence of Connection Detailing

  • Connection Length (LcL_c): The longer the connection (more bolts or longer weld lines), the greater the longitudinal distance available for shear stresses to diffuse into the outstanding leg. Consequently, larger LcL_c increases β\beta and minimizes shear lag loss.
  • Outstand Width (ww): Wider outstanding legs require shear to travel farther to reach the tip. Thus, smaller ww reduces shear lag.
  • Engineering Golden Rule: To minimize shear lag in unequal angles, always connect the longer leg to the gusset plate (b1>b2b_1 > b_2).

4. Mathematical Formulations & Derivations

4.1 Division of Angle Cross-Sectional Areas

To prevent double-counting the corner junction of thickness tt, the angle cross-section is divided symmetrically at the root:

  1. Net Area of Connected Leg (AncA_{nc}):
    • For a bolted angle with one line of holes: Anc=(b1−d0−t2)⋅tA_{nc} = \left( b_1 - d_0 - \frac{t}{2} \right) \cdot t
    • For a welded angle (no hole deduction): Anc=(b1−t2)⋅tA_{nc} = \left( b_1 - \frac{t}{2} \right) \cdot t
  2. Gross Area of Outstanding Leg (AgoA_{go}): Ago=(b2−t2)⋅tA_{go} = \left( b_2 - \frac{t}{2} \right) \cdot t
  3. Total Gross Area (AgA_g): Ag=Agc+Ago=(b1−t2)t+(b2−t2)t=(b1+b2−t)⋅tA_g = A_{gc} + A_{go} = \left( b_1 - \frac{t}{2} \right) t + \left( b_2 - \frac{t}{2} \right) t = (b_1 + b_2 - t) \cdot t

4.2 Shear Lag Width (bsb_s)

The parameter bsb_s represents the unfolded distance from the extreme free edge of the outstanding leg to the nearest line of fasteners in the connected leg:

  • Bolted Connection: bs=w+w1−tb_s = w + w_1 - t where:
    • w=b2w = b_2: Width of the outstanding leg.
    • w1w_1: Gauge distance from the heel of the angle to the center of the bolt hole in the connected leg.
    • tt: Thickness of the angle.
  • Welded Connection: Since fillet welds are placed along both the heel and the toe of the connected leg, the load enters across the full width of the connected leg. Hence, w1=0w_1 = 0 (or the distance is zero from the heel weld), yielding: bs=wb_s = w

4.3 Connection Length (LcL_c)

  • Bolted Connection: Distance between the centers of the first and last bolt in the joint measured parallel to the direction of tension: Lc=(n−1)⋅pL_c = (n - 1) \cdot p where nn is the number of bolts aligned in the direction of load, and pp is the pitch. (Note: If n=1n = 1, Lc=0L_c = 0, in which case β\beta is governed by the codified lower bound β=0.70\beta = 0.70.)
  • Welded Connection: Length of the weld along the load direction. If unequal welds are provided at the heel (L1L_1) and toe (L2L_2), LcL_c is taken as the length of the longer weld (Lc=max⁡(L1,L2)L_c = \max(L_1, L_2)).

5. IS 800:2007 Design Specifications & Detailing Rules

Table 1: Code Provisions for Angle Tension Members (IS 800:2007 Cl. 6.3.3)

Parameter Bolted Connection Welded Connection Code Reference
Connected Leg Net Area (AncA_{nc}) (b1−d0−t/2)⋅t(b_1 - d_0 - t/2) \cdot t (b1−t/2)⋅t(b_1 - t/2) \cdot t Cl. 6.3.3
Outstanding Leg Area (AgoA_{go}) (b2−t/2)⋅t(b_2 - t/2) \cdot t (b2−t/2)⋅t(b_2 - t/2) \cdot t Cl. 6.3.3
Shear Lag Width (bsb_s) w+w1−tw + w_1 - t ww Cl. 6.3.3
Connection Length (LcL_c) (n−1)⋅p(n - 1) \cdot p Length of longer longitudinal weld Cl. 6.3.3
Shear Lag Factor (β\beta) 1.4−0.076(wt)(fyfu)(bsLc)1.4 - 0.076 \left(\frac{w}{t}\right)\left(\frac{f_y}{f_u}\right)\left(\frac{b_s}{L_c}\right) 1.4−0.076(wt)(fyfu)(wLc)1.4 - 0.076 \left(\frac{w}{t}\right)\left(\frac{f_y}{f_u}\right)\left(\frac{w}{L_c}\right) Cl. 6.3.3
Lower Bound on β\beta 0.700.70 0.700.70 Cl. 6.3.3
Upper Bound on β\beta fuγm0fyγm1≈1.44\frac{f_u \gamma_{m0}}{f_y \gamma_{m1}} \approx 1.44 fuγm0fyγm1≈1.44\frac{f_u \gamma_{m0}}{f_y \gamma_{m1}} \approx 1.44 Cl. 6.3.3
Preliminary Design Factor (α\alpha) 0.60.6 (1-2 bolts), 0.70.7 (3 bolts), 0.80.8 (≥4\ge 4 bolts) 0.800.80 Cl. 6.3.3
Tack Bolting Spacing ≤1000 mm\le 1000\text{ mm} (Tension) / ≤600 mm\le 600\text{ mm} (Compression) ≤1000 mm\le 1000\text{ mm} (Tension) Cl. 10.2.5.5

6. Engineering Diagrams & Visual Explanations

Figure 1: Shear Lag Mechanics & Stress Distribution in Tension Angles

+----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
|                               SHEAR LAG MECHANICS IN SINGLE ANGLES                                 |
|                                                                                                    |
|    Connected Leg (Anc)                       Outstanding Leg (Ago)                                 |
|    +-----------------------------+           +---------------------------------------+             |
|    |                             |   Heel    |                                       |             |
|    |      (o) Bolt Line          |  Junction |                                       |             |
|    |                             |==== x ====|                                       |             |
|    |  Direct Load Introduction   |           |  Shear Flow Transfers Tensile Stress  |             |
|    |  Rupture: 0.90*Anc*fu/γm1   |           |  Reduced Yielding: β*Ago*fy/γm0       |             |
|    +-----------------------------+           +---------------------------------------+             |
|                                                                                                    |
|    Stress Profile:                                                                                 |
|    [Peak Stress at Bolt Line] =======> [Shear Lag Decay] =======> [Minimum Stress at Tip]          |
+----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

The structural behavior and non-uniform stress profile of angle tension members are shown below: Shear Lag Mechanics and Stress Distribution in Angles

Key Architectural Insights from Figure 1:

  1. Decoupled Capacity Model: The IS 800:2007 formulation separates the angle into two distinct behavioral zones: the connected leg which fails by net section rupture (0.90Ancfu/γm10.90 A_{nc} f_u / \gamma_{m1}), and the outstanding leg which fails by shear-lagged yielding (βAgofy/γm0\beta A_{go} f_y / \gamma_{m0}).
  2. Stress Gradient: Due to shear lag, tensile stress decays from a maximum peak at the fastener line to a minimum at the free outstand tip.
  3. Connection Diffusivity: Longer connection lengths LcL_c allow more shear flow across the heel junction, raising the shear lag factor β\beta closer to its theoretical ceiling of 1.441.44.

Figure 2: Shear Lag Width (bsb_s) & Connection Length (LcL_c) Geometry

+----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
|                                  SHEAR LAG GEOMETRIC PARAMETERS                                    |
|                                                                                                    |
|    [BOLTED ANGLE: bs = w + w1 - t]                   [WELDED ANGLE: bs = w]                        |
|                                                                                                    |
|       Gusset       Connected Leg (b1)                   Gusset       Connected Leg (b1)            |
|         ||   +-------------------+                        ||   +-------------------+               |
|         ||   |     (o) Bolt Line |                        ||   |      Toe Weld ===>|               |
|         ||   |        |          |                        ||   |                   |               |
|         ||   |        |<-- w1 -->| Heel                   ||   |                   | Heel          |
|         ||   +--------+----------+                        ||   +-------------------+               |
|         ||            |          |                             |                   |               |
|                       |<------- w ------->|                                        |<------ w ---->|
|                       |<------ bs ------->|                                        |<- bs = w ---->|
|                                                                                                    |
|    [CONNECTION LENGTH Lc]: Bolted: Lc = (n-1)*p   |   Welded: Lc = Lw (Longer weld)                |
+----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

The precise geometric definitions of w,w1,bs,w, w_1, b_s, and LcL_c are illustrated below: Shear Lag Width bs and Connection Length Geometry

Key Architectural Insights from Figure 2:

  1. Unfolded Width (bsb_s): For bolted joints, bs=w+w1−tb_s = w + w_1 - t traces the total distance from the outstand tip around the corner to the fastener centerline, deducting tt to avoid double-counting.
  2. Welded Superiority (bs=wb_s = w): In welded joints, dual weld lines along the heel and toe eliminate the w1w_1 offset, reducing bsb_s to ww. This increases β\beta and provides higher rupture resistance.
  3. Single Bolt Vulnerability: If only one bolt is provided (n=1n=1), Lc=0L_c = 0, causing severe shear lag; the code restricts β\beta to its lower bound of 0.700.70.

7. Step-by-Step Design Procedures & Workflows

7.1 Workflow: Evaluation of Angle Tension Member Capacity

[START: Given Angle Section b1 x b2 x t, Connection Type (Bolted/Welded)]
       |
       v
[Step 1: Compute Component Areas]
       --> For Bolted: Anc = (b1 - d0 - t/2) * t
       --> For Welded: Anc = (b1 - t/2) * t
       --> Outstanding Leg: Ago = (b2 - t/2) * t
       --> Gross Area: Ag = (b1 + b2 - t) * t
       |
       v
[Step 2: Determine Shear Lag Geometric Parameters]
       --> Outstand width w = b2
       --> For Bolted: bs = w + w1 - t; Lc = (n - 1) * p
       --> For Welded: bs = w; Lc = length of longer weld
       |
       v
[Step 3: Calculate Shear Lag Factor (β)]
       --> beta_calc = 1.4 - 0.076 * (w / t) * (fy / fu) * (bs / Lc)
       --> Check limits: beta = max(0.70, min(beta_calc, 1.4432))
       |
       v
[Step 4: Compute Design Capacities per IS 800:2007]
       --> Gross Yielding: Tdg = (Ag * fy) / gamma_m0
       --> Net Rupture: Tdn = (0.90 * Anc * fu / gamma_m1) + (beta * Ago * fy / gamma_m0)
       --> Block Shear: Tdb = min(Tdb1, Tdb2)  (refer to STEEL-02-03)
       |
       v
[Step 5: Determine Governing Design Tensile Strength]
       --> Td = min(Tdg, Tdn, Tdb)
       --> Compare with Factored Tensile Load Tu: Is Td >= Tu?
           |-- NO  --> Choose larger angle section or increase Lc.
           |-- YES --> SAFE. Proceed to slenderness check. [END]

8. Solved Numerical Examples (Pre-Calculated & Multi-Step)

Problem 1: Bolted Single Angle Tension Member (ISA 90×60×8 mm90 \times 60 \times 8\text{ mm})

Statement: A single unequal angle tension member ISA 90×60×8 mm90 \times 60 \times 8\text{ mm} of Fe 410 steel (fy=250 N/mm2,fu=410 N/mm2,γm0=1.10,γm1=1.25f_y = 250\text{ N/mm}^2, f_u = 410\text{ N/mm}^2, \gamma_{m0} = 1.10, \gamma_{m1} = 1.25) is connected by its longer leg (90 mm90\text{ mm}) to a 10 mm10\text{ mm} thick gusset plate using 4 bolts of M20 Class 4.6 (d0=22 mmd_0 = 22\text{ mm}) arranged in a single line. The bolt pitch is p=60 mmp = 60\text{ mm}, and the gauge distance from the heel of the angle is w1=50 mmw_1 = 50\text{ mm}. Calculate:

  1. The shear lag factor β\beta.
  2. The design net rupture strength TdnT_{dn}.
  3. The design gross section yielding strength TdgT_{dg}.
  4. The governing design tensile strength TdT_d.
       Gusset Plate (t = 10 mm)
          | |
          | |   ISA 90 x 60 x 8 mm
          | |==================================> Tu (Tension Load)
          | |     o     o     o     o
          | |    p=60  p=60  p=60
          | |<---------- Lc = 180 mm --------->

Step 1: Cross-Sectional Areas

  • Thickness t=8 mm  ⟹  t/2=4 mmt = 8\text{ mm} \implies t/2 = 4\text{ mm}.
  • Connected leg width b1=90 mmb_1 = 90\text{ mm}, hole diameter d0=22 mmd_0 = 22\text{ mm}: Anc=(b1−d0−t2)⋅t=(90−22−4)×8=64×8=512.0 mm2A_{nc} = \left( b_1 - d_0 - \frac{t}{2} \right) \cdot t = (90 - 22 - 4) \times 8 = 64 \times 8 = 512.0\text{ mm}^2
  • Outstanding leg width b2=60 mmb_2 = 60\text{ mm}: Ago=(b2−t2)⋅t=(60−4)×8=56×8=448.0 mm2A_{go} = \left( b_2 - \frac{t}{2} \right) \cdot t = (60 - 4) \times 8 = 56 \times 8 = 448.0\text{ mm}^2
  • Gross area: Ag=(b1+b2−t)⋅t=(90+60−8)×8=142×8=1136.0 mm2A_g = (b_1 + b_2 - t) \cdot t = (90 + 60 - 8) \times 8 = 142 \times 8 = 1136.0\text{ mm}^2

Step 2: Shear Lag Parameters (w,bs,Lcw, b_s, L_c)

  • Outstanding width: w=b2=60.0 mmw = b_2 = 60.0\text{ mm}.
  • Gauge from heel: w1=50.0 mmw_1 = 50.0\text{ mm}.
  • Shear lag width for bolted joint: bs=w+w1−t=60.0+50.0−8.0=102.0 mmb_s = w + w_1 - t = 60.0 + 50.0 - 8.0 = 102.0\text{ mm}
  • Length of connection (4 bolts4\text{ bolts} at p=60 mmp = 60\text{ mm}): Lc=(n−1)⋅p=(4−1)×60.0=3×60.0=180.0 mmL_c = (n - 1) \cdot p = (4 - 1) \times 60.0 = 3 \times 60.0 = 180.0\text{ mm}

Step 3: Calculation of Shear Lag Factor (β\beta) Per IS 800:2007 Cl. 6.3.3:

β=1.4−0.076(wt)(fyfu)(bsLc)\beta = 1.4 - 0.076 \left( \frac{w}{t} \right) \left( \frac{f_y}{f_u} \right) \left( \frac{b_s}{L_c} \right)

Substitute the numeric values:

wt=608=7.50\frac{w}{t} = \frac{60}{8} = 7.50 fyfu=250410=0.609756\frac{f_y}{f_u} = \frac{250}{410} = 0.609756 bsLc=102.0180.0=0.566667\frac{b_s}{L_c} = \frac{102.0}{180.0} = 0.566667 Reduction Term=0.076×7.50×0.609756×0.566667=0.076×2.59146=0.1970\text{Reduction Term} = 0.076 \times 7.50 \times 0.609756 \times 0.566667 = 0.076 \times 2.59146 = 0.1970 βcalc=1.4−0.1970=1.2030\beta_{\text{calc}} = 1.4 - 0.1970 = 1.2030

Check code limits:

  • Lower limit: 0.700.70.
  • Upper limit: βmax⁡=fu⋅γm0fy⋅γm1=410×1.10250×1.25=451.0312.5=1.4432\beta_{\max} = \frac{f_u \cdot \gamma_{m0}}{f_y \cdot \gamma_{m1}} = \frac{410 \times 1.10}{250 \times 1.25} = \frac{451.0}{312.5} = 1.4432

Since 0.70≤1.2030≤1.44320.70 \le 1.2030 \le 1.4432, adopt:

β=1.2030\beta = 1.2030

Step 4: Design Rupture Strength (TdnT_{dn})

Tdn=0.90⋅Anc⋅fuγm1+β⋅Ago⋅fyγm0T_{dn} = \frac{0.90 \cdot A_{nc} \cdot f_u}{\gamma_{m1}} + \frac{\beta \cdot A_{go} \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}}
  1. Connected leg contribution: T1=0.90×512.0 mm2×410 N/mm21.25=1889281.25=151142.4 N=151.14 kNT_1 = \frac{0.90 \times 512.0\text{ mm}^2 \times 410\text{ N/mm}^2}{1.25} = \frac{188928}{1.25} = 151142.4\text{ N} = 151.14\text{ kN}
  2. Outstanding leg contribution: T2=1.2030×448.0 mm2×250 N/mm21.10=1347361.10=122487.3 N=122.49 kNT_2 = \frac{1.2030 \times 448.0\text{ mm}^2 \times 250\text{ N/mm}^2}{1.10} = \frac{134736}{1.10} = 122487.3\text{ N} = 122.49\text{ kN}
  3. Total rupture capacity: Tdn=151.14 kN+122.49 kN=273.63 kNT_{dn} = 151.14\text{ kN} + 122.49\text{ kN} = 273.63\text{ kN}

Step 5: Design Gross Section Yielding Strength (TdgT_{dg})

Tdg=Ag⋅fyγm0=1136.0 mm2×250 N/mm21.10=2840001.10=258181.8 N=258.18 kNT_{dg} = \frac{A_g \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} = \frac{1136.0\text{ mm}^2 \times 250\text{ N/mm}^2}{1.10} = \frac{284000}{1.10} = 258181.8\text{ N} = 258.18\text{ kN}

Step 6: Governing Design Tensile Strength (TdT_d)

Td=min⁡(Tdg, Tdn)=min⁡(258.18 kN, 273.63 kN)=258.18 kNT_d = \min(T_{dg}, \, T_{dn}) = \min(258.18\text{ kN}, \, 273.63\text{ kN}) = 258.18\text{ kN}

Conclusion: The single angle tension member has a design tensile capacity of 258.18 kN258.18\text{ kN}, governed by gross section yielding.


Problem 2: Welded Single Angle Tension Member Comparison

Statement: The same unequal angle ISA 90×60×8 mm90 \times 60 \times 8\text{ mm} (Fe 410) from Problem 1 is connected to the gusset plate using longitudinal fillet welds instead of bolts. The weld along the heel has length L1=150 mmL_1 = 150\text{ mm}, and the weld along the toe has length L2=90 mmL_2 = 90\text{ mm}. Calculate the design rupture strength TdnT_{dn} and compare it with the bolted joint capacity.

Step 1: Cross-Sectional Areas for Welded Joint Since there are no bolt holes in the connected leg:

  • Connected leg: Anc=(b1−t2)⋅t=(90−4)×8=688.0 mm2A_{nc} = \left( b_1 - \frac{t}{2} \right) \cdot t = (90 - 4) \times 8 = 688.0\text{ mm}^2
  • Outstanding leg: Ago=(b2−t2)⋅t=(60−4)×8=448.0 mm2A_{go} = \left( b_2 - \frac{t}{2} \right) \cdot t = (60 - 4) \times 8 = 448.0\text{ mm}^2
  • Gross area: Ag=688.0+448.0=1136.0 mm2A_g = 688.0 + 448.0 = 1136.0\text{ mm}^2

Step 2: Shear Lag Parameters for Welded Joint

  • For welded connection: bs=w=60.0 mmb_s = w = 60.0\text{ mm}
  • Connection length: Lc=max⁡(L1, L2)=150.0 mmL_c = \max(L_1, \, L_2) = 150.0\text{ mm}

Step 3: Shear Lag Factor (β\beta)

β=1.4−0.076(wt)(fyfu)(bsLc)\beta = 1.4 - 0.076 \left( \frac{w}{t} \right) \left( \frac{f_y}{f_u} \right) \left( \frac{b_s}{L_c} \right) wt=608=7.50\frac{w}{t} = \frac{60}{8} = 7.50 fyfu=250410=0.609756\frac{f_y}{f_u} = \frac{250}{410} = 0.609756 bsLc=60.0150.0=0.40\frac{b_s}{L_c} = \frac{60.0}{150.0} = 0.40 Reduction Term=0.076×7.50×0.609756×0.40=0.1390\text{Reduction Term} = 0.076 \times 7.50 \times 0.609756 \times 0.40 = 0.1390 βcalc=1.4−0.1390=1.2610\beta_{\text{calc}} = 1.4 - 0.1390 = 1.2610

Check limits: 0.70≤1.2610≤1.4432  ⟹  β=1.26100.70 \le 1.2610 \le 1.4432 \implies \beta = 1.2610.

Step 4: Design Rupture Strength (TdnT_{dn})

Tdn=0.90⋅Anc⋅fuγm1+β⋅Ago⋅fyγm0T_{dn} = \frac{0.90 \cdot A_{nc} \cdot f_u}{\gamma_{m1}} + \frac{\beta \cdot A_{go} \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}}
  1. Connected leg: T1=0.90×688.0×4101.25=2538721.25=203097.6 N=203.10 kNT_1 = \frac{0.90 \times 688.0 \times 410}{1.25} = \frac{253872}{1.25} = 203097.6\text{ N} = 203.10\text{ kN}
  2. Outstanding leg: T2=1.2610×448.0×2501.10=1412321.10=128392.7 N=128.39 kNT_2 = \frac{1.2610 \times 448.0 \times 250}{1.10} = \frac{141232}{1.10} = 128392.7\text{ N} = 128.39\text{ kN}
  3. Total rupture strength: Tdn=203.10 kN+128.39 kN=331.49 kNT_{dn} = 203.10\text{ kN} + 128.39\text{ kN} = 331.49\text{ kN}

Step 5: Comparative Analysis

  • Bolted joint rupture capacity: Tdn,bolted=273.63 kNT_{dn,\text{bolted}} = 273.63\text{ kN}.
  • Welded joint rupture capacity: Tdn,welded=331.49 kNT_{dn,\text{welded}} = 331.49\text{ kN}.
  • Percentage gain: ΔTdn=331.49−273.63273.63×100%=57.86273.63×100%=+21.1%\Delta T_{dn} = \frac{331.49 - 273.63}{273.63} \times 100\% = \frac{57.86}{273.63} \times 100\% = +21.1\%

Conclusion: Welded connections eliminate bolt hole deductions and reduce shear lag width (bs=wb_s = w), increasing net rupture capacity by 21.1%21.1\%.


Problem 3: Double Angles Back-to-Back — Tack Bolting & Design

Statement: A tension tie in a bridge truss consists of two unequal angles 2 ISA 100×75×8 mm100 \times 75 \times 8\text{ mm} (Fe 410) connected back-to-back on opposite sides of a 10 mm10\text{ mm} gusset plate. The member is subjected to a factored axial tensile force Tu=500.0 kNT_u = 500.0\text{ kN}. The longer legs (100 mm100\text{ mm}) are connected to the gusset plate using 4 M20 bolts (d0=22 mmd_0 = 22\text{ mm}) per angle at pitch p=60 mmp = 60\text{ mm} (Lc=180 mmL_c = 180\text{ mm}), with gauge from heel w1=55 mmw_1 = 55\text{ mm}.

  1. Verify the adequacy of the double angle member against gross yielding and net rupture.
  2. Determine the maximum permissible spacing of intermediate tack bolts per IS 800:2007 Cl. 10.2.5.5 for a total clear member span of L=2.4 mL = 2.4\text{ m}.

Step 1: Section Properties for One Angle

  • Connected leg b1=100 mmb_1 = 100\text{ mm}, outstand b2=75 mmb_2 = 75\text{ mm}, thickness t=8 mmt = 8\text{ mm}.
  • Anc=(100−22−4)×8=74×8=592.0 mm2A_{nc} = (100 - 22 - 4) \times 8 = 74 \times 8 = 592.0\text{ mm}^2.
  • Ago=(75−4)×8=71×8=568.0 mm2A_{go} = (75 - 4) \times 8 = 71 \times 8 = 568.0\text{ mm}^2.
  • Ag1=(100+75−8)×8=167×8=1336.0 mm2A_{g1} = (100 + 75 - 8) \times 8 = 167 \times 8 = 1336.0\text{ mm}^2.

Step 2: Shear Lag Factor (β\beta) per Angle

  • Outstand w=75.0 mmw = 75.0\text{ mm}.
  • Gauge w1=55.0 mmw_1 = 55.0\text{ mm}.
  • Shear lag width: bs=w+w1−t=75.0+55.0−8.0=122.0 mmb_s = w + w_1 - t = 75.0 + 55.0 - 8.0 = 122.0\text{ mm}
  • Connection length: Lc=(4−1)×60.0=180.0 mmL_c = (4 - 1) \times 60.0 = 180.0\text{ mm}
  • Calculate β\beta: β=1.4−0.076(758)(250410)(122180)=1.4−0.076×9.375×0.609756×0.677778=1.4−0.2944=1.1056\beta = 1.4 - 0.076 \left( \frac{75}{8} \right) \left( \frac{250}{410} \right) \left( \frac{122}{180} \right) = 1.4 - 0.076 \times 9.375 \times 0.609756 \times 0.677778 = 1.4 - 0.2944 = 1.1056

Check limits: 0.70≤1.1056≤1.4432  ⟹  β=1.10560.70 \le 1.1056 \le 1.4432 \implies \beta = 1.1056.

Step 3: Rupture Strength for One Angle (Tdn1T_{dn1})

Tdn1=0.90×592.0×4101.25+1.1056×568.0×2501.10=174766.1+142722.9=317489.0 N=317.49 kNT_{dn1} = \frac{0.90 \times 592.0 \times 410}{1.25} + \frac{1.1056 \times 568.0 \times 250}{1.10} = 174766.1 + 142722.9 = 317489.0\text{ N} = 317.49\text{ kN}

Step 4: Total Capacity of Double Angle Member (2 Angles)

  1. Total Net Rupture Strength: Tdn,total=2×Tdn1=2×317.49 kN=634.98 kNT_{dn,\text{total}} = 2 \times T_{dn1} = 2 \times 317.49\text{ kN} = 634.98\text{ kN}
  2. Total Gross Section Yielding Strength: Ag,total=2×1336.0 mm2=2672.0 mm2A_{g,\text{total}} = 2 \times 1336.0\text{ mm}^2 = 2672.0\text{ mm}^2 Tdg,total=Ag,total⋅fyγm0=2672.0×2501.10=6680001.10=607273 N=607.27 kNT_{dg,\text{total}} = \frac{A_{g,\text{total}} \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} = \frac{2672.0 \times 250}{1.10} = \frac{668000}{1.10} = 607273\text{ N} = 607.27\text{ kN}
  3. Controlling Design Strength: Td=min⁡(Tdg,total, Tdn,total)=min⁡(607.27 kN, 634.98 kN)=607.27 kNT_d = \min(T_{dg,\text{total}}, \, T_{dn,\text{total}}) = \min(607.27\text{ kN}, \, 634.98\text{ kN}) = 607.27\text{ kN}

Check adequacy:

Td=607.27 kN≥Tu=500.0 kN(SAFE, 82.3% Capacity Utilization)T_d = 607.27\text{ kN} \ge T_u = 500.0\text{ kN} \quad (\text{SAFE, 82.3\% Capacity Utilization})

Step 5: Tack Bolting Requirements per IS 800:2007 Cl. 10.2.5.5

  • For double angle members subjected to axial tension, the pitch of tacking bolts shall not exceed 1000 mm1000\text{ mm}.
  • For total member length L=2.4 m=2400 mmL = 2.4\text{ m} = 2400\text{ mm}: Maximum spacing ≤1000 mm\text{Maximum spacing } \le 1000\text{ mm}
  • Specification: Provide intermediate tack bolts with 10 mm10\text{ mm} pack washers at 800 mm800\text{ mm} centers (2 intermediate tack bolts along the span).

9. Common Pitfalls, Edge Cases & Failure Modes

  1. Forgetting t/2t/2 Deduction in AncA_{nc} and AgoA_{go}:
    • Pitfall: Computing Anc=(b1−d0)⋅tA_{nc} = (b_1 - d_0) \cdot t and Ago=b2⋅tA_{go} = b_2 \cdot t.
    • Consequence: Double-counting the corner square of area t2t^2, overestimating cross-sectional area and design capacity.
  2. Applying Bolted bsb_s Equation to Welded Connections:
    • Pitfall: Using bs=w+w1−tb_s = w + w_1 - t for welded angles.
    • Correction: In welded angles, w1w_1 is not applicable because weld lines clamp both the heel and toe; strictly use bs=wb_s = w.
  3. Single Bolt Connection Shear Lag Limitation:
    • Pitfall: Attempting to evaluate β\beta for a 1-bolt connection (Lc=0L_c = 0), resulting in mathematical division by zero.
    • Rule: For single-bolt joints, the code enforces β=0.70\beta = 0.70 (or α=0.60\alpha = 0.60 using the preliminary formula).
  4. Connecting the Shorter Leg to the Gusset Plate:
    • Pitfall: Connecting the shorter leg (60 mm60\text{ mm}) while leaving the longer leg (90 mm90\text{ mm}) outstanding.
    • Consequence: Outstand width ww increases by 50%50\%, sharply depressing the shear lag factor β\beta and losing up to 25%25\% of member capacity. Always connect the longer leg.
  5. Omitting Tack Fasteners in Double Angle Members:
    • Pitfall: Assuming two angles placed back-to-back act together without intermediate tack bolts.
    • Consequence: Without tacking at ≤1000 mm\le 1000\text{ mm}, each angle vibrates independently, experiences transverse buckling under accidental compression, and violates IS 800 Cl. 10.2.5.5.

10. Exam-Specific Focus Points & Rapid Revision Notes

10.1 Quick Revision Formula Card

  • Rupture Formula: Tdn=0.90Ancfuγm1+βAgofyγm0T_{dn} = \frac{0.90 A_{nc} f_u}{\gamma_{m1}} + \frac{\beta A_{go} f_y}{\gamma_{m0}}
  • Shear Lag Factor: β=1.4−0.076(wt)(fyfu)(bsLc)\beta = 1.4 - 0.076 \left(\frac{w}{t}\right)\left(\frac{f_y}{f_u}\right)\left(\frac{b_s}{L_c}\right)
  • Bounds on β\beta: 0.70≤β≤fuγm0fyγm1≈1.440.70 \le \beta \le \frac{f_u \gamma_{m0}}{f_y \gamma_{m1}} \approx 1.44
  • Bolted Shear Lag Width: bs=w+w1−tb_s = w + w_1 - t
  • Welded Shear Lag Width: bs=wb_s = w
  • Connection Length: Lc=(n−1)pL_c = (n-1) p (Bolted) or LwL_w (Welded).
  • Preliminary Shortcut: Tdn=αAnfuγm1T_{dn} = \frac{\alpha A_n f_u}{\gamma_{m1}} (α=0.6,0.7,0.8\alpha = 0.6, 0.7, 0.8 for 1-2 bolts, 3 bolts, ≥4\ge 4 bolts).
  • Max Tack Bolt Spacing: 1000 mm1000\text{ mm} (Tension) / 600 mm600\text{ mm} (Compression).

10.2 Examination Nuances

  • GATE CE: Often asks to calculate the exact numerical value of β\beta for a given bolted or welded angle, testing whether the candidate remembers the 0.700.70 lower bound or correctly sets bs=wb_s = w for welds.
  • ESE Prelims: Frequently tests the partial safety factors (γm0=1.10,γm1=1.25\gamma_{m0} = 1.10, \gamma_{m1} = 1.25), the definition of bsb_s, and the preliminary values of α\alpha (0.6,0.7,0.80.6, 0.7, 0.8).
  • SSC JE & State AE/JE: Direct factual questions on maximum tack bolt spacing (1000 mm1000\text{ mm} for tension ties) and the reason why the longer leg of an unequal angle is connected to the gusset.

11. Practice Problems & Self-Assessment Question Bank

  1. Question 1 (Conceptual): Why is the shear lag factor β\beta multiplied by the yield stress fyf_y and divided by γm0\gamma_{m0}, while the connected leg area AncA_{nc} is multiplied by ultimate tensile strength fuf_u and divided by γm1\gamma_{m1}?
    • Answer: The connected leg undergoes severe localized plastic strain at the bolt holes and fails by ultimate tensile rupture (fu,γm1f_u, \gamma_{m1}). The outstanding leg is restrained from immediate fracture by the shear lag gradient; its stress is limited to an effective yield contribution (βfy,γm0\beta f_y, \gamma_{m0}) at the instant the connected leg ruptures.
  2. Question 2 (Formula Application): For an ISA 75×50×6 mm75 \times 50 \times 6\text{ mm} angle (Fe 410) connected by its 75 mm75\text{ mm} leg with welds (Lc=120 mmL_c = 120\text{ mm}), calculate bsb_s and determine β\beta.
    • Answer: For welded connection: bs=w=50 mmb_s = w = 50\text{ mm}. w/t=50/6=8.333w/t = 50/6 = 8.333. fy/fu=250/410=0.6098f_y/f_u = 250/410 = 0.6098. bs/Lc=50/120=0.4167b_s/L_c = 50/120 = 0.4167. β=1.4−0.076×8.333×0.6098×0.4167=1.4−0.1609=1.239\beta = 1.4 - 0.076 \times 8.333 \times 0.6098 \times 0.4167 = 1.4 - 0.1609 = 1.239. Since 0.70≤1.239≤1.440.70 \le 1.239 \le 1.44, β=1.239\beta = 1.239.
  3. Question 3 (GATE Numeric): An angle tension member has Anc=600 mm2A_{nc} = 600\text{ mm}^2 and Ago=400 mm2A_{go} = 400\text{ mm}^2 (Fe 410 steel). If β=1.15\beta = 1.15, compute the design net rupture strength TdnT_{dn}.
    • Answer: Tdn=0.90×600×4101.25+1.15×400×2501.10=177.12 kN+104.55 kN=281.67 kNT_{dn} = \frac{0.90 \times 600 \times 410}{1.25} + \frac{1.15 \times 400 \times 250}{1.10} = 177.12\text{ kN} + 104.55\text{ kN} = 281.67\text{ kN}.
  4. Question 4 (Preliminary Design Shortcut): Estimate the net rupture capacity of an angle with total net area An=950 mm2A_n = 950\text{ mm}^2 (Fe 410) connected by 3 bolts using the simplified preliminary equation of IS 800 Cl. 6.3.3.
    • Answer: For 3 bolts, α=0.70\alpha = 0.70. Tdn=0.70×950×4101.25=2726501.25=218120 N=218.12 kNT_{dn} = \frac{0.70 \times 950 \times 410}{1.25} = \frac{272650}{1.25} = 218120\text{ N} = 218.12\text{ kN}.
  5. Question 5 (Tack Bolting): What is the primary structural consequence if tack bolts are omitted along the span of a double-angle tension tie?
    • Answer: Without tack bolts, the two angles act as independent slender elements rather than a combined symmetric section. Any accidental compressive rebound, wind flutter, or seismic load will induce premature buckling in the individual angles at a slenderness ratio governed by their individual rmin⁡r_{\min}.

12. Bibliographic References & Standard Codes

  1. Bureau of Indian Standards: IS 800:2007 — General Construction in Steel — Code of Practice (Third Revision), BIS, New Delhi.
  2. Subramanian, N.: Design of Steel Structures (Limit State Method), Oxford University Press, 2018.
  3. Duggal, S. K.: Limit State Design of Steel Structures, McGraw Hill Education (India), 2nd Edition, 2019.
  4. Bhavikatti, S. S.: Design of Steel Structures By Limit State Method as per IS: 800-2007, I.K. International Publishing House.
  5. INSDAG: Design of Tension Members, Institute for Steel Development & Growth, Kolkata.
  6. AISC 360-16: Specification for Structural Steel Buildings, American Institute of Steel Construction, Chicago.