RCC-03-01 Chapter 03 · Design for Shear, Torsion, and Bond

Design for Shear in Reinforced Concrete Beams

Subject
Reinforced Concrete Structures (notes/reinforced_cement_concrete)
Chapter
Chapter 03: Design for Shear, Torsion, and Bond
Applicable Codes
IS 456:2000 (Clauses 22.6.2, 26.5.1.3, 26.5.1.5, 26.5.1.6, 40.1, 40.2, 40.3, 40.4, 40.5, Table 19, Table 20), IS 13920:2016, SP:16
Exam Target
GATE CE, UPSC ESE, SSC JE, State AE/JE, RRB JE
In this chapter (3 topics)
On this page
  1. 1. Introduction & Executive Summary
  2. 2. Mechanics of Shear Transfer in RC Beams
  3. 2.1 State of Stress in an Uncracked Homogeneous Elastic Beam
  4. 2.2 Crack Patterns in Reinforced Concrete Beams
  5. 2.3 Internal Shear Transfer Mechanisms in a Cracked Beam
  6. 3. Influence of Shear Span-to-Depth Ratio (av/d)
  7. 4. IS 456:2000 Design Philosophy and Provisions
  8. 4.1 Nominal Shear Stress (τv)
  9. 4.2 Design Shear Strength of Concrete without Web Steel (τc)
  10. 4.3 Maximum Permissible Shear Stress (τc,max) (Table 20)
  11. 5. Critical Section for Shear (IS 456 Clause 22.6.2)
  12. 6. Mathematical Derivations of Shear Reinforcement Capacity
  13. 6.1 Derivation for Vertical Stirrups (Vus)
  14. 6.2 Derivation for Inclined Stirrups (Angle α)
  15. 6.3 Derivation for Bent-Up Bars (Single or Group)
  16. 7. High-Precision Engineering Diagrams
  17. 7.1 Shear Failure Cracks, Internal Mechanisms & Critical Section
  18. 7.2 Shear Reinforcement Types, Truss Analogy & IS 456 Detailing Rules
  19. 8. Summary of IS 456 Design Cases
  20. Minimum Shear Reinforcement (Clause 26.5.1.6)
  21. Maximum Permissible Spacing (Clause 26.5.1.5)
  22. Side Face Reinforcement (Clause 26.5.1.3 & 26.5.1.7)
  23. 9. Pre-Calculated Solved Numerical Examples
  24. Problem 1: Standard Prismatic RC Beam Shear Design (GATE / ESE)
  25. Problem 2: Beam with Bent-Up Bars and 50% IS 456 Limitation (UPSC ESE / State AE)
  26. Problem 3: Haunched Beam of Varying Depth (GATE CE)
  27. 10. Comparative Analysis: Shear Failure Modes
  28. 11. Practical Detailing & Seismic Considerations (IS 13920:2016)
  29. 12. Common Misconceptions & Exam Traps
  30. 13. Practice Questions for Self-Assessment

1. Introduction & Executive Summary

In reinforced concrete (RC) flexural members, shear forces are always accompanied by bending moments. While flexural failures of under-reinforced sections are typically ductile—preceded by large deflections and wide, visible flexural cracks—shear failure is predominantly brittle, sudden, and catastrophic, often occurring without sufficient warning.

Consequently, the primary objective of structural concrete shear design under the Limit State Method (LSM) is to ensure that the shear capacity of any cross-section equals or exceeds its flexural capacity at all points, enforcing the fundamental engineering doctrine of capacity design: ductile flexural yielding must always precede brittle shear failure.

In IS 456:2000, the nominal shear stress τv\tau_v is calculated and evaluated against two material thresholds:

  1. τc\tau_c: The design shear strength of concrete without shear reinforcement (dependent on concrete grade fckf_{ck} and longitudinal tensile steel percentage ptp_t).
  2. τc,max⁡\tau_{c,\max}: The maximum permissible shear stress beyond which brittle diagonal crushing of concrete compressive struts occurs, mandating section redesign.

2. Mechanics of Shear Transfer in RC Beams

2.1 State of Stress in an Uncracked Homogeneous Elastic Beam

In an uncracked beam, an infinitesimal stress element situated at depth yy from the neutral axis experiences a normal bending stress σx=MyI\sigma_x = \frac{M y}{I} and a horizontal/vertical shear stress τ=VQIb\tau = \frac{V Q}{I b}. The principal stresses are determined from Mohr's circle of stress:

σ1,2=σx2±(σx2)2+τ2\sigma_{1, 2} = \frac{\sigma_x}{2} \pm \sqrt{\left(\frac{\sigma_x}{2}\right)^2 + \tau^2}

The inclination θ\theta of the principal planes with respect to the longitudinal beam axis is given by:

tan⁡2θ=2τσx\tan 2\theta = \frac{2\tau}{\sigma_x}
  • At the Neutral Axis (y=0y = 0): Flexural stress σx=0\sigma_x = 0. Hence: σ1,2=±τ,tan⁡2θ=∞  ⟹  2θ=90∘  ⟹  θ=45∘\sigma_{1, 2} = \pm \tau, \quad \tan 2\theta = \infty \implies 2\theta = 90^\circ \implies \theta = 45^\circ The principal tensile stress σ1\sigma_1 equals τ\tau and acts at an inclination of 45∘45^\circ to the longitudinal axis. This inclined tensile stress is termed diagonal tension.
  • At the Extreme Tension Fiber: Shear stress τ=0\tau = 0, and normal bending stress σx\sigma_x reaches its maximum tensile value. Thus θ=0∘\theta = 0^\circ, and cracks form purely vertically.
  • Between the Neutral Axis and Extreme Fiber: Both σx\sigma_x and τ\tau coexist. The trajectory of principal tensile stress forms a curved path that curves upward from the bottom fiber at 90∘90^\circ and flattens toward 45∘45^\circ as it crosses the neutral axis.

2.2 Crack Patterns in Reinforced Concrete Beams

Because concrete possesses high compressive strength but very low tensile strength (approximately fcr=0.7fckf_{cr} = 0.7\sqrt{f_{ck}}), cracks initiate perpendicularly to the trajectories of principal tensile stresses:

  1. Flexural Cracks (Vertical Cracks): Located near midspan where bending moment is high and shear force is low (M≫VM \gg V). They initiate at the bottom tension face and propagate vertically toward the neutral axis.
  2. Flexure-Shear Cracks: The most common crack pattern in prismatic beams. They initiate as vertical flexural cracks near the quarter-span points where both MM and VV are significant. As they propagate upward into regions of increasing shear stress, they curve obliquely at roughly 45∘45^\circ toward the compressive load point.
  3. Web-Shear Cracks: Observed primarily in thin-webbed sections (such as I-girders or flanged beams near supports) and prestressed concrete members where shear stress τ\tau is extremely high and bending stress σx\sigma_x is minimal. These cracks initiate directly at the neutral axis at approximately 45∘45^\circ and propagate diagonally before any flexural cracking occurs.

2.3 Internal Shear Transfer Mechanisms in a Cracked Beam

After diagonal tension cracking occurs, a beam without shear reinforcement cannot function as a homogeneous elastic element. The total internal shear resistance VcV_c is transferred across the crack by four distinct physical mechanisms:

Vc=Vcz+Vai+VdV_c = V_{cz} + V_{ai} + V_d
  1. Shear Resistance of Uncracked Concrete Compression Zone (VczV_{cz}):
    The intact concrete head above the tip of the diagonal crack remains in a state of combined compression and shear. It carries approximately 20%20\% to 40%40\% of the total shear force.
  2. Aggregate Interlock across Crack Surfaces (VaiV_{ai}):
    As the crack faces open and slide past one another, rough protruding coarse aggregates interlock, generating substantial tangential friction and interlock forces. This represents the largest single contributor, transferring 33%33\% to 50%50\% of total concrete shear resistance in normal aggregate concretes. (Note: in lightweight concrete or very high-strength concrete where cracks shear directly through aggregate particles, aggregate interlock is severely degraded).
  3. Dowel Action of Longitudinal Reinforcement (VdV_d):
    The longitudinal tension bars crossing the diagonal crack resist transverse displacement analogous to dowel pins. This dowel action carries 15%15\% to 25%25\% of the shear force, supported by the concrete cover underneath. If the concrete cover splits horizontally along the bar line, dowel action drops abruptly to zero.
  4. Shear Reinforcement (VusV_{us}):
    When web reinforcement (transverse stirrups or bent-up bars) is present, it directly bridges the diagonal crack, resisting opening displacements by tensile yielding (VusV_{us}). Furthermore, stirrups physically restrain the longitudinal bars, preventing premature dowel splitting failure and holding the aggregate interlock surfaces tightly together.

3. Influence of Shear Span-to-Depth Ratio (av/da_v/d)

The behavior and failure mode of an RC beam depend critically on the ratio of the shear span ava_v (distance between the point load and support) to the effective depth dd:

                       BEAM ACTION vs ARCH ACTION
   a_v/d < 1.0           1.0 ≤ a_v/d ≤ 2.8               a_v/d > 2.8
 ┌───────────────┐     ┌──────────────────────┐     ┌───────────────────────┐
 │   DEEP BEAM   │     │  SHORT / NORMAL BEAM │     │      SLENDER BEAM     │
 │  Arch Action  │     │ Shear-Compression /  │     │  Flexural-Shear Crack │
 │ Direct Strut  │     │   Diagonal Tension   │     │   True Beam Action    │
 └───────────────┘     └──────────────────────┘     └───────────────────────┘
  1. Slender Beams (av/d>2.8a_v/d > 2.8):
    True "beam action" dominates. Failure is initiated by flexure-shear cracking, followed by diagonal tension splitting. Linear strain distributions (Bernoulli-Euler hypothesis) are broadly applicable.
  2. Intermediate Beams (1.0≤av/d≤2.81.0 \le a_v/d \le 2.8):
    Transition zone. After diagonal cracking, the beam can sustain additional load through redistributed internal arch action until the uncracked compression zone crushes in combined shear and compression (shear-compression failure).
  3. Deep Beams (av/d<1.0a_v/d < 1.0):
    "Arch action" completely dominates. The applied concentrated load is transferred directly to the support by an inclined compression strut of concrete acting between the load point and the support reaction, with the longitudinal steel serving as a tie-rod (Strut-and-Tie Model). Beam theory is invalid; design must follow IS 456 Annex H or Strut-and-Tie Modeling.

4. IS 456:2000 Design Philosophy and Provisions

4.1 Nominal Shear Stress (τv\tau_v)

Prismatic Beams of Uniform Depth (Clause 40.1)

τv=Vubd\tau_v = \frac{V_u}{b d}

Where:

  • VuV_u = Factored shear force at the design section (N\text{N}).
  • bb = Breadth of the beam web (mm\text{mm}). (For flanged beams, b=bwb = b_w).
  • dd = Effective depth of the beam (mm\text{mm}).

Beams of Varying Depth (Clause 40.1.1)

In haunched beams or tapered cantilevers where the effective depth dd varies along the span:

τv=Vu±Mudtan⁡βbd\tau_v = \frac{V_u \pm \frac{M_u}{d}\tan\beta}{b d}

Where:

  • MuM_u = Factored bending moment occurring simultaneously with VuV_u at the section (N⋅mm\text{N}\cdot\text{mm}).
  • β\beta = Angle between the top and bottom edges of the beam.
  • Sign Convention (Critical Rule for Competitive Exams):
    • Negative sign (−-) is used when bending moment MuM_u increases in the same direction in which the effective depth dd increases (favorable case: internal couple lever arm increases, generating a vertical component of compressive/tensile forces that opposes shear).
    • Positive sign (++) is used when bending moment MuM_u decreases in the direction of increasing depth dd (unfavorable case: vertical components add to the external shear force).

4.2 Design Shear Strength of Concrete without Web Steel (τc\tau_c)

Per IS 456 Table 19, the design shear strength τc\tau_c is an empirical function of:

  1. Grade of concrete (fckf_{ck}): Higher compressive strength improves tensile strength and aggregate interlock.
  2. Percentage of longitudinal tensile steel (pt=100Astbdp_t = \frac{100 A_{st}}{b d}): Higher tensile steel increases dowel action, restrains crack widening (enhancing aggregate interlock), and increases the depth of the compression zone xux_u (enhancing VczV_{cz}).

The mathematical formula underlying Table 19 is:

τc=0.850.8fck(1+5β−1)6β\tau_c = \frac{0.85 \sqrt{0.8 f_{ck}}\left(\sqrt{1 + 5\beta} - 1\right)}{6\beta}

Where:

β=0.8fck6.89pt≥1.0,pt=100Astbd\beta = \frac{0.8 f_{ck}}{6.89 p_t} \ge 1.0, \quad p_t = \frac{100 A_{st}}{b d}

Representative Values of τc\tau_c (MPa\text{MPa}) from IS 456 Table 19:

pt=100Astbdp_t = \frac{100 A_{st}}{b d} M20 M25 M30 M35 M40 & above
≤0.15%\le 0.15\% 0.28 0.29 0.29 0.29 0.30
0.25%0.25\% 0.36 0.36 0.37 0.37 0.38
0.50%0.50\% 0.48 0.49 0.50 0.50 0.51
0.75%0.75\% 0.56 0.57 0.59 0.59 0.60
1.00%1.00\% 0.62 0.64 0.66 0.67 0.68
1.25%1.25\% 0.67 0.70 0.71 0.73 0.74
≥3.00%\ge 3.00\% 0.82 0.85 0.87 0.90 0.92

Note: For flanged beams, ptp_t is computed using the web width bwb_w, i.e., pt=100Astbwdp_t = \frac{100 A_{st}}{b_w d}.

Modification Factors for τc\tau_c:

  1. Solid Slabs (Clause 40.2.1.1): For thin solid slabs, shear failure occurs under multi-axial constraint. The shear strength is increased by a factor kk:
    • For overall slab depth D≤150 mmD \le 150\text{ mm}, k=1.30k = 1.30.
    • For D≥300 mmD \ge 300\text{ mm}, k=1.00k = 1.00.
    • For 150 mm<D<300 mm150\text{ mm} < D < 300\text{ mm}, linear interpolation applies: k=1.60−0.002Dk = 1.60 - 0.002 D.
  2. Members under Axial Compression (PuP_u) (Clause 40.2.2): Axial compression closes diagonal cracks and increases shear capacity: δ=1+3PuAgfck≤1.5\delta = 1 + \frac{3 P_u}{A_g f_{ck}} \le 1.5
  3. Members under Axial Tension (PuP_u) (Clause 40.2.2): Axial tension accelerates crack opening: δ=1−Pu0.8Agfy≥0\delta = 1 - \frac{P_u}{0.8 A_g f_y} \ge 0

4.3 Maximum Permissible Shear Stress (τc,max⁡\tau_{c,\max}) (Table 20)

Regardless of the quantity of shear reinforcement provided, the nominal shear stress τv\tau_v must never exceed τc,max⁡\tau_{c,\max}. This upper limit prevents brittle diagonal compressive crushing of the concrete web struts before the transverse steel can yield:

τv≤τc,max⁡=0.62fck\tau_v \le \tau_{c,\max} = 0.62 \sqrt{f_{ck}}
Concrete Grade M15 M20 M25 M30 M35 M40 & above
τc,max⁡\tau_{c,\max} (MPa\text{MPa}) 2.5 2.8 3.1 3.5 3.7 4.0

Crucial Rule: If τv>τc,max⁡\tau_v > \tau_{c,\max}, increasing the stirrup steel is completely useless. The cross-sectional dimensions (bb and/or dd) or the concrete grade fckf_{ck} must be increased.


5. Critical Section for Shear (IS 456 Clause 22.6.2)

The design shear force is not necessarily the maximum shear force occurring at the center of the support. The location of the critical section depends on the support conditions:

        CASE A: DIRECT COMPRESSIVE SUPPORT                  CASE B: INDIRECT / SUSPENDED SUPPORT
        (Supported on Column or Wall)                      (Secondary Beam Framing into Main Girder)
        
         ↓↓↓↓↓↓ Factored Load                              ↓↓↓↓↓↓ Factored Load
      ══════════════════════════════════                 ══════════════════════════════════
     │                                  │               │                                  │
     │      Critical Section            │               │      Critical Section            │
     │       at distance d              │               │       at SUPPORT FACE            │
     │            ↓                     │               │            ↓                     │
     ├────────────┆─────────────────────┤               ├────────────┆─────────────────────┤
     │            ┆                     │               │            ┆                     │
     │ 45° Strut  ┆                     │               │ Tension    ┆                     │
     │  ┌──────┐  ┆                     │               │ Hanging    ┆                     │
     └──┴──────┴──┴─────────────────────┘               └──┬──────┬──┴─────────────────────┘
        │← d/2 →│                                          │Girder│
        Face of Support                                    └──────┘
  1. Direct Compressive Support (Clause 22.6.2.1):
    When the reaction at the support introduces compressive stress into the end region of the beam (e.g., beam resting on a wall or framed monolithic into a column), an inclined concrete compressive strut forms at roughly 45∘45^\circ from the support face. Any potential diagonal crack within this zone is clamped shut by the vertical compressive reaction.
    Therefore, the critical section for shear is taken at a distance dd (effective depth) from the face of the support. The shear reinforcement designed for this critical section is continued uniformly into the support face.
  2. Indirect Support / Hanging Load:
    When the support reaction introduces tensile forces (e.g., when a secondary beam frames into the web of a primary girder, or when the load is applied at the bottom of the beam), no clamping compressive strut exists.
    Therefore, the critical section is located directly at the face of the support, and specialized hanger reinforcement (closed stirrups) must be provided in the intersection zone to transfer the reaction upward into the compression zone.

6. Mathematical Derivations of Shear Reinforcement Capacity

                               MÖRSCH 45° TRUSS ANALOGY
                         Top Chord: Concrete Compression Zone
                 ┌──────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
                 │ C = M / z                                        │
                 └──┬─────────┬─────────┬─────────┬─────────┬───────┘
                    │        /│        /│        /│        /│
                    │       / │       / │       / │       / │
   Stirrup Tension  │      /  │      /  │      /  │      /  │ Concrete Strut
     Ties at 90°    │     /   │     /   │     /   │     /   │ Compression Diagonals
   T_v = 0.87 fy Asv│    / θ  │    /    │    /    │    /    │ at θ = 45°
                    │   /     │   /     │   /     │   /     │
                    │  /      │  /      │  /      │  /      │
                 ┌──┴─▼───────┴─▼───────┴─▼───────┴─▼───────┴─┐
                 │ T = M / z                                  │
                 └────────────────────────────────────────────┘
                        Bottom Chord: Tension Steel
                 │←   s_v   →│
                 │←─────── Horizontal Crack Projection = d ──────→│

6.1 Derivation for Vertical Stirrups (VusV_{us})

Consider a diagonal crack inclined at an angle θ=45∘\theta = 45^\circ to the horizontal axis of the beam.

  1. The horizontal projection of this 45∘45^\circ crack across the effective depth dd is: Lcrack=dcot⁡45∘=dL_{\text{crack}} = d \cot 45^\circ = d
  2. Let the vertical stirrups be spaced at a uniform center-to-center spacing svs_v. The number of stirrups NN intercepted by the diagonal crack is: N=Lcracksv=dsvN = \frac{L_{\text{crack}}}{s_v} = \frac{d}{s_v}
  3. Each stirrup provides a cross-sectional area AsvA_{sv} (equal to n×π4ϕ2n \times \frac{\pi}{4}\phi^2 for an nn-legged stirrup). Under limit state conditions, the tensile stress in the stirrups reaches its design yield strength: fsv=0.87fyf_{sv} = 0.87 f_y
  4. The total tensile force developed in one stirrup is: Tv=0.87fyAsvT_v = 0.87 f_y A_{sv}
  5. Summing the tensile capacities of all NN stirrups crossing the crack gives the shear resistance VusV_{us}: Vus=N⋅Tv=(dsv)(0.87fyAsv)V_{us} = N \cdot T_v = \left(\frac{d}{s_v}\right) \left(0.87 f_y A_{sv}\right)
Vus=0.87fyAsvdsv  ⟹  sv=0.87fyAsvdVus\mathbf{V_{us} = \frac{0.87 f_y A_{sv} d}{s_v}} \implies \mathbf{s_v = \frac{0.87 f_y A_{sv} d}{V_{us}}}

6.2 Derivation for Inclined Stirrups (Angle α\alpha)

If the stirrups are inclined at an angle α\alpha to the longitudinal axis:

  1. The horizontal length over which stirrups intercept the 45∘45^\circ crack is: Lh=d(cot⁡θ+cot⁡α)=d(1+cot⁡α)(for θ=45∘)L_h = d(\cot \theta + \cot \alpha) = d(1 + \cot \alpha) \quad (\text{for } \theta = 45^\circ)
  2. The number of inclined stirrups crossing the crack is: N=Lhsv=d(1+cot⁡α)svN = \frac{L_h}{s_v} = \frac{d(1 + \cot \alpha)}{s_v}
  3. Resolving the tensile capacity of each stirrup (0.87fyAsv0.87 f_y A_{sv}) in the vertical direction: Vus=N(0.87fyAsv)sin⁡α=d(1+cot⁡α)sv(0.87fyAsv)sin⁡αV_{us} = N (0.87 f_y A_{sv}) \sin\alpha = \frac{d(1 + \cot\alpha)}{s_v} (0.87 f_y A_{sv}) \sin\alpha Since (1+cot⁡α)sin⁡α=sin⁡α+cos⁡α(1 + \cot\alpha)\sin\alpha = \sin\alpha + \cos\alpha:
Vus=0.87fyAsvdsv(sin⁡α+cos⁡α)\mathbf{V_{us} = \frac{0.87 f_y A_{sv} d}{s_v} (\sin\alpha + \cos\alpha)}

6.3 Derivation for Bent-Up Bars (Single or Group)

When longitudinal tension bars are bent up at an angle α\alpha (typically α=45∘\alpha = 45^\circ or 60∘60^\circ) at a single location:

  • The bars intercept the diagonal crack directly.
  • Resolving the bar tensile force Tb=0.87fyAsvT_b = 0.87 f_y A_{sv} vertically:
Vus=0.87fyAsvsin⁡α\mathbf{V_{us} = 0.87 f_y A_{sv} \sin\alpha}

The Mandatory IS 456 50% Limitation (Clause 40.4.b):

In competitive examinations and practical design, this rule is paramount:

IS 456 Clause 40.4 (b): "Where bent-up bars are provided, their contribution to shear resistance shall not be taken more than half that of the total shear reinforcement (VusV_{us})."

Vsb≤0.50Vus\mathbf{V_{sb} \le 0.50 V_{us}}

The remaining 50%50\% (or more) of the shear force must be carried by vertical or inclined stirrups (Vsv≥0.50VusV_{sv} \ge 0.50 V_{us}). Bent-up bars alone can never be used as the sole shear reinforcement.


7. High-Precision Engineering Diagrams

7.1 Shear Failure Cracks, Internal Mechanisms & Critical Section

The diagram below details the principal stress trajectories, transition from vertical flexural cracks to inclined flexure-shear and web-shear cracks, the equilibrium of aggregate interlock and dowel action across crack surfaces, and the critical design section at distance dd from support.

Shear Failure Cracks, Mechanisms and Critical Section

7.2 Shear Reinforcement Types, Truss Analogy & IS 456 Detailing Rules

The diagram below details the 45° Mörsch truss model, the 3 types of shear reinforcement, the 50% capping rule for bent-up bars, and mandatory spacing and side-face reinforcement limits.

Shear Reinforcement Types, Truss Analogy and Detailing Rules

8. Summary of IS 456 Design Cases

                           SHEAR DESIGN DECISION TREE
                                 Evaluate τ_v
                                      │
            ┌─────────────────────────┴────────────────────────┐
            ▼                                                  ▼
     τ_v > τ_c,max                                       τ_v ≤ τ_c,max
    ┌───────────────┐                                   ┌──────────────┐
    │ REDESIGN BEAM │                                   │ Section Safe │
    │ Increase b, d │                                   │ From Strut   │
    │  or Concrete  │                                   │   Crushing   │
    └───────────────┘                                   └──────┬───────┘
                                                               │
                         ┌─────────────────────────────────────┴──────────────────┐
                         ▼                                                        ▼
                    τ_v ≤ τ_c                                                τ_v > τ_c
            ┌───────────────────────┐                                ┌─────────────────────────┐
            │ Provide Minimum Shear │                                │ Design Shear Steel for: │
            │     Reinforcement     │                                │  V_us = V_u - τ_c · b d │
            │  Asv/(b sv) ≥         │                                │  (Subject to s_v limits)│
            │  0.4 / (0.87 fy)      │                                └─────────────────────────┘
            └───────────────────────┘
  1. Case 1: τv>τc,max⁡\tau_v > \tau_{c,\max}: Section is inadequate. Danger of diagonal compression failure. Redesign cross-section.
  2. Case 2: τc<τv≤τc,max⁡\tau_c < \tau_v \le \tau_{c,\max}: Concrete shear capacity is exceeded. Shear reinforcement must be designed to carry the excess shear: Vus=Vu−τcbdV_{us} = V_u - \tau_c b d The calculated spacing svs_v must satisfy: sv≤min⁡(0.87fyAsvdVus,  0.87fyAsv0.4b,  0.75d,  300 mm)s_v \le \min\left(\frac{0.87 f_y A_{sv} d}{V_{us}}, \; \frac{0.87 f_y A_{sv}}{0.4 b}, \; 0.75 d, \; 300\text{ mm}\right)
  3. Case 3: τc2<τv≤τc\frac{\tau_c}{2} < \tau_v \le \tau_c: Concrete alone can theoretically resist shear, but minimum shear reinforcement is legally mandatory for all beams to prevent sudden brittle collapse.
  4. Case 4: τv≤τc2\tau_v \le \frac{\tau_c}{2}: Minimum shear reinforcement is still mandatory in beams (Clause 26.5.1.6). It is only exempt in members of minor structural importance, thin solid slabs, and footings.

Minimum Shear Reinforcement (Clause 26.5.1.6)

Asvbsv≥0.40.87fy  ⟹  sv,max⁡=0.87fyAsv0.4b\frac{A_{sv}}{b s_v} \ge \frac{0.4}{0.87 f_y} \implies s_{v,\max} = \frac{0.87 f_y A_{sv}}{0.4 b}

Maximum Permissible Spacing (Clause 26.5.1.5)

  • For vertical stirrups: sv≤min⁡(0.75d,300 mm)s_v \le \min(0.75 d, 300\text{ mm}).
  • For inclined stirrups (at 45∘45^\circ): sv≤min⁡(d,300 mm)s_v \le \min(d, 300\text{ mm}).

Side Face Reinforcement (Clause 26.5.1.3 & 26.5.1.7)

In deep beams, diagonal tension cracks develop along the side faces of the web between the main tension steel and the compression zone.

  • Trigger Conditions:
    • Where the depth of the web in a beam exceeds 750 mm750\text{ mm} (for flexure and shear).
    • Where the overall depth exceeds 450 mm450\text{ mm} when the member is subjected to torsion.
  • Quantity: Total area of side-face reinforcement As,side≥0.1%A_{s,\text{side}} \ge 0.1\% of the web area (bw⋅Db_w \cdot D).
  • Distribution: Divided equally on the two lateral faces (0.05%bwD0.05\% b_w D per face).
  • Spacing: Spacing between side bars shall not exceed min⁡(300 mm,web thickness bw)\min(300\text{ mm}, \text{web thickness } b_w).

9. Pre-Calculated Solved Numerical Examples

Problem 1: Standard Prismatic RC Beam Shear Design (GATE / ESE)

Statement:
A reinforced concrete beam of rectangular section has a breadth b=300 mmb = 300\text{ mm}, effective depth d=500 mmd = 500\text{ mm}, and overall depth D=550 mmD = 550\text{ mm}. The beam is reinforced with 4 bars of 20 mm20\text{ mm} diameter (Ast=1256.64 mm2A_{st} = 1256.64\text{ mm}^2) continuing straight into the support. At the critical section located at distance dd from the support face, the factored shear force is Vu=180 kNV_u = 180\text{ kN}. The materials are concrete grade M25 (fck=25 MPaf_{ck} = 25\text{ MPa}) and steel grade Fe 415 (fy=415 MPaf_y = 415\text{ MPa}).
Design the vertical shear reinforcement using 8 mm8\text{ mm} diameter 2-legged stirrups.

Step 1: Nominal Shear Stress (τv\tau_v)

τv=Vubd=180×103 N300 mm×500 mm=1.2000 MPa\tau_v = \frac{V_u}{b d} = \frac{180 \times 10^3\text{ N}}{300\text{ mm} \times 500\text{ mm}} = 1.2000\text{ MPa}

Step 2: Maximum Permissible Shear Stress (τc,max⁡\tau_{c,\max})

From IS 456:2000 Table 20, for M25 concrete:

τc,max⁡=3.10 MPa\tau_{c,\max} = 3.10\text{ MPa}

Since τv=1.20 MPa<τc,max⁡=3.10 MPa\tau_v = 1.20\text{ MPa} < \tau_{c,\max} = 3.10\text{ MPa}, the cross-section is safe against diagonal compression crushing.

Step 3: Design Shear Strength of Concrete (τc\tau_c)

Calculate percentage of longitudinal tensile reinforcement at the section:

pt=100Astbd=100×1256.64300×500=0.8378%p_t = \frac{100 A_{st}}{b d} = \frac{100 \times 1256.64}{300 \times 500} = 0.8378\%

From IS 456:2000 Table 19 for M25 concrete:

  • At pt=0.75%  ⟹  τc=0.57 MPap_t = 0.75\% \implies \tau_c = 0.57\text{ MPa}
  • At pt=1.00%  ⟹  τc=0.64 MPap_t = 1.00\% \implies \tau_c = 0.64\text{ MPa}

Using linear interpolation:

τc=0.57+0.8378−0.751.00−0.75×(0.64−0.57)=0.57+0.08780.25×0.07=0.57+0.0246=0.5946 MPa\tau_c = 0.57 + \frac{0.8378 - 0.75}{1.00 - 0.75} \times (0.64 - 0.57) = 0.57 + \frac{0.0878}{0.25} \times 0.07 = 0.57 + 0.0246 = 0.5946\text{ MPa}

Step 4: Comparison & Determination of Shear to be Resisted

τv=1.2000 MPa>τc=0.5946 MPa\tau_v = 1.2000\text{ MPa} > \tau_c = 0.5946\text{ MPa}

Since τv>τc\tau_v > \tau_c, shear reinforcement is mandatory to resist the net excess shear.

  • Shear carried by concrete: Vc=τcbd=0.5946 MPa×300 mm×500 mm=89,190 N=89.19 kNV_c = \tau_c b d = 0.5946\text{ MPa} \times 300\text{ mm} \times 500\text{ mm} = 89,190\text{ N} = 89.19\text{ kN}
  • Net factored shear to be carried by transverse stirrups: Vus=Vu−Vc=180.00 kN−89.19 kN=90.81 kN=90,810 NV_{us} = V_u - V_c = 180.00\text{ kN} - 89.19\text{ kN} = 90.81\text{ kN} = 90,810\text{ N}

Step 5: Design of 2-Legged 8 mm Stirrups

Area of 2-legged 8 mm8\text{ mm} stirrups (AsvA_{sv}):

Asv=2×π4×82=2×50.27=100.53 mm2A_{sv} = 2 \times \frac{\pi}{4} \times 8^2 = 2 \times 50.27 = 100.53\text{ mm}^2
  1. Calculated Spacing for Strength (sv,calcs_{v,\text{calc}}):

    sv,calc=0.87fyAsvdVus=0.87×415×100.53×50090,810=199.84 mms_{v,\text{calc}} = \frac{0.87 f_y A_{sv} d}{V_{us}} = \frac{0.87 \times 415 \times 100.53 \times 500}{90,810} = 199.84\text{ mm}
  2. Spacing for Minimum Shear Reinforcement (sv,min⁡s_{v,\min}):

    sv,min⁡=0.87fyAsv0.4b=0.87×415×100.530.4×300=302.47 mms_{v,\min} = \frac{0.87 f_y A_{sv}}{0.4 b} = \frac{0.87 \times 415 \times 100.53}{0.4 \times 300} = 302.47\text{ mm}
  3. Maximum Code Permissible Spacing (sv,max⁡s_{v,\max}):

    sv,max⁡=min⁡(0.75d,  300 mm)=min⁡(0.75×500,  300 mm)=min⁡(375 mm,  300 mm)=300.00 mms_{v,\max} = \min(0.75 d, \; 300\text{ mm}) = \min(0.75 \times 500, \; 300\text{ mm}) = \min(375\text{ mm}, \; 300\text{ mm}) = 300.00\text{ mm}
  4. Governing Spacing:

    sv≤min⁡(199.84 mm,  302.47 mm,  300.00 mm)=199.84 mms_v \le \min(199.84\text{ mm}, \; 302.47\text{ mm}, \; 300.00\text{ mm}) = 199.84\text{ mm}

Final Detailing Specification:

Provide 2-legged 8 mm8\text{ mm} dia vertical stirrups @ 200 mm200\text{ mm} center-to-center near the supports.


Problem 2: Beam with Bent-Up Bars and 50% IS 456 Limitation (UPSC ESE / State AE)

Statement:
An RC beam has breadth b=300 mmb = 300\text{ mm} and effective depth d=600 mmd = 600\text{ mm}. Concrete is M25 and steel is Fe 415. At midspan, the beam is reinforced with 6 bars of 25 mm25\text{ mm} diameter. Towards the support, 2 of these bars are bent up at 45∘45^\circ where bending moment is low, while 4 bars (Ast=1963.50 mm2A_{st} = 1963.50\text{ mm}^2) continue straight into the support.
The factored shear force at the critical section is Vu=350 kNV_u = 350\text{ kN}.
Calculate the shear resistance provided by the bent-up bars under IS 456 rules, and design the complementary 2-legged 10 mm10\text{ mm} vertical stirrups required.

Step 1: Nominal Shear Stress (τv\tau_v)

τv=Vubd=350×103300×600=1.9444 MPa\tau_v = \frac{V_u}{b d} = \frac{350 \times 10^3}{300 \times 600} = 1.9444\text{ MPa}

From Table 20, for M25: τc,max⁡=3.10 MPa\tau_{c,\max} = 3.10\text{ MPa}.
Since τv=1.944 MPa<3.10 MPa\tau_v = 1.944\text{ MPa} < 3.10\text{ MPa}, section size is adequate.

Step 2: Concrete Shear Strength (τc\tau_c)

Percentage of straight tension steel at the support:

pt=100×1963.50300×600=1.0908%p_t = \frac{100 \times 1963.50}{300 \times 600} = 1.0908\%

From Table 19 for M25:

  • At pt=1.00%  ⟹  τc=0.64 MPap_t = 1.00\% \implies \tau_c = 0.64\text{ MPa}
  • At pt=1.25%  ⟹  τc=0.70 MPap_t = 1.25\% \implies \tau_c = 0.70\text{ MPa}

Interpolating:

τc=0.64+1.0908−1.000.25×(0.70−0.64)=0.64+0.3632×0.06=0.6618 MPa\tau_c = 0.64 + \frac{1.0908 - 1.00}{0.25} \times (0.70 - 0.64) = 0.64 + 0.3632 \times 0.06 = 0.6618\text{ MPa}

Step 3: Total Shear to be Resisted by Steel (VusV_{us})

  • Concrete shear resistance: Vc=τcbd=0.6618×300×600=119,124 N=119.12 kNV_c = \tau_c b d = 0.6618 \times 300 \times 600 = 119,124\text{ N} = 119.12\text{ kN}
  • Total excess shear: Vus=Vu−Vc=350.00−119.12=230.88 kN=230,880 NV_{us} = V_u - V_c = 350.00 - 119.12 = 230.88\text{ kN} = 230,880\text{ N}

Step 4: Capacity of Bent-Up Bars and 50% Rule

Two 25 mm25\text{ mm} bars bent up at α=45∘\alpha = 45^\circ:

Asv,bent=2×π4×252=2×490.87=981.75 mm2A_{sv,\text{bent}} = 2 \times \frac{\pi}{4} \times 25^2 = 2 \times 490.87 = 981.75\text{ mm}^2

Nominal vertical capacity of the bent bars:

Vus,bent=0.87fyAsv,bentsin⁡45∘=0.87×415×981.75×sin⁡45∘=250,641 N=250.64 kNV_{us,\text{bent}} = 0.87 f_y A_{sv,\text{bent}} \sin 45^\circ = 0.87 \times 415 \times 981.75 \times \sin 45^\circ = 250,641\text{ N} = 250.64\text{ kN}

Application of IS 456 Clause 40.4 (b): The contribution of bent-up bars cannot exceed 50%50\% of the total shear reinforcement requirement VusV_{us}:

Vsb,max⁡=0.50×Vus=0.50×230.88 kN=115.44 kNV_{sb,\max} = 0.50 \times V_{us} = 0.50 \times 230.88\text{ kN} = 115.44\text{ kN}

Although the bent bars possess a capacity of 250.64 kN250.64\text{ kN}, they are permitted to resist only 115.44 kN115.44\text{ kN}.

Step 5: Design of Vertical Stirrups (VsvV_{sv})

The remaining shear must be resisted by vertical stirrups:

Vsv=Vus−Vsb=230.88−115.44=115.44 kN=115,440 NV_{sv} = V_{us} - V_{sb} = 230.88 - 115.44 = 115.44\text{ kN} = 115,440\text{ N}

Using 2-legged 10 mm10\text{ mm} stirrups:

Asv=2×π4×102=157.08 mm2A_{sv} = 2 \times \frac{\pi}{4} \times 10^2 = 157.08\text{ mm}^2
  1. Calculated spacing: sv=0.87fyAsvdVsv=0.87×415×157.08×600115,440=294.77 mms_v = \frac{0.87 f_y A_{sv} d}{V_{sv}} = \frac{0.87 \times 415 \times 157.08 \times 600}{115,440} = 294.77\text{ mm}
  2. Minimum shear steel spacing: sv,min⁡=0.87×415×157.080.4×300=472.61 mms_{v,\min} = \frac{0.87 \times 415 \times 157.08}{0.4 \times 300} = 472.61\text{ mm}
  3. Maximum code spacing: sv,max⁡=min⁡(0.75×600,  300)=min⁡(450 mm,  300 mm)=300.00 mms_{v,\max} = \min(0.75 \times 600, \; 300) = \min(450\text{ mm}, \; 300\text{ mm}) = 300.00\text{ mm}

Final Specification:

Provide the 2 bent-up bars of 25 mm25\text{ mm} dia at 45∘45^\circ accompanied by 2-legged 10 mm10\text{ mm} vertical stirrups @ 280 mm280\text{ mm} c/c.


Problem 3: Haunched Beam of Varying Depth (GATE CE)

Statement:
A reinforced concrete beam of rectangular web width b=300 mmb = 300\text{ mm} has a linearly varying effective depth. At a section XX, the effective depth is d=600 mmd = 600\text{ mm}, and the slope of the haunch is tan⁡β=112=0.0833\tan\beta = \frac{1}{12} = 0.0833. At this section, the factored shear force is Vu=220 kNV_u = 220\text{ kN} and the factored bending moment is Mu=150 kN⋅mM_u = 150\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}.
Calculate the nominal shear stress τv\tau_v for:

  • Case A: Bending moment MuM_u increases in the direction of increasing depth dd.
  • Case B: Bending moment MuM_u decreases in the direction of increasing depth dd.

Solution:

Per IS 456:2000 Clause 40.1.1:

τv=Vu±Mudtan⁡βbd\tau_v = \frac{V_u \pm \frac{M_u}{d}\tan\beta}{b d}

First evaluate the moment-haunch interaction term:

Mudtan⁡β=150×106 N⋅mm600 mm×112=250,000×0.08333=20,833.33 N=20.833 kN\frac{M_u}{d}\tan\beta = \frac{150 \times 10^6\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm}}{600\text{ mm}} \times \frac{1}{12} = 250,000 \times 0.08333 = 20,833.33\text{ N} = 20.833\text{ kN}

Case A: MuM_u increases as dd increases (Favorable Case)

The negative sign applies:

Vu,eff=Vu−Mudtan⁡β=220.00 kN−20.833 kN=199.167 kN=199,167 NV_{u,\text{eff}} = V_u - \frac{M_u}{d}\tan\beta = 220.00\text{ kN} - 20.833\text{ kN} = 199.167\text{ kN} = 199,167\text{ N} τv=199,167 N300 mm×600 mm=1.1065 MPa\tau_v = \frac{199,167\text{ N}}{300\text{ mm} \times 600\text{ mm}} = \mathbf{1.1065\text{ MPa}}

Case B: MuM_u decreases as dd increases (Unfavorable Case)

The positive sign applies:

Vu,eff=Vu+Mudtan⁡β=220.00 kN+20.833 kN=240.833 kN=240,833 NV_{u,\text{eff}} = V_u + \frac{M_u}{d}\tan\beta = 220.00\text{ kN} + 20.833\text{ kN} = 240.833\text{ kN} = 240,833\text{ N} τv=240,833 N300 mm×600 mm=1.3380 MPa\tau_v = \frac{240,833\text{ N}}{300\text{ mm} \times 600\text{ mm}} = \mathbf{1.3380\text{ MPa}}

Observation: Tapering depth in the direction of increasing moment reduces design shear stress by 17.3%17.3\%, demonstrating the structural efficiency of haunched frames.


10. Comparative Analysis: Shear Failure Modes

Failure Mode Typical av/da_v/d Range Concrete Grade & Web Type Mechanism & Visual Characteristics Prevention Strategy
Diagonal Tension Failure av/d>2.8a_v/d > 2.8 Normal beams with thin webs, low web steel Flexural crack inclines diagonally at 45° across the web, rapidly splitting the beam into two separate halves. Extremely brittle. Provide adequate vertical stirrups crossing the crack (sv≤0.75d,300 mms_v \le 0.75 d, 300\text{ mm}).
Shear-Compression Failure 1.0≤av/d≤2.81.0 \le a_v/d \le 2.8 Short beams with moderate web reinforcement Diagonal crack penetrates deep into the concrete head. The reduced uncracked concrete zone crushes under combined shear and compressive stresses. Increase beam effective depth dd or concrete grade fckf_{ck}.
Web Crushing Failure Any, when τv>τc,max⁡\tau_v > \tau_{c,\max} Heavily reinforced beams, thin I-webs Inclined concrete struts between diagonal cracks crush under excessive diagonal compression before stirrups reach yield. Redesign cross-section. Limit τv≤τc,max⁡=0.62fck\tau_v \le \tau_{c,\max} = 0.62\sqrt{f_{ck}}.
Dowel Splitting Failure All av/da_v/d Beams with inadequate bottom cover or bar spacing Horizontal splitting cracks develop along the longitudinal tension steel line due to upward dowel forces. Provide vertical stirrups enclosing longitudinal bars; maintain minimum bottom/side cover.
Arch-Rib Failure av/d<1.0a_v/d < 1.0 Deep beams, corbels, pile caps Concrete arch strut crushes directly between concentrated load and support reaction plate. Follow Strut-and-Tie model or IS 456 Annex H deep beam detailing.

11. Practical Detailing & Seismic Considerations (IS 13920:2016)

  1. Stirrup Anchorage & Hook Bending:
    Under severe earthquake shaking, concrete cover spalls away. If standard 90∘90^\circ hooks are used, the stirrups open outward, completely destroying shear capacity and causing instantaneous column or beam collapse.
    • IS 13920:2016 mandates 135∘135^\circ seismic hooks with an extension of at least 10ϕ10\phi (or 75 mm75\text{ mm}) embedded into the core concrete.
  2. First Stirrup Location:
    The first stirrup from the face of any column or beam support must be placed at a distance of not more than 50 mm50\text{ mm} from the support face.
  3. Curtailment of Tension Reinforcement & Shear:
    When longitudinal tension bars are terminated (curtailed) where no longer needed for flexure, the abrupt cessation of steel causes local stress concentrations that trigger premature diagonal cracks. IS 456 Clause 26.2.3.2 enforces strict shear checks at cut-off points: τv≤23τcor provide extra stirrups Asv=0.4bsv0.87fy\tau_v \le \frac{2}{3}\tau_c \quad \text{or provide extra stirrups } A_{sv} = \frac{0.4 b s_v}{0.87 f_y}
  4. Modern Site Preference:
    While bent-up bars were historically favored to save steel, modern industrialized construction universally prefers pure vertical stirrups due to ease of fabrication, automated rebar tying, and elimination of cage congestion.

12. Common Misconceptions & Exam Traps

[!WARNING]

  1. Over-Reinforcing for Shear when τv>τc,max⁡\tau_v > \tau_{c,\max}:
    A common error in competitive exam problems is attempting to solve τv>τc,max⁡\tau_v > \tau_{c,\max} by decreasing stirrup spacing svs_v. No amount of stirrup reinforcement can prevent diagonal compression crushing of concrete. The section dimensions must be increased.

  2. Neglecting the 50% Rule for Bent-Up Bars:
    In objective exams (GATE/ESE), questions frequently state: "A bent-up bar carries 200 kN200\text{ kN} of shear, and total excess shear is 160 kN160\text{ kN}. What shear must stirrups carry?"
    Trap: Answering 0 kN0\text{ kN}.
    Correct: Bent-up bars cannot take more than 50%50\% of 160 kN=80 kN160\text{ kN} = 80\text{ kN}. Therefore, vertical stirrups must carry at least 80 kN80\text{ kN}.

  3. Critical Section Distance Misapplication:
    Using dd from the centerline of the support instead of the face of the support. For a 400 mm400\text{ mm} wide column, the critical section is at 200 mm+d200\text{ mm} + d from the centerline!

  4. Varying Depth Sign Error:
    Remember: When MuM_u and dd both increase simultaneously (e.g. at the support of a haunched continuous beam or cantilever), the internal forces produce a vertical upward component that opposes shear   ⟹  \implies use minus sign (Vu−Mudtan⁡βV_u - \frac{M_u}{d}\tan\beta).

  5. Confusing Maximum Spacing with Minimum Steel:
    Maximum spacing is min⁡(0.75d,300 mm)\min(0.75 d, 300\text{ mm}). Minimum steel is Asvbsv≥0.40.87fy\frac{A_{sv}}{b s_v} \ge \frac{0.4}{0.87 f_y}. Both criteria must be satisfied independently, and the smaller spacing governs.


13. Practice Questions for Self-Assessment

  1. GATE CE: A rectangular reinforced concrete beam of width 250 mm250\text{ mm} and effective depth 450 mm450\text{ mm} is subjected to a factored shear force of 120 kN120\text{ kN}. The concrete is M20 (fck=20 MPaf_{ck} = 20\text{ MPa}, τc,max⁡=2.8 MPa\tau_{c,\max} = 2.8\text{ MPa}) and longitudinal steel provides τc=0.50 MPa\tau_c = 0.50\text{ MPa}. Using Fe 415 steel and 2-legged 8 mm8\text{ mm} stirrups, the required spacing is:
    (Answer: 174.5 mm  ⟹  Adopt 170 mm174.5\text{ mm} \implies \text{Adopt } 170\text{ mm})
  2. UPSC ESE: State four reasons why minimum shear reinforcement is mandatory in all reinforced concrete beams even when the factored shear stress τv\tau_v is less than the concrete shear strength τc\tau_c.
    (Key points: sudden thermal/shrinkage cracking, dowel splitting restraint, holding cage in place during compaction, preventing catastrophic unheralded brittle collapse).
  3. SSC JE / State AE: What is the maximum permissible spacing of vertical shear stirrups for an RC beam of effective depth 400 mm400\text{ mm}?
    (Answer: min⁡(0.75×400=300 mm,300 mm)=300 mm\min(0.75 \times 400 = 300\text{ mm}, 300\text{ mm}) = 300\text{ mm})
  4. RRB JE: What is the maximum percentage of shear force that can be resisted by bent-up bars alone according to IS 456:2000?
    (Answer: 50%50\% of the total shear reinforcement requirement VusV_{us})