SA-03-04 Chapter 03 · Classical Indeterminate Structures

Moment Distribution Method (Hardy Cross Method)

Prerequisites
Static Indeterminacy of Beams, Trusses & Rigid Frames (2D & 3D) SA-01-01 , Kinematic Indeterminacy & Degrees of Freedom SA-01-02 , Propped Cantilevers & Fixed Beams: Classical Indeterminate Formulations SA-03-01 , Clapeyron's Three-Moment Equation for Continuous Beams SA-03-02 , Slope-Deflection Method for Beams and Rigid Frames SA-03-03
Keywords
moment distribution method · hardy cross · rotational stiffness · distribution factor · carry over factor · sway analysis · iterative relaxation
In this chapter (4 topics)
On this page

1. Introduction & Historical Significance

The Moment Distribution Method, developed by Professor Hardy Cross and published in the May 1930 proceedings of the American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), is universally regarded as one of the greatest milestones in structural engineering history.

Before the advent of digital computers, analyzing continuous indeterminate frames using the Slope-Deflection Method or classical Force Methods required solving massive systems of simultaneous algebraic equations. In complex multi-story building frames, solving dozens or hundreds of coupled equations by hand was practically impossible.

Hardy Cross conceived an elegant, physically intuitive successive relaxation method:

  • Instead of solving simultaneous equations, joints are artificially "locked" against rotation.
  • Joints are then unlocked (released) one by one in an iterative cycle: unbalanced joint moments are distributed among meeting members in proportion to their rotational stiffnesses, and half of the distributed moment is "carried over" to the opposite ends.
  • As the unbalanced increments diminish exponentially, the process converges rapidly to the exact theoretical solution.
Mathematical Classification:
┌────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ The Moment Distribution Method is a displacement method that performs │
│ successive Gauss-Seidel relaxation on the underlying Slope-Deflection  │
│ equilibrium equations without ever forming an explicit matrix!         │
└────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

2. Mathematical Foundation & Fundamental Definitions

The entire method rests on four fundamental concepts: Fixed-End Moments, Rotational Stiffness, Distribution Factor, and Carry-Over Factor.

2.1 Sign Convention

In accordance with classical displacement method standards:

  • Clockwise member end moments acting on the joint or member end are taken as POSITIVE (+).
  • Anticlockwise member end moments are taken as NEGATIVE (-).

2.2 Member Rotational Stiffness (KK)

Rotational Stiffness (KK) is defined as the bending moment required to produce a unit rotation (θ=1.0 radian\theta = 1.0\text{ radian}) at the near end of a member while maintaining the boundary condition at the far end:

Near End A (Rotated by θ = 1)                 Far End B
       (↻) M = K ────────────────────────────── [Support Condition]

Case 1: Far End Clamped / Fixed

When the far end BB is rigid and locked against rotation (θB=0\theta_B = 0):

K=4EIL\boxed{ K = \frac{4EI}{L} }

where EE is Young's modulus, II is the second moment of area, and LL is the member length.

Case 2: Far End Hinged / Pinned / Roller

When the far end BB is free to rotate without moment restraint (MB=0M_B = 0):

K=3EIL=34(4EIL)\boxed{ K = \frac{3EI}{L} = \frac{3}{4} \left(\frac{4EI}{L}\right) }

The rotational stiffness is reduced by exactly 25%25\% because the far end hinge offers no rotational restraint.

Case 3: Far End Guided Roller (Shear-Free, Slope-Restrained)

When the far end BB cannot rotate but can translate transversely:

K=EIL\boxed{ K = \frac{EI}{L} }

Case 4: Cantilever Overhang

An overhanging span has a completely free end. It offers zero rotational restraint to the joint:

K=0\boxed{ K = 0 }

2.3 Relative Stiffness (kk)

When all members of a structure share the same modulus of elasticity (E=constantE = \text{constant}):

  • Far end fixed: k=ILk = \frac{I}{L}
  • Far end hinged: k=34(IL)k = \frac{3}{4} \left(\frac{I}{L}\right)
  • Overhang: k=0k = 0

2.4 Distribution Factor (DFDF)

When a rigid monolithic joint connecting mm members is subjected to an unbalanced moment MunbalM_{\text{unbal}}, all meeting member ends rotate through the exact same joint rotation angle θ\theta.

Because the moment developed in each member is Mi=KiθM_i = K_i \theta, the total balancing moment is:

Mbal=∑i=1mMi=(∑i=1mKi)θM_{\text{bal}} = \sum_{i=1}^m M_i = \left(\sum_{i=1}^m K_i\right) \theta

Dividing member moment by total joint moment yields the Distribution Factor (DFDF):

DFi=Ki∑Kj\boxed{ DF_i = \frac{K_i}{\sum K_j} }

Axiom of Joint Distribution:

At every joint in a structure, the sum of distribution factors of all framing members must equal unity:

∑i=1mDFi=1.00\boxed{ \sum_{i=1}^m DF_i = 1.00 }

2.5 Carry-Over Factor (COFCOF)

The Carry-Over Factor (COFCOF) is the ratio of the bending moment induced at the far end to the balancing moment applied at the near end:

COF=Moment induced at Far EndMoment applied at Near EndCOF = \frac{\text{Moment induced at Far End}}{\text{Moment applied at Near End}}
  • Far End Fixed: COF=+12=+0.50\mathbf{COF = +\frac{1}{2} = +0.50} (The carried-over moment has the same algebraic sign / clockwise sense as the distributed moment).
  • Far End Hinged / Roller: COF=0\mathbf{COF = 0} (A simple hinge cannot sustain or carry over moment).

3. Engineering Diagrams & Visual Explanations

3.1 Stiffness Profiles & Iteration Cycle

The diagram below presents the member rotational stiffness states, the joint moment distribution mechanism, and the circular flow of the iterative Hardy Cross cycle.

Moment Distribution Stiffness and Cycle

3.2 Portal Frame Sway Analysis Framework

When portal frames are subjected to lateral loads or asymmetric conditions, side sway develops. The diagram below illustrates the classical Two-Stage Superposition method developed by Hardy Cross to solve frame sway.

Hardy Cross Sway Superposition

4. Special Structural Considerations in Moment Distribution

4.1 Treatment of Cantilever Overhangs

When a continuous beam features an overhanging span extending beyond an exterior support:

  1. The cantilever moment is statically determinate: Mcant=−P⋅aM_{\text{cant}} = -P \cdot a or −wa22-\frac{w a^2}{2}.
  2. This determinate moment is placed directly in the initial moment row at the support.
  3. Because the cantilever has zero rotational stiffness (K=0K = 0), its distribution factor is: DFcant=0DF_{\text{cant}} = 0
  4. Consequently, no balancing moment is ever distributed into the cantilever, and no moment is ever carried over from the cantilever.

4.2 Far End Hinged Shortcut (Modified Stiffness)

If an exterior support is a simple pin or roller (e.g., Support CC):

  • Standard Approach: Treat K=4EILK = \frac{4EI}{L}, carry over back and forth in every cycle, and observe the pinned end moment slowly oscillating to zero.
  • The Modified Shortcut (Recommended):
    1. In Cycle 1, release and balance the exterior hinged support: ΔMpin=−MF,pin\Delta M_{\text{pin}} = - M_{F,\text{pin}}.
    2. Carry over once to the interior adjacent support: +0.50×ΔMpin+0.50 \times \Delta M_{\text{pin}}.
    3. Lock the hinged support permanently.
    4. For all subsequent cycles, use the modified stiffness for that member: K=3EILandCOF=0K = \frac{3EI}{L} \quad \text{and} \quad COF = 0
    This completely eliminates the pinned end from future iteration, slashing computational steps by 50%50\%.

4.3 Support Sinking (Differential Settlement)

If an interior support settles downward by Δ\Delta:

  • It induces initial Settlement Fixed-End Moments before the joints are unlocked: MFAB=MFBA=−6EIΔL2(if chord rotates clockwise)M_{FAB} = M_{FBA} = - \frac{6EI\Delta}{L^2} \quad (\text{if chord rotates clockwise}) MFBC=MFCB=+6EIΔL2(if chord rotates anticlockwise)M_{FBC} = M_{FCB} = + \frac{6EI\Delta}{L^2} \quad (\text{if chord rotates anticlockwise})
  • These settlement FEMs are added to the span load FEMs in the initial row, and standard distribution proceeds normally.

5. Side Sway Analysis of Portal Frames (Two-Stage Superposition)

In rigid portal frames, joint moment distribution enforces joint rotational equilibrium (∑Mjoint=0\sum M_{\text{joint}} = 0), but cannot inherently satisfy global column horizontal shear equilibrium (∑H=0\sum H = 0). If lateral forces or asymmetries exist, the frame will experience lateral translation (sway Δ\Delta).

Hardy Cross solved this via a rigorous Two-Stage Superposition:

[Real Frame with Sway] = [Stage 1: Non-Sway Frame] + k × [Stage 2: Arbitrary Sway Frame]

Stage 1: Non-Sway Analysis (Artificial Restraint)

  1. Introduce an imaginary lateral roller support (restrainer) at the roof beam level to prevent sway (Δ=0\Delta = 0).
  2. Carry out standard moment distribution under the actual applied loads.
  3. From the resulting member end moments, calculate the horizontal column base shears: HA1=MAB1+MBA1+Mloadh1,HD1=MCD1+MDC1+Mloadh2H_{A1} = \frac{M_{AB1} + M_{BA1} + M_{\text{load}}}{h_1}, \qquad H_{D1} = \frac{M_{CD1} + M_{DC1} + M_{\text{load}}}{h_2}
  4. Calculate the artificial restraining force RR required to prevent sway: R=HA1+HD1+∑PlateralR = H_{A1} + H_{D1} + \sum P_{\text{lateral}}
  5. If R=0R = 0, the frame is symmetric and non-swaying; Stage 1 gives the final moments!
  6. If R≠0R \ne 0, an artificial force is holding the frame. To neutralize it, the frame must be subjected to an equal and opposite lateral swaying force: S=−RS = - R

Stage 2: Arbitrary Sway Analysis

  1. Remove all applied transverse span loads.
  2. Impose an arbitrary lateral sway displacement Δ0\Delta_0 to the right.
  3. Assume convenient arbitrary column sway fixed-end moments (typically MF=−100 kN⋅mM_F = -100\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} for uniform columns): MFAB0=MFBA0=−6EI1Δ0h12,MFCD0=MFDC0=−6EI2Δ0h22M_{FAB0} = M_{FBA0} = - \frac{6EI_1\Delta_0}{h_1^2}, \qquad M_{FCD0} = M_{FDC0} = - \frac{6EI_2\Delta_0}{h_2^2}
  4. Distribute these sway FEMs through standard Hardy Cross cycles to obtain Stage 2 moments (M2M_2).
  5. Calculate the resulting Stage 2 column shears and the lateral force R0R_0 that produces this arbitrary sway: R0=−(HA0+HD0)=−(MAB0+MBA0h1+MCD0+MDC0h2)R_0 = - \left( H_{A0} + H_{D0} \right) = - \left( \frac{M_{AB0} + M_{BA0}}{h_1} + \frac{M_{CD0} + M_{DC0}}{h_2} \right)

Stage 3: Superposition with Sway Correction Factor kk

To produce the exact required swaying force S=−RS = -R, the Stage 2 results must be scaled by:

k=SR0=−RR0\boxed{ k = \frac{S}{R_0} = - \frac{R}{R_0} }

The final member end moments throughout the frame are:

Mfinal=MStage 1+k×MStage 2\boxed{ M_{\text{final}} = M_{\text{Stage 1}} + k \times M_{\text{Stage 2}} }

6. Step-by-Step Analytical Algorithm

[Step 1: Compute Member Stiffnesses & Distribution Factors]
  └─ Evaluate K = 4EI/L (fixed far end) or K = 3EI/L (hinged far end). K = 0 (cantilever).
  └─ At each joint: DF_i = K_i / Σ K_j. Verify Σ DF = 1.00.

[Step 2: Calculate Fixed-End Moments (FEMs)]
  └─ Compute standard FEMs (Clockwise +, Anticlockwise -).
  └─ Include settlement FEMs (-6EIΔ/L²) if applicable.

[Step 3: Setup the Distribution Table]
  └─ Columns: One column per member end (e.g., AB, BA, BC, CB, CD, DC).
  └─ Header: Enter Joint names and corresponding Distribution Factors.

[Step 4: Execute Initial Releases (Hinged Ends & Overhangs)]
  └─ Enter known determinate cantilever moments directly (DF = 0).
  └─ Release pinned ends once: Bal = - FEM_pin. Carry over +0.50 × Bal to interior support.
  └─ Modify interior member stiffness to 3EI/L and set COF = 0 for future cycles.

[Step 5: Perform Successive Distribution Cycles]
  └─ Balance: Compute unbalanced moment at joint: M_unbal = Σ M. Apply Bal = - M_unbal × DF.
  └─ Carry Over: Transfer 0.50 × Bal to opposite fixed ends.
  └─ Repeat until carried-over increments are negligible (< 0.10 kNm).

[Step 6: Algebraic Column Summation]
  └─ Sum all moments from the FEM row down to the last balancing row.
  └─ Verify joint equilibrium: Σ M_joint = 0.

[Step 7: Statics & Diagram Construction]
  └─ Determine span reactions from free-body equilibrium: R = R_0 ± (M_left + M_right)/L.
  └─ Construct final SFD and superposed BMD.

7. Solved Numerical Examples

Example 1: Continuous Beam with Cantilever Overhang and Pinned Far End

Problem Statement:
Analyze the continuous beam shown below using the Moment Distribution Method:

  • Overhang OAOA: Length a=2.0 ma = 2.0\text{ m}, carrying a concentrated load of P0=20.0 kNP_0 = 20.0\text{ kN} at free tip OO.
  • Span ABAB: Length L1=6.0 mL_1 = 6.0\text{ m}, flexural rigidity (EI)1=2EI(EI)_1 = 2EI. Load: Uniformly distributed load w=30.0 kN/mw = 30.0\text{ kN/m}.
  • Span BCBC: Length L2=4.0 mL_2 = 4.0\text{ m}, flexural rigidity (EI)2=EI(EI)_2 = EI. Load: Central concentrated point load P=50.0 kNP = 50.0\text{ kN} at midspan.
  • Support AA is a roller with overhang. Support BB is a continuous roller. Support CC is a simple pin.

Determine all final member end moments and vertical support reactions.

       20 kN                  30 kN/m                         50 kN
         ↓            ┌───────────────────────┐                 ↓
  O ─────────── [▲] ──┴───────────────────────┴── [▲] ──────────┴────────── [▲]
     a = 2 m     A            L₁ = 6 m, 2EI        B         L₂ = 4 m, EI     C (Pin)

Solution:

Step 1: Overhang Determinate Moment
At support AA, the cantilever load produces an anticlockwise hogging moment on the beam:

MAO=−(20.0×2.0)=−40.0 kN⋅mM_{AO} = - (20.0 \times 2.0) = -40.0\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}

For equilibrium of joint AA, the moment in member ABAB must balance the overhang:

MAB=+40.0 kN⋅m(Clockwise)M_{AB} = +40.0\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} \quad \text{(Clockwise)}

Step 2: Member Rotational Stiffnesses & Distribution Factors at Joint BB

  • Looking from BB to AA: Support AA is a simple roller support with known overhang moment (free to rotate)   ⟹  \implies Far end hinged: KBA=3(2EI)6.0=1.00EIK_{BA} = \frac{3 (2EI)}{6.0} = 1.00 EI
  • Looking from BB to CC: Support CC is a simple pin   ⟹  \implies Far end hinged: KBC=3(1EI)4.0=0.75EIK_{BC} = \frac{3 (1EI)}{4.0} = 0.75 EI
  • Total joint stiffness: ∑KB=1.00EI+0.75EI=1.75EI\sum K_B = 1.00 EI + 0.75 EI = 1.75 EI.
  • Distribution Factors: DFBA=1.001.75=47≈0.5714DF_{BA} = \frac{1.00}{1.75} = \frac{4}{7} \approx \mathbf{0.5714} DFBC=0.751.75=37≈0.4286DF_{BC} = \frac{0.75}{1.75} = \frac{3}{7} \approx \mathbf{0.4286} ∑DF=0.5714+0.4286=1.0000\sum DF = 0.5714 + 0.4286 = 1.0000

Step 3: Fixed-End Moments (FEMs)

  • Span ABAB (w=30 kN/m,L=6 mw = 30\text{ kN/m}, L = 6\text{ m}): MFAB=−wL212=−30×3612=−90.00 kN⋅mM_{FAB} = - \frac{w L^2}{12} = - \frac{30 \times 36}{12} = -90.00\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} MFBA=+wL212=+90.00 kN⋅mM_{FBA} = + \frac{w L^2}{12} = +90.00\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}
  • Span BCBC (P=50 kN,L=4 mP = 50\text{ kN}, L = 4\text{ m}): MFBC=−PL8=−50×48=−25.00 kN⋅mM_{FBC} = - \frac{P L}{8} = - \frac{50 \times 4}{8} = -25.00\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} MFCB=+PL8=+25.00 kN⋅mM_{FCB} = + \frac{P L}{8} = +25.00\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}

Step 4: Initial Releases & Modified Moments

  • Joint AA Release:
    The moment at AA must be +40.0 kN⋅m+40.0\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}.
    Balancing increment at A=+40.0−(−90.0)=+50.0 kN⋅mA = +40.0 - (-90.0) = +50.0\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}.
    Carry-over to B=+0.50×(+50.0)=+25.00 kN⋅mB = +0.50 \times (+50.0) = +25.00\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}.
    Modified moment at BABA:

    MFBA′=+90.00+25.00=+115.00 kN⋅mM_{FBA}' = +90.00 + 25.00 = \mathbf{+115.00\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}
  • Joint CC Release (Pinned end MCB=0M_{CB} = 0):
    Balancing increment at C=−25.00 kN⋅mC = -25.00\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}.
    Carry-over to B=+0.50×(−25.00)=−12.50 kN⋅mB = +0.50 \times (-25.00) = -12.50\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}.
    Modified moment at BCBC:

    MFBC′=−25.00−12.50=−37.50 kN⋅mM_{FBC}' = -25.00 - 12.50 = \mathbf{-37.50\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}

Step 5: Moment Distribution at Joint BB (Single Exact Cycle)
Because both far ends AA and CC are now permanently released (hinged with K=3EI/LK = 3EI/L and COF=0COF = 0), there are no carry-overs back to BB. The distribution converges in one single step!

  • Unbalanced moment at BB: Munbal=MFBA′+MFBC′=+115.00−37.50=+77.50 kN⋅mM_{\text{unbal}} = M_{FBA}' + M_{FBC}' = +115.00 - 37.50 = +77.50\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}
  • Balancing moment = −77.50 kN⋅m-77.50\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}.
  • Distribution to BABA: ΔMBA=−77.50×47=−44.286 kN⋅m\Delta M_{BA} = -77.50 \times \frac{4}{7} = \mathbf{-44.286\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}
  • Distribution to BCBC: ΔMBC=−77.50×37=−33.214 kN⋅m\Delta M_{BC} = -77.50 \times \frac{3}{7} = \mathbf{-33.214\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}

Moment Distribution Table:

Joint O A B C
Member OA AB BA BC CB
DF - - 0.5714 0.4286 -
FEM -40.00 -90.00 +90.00 -25.00 +25.00
Release A & C - +50.00 - - -25.00
Carry-Over - - +25.00 -12.50 -
Modified Initial -40.00 +40.00 +115.00 -37.50 0.00
Balance B - - -44.29 -33.21 -
Final Moments -40.00 +40.00 +70.71 -70.71 0.00

Equilibrium Check at Joint B: MBA+MBC=+70.7143−70.7143=0.000 kN⋅mM_{BA} + M_{BC} = +70.7143 - 70.7143 = 0.000\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}.

Step 6: Support Reactions

  • Support AA Reaction:
    Taking moments about BB for the overhang and span ABAB: RA×6.0−(20.0×8.0)−(30.0×6.0×3.0)+MBA=0R_A \times 6.0 - (20.0 \times 8.0) - (30.0 \times 6.0 \times 3.0) + M_{BA} = 0 6.0RA=160.0+540.0−70.7143=629.2857  ⟹  RA=104.881 kN6.0 R_A = 160.0 + 540.0 - 70.7143 = 629.2857 \implies \mathbf{R_A = 104.881\text{ kN}}
  • Shear to right of BB in span ABAB: RBA=(20.0+30.0×6.0)−104.8810=95.119 kNR_{BA} = (20.0 + 30.0 \times 6.0) - 104.8810 = \mathbf{95.119\text{ kN}}
  • Span BCBC:
    Taking moments about BB: RC×4.0−(50.0×2.0)−MBC=0  ⟹  4.0RC=100.0−70.7143=29.2857R_C \times 4.0 - (50.0 \times 2.0) - M_{BC} = 0 \implies 4.0 R_C = 100.0 - 70.7143 = 29.2857 RC=7.321 kN\mathbf{R_C = 7.321\text{ kN}} RBC=50.0−7.3214=42.679 kNR_{BC} = 50.0 - 7.3214 = \mathbf{42.679\text{ kN}}
  • Total Reaction at Support BB: RB=RBA+RBC=95.1190+42.6786=137.798 kNR_B = R_{BA} + R_{BC} = 95.1190 + 42.6786 = \mathbf{137.798\text{ kN}}

Global Vertical Equilibrium Check:

∑Fy=RA+RB+RC=104.8810+137.7976+7.3214=250.000 kN\sum F_y = R_A + R_B + R_C = 104.8810 + 137.7976 + 7.3214 = 250.000\text{ kN} Total applied load=20.0+(30.0×6)+50.0=250.0 kN[EXACT MATCH]\text{Total applied load} = 20.0 + (30.0 \times 6) + 50.0 = 250.0\text{ kN} \quad \text{[EXACT MATCH]}

Example 2: Continuous Beam Subjected to Support Sinking

Problem Statement:
A continuous beam ABCABC consists of two equal spans AB=BC=6.0 mAB = BC = 6.0\text{ m}.

  • Flexural rigidity EI=40,000 kN⋅m2EI = 40,000\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}^2 is constant.
  • End AA is fixed, and end CC is pinned.
  • Intermediate support BB sinks downward by ΔB=15.0 mm=0.015 m\Delta_B = 15.0\text{ mm} = 0.015\text{ m}.
  • Neglect span loads to determine the pure settlement bending moments.

Solution:

Step 1: Settlement Fixed-End Moments (FEMs)

  • Span ABAB: Support BB sinks relative to AA   ⟹  \implies Clockwise chord rotation: MFAB=MFBA=−6EIΔBL2=−6×40,000×0.01536.0=−100.00 kN⋅mM_{FAB} = M_{FBA} = - \frac{6EI\Delta_B}{L^2} = - \frac{6 \times 40,000 \times 0.015}{36.0} = \mathbf{-100.00\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}
  • Span BCBC: Support BB sinks relative to CC   ⟹  \implies Anticlockwise chord rotation: MFBC=MFCB=+6EIΔBL2=+6×40,000×0.01536.0=+100.00 kN⋅mM_{FBC} = M_{FCB} = + \frac{6EI\Delta_B}{L^2} = + \frac{6 \times 40,000 \times 0.015}{36.0} = \mathbf{+100.00\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}

Step 2: Distribution Factors at Joint BB

  • Far end AA is fixed: KBA=4EI6.0=23EI=0.6667EIK_{BA} = \frac{4EI}{6.0} = \frac{2}{3} EI = 0.6667 EI.
  • Far end CC is pinned: KBC=3EI6.0=0.5000EIK_{BC} = \frac{3EI}{6.0} = 0.5000 EI.
  • Total stiffness: ∑KB=23+12=76EI≈1.1667EI\sum K_B = \frac{2}{3} + \frac{1}{2} = \frac{7}{6} EI \approx 1.1667 EI. DFBA=2/37/6=47≈0.5714DF_{BA} = \frac{2/3}{7/6} = \frac{4}{7} \approx \mathbf{0.5714} DFBC=1/27/6=37≈0.4286DF_{BC} = \frac{1/2}{7/6} = \frac{3}{7} \approx \mathbf{0.4286}

Step 3: Initial Release of Pinned Support CC

  • At support CC, MC=0M_C = 0. Balancing increment =−100.00 kN⋅m= -100.00\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}.
  • Carry-over to B=+0.50×(−100.00)=−50.00 kN⋅mB = +0.50 \times (-100.00) = -50.00\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}.
  • Modified initial moment at BCBC: MFBC′=+100.00−50.00=+50.00 kN⋅mM_{FBC}' = +100.00 - 50.00 = \mathbf{+50.00\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}

Step 4: Distribution at Joint BB

  • Unbalanced moment at B=MFBA+MFBC′=−100.00+50.00=−50.00 kN⋅mB = M_{FBA} + M_{FBC}' = -100.00 + 50.00 = -50.00\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}.
  • Balancing moment =+50.00 kN⋅m= +50.00\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}. ΔMBA=+50.00×47=+28.571 kN⋅m\Delta M_{BA} = +50.00 \times \frac{4}{7} = \mathbf{+28.571\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}} ΔMBC=+50.00×37=+21.429 kN⋅m\Delta M_{BC} = +50.00 \times \frac{3}{7} = \mathbf{+21.429\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}
  • Carry-over to fixed end AA: ΔMAB=+0.50×(+28.5714)=+14.286 kN⋅m\Delta M_{AB} = +0.50 \times (+28.5714) = \mathbf{+14.286\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}

Moment Distribution Table:

Joint A B C
Member AB BA BC CB
DF - 0.5714 0.4286 -
FEM (Sinking) -100.00 -100.00 +100.00 +100.00
Release C - - - -100.00
Carry-Over - - -50.00 -
Modified Initial -100.00 -100.00 +50.00 0.00
Balance B - +28.57 +21.43 -
Carry-Over to A +14.29 - - -
Final Moments -85.71 -71.43 +71.43 0.00
MAB=−85.714 kN⋅m,MBA=−71.429 kN⋅m,MBC=+71.429 kN⋅m,MCB=0.000\mathbf{M_{AB} = -85.714\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}, \quad \mathbf{M_{BA} = -71.429\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}, \quad \mathbf{M_{BC} = +71.429\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}, \quad \mathbf{M_{CB} = 0.000}

Example 3: Side Sway Analysis of Portal Frame via Two-Stage Superposition

Problem Statement:
Analyze the portal frame ABCDABCD shown below using the Hardy Cross Two-Stage Sway Superposition Method:

  • Columns ABAB and CDCD have height h=4.0 mh = 4.0\text{ m} and flexural rigidity EIEI. Bases AA and DD are fixed.
  • Beam BCBC has span L=5.0 mL = 5.0\text{ m} and flexural rigidity EIEI.
  • A horizontal lateral load of P=40.0 kNP = 40.0\text{ kN} acts at roof joint BB towards the right.
  • No transverse span loads are present.
       P = 40 kN
       ───► B ─────────────────────────── C
            │        L = 5 m, EI          │
            │                             │
     h = 4m │ EI                       EI │ h = 4m
            │                             │
           [▲]                           [▲]
         Fixed A                       Fixed D

Solution:

Step 1: Distribution Factors

  • Joint BB: KBA=4EI4.0=1.00EI,KBC=4EI5.0=0.80EIK_{BA} = \frac{4EI}{4.0} = 1.00 EI, \qquad K_{BC} = \frac{4EI}{5.0} = 0.80 EI ∑KB=1.80EI\sum K_B = 1.80 EI DFBA=1.001.80=59≈0.5556,DFBC=0.801.80=49≈0.4444DF_{BA} = \frac{1.00}{1.80} = \frac{5}{9} \approx \mathbf{0.5556}, \qquad DF_{BC} = \frac{0.80}{1.80} = \frac{4}{9} \approx \mathbf{0.4444}
  • By symmetry: DFCD=0.5556,DFCB=0.4444DF_{CD} = 0.5556, DF_{CB} = 0.4444.

Step 2: Stage 1 — Non-Sway Analysis
An artificial lateral support holds joint CC against sway (Δ=0\Delta = 0).
Because there are no span loads on AB,BC,CDAB, BC, CD, all Fixed-End Moments are zero:

MF=0  ⟹  All Stage 1 Moments are zero: MStage 1=0M_{F} = 0 \implies \text{All Stage 1 Moments are zero: } M_{\text{Stage 1}} = 0
  • Stage 1 Column base shears: HA1=0,HD1=0H_{A1} = 0, H_{D1} = 0.
  • Artificial Restraining Force required to hold the 40 kN40\text{ kN} load: R=P=40.00 kN (acting to the left)R = P = \mathbf{40.00\text{ kN}}\text{ (acting to the left)}
  • The force driving side sway is S=−R=+40.00 kN (to the right)S = - R = \mathbf{+40.00\text{ kN}}\text{ (to the right)}.

Step 3: Stage 2 — Arbitrary Sway Analysis
Apply an arbitrary sway displacement Δ0\Delta_0 causing arbitrary column fixed-end moments:

MFAB0=MFBA0=MFCD0=MFDC0=−100.00 kN⋅mM_{FAB0} = M_{FBA0} = M_{FCD0} = M_{FDC0} = \mathbf{-100.00\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}

Beam BCBC experiences no sway FEMs: MFBC0=MFCB0=0M_{FBC0} = M_{FCB0} = 0.

Stage 2 Moment Distribution Table:

Joint A B C D
Member AB BA BC CB CD DC
DF - 0.5556 0.4444 0.4444 0.5556 -
Sway FEM -100.00 -100.00 0.00 0.00 -100.00 -100.00
Balance 1 - +55.56 +44.44 +44.44 +55.56 -
Carry-Over 1 +27.78 - +22.22 +22.22 - +27.78
Balance 2 - -12.35 -9.88 -9.88 -12.35 -
Carry-Over 2 -6.17 - -4.94 -4.94 - -6.17
Balance 3 - +2.74 +2.20 +2.20 +2.74 -
Carry-Over 3 +1.37 - +1.10 +1.10 - +1.37
Balance 4 - -0.61 -0.49 -0.49 -0.61 -
Stage 2 Sum -85.29 -70.59 +70.59 +70.59 -70.59 -85.29

Equilibrium Check: Joint BB: −70.59+70.59=0-70.59 + 70.59 = 0. Joint CC: +70.59−70.59=0+70.59 - 70.59 = 0.

Step 4: Arbitrary Sway Resistance R0R_0
Column base shears produced by the Stage 2 moments:

HA0=MAB0+MBA0h=−85.2941−70.58824.0=−155.88234.0=−38.9706 kNH_{A0} = \frac{M_{AB0} + M_{BA0}}{h} = \frac{-85.2941 - 70.5882}{4.0} = \frac{-155.8823}{4.0} = \mathbf{-38.9706\text{ kN}} HD0=MCD0+MDC0h=−70.5882−85.29414.0=−38.9706 kNH_{D0} = \frac{M_{CD0} + M_{DC0}}{h} = \frac{-70.5882 - 85.2941}{4.0} = \mathbf{-38.9706\text{ kN}}

The total lateral shear force producing this arbitrary sway is:

R0=−(HA0+HD0)=−(−38.9706−38.9706)=+77.9412 kNR_0 = - (H_{A0} + H_{D0}) = - (-38.9706 - 38.9706) = \mathbf{+77.9412\text{ kN}}

Step 5: Sway Correction Factor kk and Final Moments

k=SR0=+40.0077.9412≈0.5132k = \frac{S}{R_0} = \frac{+40.00}{77.9412} \approx \mathbf{0.5132}

Final moments: Mfinal=MStage 1+k×MStage 2=0+0.5132×MStage 2M_{\text{final}} = M_{\text{Stage 1}} + k \times M_{\text{Stage 2}} = 0 + 0.5132 \times M_{\text{Stage 2}}:

MAB=0.5132×(−85.2941)=−43.774 kN⋅mM_{AB} = 0.5132 \times (-85.2941) = \mathbf{-43.774\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}} MBA=0.5132×(−70.5882)=−36.226 kN⋅mM_{BA} = 0.5132 \times (-70.5882) = \mathbf{-36.226\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}} MBC=0.5132×(+70.5882)=+36.226 kN⋅mM_{BC} = 0.5132 \times (+70.5882) = \mathbf{+36.226\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}} MCB=0.5132×(+70.5882)=+36.226 kN⋅mM_{CB} = 0.5132 \times (+70.5882) = \mathbf{+36.226\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}} MCD=0.5132×(−70.5882)=−36.226 kN⋅mM_{CD} = 0.5132 \times (-70.5882) = \mathbf{-36.226\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}} MDC=0.5132×(−85.2941)=−43.774 kN⋅mM_{DC} = 0.5132 \times (-85.2941) = \mathbf{-43.774\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}

Step 6: Final Global Shear Equilibrium Verification

HA=MAB+MBA4.0=−43.7736−36.22644.0=−80.004.0=−20.00 kNH_A = \frac{M_{AB} + M_{BA}}{4.0} = \frac{-43.7736 - 36.2264}{4.0} = \frac{-80.00}{4.0} = \mathbf{-20.00\text{ kN}} HD=MCD+MDC4.0=−36.2264−43.77364.0=−80.004.0=−20.00 kNH_D = \frac{M_{CD} + M_{DC}}{4.0} = \frac{-36.2264 - 43.7736}{4.0} = \frac{-80.00}{4.0} = \mathbf{-20.00\text{ kN}} ∑H=HA+HD+P=−20.00−20.00+40.00=0.000 kN[EXACT EQUILIBRIUM]\sum H = H_A + H_D + P = -20.00 - 20.00 + 40.00 = \mathbf{0.000\text{ kN}} \quad \text{[EXACT EQUILIBRIUM]}

8. Practical Applications & Design Implications

  1. Pre-Computer Dominance in Structural Offices: From 1930 to 1980, almost every high-rise frame, continuous bridge, and industrial plant in India and worldwide was engineered using Hardy Cross tables.
  2. Rapid Field Checking of Software Output: Structural engineers frequently use a 2-cycle Hardy Cross calculation to verify software output (ETABS/STAAD) at critical transfer girder joints.
  3. Physical Insight into Structural Stiffness: Unlike finite element black-boxes, moment distribution visually demonstrates how stiffness attracts load: doubling a column's moment of inertia draws double the bending moment from the connecting floor girders.

9. Comparative Matrix: Classical Indeterminate Methods

Feature Moment Distribution Method Slope-Deflection Method Three-Moment Theorem Direct Stiffness Matrix
Method Family Displacement (Iterative) Displacement (Closed-Form) Force (Compatibility) Displacement (Matrix)
Solving Engine Successive numerical relaxation Simultaneous linear equations Tridiagonal recurrence Inversion / Cholesky decomposition
Hand Calculation Suitability Exceptional (No equations) Tedious for Dk>2D_k > 2 Fast for beams only Unfeasible for hand calculation
Sway Treatment Two-stage superposition Incorporated in shear equation Inapplicable to frames Direct degrees of freedom
Convergence Monotonic, geometric decay Exact in one step Exact in one step Exact in one step

10. Common Misconceptions & Exam Traps

[!WARNING]

1. Carrying Over Moments to a Pinned Support

Trap: Applying the +0.50+0.50 carry-over factor to a far end that is a simple hinge.
Reality: A simple pin or roller support cannot resist bending moment (M=0M = 0). Therefore, the Carry-Over Factor to a hinge is ALWAYS ZERO (COF=0COF = 0)!

[!WARNING]

2. The Modified Stiffness Trap

Trap: Using K=3EILK = \frac{3EI}{L} for a hinged span from the very beginning without accounting for the pinned end's initial FEM.
Reality: If you use K=3EILK = \frac{3EI}{L}, you MUST first release the pinned end in Cycle 1, carry over +0.50×ΔM+0.50 \times \Delta M to the interior joint, and only THEN use K=3EILK = \frac{3EI}{L} for subsequent balancing!

[!WARNING]

3. Forgetting the Balancing Moment Sign

Trap: Distributing Munbal×DFM_{\text{unbal}} \times DF.
Reality: To restore equilibrium, the balancing moment must oppose the unbalanced moment. The distributed moment is always:

ΔM=−Munbalanced×DF\Delta M = - M_{\text{unbalanced}} \times DF

11. Practice Problems

Problem 1 (GATE CE Standard)

A three-span continuous beam ABCDABCD of uniform flexural rigidity EIEI has equal spans L=6 mL = 6\text{ m}. Supports AA and DD are fixed; BB and CC are continuous rollers. If an external clockwise couple of M0=120 kN⋅mM_0 = 120\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} is applied directly at joint BB, determine the final moment carried over to fixed support AA using the Moment Distribution Method.

Answer:
KBA=4EI/6,KBC=4EI/6  ⟹  DFBA=0.50,DFBC=0.50K_{BA} = 4EI/6, K_{BC} = 4EI/6 \implies DF_{BA} = 0.50, DF_{BC} = 0.50.
After iterative distribution through joints BB and CC: MBA=+51.43 kN⋅mM_{BA} = +51.43\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}.
Moment carried over to AA: MAB=+25.71 kN⋅mM_{AB} = +25.71\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}.


Problem 2 (UPSC ESE Conventional Standard)

A single-bay portal frame ABCDABCD with fixed bases at AA and DD has columns AB=CD=4 mAB = CD = 4\text{ m} (Ic=II_c = I) and roof beam BC=6 mBC = 6\text{ m} (Ib=2II_b = 2I). A vertical point load of 60 kN60\text{ kN} acts at midspan of BCBC.
Using the Moment Distribution Method, state whether the frame experiences side sway, compute the non-sway distribution, and find all final member end moments.

Answer:
Because the frame geometry, member properties, and loading are completely symmetric about the centerline, the artificial restraining force R=0R = 0. The frame does NOT experience side sway!
MAB=−11.25 kN⋅mM_{AB} = -11.25\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}, MBA=−22.50 kN⋅mM_{BA} = -22.50\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}, MBC=+22.50 kN⋅mM_{BC} = +22.50\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}, MCB=−22.50 kN⋅mM_{CB} = -22.50\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}, MCD=+22.50 kN⋅mM_{CD} = +22.50\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}, MDC=+11.25 kN⋅mM_{DC} = +11.25\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}.


12. Quick Revision Formula Summary

Rotational Stiffness K:K=4EIL(Far End Fixed)K=3EIL(Far End Hinged, 25% reduction)K=0(Cantilever Overhang)Distribution Factor DF:DFi=Ki∑Kj,∑DF=1.00Carry-Over Factor COF:COF=+0.50(Far End Fixed)COF=0(Far End Hinged)Balancing Moment:ΔMi=−(∑Munbalanced)×DFiHardy Cross Sway Scale:k=−RR0  ⟹  Mfinal=MStage 1+k×MStage 2\begin{aligned} \text{Rotational Stiffness } K: \quad & K = \frac{4EI}{L} \quad (\text{Far End Fixed}) \\[6pt] & K = \frac{3EI}{L} \quad (\text{Far End Hinged, } 25\% \text{ reduction}) \\[6pt] & K = 0 \quad (\text{Cantilever Overhang}) \\[10pt] \text{Distribution Factor } DF: \quad & DF_i = \frac{K_i}{\sum K_j}, \quad \sum DF = 1.00 \\[10pt] \text{Carry-Over Factor } COF: \quad & COF = +0.50 \quad (\text{Far End Fixed}) \\[6pt] & COF = 0 \quad (\text{Far End Hinged}) \\[10pt] \text{Balancing Moment:} \quad & \Delta M_i = - \left( \sum M_{\text{unbalanced}} \right) \times DF_i \\[10pt] \text{Hardy Cross Sway Scale:} \quad & k = - \frac{R}{R_0} \implies M_{\text{final}} = M_{\text{Stage 1}} + k \times M_{\text{Stage 2}} \end{aligned}