STEEL-02-01 Chapter 02 · Design of Tension Members

Design of Tension Members (Gross Section Yielding & Net Section Rupture per IS 800:2007)

In this chapter (4 topics)
On this page

1. Topic Overview & Engineering Context

In structural steel framing, tension members (also referred to as ties, hangers, or sag rods) are structural elements subjected to axial tensile forces tending to elongate the member. Typical structural applications include:

  1. Bottom chords and tension web diagonals of roof trusses and bridge trusses.
  2. Cross-bracing systems in high-rise buildings and industrial mill bents resisting lateral wind and seismic loads.
  3. Hanger ties supporting suspended floors, bridge decks, and pedestrian walkways.
  4. Sag rods and wind ties stabilizing cold-formed steel purlins and girts in industrial sheds.
  5. Cable-stayed systems and prestressed tendon ties in long-span infrastructure.

Unlike compression members (struts and columns), tension members do not suffer from structural instability or elastic buckling under primary axial tension. Consequently, their design is governed strictly by material strength limit states. Per IS 800:2007 (Limit State Method), a tension member fails by one of three independent limit states:

  1. Yielding of Gross Cross-Section (TdgT_{dg}): Excessive plastic elongation along the clear length between joints, causing unserviceable structural deflections and redistribution of loads.
  2. Rupture of Critical Net Cross-Section (TdnT_{dn}): Localized ductile necking and fracture across the reduced cross-sectional area weakened by fastener holes.
  3. Block Shear Failure (TdbT_{db}): Localized tear-out of a block of material at the end connection along concurrent planes of shear and tension (detailed in STEEL-02-03).

The governing design tensile strength TdT_d of a structural member is the minimum of these three limit state resistances:

Td=min⁡(Tdg, Tdn, Tdb)T_d = \min(T_{dg}, \, T_{dn}, \, T_{db})
                   +-------------------------------------------------------------+
                   |             LIMIT STATE DESIGN OF TENSION MEMBERS           |
                   |                    (IS 800:2007 Section 6)                  |
                   +-------------------------------------------------------------+
                                                 |
         +---------------------------------------+---------------------------------------+
         |                                       |                                       |
         v                                       v                                       v
[GROSS SECTION YIELDING]                [NET SECTION RUPTURE]                   [BLOCK SHEAR TEAR-OUT]
  IS 800 Cl. 6.2                          IS 800 Cl. 6.3                          IS 800 Cl. 6.4
  Tdg = (Ag * fy) / γm0                   Tdn = (0.90 * An * fu) / γm1            Tdb = min(Tdb1, Tdb2)
  γm0 = 1.10                              γm1 = 1.25                              γm0 = 1.10, γm1 = 1.25
  * Overall span elongation               * Localized hole fracture               * End boundary rupture
  * Serviceability / collapse             * Catastrophic ultimate fracture        * Shear + tension planes

2. Governing Codes, Standards & Design Philosophy

The design of structural steel tension members in India is governed by IS 800:2007 (Code of Practice for General Construction in Steel):

  1. Clause 6.1 (General):
    • The factored tensile force TT in any member shall satisfy: T≤TdT \le T_d
    • The design strength TdT_d is the lowest of TdgT_{dg}, TdnT_{dn}, and TdbT_{db}.
  2. Clause 6.2 (Design Strength Due to Yielding of Gross Section): Tdg=Ag⋅fyγm0T_{dg} = \frac{A_g \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} where:
    • AgA_g: Gross cross-sectional area of member.
    • fyf_y: Yield stress of steel (250 MPa250\text{ MPa} for Fe 410).
    • γm0=1.10\gamma_{m0} = 1.10: Partial safety factor for resistance governed by yielding (Table 5).
  3. Clause 6.3 (Design Strength Due to Rupture of Critical Section):
    • Cl. 6.3.1 (Plates): Tdn=0.90⋅An⋅fuγm1T_{dn} = \frac{0.90 \cdot A_n \cdot f_u}{\gamma_{m1}} where:
      • AnA_n: Net cross-sectional area of the plate along the critical fracture line.
      • fuf_u: Ultimate tensile strength (410 MPa410\text{ MPa} for Fe 410).
      • γm1=1.25\gamma_{m1} = 1.25: Partial safety factor for resistance governed by ultimate rupture (Table 5).
      • Factor 0.900.90: Empirically calibrated factor accounting for plastic constraint and stress concentration around bolt holes.
    • Cl. 6.3.4 (Threaded Rods & Round Ties): Tdn=0.90⋅An⋅fuγm1T_{dn} = \frac{0.90 \cdot A_n \cdot f_u}{\gamma_{m1}} where AnA_n is the net core area at the root of threads (≈0.78As\approx 0.78 A_s).
  4. Table 3 (Maximum Slenderness Ratio λ=L/rmin⁡\lambda = L / r_{\min}): Even though tension members do not buckle under axial tension, maximum slenderness limits are codified to prevent excessive lateral sagging due to self-weight, wind-induced flutter, and accidental compressive damage during transport and erection:
    • Tension member carrying loads resulting from wind/seismic forces (reversal): λ≤180\lambda \le 180.
    • Tension member in roof truss or bracing system (normally in tension): λ≤350\lambda \le 350.
    • Tension member other than pretensioned cables (general tie): λ≤400\lambda \le 400.

3. Kinematics, Mechanics & Fundamental Principles

3.1 Mechanics of Gross Section Yielding (TdgT_{dg})

Under axial tension PP, the uniform tensile stress across a prismatic member of gross area AgA_g is:

σ=PAg\sigma = \frac{P}{A_g}
  1. When σ\sigma reaches the yield strength fyf_y, the entire unreduced length of the member yields plastically.
  2. In ductile mild steel (Fe 410), yielding is accompanied by a plastic strain plateau extending up to ϵ≈1.5−2.0%\epsilon \approx 1.5 - 2.0\%.
  3. Over a typical truss span of L=6.0 mL = 6.0\text{ m}, yield elongation is: ΔLyield=ϵy⋅L≈(250 MPa200 GPa)×6000 mm=7.5 mm\Delta L_{\text{yield}} = \epsilon_y \cdot L \approx \left(\frac{250\text{ MPa}}{200\text{ GPa}}\right) \times 6000\text{ mm} = 7.5\text{ mm} Post-yield plastic elongation easily exceeds 60−100 mm60 - 100\text{ mm}, which causes massive unserviceable sagging of connected floor beams, roof panels, or truss joints.
  4. Hence, gross section yielding represents a limit state of structural serviceability/collapse, safeguarded by γm0=1.10\gamma_{m0} = 1.10.

3.2 Mechanics of Critical Net Section Rupture (TdnT_{dn})

At fastener holes (bolt holes, rivet holes):

  1. Stress Concentration: Fastener holes introduce severe geometric discontinuities. Under elastic conditions, the theoretical stress concentration factor at the boundary of a circular hole in a thin plate is: Kt=3.0K_t = 3.0 The peak stress adjacent to the hole boundary is triple the average nominal net stress σnom=P/An\sigma_{\text{nom}} = P / A_n.
  2. Plastic Stress Redistribution: In ductile steel, material adjacent to the hole yields early. As load increases, plastic flow redistributes stress outward across the net ligament until the entire net cross-section reaches ultimate tensile strength fuf_u.
  3. Triaxial Stress Constraint & The 0.900.90 Factor:
    • Because localized plastic necking is laterally constrained by the surrounding unyielded plate material, the stress state becomes triaxial.
    • Extensive physical testing demonstrates that the actual rupture load across a perforated plate averages approximately 90%90\% of the theoretical solid ultimate capacity (An⋅fu)(A_n \cdot f_u).
    • To account for this constraint and ensure structural safety against sudden, brittle-like fracture, IS 800:2007 introduces the 0.900.90 reduction factor combined with γm1=1.25\gamma_{m1} = 1.25.
       [UN-DEFORMED HOLE]          [ELASTIC STRESS PEAK]         [PLASTIC REDISTRIBUTION & RUPTURE]
          +---------+                   |      ^                       |================| fu (Ultimate)
          |         |                 3*σnom   |                       |                |
          |    o    |                   |      |                       |                |
          |         |                 1*σnom   +---->                  +----------------+
          +---------+                   (Kt = 3.0 at hole edge)       Rupture Capacity: 0.90 * An * fu

4. Mathematical Formulations & Derivations

4.1 Net Cross-Sectional Area (AnA_n) for Chain Bolting

For straight transverse bolt lines arranged perpendicular to the tensile load vector:

An=[b−n⋅d0]⋅tA_n = [b - n \cdot d_0] \cdot t

where:

  • bb: Total width of plate.
  • nn: Number of bolt holes aligned along the critical transverse cross-section.
  • d0d_0: Diameter of bolt hole (d0=d+1 mmd_0 = d + 1\text{ mm} for d≤14d \le 14; d+2 mmd + 2\text{ mm} for 16≤d≤2416 \le d \le 24; d+3 mmd + 3\text{ mm} for d>24d > 24).
  • tt: Thickness of the plate.

4.2 Net Area for Staggered Bolting (Cochrane's Stagger Formulation)

When fastener holes are staggered (arranged in a zig-zag pattern), the potential rupture path can follow an inclined diagonal line between adjacent holes:

  1. Inclined Plane Mechanics: Consider an inclined failure plane inclined at angle θ\theta to the longitudinal tensile axis, spanning between two staggered holes separated by pitch pp (parallel to load) and gauge gg (perpendicular to load).
    • Length of inclined segment: Linc=p2+g2L_{\text{inc}} = \sqrt{p^2 + g^2}.
    • The inclined face is subjected to concurrent normal tensile stress σn\sigma_n and tangential shear stress τ\tau.
  2. Cochrane's Empirical Rule (1922): Cochrane demonstrated through experimental plastic limit testing that the effective resistance of an inclined perforated segment can be evaluated by projecting the path onto the transverse plane and adding an empirical correction factor: Δwstagger=p24g\Delta w_{\text{stagger}} = \frac{p^2}{4 g}
  3. Codified IS 800:2007 Formula (Clause 6.3.1): An=[b−n⋅d0+∑i=1kpsi24gi]⋅tA_n = \left[ b - n \cdot d_0 + \sum_{i=1}^k \frac{p_{si}^2}{4 g_i} \right] \cdot t where:
    • nn: Total number of bolt holes pierced by the chosen failure path.
    • kk: Total number of diagonal (staggered) path segments along the chosen path.
    • psip_{si}: Staggered pitch of segment ii.
    • gig_i: Gauge distance of segment ii.
           +---------------------------------------------+
           |       COCHRANE'S ZIG-ZAG FRACTURE PATH      |
           |                                             |
           |    [1]            [4]                       |
           |     o              o                        |
           |     | \                                     |
           |     |  \ <-- Inclined segment: + p^2 / 4g   |
           |     |   \                                   |
           |     |    o [2] (Staggered by p)             |
           |     |   /                                   |
           |     |  / <-- Inclined segment: + p^2 / 4g   |
           |     | /                                     |
           |     o              o                        |
           |    [3]            [5]                       |
           |                                             |
           |    Path 1-3: Straight across 2 holes        |
           |    Path 1-2-3: Zig-zag across 3 holes       |
           +---------------------------------------------+

5. IS 800:2007 Design Specifications & Detailing Rules

Table 1: Code Provisions for Design of Tension Members

Parameter Code Reference Design Specification / Formula
Gross Yielding Capacity IS 800 Cl. 6.2 Tdg=Ag⋅fyγm0T_{dg} = \frac{A_g \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} with γm0=1.10\gamma_{m0} = 1.10
Net Rupture of Plates IS 800 Cl. 6.3.1 Tdn=0.90An⋅fuγm1T_{dn} = \frac{0.90 A_n \cdot f_u}{\gamma_{m1}} with γm1=1.25\gamma_{m1} = 1.25
Net Area Formulation IS 800 Cl. 6.3.1 An=[b−nd0+∑ps24g]tA_n = \left[ b - n d_0 + \sum \frac{p_s^2}{4 g} \right] t
Threaded Rods / Bolts IS 800 Cl. 6.3.4 Tdn=0.90An⋅fuγm1T_{dn} = \frac{0.90 A_n \cdot f_u}{\gamma_{m1}} with An≈0.78AsA_n \approx 0.78 A_s
Minimum Pitch (pmin⁡p_{\min}) IS 800 Cl. 10.2.2 pmin⁡≥2.5×dp_{\min} \ge 2.5 \times d
Minimum Edge Distance (emin⁡e_{\min}) IS 800 Cl. 10.2.4.2 emin⁡≥1.5d0e_{\min} \ge 1.5 d_0 (machine cut) / 1.7d01.7 d_0 (hand flame cut)
Maximum Pitch (pmax⁡p_{\max}) IS 800 Cl. 10.2.3.2 pmax⁡≤min⁡(16t, 200 mm)p_{\max} \le \min(16 t, \, 200\text{ mm}) for tension members
Max Slenderness (λmax⁡\lambda_{\max}) IS 800 Table 3 180180 (reversal from wind/earthquake); 350350 (roof truss ties); 400400 (general ties)

6. Engineering Diagrams & Visual Explanations

Figure 1: Tension Member Taxonomy & Limit State Failure Modes

+----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
|                               TENSION MEMBER FAILURE MODES IN STEEL                                |
|                                                                                                    |
|    [MODE 1: GROSS SECTION YIELDING]       [MODE 2: NET SECTION RUPTURE]                            |
|    <====[==============================]====>  <====[==========x==========]====>                   |
|         Uniform plastic strain over span             Fracture across net bolt hole area            |
|         Tdg = Ag * fy / γm0                          Tdn = 0.90 * An * fu / γm1                    |
|                                                                                                    |
|    [MODE 3: BLOCK SHEAR TEAR-OUT]                                                                  |
|    <====[===============x---|=====]                                                                |
|                         |   |                                                                      |
|                         +---+ Tear-out along concurrent shear and tension planes                   |
|                         Tdb = min(Tdb1, Tdb2)                                                      |
+----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

The taxonomy of cross-sections and structural failure modes are illustrated below: Tension Member Cross Sections and Failure Modes

Key Architectural Insights from Figure 1:

  1. Three-Tier Hierarchy: The capacity of any structural tension member is governed by the minimum of gross yielding, net rupture, and block shear tear-out.
  2. Ductile vs Brittle Modes: Gross yielding is ductile and visible through span elongation, whereas net rupture is localized and sudden.
  3. The 0.900.90 Factor Calibration: Accounting for high triaxial stress concentrations (Kt≈3.0K_t \approx 3.0) and plastic necking constraint, IS 800 incorporates a 10%10\% reduction (0.900.90) into the net rupture equation.

Figure 2: Staggered Bolting Geometry & Critical Net Area Evaluation

+----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
|                               STAGGERED BOLTING FAILURE PATH ANALYSIS                              |
|                                                                                                    |
|            Path 1: Straight Cut                       Path 2: Zig-Zag Cut                          |
|         +-------------------------+                +-------------------------+                     |
|         |    o               o    |                |    o               o    |                     |
|         |    |                    |                |    | \                  |                     |
|         |    | <--- Line A-B      |                |    |  \ <--- Stagger p  |                     |
|         |    |                    |                |    |   o                |                     |
|         |    o               o    |                |    |  /                 |                     |
|         |                         |                |    o               o    |                     |
|         +-------------------------+                +-------------------------+                     |
|         An1 = (b - 2*d0) * t                       An2 = (b - 3*d0 + 2*p^2/4g) * t                 |
|                                                                                                    |
|         Governing Rupture Area: An = min( An1, An2, An3, ... )                                     |
+----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

The geometric layout and Cochrane stagger mechanics are illustrated below: Staggered Bolting Net Area and Gauge Geometry

Key Architectural Insights from Figure 2:

  1. Geometric Stagger Pitch (pp) vs Gauge (gg): Staggering fasteners increases the net fracture path length from the straight gauge distance gg to the diagonal hypotenuse p2+g2\sqrt{p^2 + g^2}.
  2. Cochrane's Term (p2/4gp^2/4g): Adding p2/4gp^2/4g compensates for the shear resistance mobilized along the inclined plane. A larger pitch pp significantly increases net area.
  3. Exhaustive Path Evaluation: Every plausible path across the width of the plate must be calculated; the path with the smallest net area AnA_n dictates the design rupture strength TdnT_{dn}.

7. Step-by-Step Design Procedures & Workflows

7.1 Workflow: Design of an Axially Loaded Tension Tie Plate

[START: Given Factored Tensile Load Tu, Member Length L, Steel Grade]
       |
       v
[Step 1: Estimate Minimum Required Gross Area (Ag,req)]
       --> From gross yielding: Ag,req = (Tu * gamma_m0) / fy
       --> From net rupture estimate: An,req = (Tu * gamma_m1) / (0.90 * fu)
       --> Estimate trial Ag: Ag,trial ≈ An,req / 0.75 to 0.85
       --> Choose trial Ag = max(Ag,req, Ag,trial)
       |
       v
[Step 2: Select Standard Plate / Flat Section]
       --> Select plate width b and thickness t such that b * t >= Ag,trial.
       |
       v
[Step 3: Lay Out Fastener Holes]
       --> Determine bolt size d, compute hole diameter d0.
       --> Choose chain or staggered pattern meeting pitch p >= 2.5d and edge e >= 1.5d0.
       |
       v
[Step 4: Compute Critical Net Area (An)]
       --> Evaluate all candidate straight and zig-zag failure paths.
       --> An = min(An1, An2, ...)
       |
       v
[Step 5: Verify Design Strengths per IS 800:2007]
       --> Tdg = (Ag * fy) / gamma_m0
       --> Tdn = (0.90 * An * fu) / gamma_m1
       --> Td = min(Tdg, Tdn)
       --> Is Td >= Tu?
           |-- NO  --> Increase plate thickness or width; repeat from Step 2.
           |-- YES --> Continue to Step 6.
       |
       v
[Step 6: Slenderness Ratio Check (IS 800 Table 3)]
       --> r_min = t / sqrt(12)  (for rectangular plate)
       --> lambda = L / r_min
       --> Is lambda <= lambda_max (e.g. 400)?
           |-- NO  --> Increase plate thickness t or add lateral ties.
           |-- YES --> SAFE. Proceed to block shear verification. [END]

8. Solved Numerical Examples (Pre-Calculated & Multi-Step)

Problem 1: Plate Tie Capacity — Chain vs Staggered Bolting

Statement: A flat tie plate of cross-section 300 mm×12 mm300\text{ mm} \times 12\text{ mm} is fabricated from Fe 410 steel (fy=250 N/mm2,fu=410 N/mm2,γm0=1.10,γm1=1.25f_y = 250\text{ N/mm}^2, f_u = 410\text{ N/mm}^2, \gamma_{m0} = 1.10, \gamma_{m1} = 1.25). The plate is connected to a gusset plate using M20 Class 4.6 bolts (d=20 mm,d0=22 mmd = 20\text{ mm}, d_0 = 22\text{ mm}). Determine the design tensile strength of the plate under:

  1. Case A: A chain bolting arrangement with 3 bolts in a single transverse line across the width.
  2. Case B: A staggered bolting arrangement where the middle bolt is staggered by pitch ps=50 mmp_s = 50\text{ mm}, with transverse gauge distance g=75 mmg = 75\text{ mm} between adjacent bolt lines. Compute the percentage increase in net rupture capacity achieved by staggering the bolts.
       Load Tu <=============================== [Plate 300 x 12 mm]
       Case A (Chain):                     Case B (Staggered):
       +-----------------------+           +-----------------------+
       |   o (Hole 1)          |           |   o (Hole 1)          |
       |                       |           |     \                 |
       |   o (Hole 2)          |           |      o (Hole 2, p=50) |
       |                       |           |     /                 |
       |   o (Hole 3)          |           |   o (Hole 3)          |
       +-----------------------+           +-----------------------+

Step 1: Gross Area and Gross Yielding Strength (TdgT_{dg})

  • Gross area: Ag=B⋅t=300 mm×12 mm=3600 mm2A_g = B \cdot t = 300\text{ mm} \times 12\text{ mm} = 3600\text{ mm}^2
  • Design gross yielding strength: Tdg=Ag⋅fyγm0=3600 mm2×250 N/mm21.10=9000001.10=818182 N=818.18 kNT_{dg} = \frac{A_g \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} = \frac{3600\text{ mm}^2 \times 250\text{ N/mm}^2}{1.10} = \frac{900000}{1.10} = 818182\text{ N} = 818.18\text{ kN}

Step 2: Case A — Chain Bolting (3 Bolts in Straight Line)

  • Net width across the transverse line of 3 holes: wn=B−n⋅d0=300−(3×22)=300−66=234 mmw_n = B - n \cdot d_0 = 300 - (3 \times 22) = 300 - 66 = 234\text{ mm}
  • Net area: An=wn⋅t=234 mm×12 mm=2808 mm2A_n = w_n \cdot t = 234\text{ mm} \times 12\text{ mm} = 2808\text{ mm}^2
  • Design rupture strength: Tdn=0.90⋅An⋅fuγm1=0.90×2808×4101.25=10361521.25=828922 N=828.92 kNT_{dn} = \frac{0.90 \cdot A_n \cdot f_u}{\gamma_{m1}} = \frac{0.90 \times 2808 \times 410}{1.25} = \frac{1036152}{1.25} = 828922\text{ N} = 828.92\text{ kN}
  • Governing design capacity for Case A: Td,Case A=min⁡(Tdg, Tdn)=min⁡(818.18 kN, 828.92 kN)=818.18 kNT_{d,\text{Case A}} = \min(T_{dg}, \, T_{dn}) = \min(818.18\text{ kN}, \, 828.92\text{ kN}) = 818.18\text{ kN} (Governed by gross section yielding!)

Step 3: Case B — Staggered Bolting (ps=50 mm,g=75 mmp_s = 50\text{ mm}, g = 75\text{ mm}) Examine all candidate failure paths:

  • Path 1 (Straight path through 2 outer holes 1 and 3): An1=[B−2⋅d0]⋅t=[300−(2×22)]×12=[300−44]×12=256×12=3072 mm2A_{n1} = [B - 2 \cdot d_0] \cdot t = [300 - (2 \times 22)] \times 12 = [300 - 44] \times 12 = 256 \times 12 = 3072\text{ mm}^2
  • Path 2 (Zig-zag path through holes 1-2-3): This path passes through 3 holes (n=3n = 3) and includes 2 staggered diagonal segments (Hole 1 to 2, and Hole 2 to 3): Δwstagger=2×ps24g=2×(50)24×75=2×2500300=2×8.3333=16.67 mm\Delta w_{\text{stagger}} = 2 \times \frac{p_s^2}{4 g} = 2 \times \frac{(50)^2}{4 \times 75} = 2 \times \frac{2500}{300} = 2 \times 8.3333 = 16.67\text{ mm} Net width along Path 2: wn2=B−3⋅d0+2×ps24g=300−66+16.67=250.67 mmw_{n2} = B - 3 \cdot d_0 + 2 \times \frac{p_s^2}{4 g} = 300 - 66 + 16.67 = 250.67\text{ mm} Net area along Path 2: An2=250.67 mm×12 mm=3008 mm2A_{n2} = 250.67\text{ mm} \times 12\text{ mm} = 3008\text{ mm}^2
  • Controlling Net Area for Case B: An=min⁡(An1, An2)=min⁡(3072 mm2, 3008 mm2)=3008 mm2A_n = \min(A_{n1}, \, A_{n2}) = \min(3072\text{ mm}^2, \, 3008\text{ mm}^2) = 3008\text{ mm}^2
  • Design rupture strength for Case B: Tdn=0.90⋅An⋅fuγm1=0.90×3008×4101.25=11099521.25=887962 N=887.96 kNT_{dn} = \frac{0.90 \cdot A_n \cdot f_u}{\gamma_{m1}} = \frac{0.90 \times 3008 \times 410}{1.25} = \frac{1109952}{1.25} = 887962\text{ N} = 887.96\text{ kN}
  • Governing design capacity for Case B: Td,Case B=min⁡(Tdg, Tdn)=min⁡(818.18 kN, 887.96 kN)=818.18 kNT_{d,\text{Case B}} = \min(T_{dg}, \, T_{dn}) = \min(818.18\text{ kN}, \, 887.96\text{ kN}) = 818.18\text{ kN}

Step 4: Comparison & Percentage Gain

  • Increase in net cross-sectional area: ΔAn=3008−28082808×100%=2002808×100%=7.12%\Delta A_n = \frac{3008 - 2808}{2808} \times 100\% = \frac{200}{2808} \times 100\% = 7.12\%
  • Increase in net rupture strength: ΔTdn=887.96−828.92828.92×100%=7.12%\Delta T_{dn} = \frac{887.96 - 828.92}{828.92} \times 100\% = 7.12\%

Conclusion: Staggering the middle bolt increases the net rupture capacity by 7.12%7.12\% without changing the plate dimensions.


Problem 2: Evaluation of Multiple Failure Paths in a Staggered Joint

Statement: A flat plate tension member of width B=240 mmB = 240\text{ mm} and thickness t=10 mmt = 10\text{ mm} (Fe 410 steel) is connected with M16 bolts (d0=18 mmd_0 = 18\text{ mm}). Four bolt holes are located on three transverse gauge lines:

  • Hole 1 and Hole 3 are located on the outer gauge lines at y=40 mmy = 40\text{ mm} and y=200 mmy = 200\text{ mm} from the edge.
  • Hole 2 is located on the middle gauge line at y=120 mmy = 120\text{ mm}, staggered longitudinally by ps=45 mmp_s = 45\text{ mm} relative to Holes 1 and 3. The transverse gauge spacing is g1=g2=80 mmg_1 = g_2 = 80\text{ mm}. Evaluate the net cross-sectional area along all candidate failure paths, identify the critical path, and determine the governing design tensile strength TdT_d.
       Edge 0 mm  ------------------------------------------
                     o Hole 1 (y = 40 mm)
       Gauge g = 80 mm
                                o Hole 2 (y = 120 mm, Stagger p = 45 mm)
       Gauge g = 80 mm
                     o Hole 3 (y = 200 mm)
       Edge 240 mm -----------------------------------------

Step 1: Stagger Correction Term For each diagonal segment between consecutive holes with ps=45 mmp_s = 45\text{ mm} and g=80 mmg = 80\text{ mm}:

ps24g=(45)24×80=2025320=6.328 mm\frac{p_s^2}{4 g} = \frac{(45)^2}{4 \times 80} = \frac{2025}{320} = 6.328\text{ mm}

Step 2: Candidate Failure Path Analysis

  1. Path 1 (Straight path through Holes 1 and 3): This path runs purely transverse, piercing 2 holes with zero staggers: An1=[B−2⋅d0]⋅t=[240−(2×18)]×10=[240−36]×10=204×10=2040 mm2A_{n1} = [B - 2 \cdot d_0] \cdot t = [240 - (2 \times 18)] \times 10 = [240 - 36] \times 10 = 204 \times 10 = 2040\text{ mm}^2
  2. Path 2 (Zig-zag path through Holes 1-2-3): This path pierces 3 holes (n=3n = 3) and traverses 2 diagonal segments (Hole 1 to 2, and Hole 2 to 3): An2=[B−3⋅d0+2×ps24g]⋅t=[240−54+(2×6.328)]×10=[186+12.656]×10=1986.56 mm2A_{n2} = \left[ B - 3 \cdot d_0 + 2 \times \frac{p_s^2}{4 g} \right] \cdot t = [240 - 54 + (2 \times 6.328)] \times 10 = [186 + 12.656] \times 10 = 1986.56\text{ mm}^2
  3. Path 3 (Zig-zag path through Holes 1 and 2 only, exiting to edge): This path pierces 2 holes (n=2n = 2) and has 1 diagonal segment (Hole 1 to 2): An3=[B−2⋅d0+1×ps24g]⋅t=[240−36+6.328]×10=210.328×10=2103.28 mm2A_{n3} = \left[ B - 2 \cdot d_0 + 1 \times \frac{p_s^2}{4 g} \right] \cdot t = [240 - 36 + 6.328] \times 10 = 210.328 \times 10 = 2103.28\text{ mm}^2

Step 3: Identification of Critical Path Comparing all three candidates:

An1=2040.00 mm2A_{n1} = 2040.00\text{ mm}^2 An2=1986.56 mm2(MINIMUM  ⟹  CRITICAL!)A_{n2} = 1986.56\text{ mm}^2 \quad (\mathbf{MINIMUM \implies CRITICAL!}) An3=2103.28 mm2A_{n3} = 2103.28\text{ mm}^2

The controlling net area is An=1986.56 mm2A_n = 1986.56\text{ mm}^2 along the zig-zag path 1-2-3.

Step 4: Design Tensile Capacities

  1. Net Section Rupture Strength (TdnT_{dn}): Tdn=0.90⋅An⋅fuγm1=0.90×1986.56 mm2×410 N/mm21.25=7330411.25=586432 N=586.43 kNT_{dn} = \frac{0.90 \cdot A_n \cdot f_u}{\gamma_{m1}} = \frac{0.90 \times 1986.56\text{ mm}^2 \times 410\text{ N/mm}^2}{1.25} = \frac{733041}{1.25} = 586432\text{ N} = 586.43\text{ kN}
  2. Gross Section Yielding Strength (TdgT_{dg}): Ag=240 mm×10 mm=2400 mm2A_g = 240\text{ mm} \times 10\text{ mm} = 2400\text{ mm}^2 Tdg=Ag⋅fyγm0=2400×2501.10=6000001.10=545455 N=545.45 kNT_{dg} = \frac{A_g \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} = \frac{2400 \times 250}{1.10} = \frac{600000}{1.10} = 545455\text{ N} = 545.45\text{ kN}
  3. Controlling Design Tensile Strength (TdT_d): Td=min⁡(Tdg, Tdn)=min⁡(545.45 kN, 586.43 kN)=545.45 kNT_d = \min(T_{dg}, \, T_{dn}) = \min(545.45\text{ kN}, \, 586.43\text{ kN}) = 545.45\text{ kN}

Conclusion: The connection is governed by gross section yielding (545.45 kN545.45\text{ kN}), with the critical net rupture path 1-2-3 providing 586.43 kN586.43\text{ kN}.


Problem 3: Complete Design of a Flat Tie Plate Tension Member

Statement: Design a flat plate tie member for a roof truss to carry a factored tensile force Tu=380.0 kNT_u = 380.0\text{ kN}. The length of the member between joint nodes is L=1.1 m=1100 mmL = 1.1\text{ m} = 1100\text{ mm}. The steel grade is Fe 410 (fy=250 N/mm2,fu=410 N/mm2f_y = 250\text{ N/mm}^2, f_u = 410\text{ N/mm}^2). The end connection uses M20 Class 4.6 bolts in two rows. Check gross section yielding, net section rupture, and the slenderness ratio per IS 800:2007 Table 3 (λmax⁡=400\lambda_{\max} = 400).

Step 1: Determine Required Gross Area (Ag,reqA_{g,\text{req}}) From the limit state of gross yielding:

Tdg≥Tu  ⟹  Ag⋅fyγm0≥TuT_{dg} \ge T_u \implies \frac{A_g \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} \ge T_u Ag,req=Tu⋅γm0fy=380.0×103 N×1.10250 N/mm2=418000250=1672.0 mm2A_{g,\text{req}} = \frac{T_u \cdot \gamma_{m0}}{f_y} = \frac{380.0 \times 10^3\text{ N} \times 1.10}{250\text{ N/mm}^2} = \frac{418000}{250} = 1672.0\text{ mm}^2

Step 2: Determine Required Net Area (An,reqA_{n,\text{req}}) From the limit state of net rupture:

Tdn≥Tu  ⟹  0.90⋅An⋅fuγm1≥TuT_{dn} \ge T_u \implies \frac{0.90 \cdot A_n \cdot f_u}{\gamma_{m1}} \ge T_u An,req=Tu⋅γm10.90⋅fu=380.0×103 N×1.250.90×410 N/mm2=475000369=1287.26 mm2A_{n,\text{req}} = \frac{T_u \cdot \gamma_{m1}}{0.90 \cdot f_u} = \frac{380.0 \times 10^3\text{ N} \times 1.25}{0.90 \times 410\text{ N/mm}^2} = \frac{475000}{369} = 1287.26\text{ mm}^2

Step 3: Select Trial Plate Section For 2 M20 bolt holes (d0=22 mmd_0 = 22\text{ mm}), the hole deduction is 2×22=44 mm2 \times 22 = 44\text{ mm}.

  • Estimating An≈0.75Ag  ⟹  Ag,trial≈1287.26/0.75=1716 mm2A_n \approx 0.75 A_g \implies A_{g,\text{trial}} \approx 1287.26 / 0.75 = 1716\text{ mm}^2.
  • Select a flat plate of size: 180 mm×10 mm\mathbf{180\text{ mm} \times 10\text{ mm}}
  • Actual gross area provided: Ag=180 mm×10 mm=1800 mm2>1672 mm2(OK)A_g = 180\text{ mm} \times 10\text{ mm} = 1800\text{ mm}^2 > 1672\text{ mm}^2 \quad (\text{OK})

Step 4: Check Capacities per IS 800:2007

  1. Gross Section Yielding Capacity: Tdg=Ag⋅fyγm0=1800×2501.10=4500001.10=409091 N=409.09 kN≥380.0 kN(SAFE, 92.9%)T_{dg} = \frac{A_g \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} = \frac{1800 \times 250}{1.10} = \frac{450000}{1.10} = 409091\text{ N} = 409.09\text{ kN} \ge 380.0\text{ kN} \quad (\text{SAFE, 92.9\%})
  2. Net Section Rupture Capacity: With 2 M20 bolts arranged in a chain across the 180 mm180\text{ mm} width: An=[b−2⋅d0]⋅t=[180−(2×22)]×10=[180−44]×10=136×10=1360 mm2A_n = [b - 2 \cdot d_0] \cdot t = [180 - (2 \times 22)] \times 10 = [180 - 44] \times 10 = 136 \times 10 = 1360\text{ mm}^2 Since An=1360 mm2≥An,req=1287.26 mm2A_n = 1360\text{ mm}^2 \ge A_{n,\text{req}} = 1287.26\text{ mm}^2: Tdn=0.90⋅An⋅fuγm1=0.90×1360×4101.25=5018401.25=401472 N=401.47 kN≥380.0 kN(SAFE, 94.7%)T_{dn} = \frac{0.90 \cdot A_n \cdot f_u}{\gamma_{m1}} = \frac{0.90 \times 1360 \times 410}{1.25} = \frac{501840}{1.25} = 401472\text{ N} = 401.47\text{ kN} \ge 380.0\text{ kN} \quad (\text{SAFE, 94.7\%})
  3. Design Tensile Strength: Td=min⁡(Tdg, Tdn)=min⁡(409.09, 401.47)=401.47 kN≥380.0 kN(SAFE)T_d = \min(T_{dg}, \, T_{dn}) = \min(409.09, \, 401.47) = 401.47\text{ kN} \ge 380.0\text{ kN} \quad (\text{SAFE})

Step 5: Check Maximum Slenderness Ratio (λ\lambda)

  • For a rectangular plate of width b=180 mmb = 180\text{ mm} and thickness t=10 mmt = 10\text{ mm}: rmin⁡=Imin⁡Ag=b⋅t3/12b⋅t=t12=1012=2.887 mmr_{\min} = \sqrt{\frac{I_{\min}}{A_g}} = \sqrt{\frac{b \cdot t^3 / 12}{b \cdot t}} = \frac{t}{\sqrt{12}} = \frac{10}{\sqrt{12}} = 2.887\text{ mm}
  • Member length L=1100 mmL = 1100\text{ mm}.
  • Slenderness ratio: λ=Lrmin⁡=1100 mm2.887 mm=381.0\lambda = \frac{L}{r_{\min}} = \frac{1100\text{ mm}}{2.887\text{ mm}} = 381.0
  • Per IS 800:2007 Table 3, for a general member normally acting as a tie: λmax⁡=400\lambda_{\max} = 400 Since λ=381.0≤400\lambda = 381.0 \le 400, the member is SAFE against excessive sagging and vibration.

Final Specification: Provide a 180 mm×10 mm180\text{ mm} \times 10\text{ mm} flat plate (Fe 410 steel) with 2 M20 Class 4.6 bolts in each connection line.


9. Common Pitfalls, Edge Cases & Failure Modes

  1. Confusing Nominal Bolt Diameter (dd) with Hole Diameter (d0d_0):
    • Pitfall: Subtracting n⋅dn \cdot d instead of n⋅d0n \cdot d_0 when calculating net area AnA_n.
    • Consequence: Underestimating the area deducted for holes by 2 mm2\text{ mm} per hole, leading to an unconservative overestimate of rupture strength.
  2. Omitting the Zig-Zag Rupture Path in Staggered Connections:
    • Pitfall: Evaluating only the straight transverse cut across holes and ignoring the staggered zig-zag path.
    • Reality: If the pitch psp_s is small or gauge gg is large, the zig-zag path through more holes almost always controls the design rupture strength.
  3. Neglecting the Maximum Slenderness Ratio (λ≤400\lambda \le 400):
    • Pitfall: Designing very thin tie plates (e.g., t=6 mmt = 6\text{ mm}) that satisfy tensile strength but have enormous slenderness ratios (λ>600\lambda > 600), resulting in excessive sag, wind flutter, and site rejection.
  4. Incorrect Stagger Term Multiplier:
    • Pitfall: Adding the stagger term once for a path that contains two diagonal segments.
    • Rule: The term ps24g\frac{p_s^2}{4 g} must be added for each individual inclined segment traversed along the failure path.

10. Exam-Specific Focus Points & Rapid Revision Notes

10.1 Quick Revision Formula Card

  • Gross Yielding: Tdg=Ag⋅fyγm0T_{dg} = \frac{A_g \cdot f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} (γm0=1.10\gamma_{m0} = 1.10).
  • Net Rupture of Plates: Tdn=0.90⋅An⋅fuγm1T_{dn} = \frac{0.90 \cdot A_n \cdot f_u}{\gamma_{m1}} (γm1=1.25\gamma_{m1} = 1.25).
  • Straight Net Area: An=[b−n⋅d0]⋅tA_n = [b - n \cdot d_0] \cdot t.
  • Staggered Net Area: An=[b−n⋅d0+∑ps24g]⋅tA_n = \left[ b - n \cdot d_0 + \sum \frac{p_s^2}{4 g} \right] \cdot t.
  • Threaded Rod Rupture: Tdn=0.90⋅An⋅fuγm1T_{dn} = \frac{0.90 \cdot A_n \cdot f_u}{\gamma_{m1}} with An≈0.78AsA_n \approx 0.78 A_s.
  • Governing Tensile Capacity: Td=min⁡(Tdg, Tdn, Tdb)T_d = \min(T_{dg}, \, T_{dn}, \, T_{db}).
  • Rectangular Plate Radius of Gyration: rmin⁡=t12≈0.2887⋅tr_{\min} = \frac{t}{\sqrt{12}} \approx 0.2887 \cdot t.
  • Max Slenderness Table 3:
    • Tie subjected to reversal of stress due to wind/earthquake: 180\mathbf{180}
    • Tie in a roof truss (normally in tension): 350\mathbf{350}
    • Tension member (other than pretensioned cables): 400\mathbf{400}

10.2 Examination Nuances

  • GATE CE: Questions typically present a plate with 3 or 4 staggered holes and ask: "What is the critical net area AnA_n?" Solve all paths and pick the minimum.
  • ESE Prelims: Frequently tests the partial safety factors (γm0=1.10,γm1=1.25\gamma_{m0} = 1.10, \gamma_{m1} = 1.25), the 0.900.90 factor in net rupture, and Table 3 slenderness limits.
  • SSC JE & State AE/JE: Direct numericals on Cochrane's formula (p2/4gp^2/4g) and the maximum permissible slenderness ratio (400400).

11. Practice Problems & Self-Assessment Question Bank

  1. Question 1 (Conceptual): Why is the partial safety factor for gross section yielding (γm0=1.10\gamma_{m0} = 1.10) lower than that for net section rupture (γm1=1.25\gamma_{m1} = 1.25)?
    • Answer: Gross section yielding is a ductile failure mode that develops visible elongation across the entire clear length prior to complete failure, providing warning. Net section rupture is a localized, sudden, and non-ductile fracture at fastener holes without warning, requiring a higher safety factor (1.251.25).
  2. Question 2 (Formula Application): A tie plate of 200 mm×8 mm200\text{ mm} \times 8\text{ mm} (Fe 410) has a single hole of diameter d0=18 mmd_0 = 18\text{ mm}. Compute its gross yielding capacity TdgT_{dg} and net rupture capacity TdnT_{dn}.
    • Answer: Ag=200×8=1600 mm2  ⟹  Tdg=(1600×250)/1.10=363.64 kNA_g = 200 \times 8 = 1600\text{ mm}^2 \implies T_{dg} = (1600 \times 250) / 1.10 = 363.64\text{ kN}. An=(200−18)×8=182×8=1456 mm2  ⟹  Tdn=(0.90×1456×410)/1.25=429.80 kNA_n = (200 - 18) \times 8 = 182 \times 8 = 1456\text{ mm}^2 \implies T_{dn} = (0.90 \times 1456 \times 410) / 1.25 = 429.80\text{ kN}. Governing capacity Td=363.64 kNT_d = 363.64\text{ kN}.
  3. Question 3 (GATE Numeric): In a staggered joint with g=60 mmg = 60\text{ mm}, what staggered pitch psp_s is required so that the net width along a zig-zag path across 2 holes equals the net width of a straight cut across 1 hole?
    • Answer: Condition: b−2d0+ps24g=b−1d0  ⟹  ps24g=d0b - 2 d_0 + \frac{p_s^2}{4 g} = b - 1 d_0 \implies \frac{p_s^2}{4 g} = d_0. For d0=22 mmd_0 = 22\text{ mm} and g=60 mmg = 60\text{ mm}: ps2=4×60×22=5280  ⟹  ps=5280=72.66 mmp_s^2 = 4 \times 60 \times 22 = 5280 \implies p_s = \sqrt{5280} = 72.66\text{ mm}.
  4. Question 4 (Slenderness Rule): What is the maximum unsupported length of an Fe 410 flat tie plate of thickness t=12 mmt = 12\text{ mm} if its maximum slenderness ratio is limited to 400400?
    • Answer: rmin⁡=12/12=3.464 mmr_{\min} = 12 / \sqrt{12} = 3.464\text{ mm}. Lmax⁡=λmax⁡⋅rmin⁡=400×3.464 mm=1385.6 mm≈1.386 mL_{\max} = \lambda_{\max} \cdot r_{\min} = 400 \times 3.464\text{ mm} = 1385.6\text{ mm} \approx 1.386\text{ m}.
  5. Question 5 (Rupture vs Yielding): Under what condition does net rupture govern over gross yielding in a plate with nn bolt holes?
    • Answer: Tdn<Tdg  ⟺  0.90Anfuγm1<Agfyγm0  ⟹  AnAg<fyγm10.90fuγm0=250×1.250.90×410×1.10=312.5405.9=0.770T_{dn} < T_{dg} \iff \frac{0.90 A_n f_u}{\gamma_{m1}} < \frac{A_g f_y}{\gamma_{m0}} \implies \frac{A_n}{A_g} < \frac{f_y \gamma_{m1}}{0.90 f_u \gamma_{m0}} = \frac{250 \times 1.25}{0.90 \times 410 \times 1.10} = \frac{312.5}{405.9} = 0.770. Thus, net rupture governs whenever the hole deductions reduce the net area below 77.0%77.0\% of the gross area.

12. Bibliographic References & Standard Codes

  1. Bureau of Indian Standards: IS 800:2007 — General Construction in Steel — Code of Practice (Third Revision), BIS, New Delhi.
  2. Subramanian, N.: Design of Steel Structures (Limit State Method), Oxford University Press, 2018.
  3. Duggal, S. K.: Limit State Design of Steel Structures, McGraw Hill Education (India), 2nd Edition, 2019.
  4. Bhavikatti, S. S.: Design of Steel Structures By Limit State Method as per IS: 800-2007, I.K. International Publishing House.
  5. INSDAG: Teaching Resource for Structural Steel Design: Tension Members, Institute for Steel Development & Growth, Kolkata.
  6. AISC 360-16: Specification for Structural Steel Buildings, American Institute of Steel Construction, Chicago.